Great food everyone enjoyed what they had. Fish & chips,…read morepeanut butter burger (sounds funny but tasted great), egg plant zucchini lasagna. Dillion was a hoot & everyone was Canada NICE! Little place inside with a nice patio right on the water.

Surly Mermaid in Sidney is so nice! Love the patio. It overlooks the pier and boardwalk which is…read moregreat for people watching and getting some fresh breeze from the ocean. The atmosphere is fun and welcoming, the staff were friendly, and the food was good. We had the poh boy, salmon burger and it comes with fries. The food in my opinion is a tad on the greasy side... but regardless now we know what it's like. We'll definitely be coming back the next time we're in Sidney. Highly recommend checking it out!

Great service, drinks and the food was all yummy! Order the burger and side caeser salad. Ignore…read morethe negative reviews!

This was one of the worst restaurants I've ever been to. After a beautiful day at Burchart Gardens,…read morewe decided to end the day having dinner at a restaurant on the water. I ordered 2 fish tacos for $5 a piece and they were literally 2 bites each and were absolutely awful! The fish was mushy and almost nonexistent. I also ordered a California roll that came 10 minutes after we had finished our meal. I ended up canceling it because I didn't want to eat alone. My boyfriend ordered a shrimp salad for $28. It was a small mediocre salad with about 2 tablespoons of what looked and tasted like canned shrimp. I don't know how this establishment stays in business!

The food is good BUT watch your back when dealing with the manager!!!! online…read more He has ripped me off a few times now. Once charged me twice for a meal and said it was my credit card's doing and the card said they put it through twice. And again tonight, I ordered TWO meals the same (I have the receipt) via UberEats and got two different meals. I phoned and the manager said I was wrong, the order he sent was correct. I HAVE THE RECEIPT! I was charged for the two exact meals! What happened to the customer is always right? ESPECIALLY when they are!

The only good food to eat was the soup. The batter on fish…read moren chips is too thick it's undercooked. One could still get the gritty raw batter. The fries on poutine seems to be pre-frozen and crumble when just held. The gravy is very thin and not hot enough to melt the cheese. Good service and nice setting overall.

Excellent Burger and fries, hot fresh and delicious. Service was genuinely friendly, and a neat…read morelittle place to sit outside under cover and enjoy a great meal. Highly recommended!

Our burgers and quesadillas were delicious. The customer service we received was outstanding. One…read moreof our family members left their purse behind and our server made an exceptional effort to get it back to us. We highly recommend the Lighthouse Eatery.

Our whole table got the Crab & Shrimp melt, it did not disappoint! We came at 7pm, got sat…read moreimmediately & had great service!

Wow! Best salmon ever! I had the salmon à la carte. First, thank you for offering food this way…read more I eat small meals. The salmon was delicious and seasoned so well that every bite was amazing. The service was very good and they had high attention to details.

I saved this place for our trip to Neah Bay!…read more Our first day in town, we stopped here for dinner and they were closing in 30-40 minutes! We ordered the crab, salmon & chips and halibut & chips! Their fries are crisp and crazy good!!! They kinda remind me of five guys French fries. The salmon looked wild/king and it was crispy on the outside and cooked fresh in the inside - same with the halibut, it was so good!! Loved the crab! Wish we got more of it but it is $18 for a cup. You get butter and a lemon wedge, so delicious with butter! We did eat outside as it is a tiny seating area inside.I'd come back again! I think this is one of the best seafood places and fast ones too in Neah Bay!

This was a fun stop in Neah bay! We got the crab and fries and salmon and fries. They said the…read moresalmon was king salmon. Tried to eat outside on the cute deck chairs but it's started raining so we went inside. It's really tiny inside with just a little bar looking out the window at the great views. Food was fast, hot and fresh! Didn't try any of the pastry items and regret it!

Decided to come to Fanny Bay for my birthday dinner while traveling in Vancouver, and it did not…read moredisappoint. This spot does traditional and classic seafood items so well- lobster poutine, are you kidding me?! How do I inject the lobster gravy from this dish into my veins? My boyfriend and I got a couple dozen raw oysters from the available options and narrowed down our favorites- the Fanny Bay and Kumamoto are fantastic! I got the uni sashimi and umami bomb, and those were to die for. The lobster poutine stole the show for my boyfriend and me, the serving size was generous and very filling. We got so much quality seafood for less than $100 CAD- this would easily go for so much more in the Bay Area.

Fanny Bay is a popular spot for oysters, and indeed oysters be everywhere here! Our group of four…read morewas fortunate to snag a spot on a busy Friday night. Being a busier night, it was a little hard to get served even when we sat at the bar; we had to wait nearly 15 minutes before being able to place an order. We each had their Clam Chowder, which was pretty salty to say the least. The addition of real clams did make it tasty, BUT the clams also had a lot of sand... were they washed? This was not a fun soup to eat... It was also served with a crumbly muffin, which was not my favorite. The Mussels & Clams in white wine sauce was tasty, though it had the same issue of being sandy. We also had their Crab Cake - thankfully not sandy here. (I'd be scared if they were...) The crab cakes with real crab were tasty - loved this one! We also had their Daily Shucker's Dozen oysters, which included two smaller ones and a larger one. The large one... was most definitely meaty, briny, and not as tasty as the smaller, sweeter ones. I believe our smaller ones may have been the Fat Bastard and Sweet Select, while the larger one was off menu from Washington. On the topic of busyness, we didn't get our oysters until very late into the meal - nearly an hour. They actually had forgotten our order, and we had to remind them, which they said "soon" until "soon" ended up being nearly 20 minutes! We were told that a shucker was working on it, only to see that tray being sent to another table... sad!

We got the seafood platter for 2 ($50). I think this was the best fish and chips I've had in my…read morelife. Not only was it a good value because it came with prawn tacos to start and a large amount of coleslaw+fries, but everything was so hot and fresh. The batter was airy and light, both the fish and fries were very crispy and hot. There are both salmon and cod. I usually find that if the fish is salmon they overcook it and it tends to be dry, but this was perfect. They even gave us an extra piece of cod.

Nice atmosphere despite being in an out of the way place. We were thrilled that the fish and chips…read morewere gluten-free and they were amazingly fresh and good with great tartar sauce!!! The hamburger not so much ...not much flavor nobody wanted to finish it ...gluten-free roll should've been buttered and toasted. Cocktails and gluten-free beer were excellent server did not know why everything was gluten-free would've liked to appreciate that. But, a fun meal !

Found this place on Google Maps on our way back from Cape Flattery and decided to stop and try. It…read morewas amazing!! Generous portions and the fish melted in your mouth. The girl at the window was so sweet and gave us her recommendations. We added on a milk shake to top it off. Would definitely recommend giving it a try!!

Outstanding halibut and chips... I and just left Cape Flattery, it was a little early for lunch,…read morebut the reviews sounded so good. I had to give it a try. A food truck like setup, order at the window and ready in minutes. Three nice pieces of battered and frying halibut. The fries were cooked perfectly. The halibut was crunchy out the outside, flaky inside. Once Google updates their 13 year old Street View of the area, you can see me out front. The Google car drove by twice while I was there. If this place weren't 2,800 miles from my home, I would be back often.