Pie95 remains my absolute favorite pizza spot in Jax! We happily drive across town because the quality is incredibly consistent, the food is delicious, and the service is always personable. You truly can't go wrong with anything on the menu. I like to start with the arugula salad, the Bianca is my personal favorite pizza and ordering the tiramisu is the best way to end the meal. If you want the best pizza in the city, this is the place! read more

We have always had great experiences here. The pizza is delish and the arugula salad is great! We have also enjoyed the wings a couple of times as well! We did receive a cold people tonight but the other times it was fantastic! The service is always quick and great. The employees are always funny, kind and welcoming! We have yet to dine in but when we walk in to pick up the ambiance always seems incredible, cozy and European like read more

Quality is slipping: Pie95 seems to be struggling with its margin, as their production seems to become more and more resource strapped. Be less stingy with the toppings - it's a $20 pizza gosh-darn-it. read more

Fabulous food, not just pizza, but the full menu is really tasty. And while the front of the house is busy, with limited seating, try to head out into the back for a really cool outdoor dining area. We were there on a clear night and it felt very special. The service is lead off by Emilia, who greeted us, walked through the menu with us, and followed up later to see how our meal was. Every restaurant needs an Emilia, with a real focus on customer service. But you want to know about the food: Broccolini - I hear it's really special, but they were sold out on the night that we went recently. Meatballs - meaty, cheesy served hot. Caprese salad - this really was a good salad with arugula, Barada cheese, and balsamic, please. They could've eaten too orders of this.. Shrimp - we couldn't get the broccolini Emilia suggested we try the shrimp, and she was right. They were delicious with just a hint of a spicy cake.. Pepperoni pizza -we got ours with hot honey, and it really lived up to the hype. The crust is charred, but it is still light and airy and the sauce is something that they should sell, it's that good.. Margarita pizza - this was my favorite by far, fresh ingredients, like crust, served hot, it was delicious. I've had my eye on the spot for quite a long time, and I'm sad that it took me this long to get here. But I'm already planning to go back next week. read more

See all

We dined in on a weekend. We were met with a warm welcome from the staff. We ordered the meatballs, the hot honey ricotta bread and the buffalo wings for starters. They were all exceptional. Flavorful and piping hot, we thoroughly enjoyed each one. The pizza was thin, crispy and had a generous portion of toppings over a tasty white sauce. We will definitely return. read more

See all

The smells coming from inside bring you right into the building. I just couldn't resist! There are only a few places to sit inside so. we entered and reviewed the menu but no one offered to help us. So we left and went down the street for a drink and then ordered online. I'm hoping this isn't common practice for their service. We ordered the Bianca pizza. It was served with a lemon wedge which was fantastic when squeezed on the pizza. I thought the pizza tasted good, but did think it was a little expensive for the small size. read more

Pie95 Pizza - Bianca Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

From the moment I walked in, I was greeted and showered with attention (the staff here really know what customer service is about). The interior is on the smaller size, but well placed and organized. I ordered the margherita pizza and garlic bread. Pizza - textually it was good , crunchy on the outside, soft on the inside from the wood fire. My only gripe is that often times the bitterness from the charred parts of the pizza would overpower those subtle flavors. Garlic Bread - Just slightly undercooked, but again subtle in flavor and forgettable with a $9 price tag. It is unfortunate that it was only the customer service that wowed me. Although, the pizza isn't far off; I will be back and look forward to bolder flavors. read more

Pie95 Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

See all

Deliciousssss pizza Clean inside Self serve water station Fast & friendly service Would be a regular if I lived here read more

See all

Spectacular crust! I tried the pepperoni pizza and fungi pizza and was blown away. Staff were kind and food was quick and fresh. read more

Pie95 Pizza - Pizza Pepperoni, Fungi Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

Great pizza. Dough is the highlight. No flop, great undercarriage, 8.1 New back yard area that is very nice! read more

Pie95 Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

Definitely my favorite pizza spot in town. Owner is super nice and knows how to make some delicious dough. read more

Pie95 Pizza - Pepperoni and fungi pizza - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

If you're looking for the BEST wood-fired pizza in Jacksonville, look no further than Pie95. Every bite is pure perfection--crispy crust, fresh ingredients, and that unbeatable smoky flavor that only comes from a true artisan oven. The team behind the counter is just as warm as the pizza--friendly, passionate, and clearly in love with what they do. Whether you're grabbing a classic Margherita or going bold with one of their creative specials, you can taste the love in every slice. It's comfort food, elevated--and I can't wait to go back! Run, don't walk. Your taste buds will thank you. read more

See all

When in Jacksonville Florida you better visit Pie95Pizza, we met Evan when he had his truck with his fire wood oven designed and built in Italy! and he took a leap of faith and after tons of work, endless days and saying goodbye to his beloved truck, Etan had a built and mortar location...nothing has changed Fresh ingredients, fire wood oven, and he loves for 5 stars pizza and desserts read more

See all

Had high expectations but turned out to be some of the blandest pizza I've ever eaten. Tried the Pepperoni, the Herbivore, and the Carnivore, all were bland. It has potential but not as good as DeCicco's in Yulee or Moon River (Fernandina or Riverside). Service was fast and ambiance was nice. read more

First time coming to Pie95, came in with a few friends. We ordered a few pies and salads. They only had one option for salad (from what I saw) and it was an arugula salad. It was a fine salad that could be split between 2, but not much to it. Minimal ingredients in the salad at the price point. The pizza was good, I don't typically like firewood pizza because the fire taste can be overwhelming but they cook the pizza just right so that it's not overly smoky tasting or burnt. An employee recommended tiramisu for dessert and it was good as well. I liked the pistachio pieces and it was presented very nicely. The service was quick, we went to the counter to order and sat down since they brought the food to our table. It's a nice restaurant that is conveniently located near other great businesses off Park and King St. read more

See all

I went for the appetizer. It was delicious with the ricotta and chili oil. I could have at two plates of it. Staff was friendly and checked on us alot while we ate in the outdoor seating area in the back. It was intimate and off the street. Will definitely be back read more

Pie95 Pizza - Broccolini app - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

Great pizza, super friendly staff and quick service. Even though there was a steady flow of customers Saturday early evening, our pizzas still came out in a very reasonable amount of time. We also had no issues finding parking along King Street. There's a few high top tables inside but I like that the outdoor seating out back was spacious & shaded by the surrounding buildings. We enjoyed both our pizzas. [ Pizza Herbivore ] Cheese Please Base Pizza Topped With All House Veggies [ Pizza Margherita ] Tomato Sauce, Basil, Fresh Mozzarell, Evoo [ Fire Roasted Meatballs ] Pomodoro Sauce, EVOO, Mikes Hot Honey, Black Pepper And Shaved Parm The meatballs also had a generous amount of sauce which we couldn't let go to waste so we used the remaining sauce to dip our pizza crust :) Our only regret was seeing the sign for the broccolini as we were leaving! We'll have to try that next time. I'm also eyeballing the Romantica & Carnivore for my next meal at Pie95Pizza. read more

See all

I have been here several times since my first review and the pizza and appetizers are amazing every single time! Today I took a pizza making class, which was much more thorough than I had expected. We learned everything from the ingredients of the dough, to how to apply seasoning, to how to fully make a pizza. I will forever recommend Pie95, it really is my favorite pizza spot in Jacksonville. If I could eat the Bianca every day, I would! read more

See all

This was our first time and it's already one of our favorite pizza spots. So FAST!! The dough was delicious AF and the staff was super friendly! They recommended to try hot honey on the pie and they were right! Go here soon!! https://maps.app.goo.gl/kGwub7dbeoRSjmfr9 read more

Pizza was really good. The restaurant has limited seating but carry out is available. I also think they have seating in the back but it was cold and we didn't venture out. Everyone is friendly and helpful. We will definitely return. read more

We have enjoyed Pie95 pizza and love their meatballs. In the nice weather we like sitting out back, but unfortunately the last two times we were there the back patio has become a playground where parents are letting their children run around. I understand the need for this as a parent but a restaurant is not the place for this. Bring the kids to the park to let them run around. read more

Very simple and fast service. You order your food, get your number, and receive your food fresh and hot right to your table! The restaurant itself is a little bit tight inside and out front but Its not a big deal most pizza spots are like that especially up north. We ended up moving to one of the tables outside. I really love that they have the back patio area with some picnic tables and warm lighting . The pizza was a bit softer than I like tbh but the flavor was there. I like my thin crusts to be a little more crunchy or cooked mine was still a bit doughy. We ordered a Margherita pizza and it was Fresh so I'll give them that. We also ordered the broccalini which was probably the most fancy broccoli I've had and it was soo good! Im not sure what the cheese cream was but it complimented the veggie and the red sauce nicely. Lastly, our Tiramisu was fresh and creamy I just wish it had more of a coffee flavor to it although it was still a nice dessert to finish off our meal. read more

See all

We've been to Pie 95 twice now that our daughter has moved to Jax. Hands down, this is the best pizza we've had outside of CT - and that's saying a lot bc we are minutes from the best pizza in the US. So easy to give this place 5 stars! Light and airy dough and the freshest toppings make the pizzas here great. The owner is a really nice guy and takes great pride in the food he serves. Can't wait to go back :) Thank you, Pie 95! read more

See all

Super yummy wood fired pizza! We want to devour the entire pie every time. Last week we tried their speciality white pizza with bacon on top and they had a lemon slice for us to use on the pizza. I never saw this before but wow did it give it a special touch!! The meatball apps are also super yummy. They have outdoors seating in the back and lent us a Jenga game to play with our daughter. Love the service and the food! read more

Pie95 Pizza - Meatball app! - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

See all

We actually like the pizza here (reason why it's a 2 star review instead of one), so I'm bummed our 2nd experience wasn't good. We came in at 4, as we'd forgotten they didn't open until 4:30 on Friday. The owner(?) was initially friendly, and invited us to wait in the back where the kids would have room to play. They had a few planters with flowers out back, but not much else to hold the kids attention. The girls picked a few flowers while our son looked for lizards. At about the 4:30 mark, owner came out and walked past us, no acknowledgment. On his way back in, he said something along the lines of, "Can you guys not let your kids pick the flowers?" I replied, "Oh sure, sorry about that," to which he just shook his head. No "Thank you guys so much for waiting, we're ready to take your order" or anything resembling kindness. Sorry dude, my daughters are 3 and 5, and there's nothing for them to do out back. It's fine to ask us to keep them from picking flowers, but why drop the friendliness you had when we came? And why not acknowledge that we just waited a half hour to give you business? There are plenty of great wood fire pizza places around here, like Moon River, where the customer service is always fantastic (and consequently where we ended up going instead of staying at Pie95). Kindness and courtesy go a long way.. unfortunately, we probably won't be coming back to Pie95. read more

Decided to try Pie95 this past Saturday. They opened at 5, I entered at 5:05 and the place was already crowded. The inside is just a vibe. Brick, wood, exposed vents. It was industrial, modern, extremely casual and welcoming. The staff were super friendly, positive and just seemed excited for me to be there. I had called ahead, live very close, and was able to watch them prepare our pizza and garlic boat. The pizza is put into the brick oven and spun by hand consistently so it cooks fully and evenly. What separates this pizza place from others? Because of the care they take in preparation, your toppings and the outer crust of your pizza is well done and crispy. But, when you bite in, the dough is soft, fresh and delicious. That is not done anywhere else and truly makes for a unique pizza experience. Our garlic bread was much the same great experience but featured great flavoring with garlic and oil. A great experience and will be back. Highly recommend this place. If there is one opportunity, it's the price point for what you get. $20 pizza and $9 garlic bread should be bigger. I don't know the exact size of the pizza, but it would be a medium in most locations. It's also their business the way they run their business but, I'd love to see the place open for lunch hours or just 7-8 hours on any given day. read more

See all

Do you Love Wood Fired pizza & wings? This is will be one of your favorite spots in northeast florida you will want to try, and keep coming back to. Now there are other wood fired pizza places here in Jax, and yes they are very good too. (V's pizza) If I could offer one tasty tip to the newbies out there: try Chef Evan's (owner) seasonal appetizers & side plates. He makes something really special based on what is currently in season, and keeps a rotating door of new things to try each time you visit which I love. You've got the staple fave's which you know you are going to order, and then you also have the new, exciting side dishes to try as well. It's really a win win. I skip lunch on days I know I'll be eating pie95 for dinner knowing I'll be ordering a lot of different items to eat : ) It's worth the wait! Check out the outdoor patio area. It's nice and open, and welcoming to four legged friends too if you want to bring the whole family along. There are big umbrellas to cover each picnic table to shade from the sun or afternoon sprinkle. This time of year, as we enter the fall season, is the best time to enjoy their outdoor patio space. Wednesday is wine night for all of you Vino lovers. Beer is also available here too. read more

See all

Place was nice and clean and the service was excellent, guy that took my order was cool and food was nicely presented and very delicious ! Will definitely be coming back ! read more

From the moment I arrived and could feel the warmth emanating from the stove I knew I was in for a special treat. Kind smiles were additionally welcoming from the employee staff and its owner. A private dinner event I was attending was being held in their spacious outdoor pavilion that was filled with picnic tables and umbrellas. The interior decor was inviting and displayed some lovely artwork. Very clean and comfy with great views of the pizza oven. From the salad and fresh mozzarella, tasty lemon pepper wings, onto a delicious meatball flatbread and amazing tasting Margherita pizza...I'm glad I saved my appetite all day to enjoy it all! You just have to stop in and try for yourself, cause I know I'll be back soon for some more! read more

See all

This place has high reviews so I set my expectations high. The pizza was ok and the ingredients were fresh. It was a little bland IMO. Reminds me of V pizza. The service was good. I'd stop by again if I was in the area and craved this style of pizza. Not my favorite but not my least favorite either. read more

I will happily drive 45 minutes for this pizza! I'm a sucker for wood fired oven pizza, and this always hits the spot. I'm a traditional girl so it's Margherita or pepperoni for me, but they're all really good. And don't sleep on Chef's specials! He creates delicious plates showcasing seasonal locally grown ingredients, and his incredible talent in the kitchen. read more

Pie95 Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

Best pizza in Jax BY FAR. Not even close. Everything is super fresh and flavorful, cooked to perfection in a legit brick oven. Owner is as nice as can be and is there EVERY DAY to ensure quality pies. I CANT RECOMMEND THIS PLACE ENOUGH!!! read more

I am a fan of wood-fired pizzas, and hands down, this is my favorite pizza place in Jacksonville. The crust flavor and bake are excellent, and the toppings are first rate. Additionally, my experience has been that their pizza quality is consistent; I get it delivered and have never been disappointed. Favorites: Romantica and Blanca read more

Pie95 had been on our radar for quite some time now. We stopped by in November last year but were turned away because they had sold out of all their dough. We finally had another chance to try them out on Friday evening. The interior was pretty cool with an open kitchen and visible wood-fired oven. Hubby and I were with several of his work colleagues, 8 of us all together. Hubby and I order the pepperoni and the Bianca along with 2 Orange Blossom beers. The pizza was really good. I also liked the size of each pizza, slightly bigger than a personal pizza. The pepperoni was a little bit more floppy than I like but I still enjoyed it. The Bianca was excellent especially with a squeeze of lemon juice. I really liked the roasted garlic and fresh mozzarella. The crust on both was nicely charred and had a nice chew to it. The pizza itself was 4 stars. Unfortunately, I had to knock a star off because of the way we were treated on our way out. I will admit our group was talking loudly, however, we were the only people left in the restaurant. We were all getting up and gathering our belongings when the owner yelled from behind the counter at us to "take it down a notch". We were taken aback since we were cleaning up, collecting our takeout boxes, etc and it was very clear that we were leaving. He kept yelling but I didn't hear everything he said because I was one of the first people to walk out. I have never been treated that way in a restaurant. It was completely uncalled for and extremely rude! There is a way to talk to customers and a way to not talk to customers. That was not the way. Due to this disrespectful treatment, I will not return to Pie95. read more

Pie95 Pizza - The Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

See all

The best wood fired Pizza in Jax! Staff is always friendly and the restaurant has a welcoming atmosphere. If you're in Jax, don't miss out on the opportunity to get some Pie 95! Eat a slice! read more

We tried a couple local pizza places on a Friday night and looking to avoid an hour+ wait time, we kept driving around. Stumbling upon pie95 and I remembered one of my friends mentioning it was their new go to pizza spot. From the outside, pie95 has a very cozy vibe with the wood burning pizza oven and open kitchen. No way would they have an open table given the small footprint, I thought. To our surprise there were several open tables. Score! We asked the staff for two of their very best pizzas and after a very enthusiastic debate from the team, they recommended that we try a margherita and a bianca. They were very proud to get the basic components of these pizzas mastered and recommended we give them a try versus other pies that were loaded up with more toppings. Okay looking at these mostly bread options sans meat I thought we might need some protein on the side. We bit off a little more than we could chew with an order of 24 hot wings. They were good! Definitely spicy but not breaded. We tried some meatballs as well and these had a nice soft texture. The garlic bread - made with the pizza dough was nice served with marinara and it seemed like a good amount of olive oil, no butter. I especially enjoyed the bianca pizza. The lemon was a super fresh twist on a classic that didn't feel out of place surprisingly. read more

See all

This is my new pizza spot! We are obsessed! Pie95 is located in Riverside and has street parking outside. They are open for dine in and takeout. I recently moved to Jacksonville and was told by probably 10 different people that this was the best pizza in Jax. They did not steer me wrong! We went on a rainy Friday night expecting to get takeout pizza and head home. Once we saw indoor dining (since it was raining), we decided to stay and have a full dinner there. The owner Evan explained that the vegetable dish changes seasonally. Right then it was red beets, and we started with that. Red beets, orange slivers, over ricotta and drizzled with good olive oil and pistachios. Amazing. I ate this whole appetizer by myself and loved every bite. On to the burrata caprese. I love Italian food and this is definitely an amazing presentation and preparation of the burrata. Don't skip the apps. My boyfriend really enjoyed the meatballs which were drizzled in hot honey. I thought that was super unique and had never heard of anything like it. For pizzas we tried the margherita and "the works" (half without pepperoni for me). Both pizzas were hot, fresh, and the perfect amount of doughy and crunchy. I thought we were spoiled with great wood fired pizza in Pittsburgh, but this is seriously the best I've had. I really love their red sauce especially. They have a great system down in the kitchen, and it wass fun to watch them make the pizzas. They could definitely charge way more for their food. Everything was incredible. We have ordered it for pick up two more times and everything was just as amazing after being in the car for 10 minutes. 5 stars! read more

See all

Omg! I'm a third generation Italian immigrant and I love fresh dough. My friends at Keg and Coin recommended I come here. Plus they sell fresh dough!! I've bought dough from Mellow Mushroom and Al's Pizza and nothing compares! A local artist Maiyae Elaine who works here sells her art work on the walls. Talk about supporting the local economy!!! They have a wide variety of pizzas available. Its a small scale fast casual business. After I ordered there was a line out the door. It looks like a fun atmosphere and I would love to work here. The first thing I ordered was a margarita pizza and then I ordered a "herbivore" to go, both checked all of my boxes! read more

See all

I am a Connecticut native who moved to Jacksonville a year ago from NY, and I have been desperately seeking good pizza since I got here. Thanks to Pie95, my search is over. This is real deal pizza that would hold its own in the tri-state area. Excellent crust, quality ingredients, a sauce that strikes a perfect balance, and nice owners. Without question, this is the best pizza in Jacksonville. I give this place my highest and unqualified recommendation, and I grew up on Sally's Appiza in New Haven! read more

Pie95 Pizza - Margherita pizza - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

Bottomless Prosecco on Wednesday nights need I say more!!! The Bianca was great and the wings were good. I needed a bit more flavor on mine but overall great and so cute in the restaurant and nice patio. Service was good and I really enjoyed. We will be back and try a special next time!!! read more

Pie95 Pizza - 7 Piece Jumbo Wood Fired Curry Lemon Pepper Wings - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

See all