All the candles are soooo cool The drinks are made with care and the well liquor is high quality. I recommend coming here if you want to experience a drink made by a mixologist. Beyond the mixology, the bar is very approachable and easy for just a regular drink as well. I ordered the vesper: gin and vodka martini with a twist. The good cocktails and super intimate vibe make for a great recipe. There are a couple high quality leather upholstered couches. Along with the couches there are a few high tops and a good amount of seats at the bar. The space would be very fun when crowded but I tend to prefer to have to have the bar to myself. Then I can spend time talking with the person behind the bar (I'm sure I can be very annoying) I was served by Karena. She was super knowledgeable and patient. I wanted to talk about different cocktails and really get the full experience. The whole visit exceeded my expectations. Beyond the drinks, service, and decor; this place is truly something special. read more

See all

For dinner the pizzas are pretty good. The lure is definitely the bar in the back! The service is great and everyone is very friendly. read more

I visited Pie Society with my friend on a Saturday evening. There was a parking lot by the building, so we had no issues with finding a spot. Locating the Pie Society speakeasy entrance was no issue--there are two ways in: through Pitfire Pizza or from the back of the building. There was initially only a couple other people when we arrived, but the place started filling up with more people throughout our meal. I ordered the vegetarian white bean soup & the everybody wants some cocktail. My friend got the margherita pizza as well as the in the cosmos cocktail & life of the party cocktail. The bartender was friendly & very helpful in offering their advice on which drink we should try. I liked the calm atmosphere & fun decor of this speakeasy. Would visit again! read more

See all

Located inside the Pitfire Pizza. You can either go through the pizza place or the back door from the parking lot. Nothing fancy but hands down for best pizzas/finger foods and amazing service from the bartenders. Drinks are also on points! read more

Pie Society - Green tea Whiskey Sour - Pizza Near Me - Costa Mesa, California

Came for the vibes stayed for the pizza. Service was quick, our server took our drink and pizza order right when we got in. The pizza took some time before it came out, but my god was it delicious. The pizza was unique and tasty. The crust had a nice texture when chewing and held together well. read more

Pie Society - Pizza Near Me - Costa Mesa, California

Had to take some back entrance to this speakeasy since it is behind a pizza shop. The drinks were good, but nothing amazing. The ambiance was pretty cool. Not a huge space, but was lucky to get a spot at the bar. I enjoyed my experience, but would probably go to other speakeasys since I wasn't in love with the drinks. read more

See all

I love this place! Parking is a lot in the back, I've never had any issues finding any. Got the California red blend wine which was yummy. For food got the honey bear pizza as well as the ifkyk. Both were tasty, hot, & fresh! Service was fast & friendly. Loved the vibe of the bar, very low lighting & nice couches to sit on with interesting decor. Would recommend to anyone. read more

Been here many time and always a breeze. Cute little speakeasy bar tucked behind the Pizza joint. They make amazing drinks and have good drink specials. Inside is small and cozy. :) We usually order Pizza and it's always great. Highly recommend this bar read more

Speakeasy located near the parking lot behind Pitfire Pizza. It's a dimly intimate space with a hustling/bustling atmosphere. Surprisingly loud for a speakeasy with limited seating inside and outside. When I think Speakeasy, I think crafted drinks. To my disappointment the cocktails were subpar. Perfect Paloma - I had high expectations of this because of the name "perfect". It was an average tasting Paloma with a very feint grapefruit flavor from the Fever Tree Grapefruit soda they use. Far from feeling like a crafted drink, and tasted a bit watered down. Green Tea Whisky Sour - Tasted sorta like a sherbet float because of the egg white texture and sweet/sour notes. I didn't taste the green tea at all. There's a lot of carb options to complement your drinking pleasure - pasta, pizzas, breads galore. We didn't try the food but will definitely try if we ever come back. Service was friendly and attentive enough despite the busy crowd. read more

Pie Society - Bar - Pizza Near Me - Costa Mesa, California

See all

Such a fun place to go to! The drinks are well priced and delish. The pizza and wings are also pretty yummy. read more

Pie Society - Pizza Near Me - Costa Mesa, California

The walk in was nice, heard laughs from the customers and voices of the barteners before i had walked in through the suspensful door. Karina made some whicked cocktails and max talked some good times. The music was a little off and could see the atmosphere being affected by it, luckily, the talks were louder. A pretty good time beside the weird music. read more

The chopped salad was delicious! The chicken pesto pizza was delicious! The crust was perfection! The bartender was really creative and my mezcal old fashioned was really good! The decor is mid-century modern, with retro signs, very cool dive bar. Definitely come here for the vibe. You won't be disappointed. read more

Pie Society - Chicken pesto pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Costa Mesa, California

First time trying pie society and it did not disappoint! It's right behind Pit Fire pizza building with a bright sign. The place is small but pretty roomy for small groups with a bar and has a cool eclectic vibe. The pizza was sooo good and tastes 100% fresh and authentic. Like the crust, cheese and that sauce, ugh, you just have to try for yourself! The cocktails are carefully crafted and also very good. Overall it's a nice little spot to check out and enjoy if you're ever in Costa Mesa and craving a delicious pizza and cocktail. read more

Pie Society - two cocktails on a table - Pizza Near Me - Costa Mesa, California

Great bar comfort food with epic drinks. It's one of the better speak easy bars. The drinks are phenomenal and the service is exceptional. I love the sign "sip down and stay humble." The staff and vibe is mellow and humble. Love it. read more

See all

I always have a great time here! A couple of the things about this bar that I love are the ambiance and seating areas. The drinks are also super delicious and the bartenders are very kind. As a girl, I have frequent the bathroom, and I've never had to wait in a line to go. Maybe I just get lucky. read more

Really cute bar, bartenders are mid career mixologists so they're pretty skilled and the design is great! Only issue is the close quarters cause noise to be pretty significant on a busy night, but that's any bar of this level really. I totally would recommend coming here! read more

For a "speakeasy", it was more of a speak loudly...it was a busy and loud night. We went on a Saturday night around 9pm and it was CROWDED. Also sticky. They do not limit the amount of people coming in like other speakeasy's, so the crowd, noise and overall feel was very dive bar-like. Luckily we found a table with enough stools for a group of 4 and went up to the bar to order since it didn't seem like there was any table service... But it did take us a while to get situated in this space, as in -- find seating, figure out if theres a menu and where we can get one, if there is table service and so on. Drinks did not impress us either. No draft beers, only cans. But we do want to come back and try the pizza from the adjoining space since that did look good.....and they have beers on tap. If we could have ordered pizzas while at pie society,, we wouldn't have known since no staff informed us. Tldr: not great for big parties, there is a parking lot, and it gets busy since there is no limit to capacity or reservation. I would not categorize this as a speakeasy, only maybe on a day where capacity is at 10 and not 40 in a small space like here. If you just want a nice space for pizza and beers, skip this place and just make the stop at pit fire next door. read more

Pie Society - Drinks menu April 2023 - Pizza Near Me - Costa Mesa, California

See all

I know I say this about a lot of places but THIS IS IT! A speakeasy with pizza?! Let me get a pizza that. It is so yummy. The pizza is delish and the drinks are great!!! I have been here on a few dates and it has such a fun and dark vibe. Very romantic! Don't love the high seats because I'm so short but the couches are fun. I wish there were games!!! Would be a fun addition. Service at the bar is good but if you're ordering pizza, it takes a minute. Worth it. I'll be back for sure !!! read more

Pie Society - Hot honey pizza - Pizza Near Me - Costa Mesa, California

See all

I absolutely love this little speakeasy. Just had my company Christmas party here and it was perfect. I used to be in the industry and I love the team's cocktail knowledge and execution. They are always so so nice. We always have a great experience here. read more

Pie Society - Shouse Construction Christmas Party time - Pizza Near Me - Costa Mesa, California

I come here for the music and the best bartenders/drinks!! Don't ever change pie society cm

I am in such a bliss having finally found a perfect place to hangout! Pie Society and Pittfire is amazing!!!! The staff here are the best and the food esp the pizza is tasty! We just got back from our Italian trip and have tasted the authentic ones but this pizza is our new go to place for a flavorful California made pizza. To the staff and the owner, thumbs up!!! read more

Always wanted to go to a speak easy and this was our first one. It was AMAZING! The experience of walking in to the secret door was so cool and the small, intimate bar was so fun. LOVED the clarified pins colada drink, pretty bird was okay. The PIZZA WOW! We got the IYKYK pizza and are hooked. Prices are reasonable as well. Such a great date night experience. Definitely will be back! read more

Pie Society - Clarified Pina Colada (small cup) and Pretty Bird (large cup) - Pizza Near Me - Costa Mesa, California

See all

The greatest speakeasy in OC, the ambiance is great. I recommend the Mac & Cheese with buffalo sauce. The service from all the bartenders is spot on, they make the best drinks. They play the best music in the bar. read more

Karina, Max, and Cade are the best! The playlist is the absolute best I love it ! The service and the food are amazing!! I can not recommend this place enough. read more

Our favorite bar ever!! The music is amazing... there's so many bars in Costa Mesa but nobody has good music and better cocktails. Max and Cade are the best. Always a good time and they're the reason we keep coming back! read more

Really cool spot! We couldn't find the entrance at first but the ambiance was cool and the drinks were good. A pretty small spot but service was good! read more

Pie Society - Pizza Near Me - Costa Mesa, California

See all

reallly cool speakeasy. The entrance was so dope. Drinks were ok taste wise, strong on alcohol tho which isn't a bad thing. didn't order food but really loved the environment. bartender was nice and recommended what to get. would come back here and maybe get a slice pizza next door hehe. read more

Pie Society - Pizza Near Me - Costa Mesa, California

Pie Society has been on my list of must try pizzas for awhile and I finally had the chance to cross it off my list! They're located behind Pitfire Pizza (enter through the back door by the parking lot. Upon first impressions...it's a super cozy spot, not too big, comfy sofas, friendly bartender, and a cute date night spot. They also have tables on their patio with heaters. We grabbed a seat at one of the sofas and ordered 3 pizzas, meatballs, and a few cocktails. My favorite of the 3 pizzas (honey bear, IYKYK, and sausage party) was honey bear. It was super unique, a perfect blend of sweet and spicy and overall just delicious. The other pizzas were really good too but that one was my favorite. I'll definitely be back soon! read more

Pie Society - Pizza Near Me - Costa Mesa, California

I never leave yelp reviews, but I feel this was more than warranted after the worst service I have EVER experienced at a restaurant in my entire life. I frequent this speakeasy quite often & have no idea if the two bartenders who closed on June 6th were just in a bad mood or what. From the moment my party sat down, they made sure our party felt like they were going out of their way for putting in an order of drinks. Literally had one round and when we walked to the bar to ask for another round, we were cut off mid sentence with "WE ARE CLOSED". Mind you, the hours of operation state you're not and they never once gave us a heads up that they were closing soon and maybe let us know in case we want a second round? Guess not, because everything is clearly revolving around the two bartenders and whatever mood they're currently in... It's an absolute shame because I truthfully love the food and drinks here, but there is zero chance I am coming back to this establishment. Figure other patrons and management need to know how horrendous the "service" was last night. Good luck, I will not be back. read more

Awesome little bar hidden behind Pitfire Pizza. Not hard to find, but if I didn't know there was a bar there, I would've never known. We came on a Tuesday evening around 8pm and the place filled up pretty quickly. Space is limited so arrive early and grab a seat. Parking was easy. Lots of drinks to choose from, including various kinds of bourbons and whiskey. They even had an option for whiskey flights which is super cool. We didn't order food but you can order food from the Pitfire and the pizza looked delicious. Next time will definitely have to try the pizza. read more

Pie Society - Pizza Near Me - Costa Mesa, California

This spot is tucked behind Pitfire Pizza. I drove through the parking lot thinking I was in the wrong place. After you park, walk towards the right side of the back and there's a door that will lead you to their outdoor seating. It wasn't too busy on a Friday night at 6pm. A few small parties spread throughout the area but the bar was open. Service was great, quick, and seamless. I only stopped for one drink, but contemplated getting food and more drinks that I don't need. I got the Pretty Bird because it sounded different from what I normally drink and there was egg white. Love a cocktail with egg whites. It wasn't as spirit forward as I usually like my cocktails, but this was very tasty and fruity. I do want to go back to try their other offerings. Great spot for a date night or small group. I couldn't imagine a larger group in this space. Music was low so you don't need to yell to have a normal conversation as well. read more

See all

Dark date vibes speakeasy with really good pizza! There's two entrances; one from the back parking lot and another through the kitchen inside the restaurant. Small and cozy inside. Saw a lot of couples on dates, even first dates (I'm nosy lol). Ordered the pepperoni and enough to feed two people. Drinks were good too. Everything is decently priced for the area. Service was also attentive and friendly. Found seats right away on a Tuesday evening. read more

See all

Sorry pictures are such a weird color - we sat outside on the speakeasy side so the lighting wasn't great. This place is so cool! It's a speakeasy but also a restaurant! There's a back patio area that is indoor/outdoor. The inside doesn't get pretty busy so try to come a little early if you want to sit inside, but the outside wasn't bad at all. The Caesar salad was so good!!! So delicious with the breadcrumbs! The margarita was delicious - I love that the cheese doesn't fall of once it comes out. read more

Pie Society - Margarita pizza - Pizza Near Me - Costa Mesa, California

See all

Absolutely delicious food! I highly recommend the Mac and Cheese, but also cannot leave here without at least a small pizza. also everything is a great size for sharing! read more

This place has been on my list for a while since they have a vegan cheese option you can add to your pizza. Upon entering your order at the counter and then take your number and sit down. I do wish they had a smaller pizza size so that I could get one pizza and half that be my serving. This is about two servings for me and so I it ended up being a little bit more expensive than I wanted to spend but I had leftovers. The vegan cheese is very delicious. They use on the pizza. I added some tomatoes olives, and bell pepper. The pizza was really delicious. However I was not that big of a fan of the thick crust. I usually really enjoy pizza crust, but I wasn't that big of a fan so I ended up leaving the crust and not eating it. The server was nice and checked on us multiple times and brought us a water and glasses, which was nice to have. Inside they have a lot of booths and it is a very casual vibe. There was a birthday party going on and for a Tuesday night the ambience was casual and pretty quiet. I have heard it gets busy here on weekends. read more

Pie Society - Vegan pizza with tomatoes olives - Pizza Near Me - Costa Mesa, California

What a happy hidden little speakeasy this is. They not only have some great cocktails on the menu, but they also serve up some fanatic food from the pizza shop! Being dairy free isn't an issue here as there's something for everyone. The bartenders are knowledgeable and the food comes out quickly. It can get a bit loud and there's not a lot of seating, but well worth it if you can make it in! read more

Great vibes and atmosphere. I always love a good speakeasy with delicious cocktails and who doesn't love pizza?!?

This is the perfect dark, vibey speakeasy with good music, consistently decent food and chilled out service. Tonight Kade waited on us and he was great- mellow but on top of everything. We had chicken meatballs with roasted cauliflower and marinara, cheesy garlic bread & chopped salad which are all pretty much classic Italian-American comfort food. Could've done without the brussel sprouts which were basically raw but it's all so chill here that we didn't even mind . Honestly, it's not fine dining or farm to table or anything fancy like that, but it's cool, solid and has plenty of healthy options of you're looking to eat. Recommend. read more

Awesome speak easy inside Pitfire. The bartender here introduced me to east sides, which are my new favorite gin drinks! read more

Pie Society - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Costa Mesa, California

Love the experience and feel of the place! Tucked away behind the pizza place. It was SO crowded, we barely found a seat. Once a server came around and took our drink orders, it was about a 20-25 minute wait for our drinks, so that was a bummer My biggest concern was the smell. It smelled faintly of throw up, so that was ruining my vibe. Altogether, it was fun to experience but I'm not sure that I will be returning. Maybe to the pizza place though, that looked yummy read more

Pie Society - Life of the party - Pizza Near Me - Costa Mesa, California