Called and ordered 2 pies to pick up the next day. Banana Cream and mixed berry. Both were in the ice chest just like he said they would be. The berry was still warm and the banana cream was cold. We were on a family union and they devoured them, with a killer seafood dinner I had flown in from Alaska. Had to have ice cream on the berry pie. Yummy! read more

We bought a French apple pie at the Farmers Market downtown from Pie Guy. It was the worst pie my husband & I have ever eaten. Had to throw it out, $15, for lots of crumples and not much apple. Nothing was tasty about this pie. I definitely wouldn't recommend Pie Guy. read more

Great pies!! You wouldn't think so because they are sold at a gas station, don't let the location fool you! Their lemon meringue is delicious and they have seasonal fruit pies as well. The raspberry peach is a household favorite! read more

I'm not from the Flagstaff area but thought pie would be a nice change for lunch, saw Pie Guy on yelp and decided to give it a try. There is no restraurant or storefront which made it very difficult.... I received various locations via text message from baker (not knowing area streets intersections etc .). I drove around a lot and finally found a Marathon gas station that had four pies, i bought 3 of the 4 and so glad i did. Apple, cherry and peach all delicious, cherry being my favorite. They were baked fresh and delivered throughout the town at various locations. I was at my wits end finding a distribution point but very happy i did :). Thank you read more

Pie Guy pies are excellent! Best in town here in Flagstaff. Happy to have discovered where to get them.

Hubs really liked the apple pie, I however found the chunks way too big and annoying that I have to cut it into bite sized pieces read more

See all

These pies are amazing. Had to get ours at a Marathon station but possibly the best apple pie I've ever had. If in Flag go find one of these pies. read more

This guy knows his pies! My parents were always baffled that I wanted a birthday pie rather than a birthday cake and if the Pie Guy had been around back then, I would've been celebrating my birthday every day! Fantastic cream pies, love the chocolate and the banana but the berry pies, heated up a bit with a scoop of good vanilla ice cream, is the piece de resistance! The Bisbeeberry, a mix of blackberry and raspberry, is the fave in this house! I had family come from SoCal recently and I typically bring Pie Guy pies with us when we visit them, and what was the first thing they wanted to eat when they came to Flagstaff? Pie from the Pie Guy! Luckily I had grabbed a couple right down the street at Silver Saddle Trading Post. Look for the Pie Guy signs outside gas station convenience stores. There are several around FLG that carry them or contact directly to order and pick up from his home! "We must have pie. Stress cannot exist in the presence of a pie." ~ David Mamet read more

Pie Guy Pies - Bisbeeberry pie, a mix of blackberry and raspberry... - Convenience Stores Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

We have had over a dozen pies from "Pie Guys" and they have all been terrific! They also have a nice variety of pies and will allow you to special order certain pies with one day advance notice. (Key Lime is one that requires special one day advance order) My favorite! read more

Wonderful pies. Great combinations and love his crust. Our guest love what we order. You can pick it up the next day and still warm or go to several of his other locations around flagstaff. read more

I'm a pie snob. Pie is my favorite food. I usually avoid buying pie at stores or restaurants because it's just not as good as homemade. But then I tried a Pie Guy pie... The crust, which makes or breaks the pie in my opinion, is flaky and savory. It just melts in your mouth. The filling is sweet, rich and delicious! I've tried the apple, too many times to count, and the chocolate cream. I'll be looking for a cherry pie next time I roll through Flag. read more

Pie Guy Pies - A slice of apple pie. - Convenience Stores Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

See all

Visiting Arizona with family and my mom wanted a pie for her birthday. We weren't able to find a berry pie in Sedona, so I yelped for options in Flagstaff. I called PGP and Charlie picked up and was super helpful and friendly. I ordered (via text) a chuckberry pie for pick up their home, at 4 pm the next day. The address was easy to navigate to and my pie was there waiting for me. We got home with some vanilla ice cream and dug right in (hence no picture of a whole pie), and it was delicious. The crust had a nice tender crumb and the filling had a nice flavor. My mom was pleased, so that's all that matters! Thank you PGP and all the Yelp reviews that guided me to you! Cheers! read more

Pie Guy Pies - Chuckberry - Convenience Stores Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

See all

Look up Charles of the Pie Guy's next time you're in Flagstaff. The pie's are exceptionally delicious. Best crust hands down. Our favorites are Cherry, pumpkin, and Chocolate Cream! He does sell them at a few local convenience stores as well. Or you can order ahead of time and pick up at his place. read more

The Pie Guy's pies are the best! Flaky crust and delicious fillings. Worth every penny.

Great pie at a great price You need to either order in advance and pick up at his place or find it on several gas stations read more

Pie Guy Pies - Berry pie - Convenience Stores Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

See all

If you are in flagstaff you must get one of these pies! Best I've every had. These 5 stores in Flagstaff carry these pies: Kachina Village's Pic and Run on I 17 Mobil at Butler and I 40 Silver Saddle on 89 in Doney Park Marathon Station on 4th and 7th Chevron at Highway 180 and Forest read more

Best pie ever! The apple filling was fresh...still had a slightly firm bite, slightly tart. The crust was flakey. This was like a home made pie...not too sweet. It's a bargain at $13.50. Pick one up from one of the gas stations indicated. You won't regret it! read more

See all

Delicious pies, funny getting them from a gas station. Loved the cherry and banana cream.

The best pie I've ever purchased from a Chevron gas station, or anywhere! The address is incorrect on the Yelp account so I called to find out which stores carry the pies. The pies are made to perfection. If you're in the area, you have to pick up one of these amazing pies. read more

We bought the crumb apple pie at the Pic-n-Run in Kachina Village. The pie looked good, but the crumb topping was super salty and had a weird, powdery texture. The pie crust itself was great. The apple filling was sparse of apples and really sweet, which made the salty crumble top stand out more. Not what we expected, as several people recommended these pies to us. Comparably, a grocery store brand pie would have been better. read more

Simply Delicious pies! The best in Flagstaff! There are four stores that carry his pies and they also may be picked up at his home. Highly recommended! read more

The peach gluten free pie was delicious! The pie guy prefers to have orders placed by text. He needs some advance notice for gluten free orders, a few days ahead of pick up. The pick up system is very easy and handy. read more

Great pies if you can hunt one down at the local convenience stores. We grabbed a banana cream pie and it was delicious. I'll definitely be on the lookout when I'm up in Flag. read more

Delicious homemade pies! We are so happy we found PIE GUY! He has his pies at the mobile station in town or you can call to order a fresh pie. We pick up the Blueberry pie at the gas station and ordered the pumpkin pie. The ingredients are so fresh, the crust melts in your mouth. Great pies! We appreciate the special order we put in; called him at 7pm and he had the pie HOT and ready for us at 7am! Birthday boy was happy he got pumpkin pie in August (special request)! We can't wait to try the Raspberry and Peach pie! Definitely coming back for more pie form THE PIE GUY! read more

Pie Guy Pies - Best pies in town! - Convenience Stores Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

Absolutely delicious pies. Got the strawberry rhubarb and the chuckberry and these are probably the best pies I've ever had. You can definitely tell they are homemade and made with the special ingredients of love and care. Will be buying again. read more

I absolutely do not recommend this location. Yelp took me to a house. There was a pie guys van in the driveway, but I'm not eating pie in a house in an "ok" residential area. They do not serve pie out of that location! Seriously upset that I drove across town for nothing. Fix Yelp business owner!!!! read more

Amazing pies. Worth trying! The strawberry rhubarb is always a hit for parties. It was also nice to be able to order one of the pies half sweet if needed. read more

Amazing pies! Easy ordering and pick up! i wish we lived closer to Flagstaff but rest assured we will order more pies whenever it is possible for us to do so! read more

BisbeeBerry‼‼. You can't go wrong with these pies. Never a disappointment. Always fresh and delicious. YUM!

Pie Guys Pies is AMAZING!! During the holidays I got some amazing tasting Gluten Free pies. I've had the Bisbeeberry, Apple, and cherry. All are my favorites!! It's hard to find decent tasting GF pies, but these really are the best I've ever had. They are made fresh, and can be found at a few local gas stations in town. For GF, or custom orders you can pick up when they are ready. I highly recommend everyone to try Pie Guys Pies! read more

Good pie but don't dare follow the Yelp map to his location as he got pissed when I did so. Said "I'm not a pie store". Why is he on Yelp with all his contact information then?? read more

Charles, my man. I called him to order a cherry pie for my mom on her birthday. It was short notice (thx, mom lol) He gave me the store that he delivered one of his pies too and if it was gone he would make us one. Luckily, they had it. These pies are fucking incredible. The crust is perfect and crumbly. Perfect to eat with ice cream! Like seriously, we ate this whole pie in a day. It's great for breakfast, too! read more

Um... How is this level of amazing even possible? And I ordered a gluten free pie that's also sugar free (okay, I ordered two because.... Pie ) so... how? This is incredible! The crust is flaky, the price reasonable, apples are perfect (my fav kind of pie). I'm kind of low-key in awe. It's kind of perfect! As much as I've always loved pies, this is by far the best one I've had. And I happen to make a great apple pie with no sugar added, so I'm glad I was feeling unmotivated & ordered these because: it's incredible! Since going gluten free I've not been able to get the great crust achieved but they sure have, goodness. Suggest anyone who enjoys pie order from here because my "okay, I'll try a bite before dinner" turned in to two pieces of pie becoming my dinner instead because it was too delicious (plus life is short; eat pie). I hope they add other dishes to their menu because the flakiness & lovely flavor of gluten free crust was kind of impossibly delicious. & it would be great to get more of that with regular meals. Having to go gluten free, begrudgingly, has made many options either impossible to find or disappointing. Not here, they absolutely rock & in an impossibly tasty way! I'll be ordering from here again! Hoping my impulse control checks out because I'm pretty sure pie is all I'll be eating until it's gone & I have no choice but to eat "traditional meals" ‍. I'm so excited & wondering how gluten free & sugar free can be this epic. Yay! Do it: order pie! Live your best life lol. read more

This guy is kinda of a jerk but his cream pies are good. When I asked about payment, because I couldn't understand his text, he became agitated. The easy pies like apple n cherry are ok but overpriced. You can find the same at Sprouts for a lot less. But the banana and chocolate creams are delightful. read more

This guy's pies are even better than my mom's - sorry mom, but you're in heaven so you won't read this. He made me a plain rhubarb pie. I love rhubarb pie, but not strawberry-rhubarb. In fact, I'm going to call him Monday and order myself a rhubarb pie to celebrate Winter Solstice. May we all find joy this season. read more

Love this place! The owner was extremely accommodating (we were visiting from Phoenix) and offered to make us a fresh pie if we didn't find the one we were looking for at the store. It was my first time purchasing a pie from a gas station, but it was WORTH IT! Even the cashiers were telling me how much they love the pies. I will definitely be going back when I visit next and really want to shine a light on how awesome the owner was. It's hard to find places with great service. read more

This address is a physical home. I think their business address should probably be removed unless they update it noting that it is a home in a housing community. read more

I can't say enough about these pies. I am completely in love and obsessed with the Lemon Creme Pie. I've tried the Banana Creme Pie and the Chocolate Cream Pie which are both yummy but lemon is my favorite in all things. When I couldn't find a Lemon Creme Pie, because they go fast, I reached out to the owner who was more than accommodating. I picked up my pie the next day. BEST. PIES. EVER! read more

Best pies I've ever eaten! Our favorite is the cherry and the pecan pie! Love that he delivers them to gas stations around Flag!

Great pies - yum yum. Someone brought a pecan pie for friends to sample. So good. Try this place.