My sis told me about this place. Went here with her on saturday morning. We got the brownie pie, honey almond apple pie, passionfruit cake, brownie, bacon quiche, and the emma sandwich. It was all delicious i just wish the pie was a bit bigger since it was pricey. read more

Pie Girl - Cafes Near Me - Hightstown, New Jersey

See all

The pizza here is so good!!! I'm def a savory girly so I love that they have other items other than sweets! The pies are so good and so fun that they change it up weekly! read more

Pie Girl - Cafes Near Me - Hightstown, New Jersey

See all

Pie Girl knows what she's doing while whipping up her incredible pies. I love the whole concept of a weekly rotating menu, and it seems that each item is perfectly curated. The way to go is ordering a "frankenpie," a slice of each of the 6 weekly pie creations. The crust is thin and flaky, and the fillings moist and heavenly. Business hours are extremely limited, open just 2 days a week from 10-2(ish?). Pie Girl had been on my radar for some time now, but my work schedule and almost 40 minute commute to her storefront had made the trip difficult. Finally, I was able to make it around 10:40 am on a Saturday. To my pleasant surprise, it was not overly busy and I was able to order within a few minutes. I left with: - frankenpie (6 different slices of pie) - sausage, onion jam & swiss galette - mushroom & goat cheese galette - sea salt brownie - earl grey lavender cornmeal cake - miso peanut butter cookie - goat cheese caramel chip cookie - cold brew with vanilla bean cold foam All of the above rang up to a whopping $75. I was definitely expecting to pay above average prices, but was still a bit shocked to hear the total cost. I have no problem paying more for excellent treats (and these were, in fact, excellent) but no where in the store, or on the website, can you find the prices of each individual item. I wanted to make the most out of my long-awaited trip and order plenty of goodies, but I honestly would have scaled back had I known the prices prior to being rung up. It almost felt... sneaky? The pies and galettes were the obvious standout menu items for me. The cold brew was also delicious. The rest of my items were very good, but probably not worth whatever price I had paid for them. Will I be back? Yes. Will I make my choices more selectively? Yes :) Overall, a charming bakery with kind staff and unique flavors, albeit on the pricier side. read more

See all

I've been looking forward to visiting Pie Girl since I first came across them on social media because of the unique offerings they have. My expectations were very high and my expectations were easily met if not exceeded! Wifey and I went there for lunch but both of us ended up getting breakfast sandwiches. I had a variation of their 'Emma' sandwich which is pork roll, egg, cheese, hash brown and mustard on a brioche bun. I subbed sausage for the pork roll. My wife ordered steak, egg and cheese on a brioche bun. Both sandwiches knocked it out of the park Aaron Judge style! We both agreed they were two of the best breakfast sandwiches we've had in a long time. We got an assortment of baked goods to take home and as of this writing everything we've eaten has been delicious! We plan on eating the rest over the weekend. We got crumb cake, a raspberry brownie, lemon chess pie, Hoosier pie and brown butter chocolate chip cookies. I got a cardamom rose latte that impressed this non coffee drinker to the point that I may consider drinking more coffee but only if it tastes like this. Cafe is very quaint with a relaxed vibe that's perfect for sipping slowly from a warm drink and just whiling the afternoon away. This was our first visit but won't be our last! read more

Pie Girl - Crumb cake and raspberry brownie. - Cafes Near Me - Hightstown, New Jersey

See all

Pie Girl is a quaint little venue only open limited hours on Fridays and Saturdays. Essentially open until everything is sold. The selection of sweet and savory pies is extraordinary and everything is baked fresh. Chelsea, the owner, is very friendly and works hard to bring her pies to life. I ordered a slice of tbe Passionfruit Pie upon the suggestion of some patrons and staff. It was certainly good, but a bit too sweet for me. Also a little pricey at $7 a slice. I look forward to going back and trying some more of the delectable creations. read more

Pie Girl - Savory Quiche - Cafes Near Me - Hightstown, New Jersey

See all

Visited Pie Girl on Friday while visiting my daughter in NJ. AMAZING! Some is the best back goods and focaccia pizza I have ever had. And I am in my 60's. Run don't walk to this amazing bakery. read more

See all

Long lines for a reason, I find myself crawling back here again and again for some pie, scones and galettes. Everything here is baked fresh for the day and the changing menu keeps things interesting. Highly recommend. read more

Heard some great things about Pie Girl so stopped by on Saturday - only open Friday & Saturday 10:00-2:00. Located on a side street off Main St in a restored building (plenty street parking). The menu changes each week so we took out a slices of quiche, buttermilk pie and chocolate chip cookies - total $19. Warmed up the quiche and it was so good (flakey crust). The buttermilk pie was perfect balance of sweetness/creamy filling with the same flakey crust. There's seating inside and they serve various coffees and drinks. Will go back soon to try more goodies. read more

Pie Girl - Daily specials - sandwiches looked amazing - Cafes Near Me - Hightstown, New Jersey

Amazing pies! We opted for the Franken-pie. A mix of types I selected, 1/4 pie each. There's other baked goods, but that's for the next visit. read more

My favorite small business in Hightstown. I love that the menu changes every weekend. I am there every weekend! So much variety of savory and sweet, there is something for everyone. I love that local and seasonal produce are used in the baked goods. I love the unique ingredient combinations. I love the flaky crust pies! They also serve teas, coffee and other beverages. My usual is a cold brew with a different flavored cold foam each week (always delicious). Its a very warm and friendly shop. read more

Pie Girl is incredible. Every week they have new, interesting, and exciting flavors and I can't help but buy an entire frankenpie almost every time I visit. The Salted Honey Lavender, Lemon Coffeecake, and Coconut Custard are some of our favorites. Aside from the pie, this bake shop also has some of the best sandwiches I've ever had in my life. How could you go wrong with fresh Italian meats and cheeses on a fresh baked focaccia and a slice of pie for dessert? The breakfast sandwiches are also loaded and delicious. I couldn't be happier to support such an outstanding small business. Every person working there is always bright and welcoming. It's so exciting to visit and see all of the creativity in the food being offered that week. Thank you for being such an amazing addition to Hightstown! read more

Pie girl has perfected the art of light and delicate treats with the most savory, flakey crust. Everything here is fantastic. Nothing is artificial and overly sweetened. Just the right hint of flavors for each unique creation she comes up with. Always something different to try from herbal to fruity. Highly recommend the pbj cookies and galettes in particular. Hours are scare; hoping that expands eventually. Prices are steep, but worth every penny for the hard work and love put into each pastry. read more

Pie Girl - Black tea and mint custard pie. Unique, light flavor and crispy crust. Pretty yummy but a steep $7 for a tiny slice. - Cafes Near Me - Hightstown, New Jersey

See all

We popped in passing through town and what a treat! The pie is amazing! Very welcoming and friendly. Service with a smile, and the best part of it all was the pie and cake tastes amazing. I like minimal crust on the bottom with a crunch and maximum filling. This was a perfect 5 star pie. Wonderful afternoon treat with a cup of tea, now off to football at the dome. We ate it before I could get a picture. read more

I don't know why I didn't come sooner, maybe because I just figured they only had pie? The service was super friendly and the food was even better. I didn't know they had coffee--though no specialty drinks like espresso, but I'll get a drink next time. We got a pumpkin scone and a broccoli quiche to stay. Both were perfect. The scone wasn't dry at all, and the quiche was flavorful. We ended up getting a couple of slices of pie to go--an apple and an orange buttermilk chess. The apple pie was quite good but the chess was a bit sweet. I'll be back to try out more items! read more

Pie Girl - Pumpkin scone - Cafes Near Me - Hightstown, New Jersey

See all

Friend brought some pastries and a Frankenpie to share and WOW- everything was so good. Highlights for me were the scones, mushroom galette, and earl grey custard. Can't wait to try more next time we're back in Jersey! read more

Pie Girl - Menu posted on IG - Cafes Near Me - Hightstown, New Jersey

My friend got a pie and was talked into an expensive franken pie, it looked horrible with missing crust when she went back she was told rudely that's what it's supposed to look like I'll never go here better off getting dunkin doughnuts next time it would look better! read more

Pie Girl - Franken pie - Cafes Near Me - Hightstown, New Jersey

Definitely a little hidden gem. The quiche was excellent and so was the scone. We did not have their coffee as we already had ours from little key coffee around the corner. Their ambiance is really nice, everything was absolutely spotless. The service was excellent as well. Definitely a place to come and do some studying and work. It is a wee bit loud if you like quiet places. Absolutely will come back. read more

Delicious, absolutely quality baked goods!! Flaky buttery pie crust and fresh seasonal flavor! I'm pretty sure I came 3 weekends in a row! If it was a little less of a trek for me I'd be there every weekend!! I have waited in line each time but it was absolutely worth it! The only note I will make is that although they have such a cute and bright/sunny seating area the savory pies and galettes do warrant some heating up so they're really ideal after a few minutes in the toaster oven! So for this reason I would say maybe have a coffee and cookie/cake to enjoy at the bakery but take your quiche home and enjoy it right out of the oven for optimal flavor! And I can say they're even great the next day! read more

See all

The best bakery I've ever been to hands down. You won't find a more unique variety of baked goods. Each week has a different selection completely. I love that they talk you through what all the items are for the day rather than have signs to just tell you. It's like a treasure hunt each time you go. You can feel the love from the owners and workers. They have everything from savory to sweet. So so so so good! read more

Pie Girl - Cafes Near Me - Hightstown, New Jersey

Such a cute little hidden gem in Hightstown. I got the Mexican chocolate and strawberry coconut cornmeal cake - also brought home a slice of the cranberry oat for my mom. Everything was delicious and the staff was very informative when I was trying to decide what to pick. I will definitely be back! read more

For as long as I can remember I've been obsessed with pie and I finally found nirvana at pie girl in highstown NJ. The pies were impeccable in every aspect. In fact, I'd even go so far as to say that on a technical level they were the BEST PIES I'VE EVER HAD. Be it the ultra flaky and tender crust, the expertly balanced flavors, the delightful combination of textures, the flawless consistency, or even the colors. They were simply perfection. First up was the SALTED HONEY LAVENDER PIE which is 100% in the conversation for best singular pie I've ever had. Its delicate infusion of floral lavender, subtle saltiness, and sweet honey created a flavor symphony that enchanted my taste buds.Next came the STRAWBERRY RHUBARB PIE which was a delightful fusion of tangy rhubarb and sweet strawberries, encased in a flawlessly baked crust. The CHOCOLATE CHIP OAT PIE was also a heavenly creation that combined gooey chocolate chips with the hearty texture of oats that were just soft enough not to feel like a chore while chewing. Finally, there was the DARK CHOCOLATE COCONUT PIE which transported me to a tropical paradise with its velvety smooth chocolate filling infused with exotic coconut. There was also a MUSHROOM GALETTE W/ RAMP & PRESERVED LEMON GOAT CHEESE which showcased the shop's culinary expertise. The flaky, buttery pastry enveloped a medley of earthy mushrooms, elevated by the tangy ramp and creamy preserved lemon goat cheese. Along with with an unreal GOLDEN LATTE BLONDIE that was among the best bars I've had in recent memory. Its golden hues and warm spices offered a perfect balance of flavors and texture, making it a sweet and comforting finale that you must try if/when it's available. Beyond the extraordinary treats, the AMBIANCE of the shop was reminiscent of a charming scene from a Nancy Meyers or Nora Ephron movie. From the decor to the lighting and demeanor of the staff, the cozy and romantic atmosphere enveloped me completely. Bottom Line: the best pies I've ever had from the most charming bakery you'll ever visit. Highly recommend. read more

See all

Pie girl NJ perfectly flaky crust. Filled with top quality ingredients. Served by warm knowledgeable staff. Attention to detail and a passion for baking is present in every bite. Pie girl's Shop is where I wanna be. read more

Awesome pie, they have like a ton of new ones every week, along with various pastries, and a matcha olive oil cake that I love.

Had a tasty quiche, a slice of pie, and an iced latte on a pleasant Saturday morning. Inside was pleasantly decorated with a few tables and a small counter, which was sufficient for the time I was there. Has a lady go through the options, and give some recommendations, and food came out quickly so no complaints on service. Will definitely come back again to try more options! read more

All of the cookies, pies, and other assorted delights were so fresh and delicious. The key is ordering in advance and getting their early for the remaining selection. read more

Wonderful variety of the familiar and things with a little twist. Enjoyed everything and the staff were friendly and helpful.

We have been following Pie Girl since her pop-up days at the Baker's Grove. We are so happy that she has been able to open her own shop locally and create all her delicious goodies. Right now, the bakery is open Fri and Sat. Lines form quickly and she does sell out later in the day. All her goods are fresh, made with top notch ingredients and so tasty. Each week there is something different to choose from. They have cakes, cookies, galettes, scones, blondies, brownies, and of course pie, you name it! Check Instagram for the weekly menu. You can buy pies by the slice or whole. She makes some of the flakiest crust I've ever had. There is a small coffee bar as well. The seating area is large enough to hang out for a bit or even stay and do some work ( and eat more pie). It's hard to choose just one item so do yourself a favor and get 8-10. You won't be disappointed, and you'll be helping a small local business! Chelsea and her crew are amazing people! read more

Pie Girl - All the goodness! - Cafes Near Me - Hightstown, New Jersey

Absolutely delicious. Everything I've gotten here is good. I love their inventive takes on classics like Apple pie. It tastes like Apple pie but it's elevated by the lavender. Also their quiche is amazing! Great atmosphere as well. read more

Quality. Love it here! Her spiced turmeric breakfast cake is dreamy. Chocolate chip cookies are unreal. And her blueberry pie is perfection. I can't wait to try the quiches. Love the ambiance with the bookshelves and flowers. The whole business is just lovely. read more

Amazing yummy eats. From the pies, to the quiches and all the extras. You can taste the love that goes into these treats. The staff are all wonderful, all around great service. The place is super cute too!!! Go discover the flavor for yourself. Not sure, do a sampling. Trust me it's worth every calorie read more

I bought several slices of pie and they were amazing, the problem is there is no pricing. I spent $80 and was kind of shocked. My family and I enjoyed each different slice but I haven't been back because of the extraordinarily high prices. I understand that they are handmade, but the prices should be everywhere so that you can purchase accordingly. Amazing pies, but it's out of my price range. read more

Best Pies in NJ! And the Galettes that you can only get on Saturdays are melt in your mouth savory perfection. There was a line outside before they even opened. I only wish I lived closer, but maybe it's good because they are expensive. read more

Love it the best pie I have had. Also very friendly workers the place is super cute too

I tried to find out if this business could do a few gluten-free items for a wedding, starting several months ago. First, the town's FB page that provided info gave out the wrong business. Then, once I had the right contact information, I filled out a form on their website. It's been over 2 months & no response. I called them, again no response. I finally went in person to the store a week ago on Friday. The place was open but it was disappointing to see very little available. Of course I wasn't there to buy anything per se, I just wanted to see if they could bake some GF goodies. A nice employee told me that sometimes they have GF items but that I'd have to talk to the owner. The nice lady asked me for my name & number. It's been a week & no call back. In talking about the business with locals, we started to wonder how in the world a business that is open only twice a week is able to pay for the rent when the previous tenants, a fantastic deli that was open all week & did very well, had to leave because of the rent. The deli folks worked hard, they were friendly & their food was excellent. Is this pie thing a vanity project, with the owner able to open only twice a week (until they run out)? Regardless, I've never had any local business demonstrate such poor customer service. I've given up on the place & won't bother to ever go again. Everyone I ask wishes the deli would come back. Their food was much better suited to being net to the brewery, hands down! read more