Pie Five Pizza

I grew up in Lubbock eating here with my dad & it is exactly the same in a wonderful way! The Pasta…read moreSampler allowed us to experience all the flavors of Orlando's magic. The Italian margaritas made with Amaretto are just what I wanted to remember my dad. The tastes are wonderfully nostalgic. I will return every Lubbock visit.

Great variety and quality food here! Love the Tex-Italian idea! Wife and I got the Pasta Sampler…read moreplate. It was enough food for 4! Fresh salad as well. Love the atmosphere. Knock your socks off service! Have had many different selections from the menu previous times especially the Chicken Spaghetti! Recommend for a fun or romantic dinner for 2. They also have great made to order pizzas! When you're in Lubbock this is the place to eat!

Inside

Smashed pizza

See all

Outside

Italian Garden

3.8(253 reviews)

5.8 mi

A little out of the way, as it is located downtown. However, it's worth the time to drive down and…read moretry the place. Ambiance is casual enough, but you can dress up and not feel out of place. Not dim, but not overly bright lighting. Service was quick, friendly, and came by the table often. Now the food. I had heard good things about it, but I was quite pleased with how good it actually was. Bread is complimentary and comes out early. Very good bread. We both had the Pink Parmesan and it did not disappoint. If you don't know, that is Alfredo sauce and red sauce mixed. Chicken was well cooked and not dry at all. The tortellini it comes with is SO good! We had one plate with this, and then one with fettuccine noodles. Both are topped with the pink sauce. Tortellini was our favorite of the two, but we're both very good. Portions were generous. My wife and I could have split an order and it would have been plenty of food. Did not come with a salad or soup. I'm sure that could have been added, but was not included with the meal. Also had seafood items, but we did not try any of them. Pricing was on par with other restaurants in town. Most entrees were in the $11 to $20 range, with a few more expensive items. We will be back for sure.

Super yummy spot that's reasonably priced! We got the stuffed mushrooms that came in this yummy…read moresauce and I liked to dip the bread into. Probably one of my favorites in Lubbock. The manicotti with Italian sausage was also good with a nice cheesy bite. Service is fast and plenty of space for bigger parties

Complimentary bread

See all

Eggplant parmesan with pink sauce

One Guy From Italy Family Restaurant

4.0(200 reviews)

2.7 mi

We like the atmosphere - all three of us love the food - the calzones, the pizza, and the giant…read moremeatball spaghetti

What...was that?…read more Perhaps that's the issue. I remember what One Guy's used to be. It was formerly a place that I'd recommend to anyone visiting from out of town as a local favorite. It was a place I went when I cared less about convenience and using a coupon for some chain pizza and instead wanted something absolutely delicious. Sadly, it's not that anymore. The salad out front was decent enough, albeit pretty basic and definitely nothing special. The calzone was watery. Yes, watery. I don't even know how or why, but there was an excessive amount of watery liquid coming out of it. The pepperoni pizza was decent enough, but definitely no better than you're going to get from a chain, or (I can't believe I'm saying this) frozen. The sauce was particularly off-putting and gave me a different kind of nostalgia than I thought I would get eating here. It reminded me of eating Chef Boyardee vlin microwavable bowls as a kid. I was told that after taking the leftovers home and trying them the next day, they were even worse reheated. I didn't have that misfortune myself as I was done with it after the meal. The service was adequately good, but there was no crowd like I would have expected, and it's easy to see why. I'm fully aware of the reasons things may have gone a different direction (specifically downhill) at One Guy's and that there are now more options in town. I just hoped that this location still had some of that pizazz that made it special. Sadly, I was disappointed.

Part of the dining area.

Vodka pasta

See all

Front doors.

Stella's Restaurant & Catering

3.2(181 reviews)

3.3 mi

Hi I'm most likely a little disseminating on the food as I am Boston Italian not sure what i…read moreexpected in lubbock had chicken parm it was disappointing not much flavor sauce was poor as well , my girlfriend had Nonna's pizza which was good I will say the drinks were very good and though it was busy ( TT Graduation ) our waiter though frazzled did pretty well. it's casual dinning family friendly kind of place

Last few visits were good - tonight was sadly underwhelming and we will be reluctant to return for…read morea while. Pros- Service, ambiance, bread service and fair pricing. Cons- martini tasted watered down, could barely find any meat in the bolognese sauce, house salad was smothered in dressing, zucchini chips were way strangely over salted/seasoned, crème brûlée had a soft top ( I mean what's the point-just call it vanilla pudding) and the strawberry sauce served with cheesecake was rancid -had that tingly metallic taste -not fresh at all. We both agreed that next visit, if there will be one, we will just get a bowl of chicken soup and eat the yummy bread butter or split a pizza. Nothing we ordered was worth the gas to get over there ... sigh

Pizzeria menu circa Feb, 2026

See all

Eggplant Parmigiana

Orlando's Italian Restaurant

3.6(192 reviews)

5.1 mi

We recently stopped into our old stomping grounds for dinner because it had been some years since…read morewe had been to the original. Our experience was fantastic! The mafia queso was to die for (I love the garlic bread with it), our salads were fresh and fast out, the tortellini and spaghetti with meatballs and sausage hit the spot! All hot and fresh and timely just like we like. Our servers name was Mercedes and she was great and gave us fast and friendly service. We sat in the area behind the bar ,which we never had seen before. That was cool! Everything looked extremely clean and bright. We will definitely be making our way back over there next time we have our Italian craving!

The oldest restaurant in Lubbock! It definitely lived up to its reputation... Amazing flavor from…read moreevery dish! Quiet location with an emphasis on intimacy & authenticity. All staff were attentive & super friendly... which is always a great sign of leadership within the organization. THANKS ORLANDO'S for a great evening experience!

Best restaurant to sit at the bar. Avoid the wait!

Italian Sausage Hoagie

See all

Pesto Linguine Almondine**

Atomic Lounge & Pizza Kitchen

4.4(81 reviews)

4.5 mi

So, I don't tend to write a lot of negative reviews, but I had such a poor experience here that I…read morefeel compelled to comment. I went in by myself on a Thursday evening, as I was in Lubbock (and at TTU) for work meetings, and sat at the bar for a beer and dinner. Three employees -- servers and bartenders -- were working the place, as it was summer and school wasn't yet in session, so while most tables were filled, the bar had empty seats and a couple of tables were still empty. TEN MINUTES I sat at the bar before I was even acknowledged, and that was because the two guys next to me, who'd been there at least that long themselves, finally asked for menus, and so I said, "I'd like one, too." The guy got me a menu and I decided on what to order. Set the menu down, and another 5+ minutes went by while the servers dealt with other tables and even other customers at the bar. Now, we are 15+ minutes in, and finally the guy who got me the menu asked if I wanted something to drink. I ordered a beer, where he could have TURNED AROUND to enter it in the register and pour it from the tap, but he went to another table and I didn't see him again for another 5 or so minutes. At that point, I'd had enough, and I left. I would have enjoyed trying the pizza and enjoying a beer there. The place had a cool vibe and the food looked and smelled good, from what I could see from neighbors. But the dismissive attitude of the staff who must actually have looked THROUGH me (I was at the very center of the bar and I'm pretty sure I'm not transparent) and having been ignored for about 20 minutes was enough. Went down the road to Flippers Tavern and had a wonderful experience there! Sorry, but if you can't even acknowledge your customers when you're busy but not slammed, you don't deserve my business. Maybe it's because I'm an Old Dude and not a young hipster or college student, but it was disappointing and frustrating. Bottom line: skip this place, especially if you're over 35 or so.

I've been to Atomic twice in my life. Both times were impeccable. I'm not sure I have a single…read morecomplaint. The service and staff make you feel welcome, they're friendly, quick - all the things you could ask for to enhance your experience. They offer it. The location is nice if you're anywhere near the Tech campus area. It's right on Broadway. Parking can be tough if it's busy. There is street parking and a lot, but neither are the most plentiful. The food is the real star though. Their wings are incredible, and they don't mess around with the spice. They can be hot! I love the jalapeño poppers. Where else gives you a real popper and not just a frozen and deep fried version? As for the pizza...I'm pleased to say it's the best part of an already awesome place. It doesn't matter what kind you get, you'll be happy with your choice. The Last Call Pizza deserves it's own paragraph. I think I can confidently say it's my favorite pizza of all time. And the second time I had it, confirmed just that. Look at this description - "Homemade smoky pizza sauce and alfredo sauce, topped with cheese, bacon, sausage, sunny-side-up eggs, and drizzled with our sriracha sauce". It's INCREDIBLE! Can't recommend this place enough, if you're in Lubbock get over here!

Bar sign

Wings were tasty!!

See all

Margherita pizza was delicious!!

Papa V Pizza

4.8(108 reviews)

3.5 mi

Fantastic pizza. Love the whole vibe of this place and my man Papa V is a character. Love this…read moreguy. Go grab some pizza

The House Calzone is one of the best I've eaten. A small family joint that treats patrons like…read morefamily.

Pepperoni pazza and Meatball Pizza

See all

Dining area is large and clean.

Fazoli's

3.9(32 reviews)

4.2 mi

The food was delicious, staff was very courteous and a gentleman was walking around making sure…read moreeverything was great. Awesome place to eat.

Stopped in for a quick meal. The staff is so friendly! The lunch specials are amazing...only 7.99…read moreand add a dollar for a protein. What a steal. Jack came by to make sure everything was great and that definitely helps make this a 5 star meal. Thank you! Clean inside and they were pretty busy! Loved it.

Baked Lasagna and Spaghetti with Meat Sauce

See all

Pasta/ cheese slice

Las Brisas

4.0(304 reviews)

5.6 mi

•$$$

Ridiculous. In the best possible way…read more The two Lambo's in the parking lot should have been a clue, but this place stands shoulder to shoulder with the boys in the big cities. The service was top notch, the apps were different from "the usual" but were all delicious. You have to try the smoked meatballs and the calamari. The steak was cooked perfectly. This place is a gem.

First- definitely our favorite in Lubbock; great ambiance, quality food, and attentive waitstaff…read more The ONLY issue that we see, and continue to see over the past decade is CONSISTENCY in dishes. I always order the filet mignon, with steamed broccoli AND ask for NO BUTTER (IBS-can't tolerate well...)... well again, everything came out swimming in butter - luckily our waiter noticed and took the plate right away (without me saying anything)- came back within 60 seconds (obviously just re-plated it)- I asked about the butter and he said " everything is cooked on the flattop in butter"--- uhhhhh?? What? The steamed broccoli?? (And since I asked for broccoli INSTEAD of the truffle potatoes, I was uncharged - & unfortunately didn't eat any of the vegetables). Every time my entree is different - sometimes it's PERFECT- other times I'm leaving only eating the steak.

Inside the main dining room

1/2 dozen oysters

See all

Espresso Martini

Dion's Pizza

4.2(91 reviews)

5.2 mi

service is good but we got take out. The green chile had no flavor and it's kind of soggy. A little…read moregreasy as well. Not my favorite but not bad. Green chile ranch is 50 cents each.

Let's start with the drink refill policy, charging $3 for each refill feels excessive…read more I came here based on recommendations that this is the best pizza in Lubbock, and if that's the case, that's honestly disappointing. The pizza isn't terrible, but it's nothing special and definitely wouldn't make my top 10. As for the subs, credit where it's due, the crusty bread they use is very good. I'll give Dion's that. The Greek salad was decent, not the Caesar salad though. The dressing is packaged so you get what you get.

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

9 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Debbie C.

0

1

0

7 years ago

You go through a line and pick your crust, sauce, meats, veggies, cheese and toppings. They bake the pizza and 5 minutes later you have exactly what you wanted. Prices are very reasonable and the app is super easy. You can even order specialty pizza and remove one ingredient and add another on the app. The nutritional information is easy to access and after you have taken a bite of awesome pizza, the calorie count will surprise you! read more

Steffany F.

1

44

0

10 years ago

Been SEVERAL times. It is really good if they cook the pizzas long enough! The first few times it was nice cooked and crispy the last 3 times we have been doughy in the middle, which is gross, and we haven't been able to give it another go quite yet. A thin crust pizza should not be doughy. LOVE that you personalize your own pizza though! read more

Juan M.

16

3

2

10 years ago

The flavor and the amount of toppings they have you was great .i just wish it came in different sizes ,not just2. And if the price was a little cheaper read more

Ryen S.

0

3

2

5 years ago

Great pizza overall overall delicious everything was awesome definitely going back for seconds plus they had all the toppings I want

Ricky M.

6

2

3

6 years ago

The large High Five pizza was fantastic! All the employees were so polite and helpful. We will definitely be back soon. Thank you!

Tammi C.

37

3

0

9 years ago

The pizza was good. There was hardly any wait time which is a plus. The restaurant was clean and the staff was friendly

Aaron A.

0

3

0

11 years ago

First time here, will definitely go into the rotation! Fresh ingredients, fast service, delicious!

Laura A.

157

15

1

4 years ago

Love this place. No arguments about what toppings.

Allison C.

0

1

0

5 years ago

Great food! Love this place

Pie Five Pizza - pizza - Updated September 2026

People who viewed Pie Five Pizza also viewed

Giorgio's Pizza

4.2

(64 reviews)

Robert was a pleasure to talk to and the calzone and cheesy bread was a 10 out of 10. I come to…read morethis place every time I get my vehicle worked on at the tire shop down the way and they never disappoint!!

came to purchase pizza asked if I could get ice in my cup and was told no I would have to purchase…read morea drink under the Americans with disability act. They are to provide water or a cup of ice for anyone that asks if they are disabled customer service in this restaurant seems to need help. I am visually impaired and could not read the menu so she's told my options of what I could order, I could not add a replaced toppings on a special which I understand could not add or remove sauce, which I understand on a lunch special. We'll see how the pizza tastes when I get the order.

Papa Murphy's

4.1

(14 reviews)

I love this pizza; it is a great one to take and freeze. I also love to get the crustless pizza…read more Heat and put over lettuce. YUM I wish there were more stores.

Food and service are always excellent. The Ambiance says PIZZA as you enter. Thank Youread more

Dario's Pizza and Calzones

4.7

(78 reviews)

Absolute Perfection!…read more I know Dario himself has been a mainstay in the Lubbock area for what feels like a generation, and I'm so thrilled to see him succeeding at this location. There's not an item on the menu that I wouldn't recommend. The pizza is arguably the best in town. The calzones alone are worth the trip. Even the cheesecake was marvelous. Yes, you're probably going to have a wait unless you order ahead, but it's absolutely worth it. Besides that you get to see Dario working hard making your pizza and chatting it up with various customers while a gaggle of teenagers who Dario is probably giving their first job do their best to look busy and add to a friendly experience. Maybe the only thing as great as Dario's calzones is his personality. It's an experience you can't get anywhere else in Lubbock. Dario's is everything you'd expect when you're looking for a great, locally-owned pizza shop in Lubbock. This will be the place I take any friends who visit or recommend to any out of towners who want to try something Lubbock is proud to call its own.

My wife and I love Dario's so much! We are here frequently but not as much as I would like! You…read moreknow how when you want one of your favorite things to eat you can just taste it... Your mouth begins to water, and you haven't even made it to the restaurant yet. Well, then picture the same but with calzone! Dario's calzone, fresh out of the oven... Too hot to eat, so you tease it open with your knife and fork... The steam rises, and you are treated to the amazing smells of pepperoni... soft, juicy pieces of Italian sausage, melted mozzarella, tangy pizza sauce... Now you convince yourself that it is not too hot to pick up... Gently you grab one half of the calzone, lifting your fingers one at a time like you are playing a flute so they don't all burn at the same time... the smells are closer to your nose now... You can't wait any longer! You sneak the first careful bite... Exhaling over the hot morsel in your mouth helps cool it, but not perfectly. You shift the bite around in your mouth to cool it even more. The taste of the warm dough is so comforting, but that is not what made your stomach rumble is it? No... It was the blending of ingredients, the expertise, and knowing hand of a master. The bite is cool enough now... go ahead... you know you want to... I will see you there!

Orlando's Italian Restaurant

3.7

(326 reviews)

I grew up in Lubbock eating here with my dad & it is exactly the same in a wonderful way! The Pasta…read moreSampler allowed us to experience all the flavors of Orlando's magic. The Italian margaritas made with Amaretto are just what I wanted to remember my dad. The tastes are wonderfully nostalgic. I will return every Lubbock visit.

Great variety and quality food here! Love the Tex-Italian idea! Wife and I got the Pasta Sampler…read moreplate. It was enough food for 4! Fresh salad as well. Love the atmosphere. Knock your socks off service! Have had many different selections from the menu previous times especially the Chicken Spaghetti! Recommend for a fun or romantic dinner for 2. They also have great made to order pizzas! When you're in Lubbock this is the place to eat!

The Ransom Grill

5.0

(4 reviews)

Excellent service and food tonight. We had the supreme pizza and sopapillas. Our waitress, Krissen,…read morewas so kind and friendly. Loved the homemade ranch. Couldn't quite put my finger on it but it tasted like it had a hint of dill pickle in it. Very good!

Best chicken fried steak in a hundred mile radius!!! The waitresses and the actual owner r the…read morenicest people u will ever meet!!! Coldest beer too !!!! I give these guys a 5 plus !!!

All American Eatery & Catering Co.

4.4

(144 reviews)

This place is amazing! The food, the service are top notch! The family that own this do such an…read moreamazing job. We have had breakfast and lunch, everything from biscuits and gravy, steak fingers, fried fish and pie! Let me tell you the pies are the best ever! Thank you to the owners for always taking great care of us and remembering my wife's coconut cream pie everytime!

We came for breakfast. The service was phenomenal. Our waitress was super sweet, attentive and…read moreanswered all of our questions. My husband is super keen on breakfast and she offered him the lunch menu and gave great suggestions. I had the huevos rancheros and he had the Philley Cheesesteak. All were great!

The Plaza

3.7

(21 reviews)

I've always loved the Plaza! This atmosphere at this newer location is very pleasant and the food…read moreis just as good. Was a bit quieter in here than the other location, which we preferred! Highly recommend their brisket enchiladas with jalapeño cream sauce! Fast and friendly service.

Came here for lunch to visit a friend. The waitress was incredibly friendly and diligent while we…read morewere here. I ordered the California chicken plate which was good. No complaints!

Spanky's

3.3

(371 reviews)

11June2026 I have been married to a Lubbock Native for 27…read moreyears now, and for all of this time, I have been hearing about Spanky's, just across from Texas Tech University. She has been hyping up this joint forever and during this trip to her hometown, we ended up there on our first night we were in town. On the outside, it looks like the typical university food joint that could be at any university town across America. It was small with a few tables and booths and had stuff across the walls that yelled TEXAS TECH RED RAIDERS so loud that it could be seen from the ISS. Apparently, the owner is a big fan and possibly an Alumna of TTU. We ordered the hand dipped mushrooms and onion rings to go along with our burgers. Little did I know what an experience the two appetizers would be. Lets just say that I have NEVER has such wonderful shrooms and rings ... ever. Thats saying something. The mushrooms are not the typical soft, mushy ones that many places serve out of the Sysco bags ... no, these were easily identifiable as button mushrooms even through the crispiness of the batter. Firm, sliceable and easily skewered by a fork to be dipped in ranch sauce. In short ... they were lip-smackin good. The onion rings, dipped in the same batter, cooked in the same oil and served at the same temperature were just as delectable. They were thick sliced sweet yellows that held their toothiness throughout the frying process. Just the bite into it was yummy, sweet and crispy ... all at the same time. These reminded me of the onion rings I used to get at Tookies down in Seabrook, Tx during the 70's and 80's. For my main, I chose the "Hotter than Hell Burger" with crinkle fries. I like hot and spicy and expected it to actually be hotter than it was. The sliced jalapeño and habanero spread were present and did the job of letting my taste buds know they were doing their job. It just wasn't the knockout I was expecting from a burger place serving university students that would eat really spicy stuff on a dare. Don't get me wrong, that burger was really good, just as my Wife said it would be. That statement is truth, not hype, but hotter than hell, naah. More like hotter than heck. My biggest disappointment was the limited selection of good beer. Light beer, cheap lagers and Mexican standards. Would it hurt to put in an IPA or a Stout? Overall, the staff were wonderful and answered any of the myriad of questions I had about their fare. It was an actual experience for me, especially after all of the hype my Wife told me over the decades. Usually, after a big span of time, places from our youth let us down. Spanky's is NOT a place like that. I will be sure to make it there on the next trip to Lubbock ... even if my Wife isn't with me. Ciao, Darrell

The online menu is out of date. The margaritas was insanely bitter…read more The burger was pretty good This is a classically overrated college haunt. Its ok. Nothing special about it though. Don't go out of your way for it

S'barros Pizza

3.0

(2 reviews)

The employees are friendly, management is energetic, to say the least! It's a nice break from the…read morechickfila routine... the pizza can be a little greasy, but what pizza isnt? The crust is awesome... and free refills on drinks!

Awful, awful overpriced pizza. If you're hungry in the mall you should skip pizza, go for a pretzel…read moreinstead.

It's Greek To Me

3.6

(73 reviews)