We came here while passing through town based on my wife's recommendation, who had eaten their pizza before. We were hungry and tired and it seemed a nice place. It proved to be just decent. Their location has lots of tables to sit in, but to my chagrin if you order a medium or large pizza it is served on a piping hot pan that doesn't really fit on the table. So, you must put it on one table and sit and eat at another table. It seems a bit strange, but if it works... at least the pizza was nice and hot. We had half-pepperoni and half-cheese, and it was dripping (literally) with grease. And so floppy that it was impossible to pick a slice up without it folding over in a greasy mess. I can only imagine what a full pepperoni pizza would be like. The sauce tasted heavily of dried herbs which really isn't my preference. It tasted a bit fake. It was okay pizza when hot, and very dull and tasteless when cold and leftover. Coming here was okay, but it wasn't a picnic. read more

There is no better option than Horseheads Picnic Pizza. I am a chicken wing pizza fan, and these guys knock it out of the park every time I go there! The service is amazing. You are always greeted with a smile. Great atmosphere. 10 out of 10 would recommend to anyone looking for great food! read more

Paid over 40$ for a large pizza with pepperoni, half sausage and a large soda. Expensive for no reason.

We ordered pepperoni pizza. Topping is extra cost. Overall it's good but a little pricier than expected.

Dude seriously. We order $54 worth of pizza one completely wrong the second unexpected and the way it's handled is ridiculous. Ordered a pepper and onion got a pepperoni. Ordered a cheese..that was correct. Ordered a meatball and ricotta cheese pizza. How the hell do I know that when I order meatball and ricotta that u don't put red sauce?? I don't ask for red sauce with a cheese pizza but that's what I get. Meatball was ground and not sliced as per menu topping description. Ricotta is a CHEESE not a sauce. Had to literally fight to get money back as guy wanted to bring back a pizza the driver had in his car for half hour. Being rude about it is completely unacceptable. Yup u gave me my money back yup u took the pizza back that was not as described or ordered. But have a little customer service and don't treat customers like crap. Let the hotel staff know after they asked why we ordered pizza elsewhere after this order. Hopefully they don't recommend again. Thankfully driver was nice read more

I came to visit my Mom for two weeks from East Tennessee. This place was recommended by my Mom. She said they usually have very good pizza. I was not impressed. The bottom of most of the crust was very dark, I would call it burnt. We ordered it delivery. It was cold. We wanted half with onions and peppers and cheese on the other half. My Mom had to actually use a pair of scissors to cut through it because it was impossible with a knife. Very disappointed. Next time I'm ordering from Pudgie's. They have never failed me yet. read more

I used to live in the area, and decided to stop in and see how the pie was. While the service was friendly, the ability to serve what was requested was non existent. The pie was non eatable, possibly because they messed up the order so badly. A Tombstone Pizza was far more tastier read more

Called in to make an order for pick up and was told it'd be 30 minutes. They also didn't give me a total. I showed up on time and waited for an extra 25 minutes for my food to be ready. On top of that it was $65 to pick up 2 large pizzas and 2 dozen wings. Not impressed by the quality either. 1/10 would not recommend read more

Ordered slice for each of my girls and my husband ordered the LAST slice of another pizza. Order goes in. 3 people come in AFTER us, order whatever, yup, slices up and the jerks took our pizza slices!!!! I said those are ours. Nope no one did a thing. So now my kids have to wait longer so the fat jerks can eat! Unreal! read more

Had an order last night delivered ! Wife got a calzone that had glass in it!!!! We also bought a cheese pie! Let owners know that we had glass in the calzone! We also asked if it was ok to eat the pizza!? They told us they didn't know how glass got into it!!! Took off the calzone! We tossed the pizza! Never again go back their again! Where did the glass come from???? If you don't know then maybe you might look into getting a better system!!! read more

Love the pizza and the atmosphere and the staff! It's real pizza, not that cardboard stuff from a chain restaurant and it's all handmade, seriously, you can watch them make the dough and all! Personal favorite: turkey sub, with everything on it and a side of hot sauce. It's to die for! read more

About the the best sub and Pizza place in Horseheads. The staff is always friendly and you can tell its family operated.

Pizza is amazing. Subs are amazing. And I don't usually eat salads but they have the best! read more

Picnic Pizza - Garden salad - Italian Near Me - Horseheads, New York

While their New York style pie is pretty good, for me the real stars of Picnic Pizza are their squares. Their sheet pizza is very good IMO and their Sicilian is also good if you like a thick, spongy crust. Their tomato sauce is nice and generous toppings. Their chicken wings are some of the best in the area. Very good subs as well. I love that they offer Pepsi products instead of Coca-Cola as most places do. read more

Went back to try again. Not impressed at all. The pizzas we got were way over priced for what it was. Walmart has better frozen pizza then this. Better off going elsewhere. It was so bad my wife was shocked when she was away for business that the pizza was not eaten and I tossed it. Wasnt good and no toppings really for adding toppings. Not sure how others like this pizza. Might want to take a trip to NYC and get a taste for real pizza before selling this stuff... yuck. read more

best pizza on the planet, served by the nicest staff on the planet!!!! love their subs too. for real, though..do not pass the chance up to eat here! read more

Order all the time!! Never lets me down. For a little town in upstate NY it's amazing. I've had pizza all over the place and have had very few that I find better. Plus the picnic special sub is always on point. read more

Great pizza!! Their Hot ham subs are the best !! The drivers are very polite and prompt! Never a bad meal . Prices are good !

Picnic Pizza is my favorite in the area! We order delivery from the store in Miners plaza. It always comes hot and fresh, and in a timely manner. I love the flavor of the sauce and it's always cheesy. The Hawaiian is good, too! We like the thinner NY Style crust but if you like thicker pizza, the Sicilian is good. I've also had their calzones, which are huge and packed with the toppings you choose. read more

This is one of my favorite pizza places in my area and it's very upsetting when the manager of the business was very rude over the phone to weekly regular customers and tried to make it sound like I was lying when I said I ordered fries and was CHARGED for the fries but then told me I didn't order fries. Yeah it's only fries but it's the moral of it that you don't call your customers liars and you simply fix the problem. read more

Placed an order over the phone without getting a total. Assumed that the prices they had posted on Facebook and an OFFICIAL website were correct. Snack pack price posted was $19.99. When I went in to pay for the food, it came to $25+ tax. Was told that I couldn't get the food for the price that THEIR business posted. Employees were extremely rude and very unapologetic. Instead, they told me that they "don't update" their Facebook page and that the extremely official website was "not theirs." It is very clearly NOT a third party sight. Apparently they would rather throw the food away and lose a local customer over $7.‍ read more

When they get it right, Picnic Pizza delivers good. The problem is they rarely get it right. More often than not, Picnic delvers their food COLD. read more

Local pizzeria. Coming from NYC, Picnic offers a reasonable facsimile of what I grew up with. Usual pizzeria fare: subs, salads, slices. Not quite top notch, but better than other local pizzerias. read more

I love the pizza here and the picnic special is one of my all time favorite subs. One thing that is really lacking is the sausage sandwich. If you are a true lover of great italian sausage sandwiches you will be severely disappointed. The sausage is dry and overcooked and they use the overcooked green peppers instead of the sweet red ones. read more

I've always enjoyed their subs and never had a problem with service. I went in to get a slice of pizza for my girlfriend and the guy at the counter is handling my money and my pizza without gloves. Then I ask for a different slice and the same guy gets it for me without gloves. I left without a refund. told them to keep their pizza. read more

Pizza isn't too bad but the subs are amazing it's too bad they absolutely refuse to put pepperoni on a sub when you are will to pay extra. I had to ask to get pepperoni on the side and that was even a battle. So the amount of energy they are going to use to put pepperoni on the side in a bag they could have just just out it in the sub. The picnic in bigflats will do it no problem. I do not recommend this location at all. They always give you are hard time. read more

Had the antipasto salad for lunch . It was okay not a lot of meat or lettuce . Previously had a garlic and tomato pizza and it was delicious

Be VERY careful when ordering from this place! My husband ordered mozzarella sticks for me and a Turkey sub with fries to go, they shoved everything in a small bag. The marina sauce opened up and spilled all over the order and the fries container opened up and spilled all over. My husband drove BACK which is 30 minutes away and the manager would NOT remake this order OR give us our money back! So sad that a place like this would treat their customers so horribly. We went there atleast once a week, well, no longer! What a terrible way to treat a customer, they must be really money hungry to not make it right! I will make sure to also post this experience on my Facebook page. You are a TERRIBLE establishment Picnic Pizza! So sad to know you are such a dishonorable business. read more