We stayed in town and saw this pizza place pop up. It only had one other review but it was a solid…read more5 stars, so I figured we'd give it a try. I'm so glad we did. We got a sheet which has 24 square pieces and it was delicious! Great customer service, we got there before it was done so he said he'd bring it out when it was ready. He did so and was wearing a mask. We have 4 kids, 2 young and 2 older teens and they all liked it. Nice chewy crust, sauce that isn't too sweet (I'm not a fan of sweet sauce). I would have preferred more pepperonis on such a large pizza but that's not worth knocking off a star.

The gentleman who answers the phone is incredibly friendly. Great first impression. This is our…read morefave local pizza especially because of the quality of the toppings! The pizza is presented as you pick it up which is a meaningful, classy touch. Thank you for your devotion to the details Fratello's!!!

Great pizza! We were just passing through and decided to grab some takeout. The pizza had the…read moreperfect amount of sauce and cheese, and the thin crust had just the right amount of chew. We really enjoyed it!

Omg it so good pizza come here fast cheap definitely order again very good order now 2nd best pizza…read moreplace in Horseheads and Elmira and Corning and Saracuse

Free cheesy garlic bread! Did that catch your attention?…read more Friendly service, an interesting interior with a somewhat "tropical vibe," and pretty decent food. I can understand why the reviews on TripAdvisor say that this is a local favorite. Why not a 5 rating, though? The food was okay. The waiter said that they won "Best Pizza" in New York a few years back, and when I asked which area of New York, he said it was for the entire state. So, naturally, that made my expectations for the food go up a notch. We got the burrata salad, a supreme pizza, and linguine with red clam sauce (which came with a side salad). The burrata salad was okay. The linguine with red clam sauce was also okay, but the side salad looked like one of those premade salads that might have been sitting in the fridge for a bit. The lettuce was on the verge of wilting, and the cucumbers looked dry. As for the pizza? Okay. Was it worthy of the title of "Best Pizza"? Sorry, I don't think so. Overall, though, if you're in the mood for Italian food in the area, check it out.

Ok wow. From the outside you wouldn't know your about to have the best garlic knots ever!!…read more Inside is quaintly decorated in an Italian theme, Our waiter was fine and answered our questions. Honestly the best part is the food here, everything we got was amazing. The only down side was no Coke Zero

Awesome, authentic New York pizzeria. Great atmosphere in a…read morehistoric building. Fantastic staff and service. Also great prices for the quality and quantity of food. I will most definitely go back when in town.

Still cranking out some of the best NYS style pizza in the area. Went for lunch on a Saturday…read moreafternoon. Packed. Tables full. Line by the door. Thankfully, we were seated promptly. Locals know where to go, and when we return for a visit, no trip home is complete without a pie from Aniello's. Mangia, mangia!!

Great spot , always a line out the door. The vodkaroni & the creamy Alfredo are to die for. The…read moreprices are really solid for the quality - ambience wise it is a bit loud for basic conversation but not horrible. Overall if you're in the area this is a just visit

It is worth arriving at opening time for this restaurant, as it is walk-in only. Larger parties may…read morebe difficult to seat as the restaurant is relatively small. If you are not able to arrive at 5pm, I'd recommend calling ahead to get the estimated wait time to plan accordingly. The food is solid. The portions are large and the pastas especially are quite heavy. The dough on the pizza is thin with a thicker crust and nice wood-fired crisp to it. I'd recommend splitting the entrees or ordering family style if you are with a large group. This is a common nicer date spot in the area and is very busy on family weekend or other major dates for the surrounding universities.

We came here while passing through town based on my wife's recommendation, who had eaten their…read morepizza before. We were hungry and tired and it seemed a nice place. It proved to be just decent. Their location has lots of tables to sit in, but to my chagrin if you order a medium or large pizza it is served on a piping hot pan that doesn't really fit on the table. So, you must put it on one table and sit and eat at another table. It seems a bit strange, but if it works... at least the pizza was nice and hot. We had half-pepperoni and half-cheese, and it was dripping (literally) with grease. And so floppy that it was impossible to pick a slice up without it folding over in a greasy mess. I can only imagine what a full pepperoni pizza would be like. The sauce tasted heavily of dried herbs which really isn't my preference. It tasted a bit fake. It was okay pizza when hot, and very dull and tasteless when cold and leftover. Coming here was okay, but it wasn't a picnic.

There is no better option than Horseheads Picnic Pizza. I am a chicken wing pizza fan, and these…read moreguys knock it out of the park every time I go there! The service is amazing. You are always greeted with a smile. Great atmosphere. 10 out of 10 would recommend to anyone looking for great food!

We stumbled on this little hole-in-the-wall on our way back from Niagara and I'm so glad we did…read more The pizza was easily one of the best we've ever had: fresh, perfectly baked, and huge. The hoagie was fantastic too, loaded and full of flavor. The staff was super friendly and made us feel welcome from the moment we walked in. The space itself could use a little refresh, but honestly, the food and service more than make up for it. If you're passing through, don't skip this place!

I had to visit beautiful Horseheads, NY for work. Each town I visit I must try the pizza. I chose…read moreto go with the plain cheese but they had a bunch of flavors ready for the lunch rush. Cheese was good and sauce was decent. They could have left the pie in the oven for at least a few more minutes. It was a little doughy. The place was clean and the staff were friendly. Not a bad place to grab a slice.

The pizza is fantastic! Good salads and garlic bread. The…read morepastas are pretty watery and bland, the only thing we've ordered that we were unhappy with. Customer service is always very friendly and quick delivery.

Hi , Absolutely disgusting food I said to my girlfriend just…read morethrow it away . Breadsticks were fused together with the cheese that erupted out of them and the pizza was bland with poor quality cheese that wasn't even fully melted . Cheesesteak was so dry and the roll ha . I can go to the grocery store and buy mozzarella sticks and and ellios pizza that would put this place to shame . 26$ and it's in the garbage .

The food is amazing!! especially the garlic and broccoli pizza! The service is amazing, nice and…read moresweet people! Plus gotta love Billy

Ordered a meatball sub , with cheese and we got meatballs a roll and no cheese and no sauce on the…read moremeatballs. Disappointed Staff pleasant