Very good pizza,as close to Brooklyn pizza you can get up here. Their sandwiches are very good as…read morewell. Highly recommend. Excellent service as well.

Great NY style slices! Not much to choose from at the Mall, but there is still pizza!read more

Omg it so good pizza come here fast cheap definitely order again very good order now 2nd best pizza…read moreplace in Horseheads and Elmira and Corning and Saracuse

New York style pizza that does not disappoint Reasonably…read morepriced Best in the area at this time

Absolutely the best Pizza in the entire area !! I know his is a bold statement, as everyones tastes…read moreare different. Try a mushroom and fresh tomato pizza first then it will be difficult to argue with me. Note: for pickup go earlier than they tell you. It will most likely be ready.

4.5 stars We stopped…read morehere on our way down from Niagara Falls. We were hungry and in the mood for pizza. Rico, the owner, recommended the Big Game special - which was a large cheese pizza, 10 wings and garlic knots. Garlic knots (at least 8, maybe 10) were fresh and coated in a delicious buttery garlic sauce. The pizza was decent, fresh and cheesy. I prefer my NY style pizza to be super crispy on the bottom, and this one came out normal. The wings were the highlight: steaming, freshly made and large. I hate paying for dinky small wings and these did not disappoint. The service was even better - Rico was very friendly and promptly brought out food, plates, waters for us, etc. When we first pulled up, there were some friendly state troopers having lunch here, so you know it's well enjoyed by the locals! Definitely worth a visit! Tip: the marinara that came with the garlic knots was yummy and great for dipping pizza crust too, and Rico was nice enough to give us some extra garlic dip that the garlic knots came in. Great dipping sauce for pizza crust!

We were craving pizza but are new to the area so chose this place. I'm glad we did. The food was…read moreamazing. The sheet pizza was huge. I did think it had too much sauce but that's my own taste. The wings were phenomenal. We were addicted to the mild boneless wings and garlic knots. Everything was so flavorful. The garlic parmesan wings were really good but I think it needs a little bit more salt. Overall happy and will definitely be ordering from there again.

We stayed in town and saw this pizza place pop up. It only had one other review but it was a solid…read more5 stars, so I figured we'd give it a try. I'm so glad we did. We got a sheet which has 24 square pieces and it was delicious! Great customer service, we got there before it was done so he said he'd bring it out when it was ready. He did so and was wearing a mask. We have 4 kids, 2 young and 2 older teens and they all liked it. Nice chewy crust, sauce that isn't too sweet (I'm not a fan of sweet sauce). I would have preferred more pepperonis on such a large pizza but that's not worth knocking off a star.

I bought a pepperoni pizza. It was hot and delicious. Only took 20 minutes. Staff was nice and…read morequick.

It took 51 mins to get my 2 pizzas. I ordered online. Arrived at the store 20 min later and there…read morewas a line out the door. Got to the cashier and the pizzas weren't even made let alone cooked yet. The people in front of me ordered at the counter and received their pizza before I did. Girl didn't answer the phone the entire time I was there and eventually took it off the hook. Very unprofessional.

There is no better option than Horseheads Picnic Pizza. I am a chicken wing pizza fan, and these…read moreguys knock it out of the park every time I go there! The service is amazing. You are always greeted with a smile. Great atmosphere. 10 out of 10 would recommend to anyone looking for great food!

Paid over 40$ for a large pizza with pepperoni, half sausage and a large soda. Expensive for no…read morereason.

Always a go-to when I come into town! Love the pizza, wings, Pudgie burger, etc.... Love dipping…read morethe pizza in the wing sauce, can't ever go wrong. The price seems kinda steep, but like anyone one who comes into town, I'll pay it for some Pudgies! We got the medium wing sauce, and it's not too hot and not too mild, just right! And the pizza, always on point.

The best grilled ham and cheese and Pudgie burger... Other than that I'm not a fan... Slices are…read morejust ok and so is about everything else and they're over priced for what you get...

First thing I noticed when I walked in here was the Calabria poster. That gets you an extra star in…read moremy book. As usual I tried a plain cheese . I also got white slice. Plain cheese was very good. A little flop but not too bad. Nice sauce and good cheese. The white slice was ok. A little too much ricotta but overall was decent. They had a great menu of Italian food. I noticed all the customers there ordered a bunch of things besides pizza. Everything looked good. I would go again.

Delicious, quick, satisfying. Went back for seconds. Will definitely return whenever I'm in townread more

I'm giving this place one star ONLY because of their yelp page. Have not eaten anything from there…read moreyet. Although they have been in business for years, only one review ?. No pictures, no website, I could find, no menu online. I Have been afraid to try their pizza because of this. Some day when I feel adventurous I may give it a try. If I do, I will place a review with picks.

GREAT WINGS GREAT PIZZA awesome staff highly recommend. Also the prices are fair. This local…read morerestaurant is far better than any of the chains

Always good beer and good food. People are always super nice as well! Will be back for sure.read more

The interior is so cute! I read it used to be a federal building and I can definitely tell the…read morevibes from how they've recreated it into a restaurant. There are lots of tables so I imagine it can get real busy. Upon entering you take a menu and pick anywhere to sit. You order at the bar and they bring it to your table. I got the buffalo chicken flatbread which was pretty tasty and my bf got the grilled chicken club sandwich with fries. The fries weren't as crispy as we like (some a bit soft) but flavor was there overall. The chipotle mayo sauce they used in the sandwich was really good. We saw they recently opened up a rooftop area and we saw signs for it but didn't go up. Maybe next time!