My husband and I FINALLY got around to trying Picnic today, and we had high hopes for some great barbeque since it had been on our list for a while. However, I left with mixed feelings about what was actually a rather average meal (which means our likelihood to return is very low, considering the plethora of above-average barbeque options in the area).
First of all, the good! The restaurant itself is in a great location (is anyone else tired of trying to find parking downtown just to get to a decent restaurant?) on the northwest side of town where we live, and considering I am a lazy person who will whine about any drive over 20 minutes, convenience is a bonus. The rustic-style decoration is also great, and the restaurant features a cute, comfortable outdoor covered-porch seating with fans! Anyone who wants to eat outside in the summer in July knows that the overhead fans are a must. Inside, there's a large, easy-to-read blackboard which features their beer selection and daily specials. They have an open kitchen, and you can see from the dining room that the kitchen is clean, well organized, and all the cooks (and bussers) we saw were wearing gloves (my husband is a kitchen manager, so seeing a well run kitchen with good sanitary practices is important to him). The service was also prompt and pleasant.
Where Picnic falls into the "meh" category is, unfortunately, with the food....which is kind of the whole point, right? The shining star exception was the quality of the meat itself- the pulled pork sandwich had tender, juicy meat that is characteristic of a well executed whole-hog approach to barbeque. However, the sauce (yes, singular sauce) was underwhelming, the sides were bland, and the deviled egg starter was downright bad.
Picnic only offers their namesake sauce, the Pig Whistle, which NC barbeque traditionalists would be hard pressed to categorize correctly....which is what they claim makes it the best (the website describes it as "A little bit East, a little bit West - we call it The Great Carolina Compromise.") The main component is apple cider vinegar, followed by spiced tomato sauce- putting it squarely in the middle of the eastern vs. western style. My husband didn't appreciate the tomato-y component, being a strictly eastern-style fan, and I didn't appreciate the flavor or how thin it was, being a strictly western-style fan. Sometimes, compromise is NOT the answer.
The sides/apps ranged from uninspiring to unpleasant. We started off with the deviled eggs, which were CRAZY mustardy and unbalanced, flavor-wise. Everyone knows good Southern style deviled eggs rely on both the proper texture and the proper flavor, and these had neither. The macaroni and cheese, while creamy as all get out, was also super bland and lacked any kind of discernible seasoning (no pepper, and no real cheese flavor either....it's as if they got lost in the cream and forgot to add the rest of the cheese). The shoestring fries were also under seasoned, and I would have appreciated if the menu had mentioned they were going to be shoe string before we ordered them (they are not my favorite fries, and if the menu doesn't specify, I'm going to expect regular fries). Continuing with the bland theme, the hush puppies (while super smooth-battered and not gritty in the least) lacked flavor, and the sweet tea was just meh.
While I'm glad we finally got around to trying out Picnic, I'll continue to look at other restaurants in the area for my barbeque needs. read more