I would have given this place 5 starts but paying $19 for a flat bagel with tuna is a bit too much. Yea the bagel is slightly bigger but still that's a bit overkill with the price. The flat bagel was very good I really enjoyed it, the tuna was good but it was just like a regular tuna nothing special. I would come back here again but this time I would try the same bagel but with one of their cream cheeses. The place overall is clean and the staff was very nice and helpful. read more

See all

despite some people having negative comments, available location, address experience in my side. Bagels are good. The only thing I would say with this location didn't have quite as many options on their selection. I like blueberry bagels as one of my favorites and this one doesn't have those. Other than that I was very happy with this location. I do really like the quality of bagels here. They are fluffy on the inside and have a little bit of a crunch on the outside. read more

The bagel is really good, really big too. The service was great. Also they have a large selection of cream cheeses. The only issue is that it's pricey, but hey sometimes you gotta splurge. read more

Pick a Bagel - Coffee and a an everything bagel with calamity cream cheese - Bagels Near Me - New York, New York

Rude manager was so awful I will never go back. Cant even get a buttered bagel right anymore, and I've been going there for years. They put on so little butter it was invisible. When I asked for more the manager told me I like to complain and that I don't understand how expensive butter is. You'd think $3.80 for a buttered bagel would actually have butter on it, guess not. read more

I tried to place an order for a TooGoodTooGo bag at Gramercy's Bagels, but for some reason, it didn't go through. After struggling with the app and watching the last bag leave with someone else, I was left heartbroken and bagel-less. Determined to satisfy my craving, I searched for nearby bagel spots and stumbled upon Pick-a-Bagel. Despite some mixed reviews, I gave it a shot; and I'm glad I did! I ordered an everything bagel with the Lox caper dill cream cheese, and it was fantastic. It lifted my spirits immediately, so much so that I even grabbed two pumpernickel bagels to take home. The cream cheese was rich and flavorful, and more reasonable than spending $20 for lox on your bagel. I'll definitely be back! My only critique: when they toasted the everything bagel, some of the toppings got a bit burnt. If they can fix that, it would be perfect! Also, the cream cheese portion was so generous, I'll have enough left for another bagel in the morning. read more

Pick a Bagel - Everything bagel LOX CAPERS DILL SANDWICH - Bagels Near Me - New York, New York

Moshe L. A couple things. See image below and thank you for validating my extremely accurate review. Also if you're not responding to negative reviews or apologizing for poor behavior.....what made you respond to mine? The proof is in the pudding. Your lines are way shorter then your competitors just down the street. Maybe instead of focusing on not apologizing for bad behavior try focusing on ways to improve. You have a lot of opportunity there. Best of luck. read more

Pick a Bagel - Review and response from Moshe the owner. - Bagels Near Me - New York, New York

Pick a Bagel is now my favorite and go-to bagel place. Officially. My former favorites one by one stopped offering low-fat/lite cream cheese. I tried tofu cream cheese at all of those bagel shops. Just. Not. the. Same. That said, I never thought of Pick a Bagel because there wasn't one in my immediate neighborhood. I since discovered this one, since it's near Chelsea. I think their bagels are better than my former faves. Plus their low-fat/lite cream cheese is so creamy and yummy. Highly recommend to any fellow bagel aficionado. Or anyone at all! read more

On Thursday I had an Everything Bagel with chicken salad. It cost $13 & change. I was shocked as I had no idea that prices had skyrocketed through the roof. When I questioned the price the man behind the counter spoke rather rudely to me. I didn't like it. I ate the sandwich but have decided to find another bagel place with better prices. The slice of pound cake has also risen to $5.15. Sticker shock all around. read more

See all

Pick A Bagel is always fresh and spotless, with flaky croissants and smooth lattes, all complemented by exceptional customer service. read more

Pick a Bagel - Croissant- with cream cheese, toasted - Bagels Near Me - New York, New York

See all

9.75 for a bagel with cream cheese tomato and onion. what a joke. bagel was mediocre at best and service was rude.

Finding a new favorite place happens when you venture off your path. They serve dishes covering various tastes. You can taste they don't use cheap ingredients. The employees' attention to guests was outstanding! This completes my feedback. read more

First visit back in a while. Got a late breakfast. Wanted to stay. Interestingly, 1/3 of the small number of tables were occupied by the staff- mildly annoying. Finally scored a table. Had a perfectly fine bacon egg and cheese on an onion bagel. Coffee was good enough. Good diner alternative for breakfast. read more

One of my favorite bagel spots in the city. They have fast service, indoor and outdoor seating, and some BIG bagels. Get the sausage egg and cheese toasted on any bagel and it'll be a good time. Reasonable prices and lines that will not kill you. Should be a classic NYC bagel on all peoples lists. They also have gift card specials if you realize you want to be a regular! read more

Pick a Bagel - Gift card special - Bagels Near Me - New York, New York

I've lived in NYC for 7 years and have had my fair share of bagels over my time; and Pick a Bagel is up there with some of the best. That said, their BLT's are without a doubt one of the best sandwiches (bagel or not) in the city! If you're a BLT fan, you must try immediately... you'll be happy you did! Lastly, their staff is always so incredibly kind and appreciative of any/all customers. I'm a big Pick a Bagel On 23rd St fan and think 5-stars is very much deserved! read more

Pick a Bagel - Bagels Near Me - New York, New York

Pick a Bagel was my savior. I was meaning to pick up some bagels to take back with me on my flight for the next day, but due to poor planning, I waited until just before dinnertime and most bagel shops were closed! I had originally planned to stop by a different bagel place to pick up, but they were closed even though their online hours said they were open. I was a little hesitant to come here because I know it's a chain, but their bagels are actually very good. I bought a dozen to bring back with me on the plane and they survived! The guy behind the counter even threw in a couple extra bagels for me. Surprisingly, the dry air on the plane didn't really make the bagels hard or anything and they still tasted fresh. read more

Bagels are nice and chewy. Just a bit dense and the prices a bit high which is to be expected in NYC and the heart of 23rd street. But it's nice to have choices of mini bagels and flat bagels. The toppings and cream cheese flavors are super fresh and good. Lots of tuna, whitefish, salmon, lox, and vege choices. Nice healthy juices and coffee made here. The best part the staff were very nice. That always makes me appreciate the place more than the food. read more

See all

We had to get an NYC bagel while we visited, and Pick a Bagel didn't disappoint! I got an everything bagel with scallion cream cheese and it was so delicious. We picked them up and ate them at the park - a perfect Sunday morning. I miss the bagels already!! read more

Pick a Bagel - Bagels Near Me - New York, New York

See all

A staple in the neighborhood. It's open all day long and closes at midnight. I grab food here when I am not in the mood for a big appetite. The new space looks amazing and has more sidewalk space to wait for your friend to hang out with in front while preparing for what's next on the agenda. The variation in bagels and cream cheese will blow your mind. I always get the everything with regular cream cheese. read more

Pick a Bagel - Everything Bagel - Bagels Near Me - New York, New York

The only reason I'm giving it 4 stars is because a closer bagel shop to my home is much cheaper. This lox spread bagel was ~$7. It was delicious but that's too expensive. Generally I pay $5. This place is good but pricey!!! read more

Pick a Bagel - Lox Spread Sandwich - Bagels Near Me - New York, New York

My go-to bagel place when I am rotating at the VA hospital. The staff is kind, helpful and efficient. My routine order is a bagel with turkey bacon egg and cheese, with salt pepper and ketchup. Their turkey bacon is cooked nicely, egg and cheese is tasty and creamy not overcooked. Their coffee is very nice too. read more

Their white fish salad is probably the best I've had in the city, it is not overwhelmed by mayo, it is mainly just delicious fish. read more

Pick a Bagel - Lox bagel - Bagels Near Me - New York, New York

Jalapeño cream cheese on a FLAT sesame bagel toasted lightly will change your life. I always walk into this location looking a hot mess but the girl who runs the register always seems to give me a compliment every time and literally told me I have nice nails with no nail polish on last time. Like how cute and sweet. So, customer service is on point. They move FAST! The line is quick so if you are in a rush in the morning commute, definitely come to this location. It's hard to find a morning breakfast quick casual that has fast service but is not RUDE TO YOU. And this place is quite the opposite :) Food is on point and I love their coffee. They serve it super hot which I prefer. Only thing I wish they had is French vanilla creamer. They only offer half and half but no biggie. Pick a YAYgel ;) love em. read more

See all

May 2020, During Covid: After calling a couple Bagel spots without being able to reach someone directly and hearing 2 other shops didn't have Tofu Scallion Cream Cheese, Pick a Bagel answered and supplied! As always the shop is clean, service is quick and order is exactly what I wanted. read more

See all

I've been going to this place off and on for the past 24 years, (all the way back when it was on 3rd Ave), and over that time have seen the place decline significantly. Today I ordered an everything bagel with butter and what I got, for $3.10, is something that looked more like a plain bagel with lard, (to be fair it was like 40% butter and 60% lard). I will not be going back to this place again. read more

Everything bagel with scallion cream cheese was GREAT! Coffee was just ok. They have one bathroom, which was locked and didn't have a sign on it. read more

Decent everything bagel with lox spread, but not my go to black and white cookie spot. Finally had a pick a bagel after almost 2 years in the city. I use an everything bagel with lox spread as my comparison, and sometimes black and white cookies if they carry them. The bagel itself was slightly overdone but seasoned well. The lox spread had a very healthy schmear. There were some chunks of salmon throughout and the only complaint was that it was slightly too salty, but it is what it is. The black and white was ok. The cookie overall had good flavors, but I prefer my cookie and frosting to be soft in nature. Not the case here. read more

See all

Great bagel store. They make fresh ones everyday and they have tons of different cream cheeses to pick from. They make breakfast bagels too which are pretty good. They also have a bunch of different bagels. The counter is on the left when you walk in. They have drinks and seating in the back as well. I used to come here all the time years ago when I worked in the area. read more

See all

I walked out of here and went to the place with inferior bagels up the street. Why? Because the employees here were not wearing their masks properly. The guy stocking the beverage cooler and at least one of the guys serving bagels had their masks below their noses. If you don't make sure your employees are wearing their masks properly, you will not get my business. read more

Great, hearty bagels with a big selection of shmears - the plain with chives was incredibly satisfying. Bought a dozen and they stayed fresh for several days. Also very good bagel chips and black and white cookies. read more

Pick-A-Bagel is a typical ye ol' neighborhood bagel shop. The bagel portions are huge and come with a huge dollop of cream cheese of your choosing. You can get your bagel microwaved or toasted. The bagels are decent, but not spectacular. Just a typical new york bagel to fill you up. I tried a toasted sesame bagel with strawberry cream cheese and it was alright. The bagel was huge, making it tiring to bite into. The strawberry cream cheese still tasted mainly like cream cheese. There were bits of strawberry in it but the cream cheese seemed to have been mixed with red food coloring(???not sure). If you come here, come starving. read more

See all

I've been told before that I can be a real asshole when it comes to food. But when it really comes down to it, I love food, and I appreciate good quality food. So if I'm buying a bagel, I expect a real bagel, not some generic piece of dough that is shaped like a bagel. So I walked in here and saw all the fresh bagels being made in the back, I knew immediately this place is definitely kosher! I ordered their egg sandwich on whole wheat bagel with very little butter ($2.50) and boy was it good!!! The bagel is fat and their eggs were perfect. It was so big that I could only eat half of it and was still feeling pretty darn satisfied. All in all, I really like this place. Their location is spacious, clean and the servers are friendly and quick as a New York minute! read more

See all

I hear from very reliable sources that this place is dirty. The one thing any restaurant can control is its cleanliness. If the owner spent less time acting like a juvenile with his responses to negative reviews and more time cleaning, this might be a place to visit. Until then stay away. read more

Sooooo good! I wanted a lox bagel so bad and pick-a-bagel did not disappoint! I mobile ordered and everything was ready when I got there. The employees were super nice. Will definitely come back again, already missing my lox bagel. read more

Pick a Bagel - Belly Lox Sandwich with Tomatoes - Bagels Near Me - New York, New York

do not waste your money here - the staff is so rude, horrible horrible customer service. I have never interacted with someone so RUDE for absolutely no reason. If you want to be disrespected, definitely head to this bagel place. read more

Best bacon egg and you will ever have. Even their bagel with cream cheese will change your life. Get the chocolate chocolate muffin too- it's so moist. Service is quick and the vibes are great. I love this Pick a Bagel read more

Pick a Bagel - bacon egg and cheese - Bagels Near Me - New York, New York

Man, the audacity of this place. Where to begin? Let me first start by saying I've owned bagel stores in Manhattan and New Jersey for 20 years. I understand inflation, rent hikes, recessions and everything in between. But paying $10.25 for a baconeggandcheese on a wrap is straight bunk. And to have the employee roll his eyes when I ask for ketchup packets is beyond offensive. As I peruse the reviews, the fact that the owner goes off the rails like an entitled kid in a candy is disgusting. Food actually isn't bad. Hard to enjoy when your bank account suffers and any vocalization will be met by the bagel nazi. read more

As a response the the comment left my the owner to my post from a month ago ... the whole tone of his comment is another reason why I don't recommend his business and reflects exactly what I said about his attitude. Also I did not say I ate the bagel I actually threw it out. What I did do was place an order the next day to pick up like I did every single day just like always because I figured your business made an error when they made it incorrectly and like I stated in my fist post and in person and I will state here again ... yes I work next door... however I was working and the whole point of picking it up was because I could not leave the office once I was there. The order was wrong, I could not and would not eat it and therefore should not have had to pay for it so I reported it to grubhub which is where I ordered it through as I should have. End of story. I went on with my day. Your business is the only one I have ever had an issue with like this. You are highly unprofessional. I care not what other people did. Your behavior is what makes your business terrible. The mistake made by the person preparing it wasn't an issue. You are the issue. The fact you are even continuing this is appalling. Unfortunately after meeting you in person, I expected nothing less. read more

10x better bagels and suckers, really good service. Odd thing is that a bagel with cream cheese and lox is 13.50, a bagel with lox and cream cheese on the side is 16.50. Employee says it's the boss' policy. What if I like to control my cream cheese distribution?? It's $3 extra? Could be 4 starts but owner's policy drop it a star. read more

I used to love Pick a Bagel at their old spot and have debated writing this for a while, but at the end of a day if you're looking for a bagel you need to Pick-a-somewhere else because this is more miss than hit as of late. First, the food: the bagels are extremely dense and chewy. While you want a good bagel, here one bite will have you chewing for a while. Their bacon is paper thin and leaves a lot to be desired. They do earn a point because at least the eggs are cooked here and not a microwave. Second: the service is okay. The cashier is nice, but honestly the rest is lacking in my opinion. Maybe it's just my experience. They are quick at the very least. Third: pricing. Their pricing is OKAY. not great, not terrible. However they'll up charge you if you use a card, and forget ordering online. What bagel spot has a $20 dollar minimum for delivery (which is subpar and often arrives cold)?! Finally, we come to the overall value. When you factor in all of the above you get a solidly mediocre experience. I wish they offered delivery with less than a $20 minimum, or went back to their old bagels because it feels like it's changed drastically. Maybe I'm looking at it with rose tinted glasses, but I remember pick a bagel being the best in the area at one point. read more

In Manhattan, you either get "jaw-droppingly expensive" or "terrible service," but Pick A Bagel goes the extra mile and delivers both. I stood in front of the cash register for several minutes before the girl acknowledged my existence, and that was only because I asked if I could please have the coffee I ordered. She started to check out the guy in line behind me (?) so I had to ask if I could check out...it made me wonder why they had anyone working the register. All of that might be excusable if the food was good, but the pastrami sandwich is quite bland. And it's hard to mess up a pastrami sandwich. Just go to a deli or any other bagel place. I never heard of a $15 bagel sandwich until I came here. read more