I'm going to say something controversial yet brave. I really think this place is…read moreoverrated....SORRY! I know this is an absolute staple in the area and it has its own regulars and cult following. However, if I wanted to go out for Italian food, I would not pick this place. In fact, every time I go here, it's always because of someone else's suggestion. There are some things on here that are fine - the pizza, for example, is sufficient. Their salads are also decent - usually large and fresh. But I've had some of their other hot foods and have been majorly disappointed. The calamari - from a bag, greasy. The grilled chicken panini - no flavor at all. I asked for balsamic vinegar and they had none, which is wild for an Italian restaurant. Even the wine tasted stale the last time I went here. I will give props to the waiters who are always very accommodating and pleasant. The vibe here is nothing fancy - more like a step up from a pizzeria, great to go after a movie or another activity. Like I said, this just wouldn't be my first choice for Italian food because there are much better places in the area, IMO.

I have been here numerous times over the years and I have always had a good experience here from…read morethe service to the food. The pizza here is really good, I believe it's brick oven. I've ordered their specialty pies to margarita pies and all have been solid. The large size comes in square form and the small comes as a pie. I've had pasta here as well and recently had the fettuccine Alfredo which was tasty and came with a grilled chicken pieces which was abundant. I highly recommend this spot if you're in the mood for good brick oven pizza especially since Brooklyn Pizzeria closed in Edgewater... * First come first serve - no reservation option

I have been here many times. This time I was craving a pizza and a glass of wine…read more It is so cozy here and the see ice is excellent. I had a maguerita pizza So so good. I was able to taste 2 wines and choose which on e I liked Great neighborhood place

Quality has taken a HUGE hit. I would usually give a place benefit of the doubt, of having an off…read moreday, but man this is on another level. Pizza has little to no sauce and the minimal cheese is over cooked so you get a red tinted pizza with chewy cheese. Salad is advertised to have Gorgonzola and some pears and walnuts, all you get is a pile of arugula and few shavings of Parmesan Had been here a few times and I'm done giving it a chance

I love this place! It brings me so much joy! Every time we go it is perfection! The trifecta…read more.. great food, great service, great ambiance! Thank me later! Incredible!

I've heard a lot of rave of this spot, many friends have hyped up their calamari, pasta, and…read moreambiance. Many reviews cover the large portion size-- which is absolutely accurate. Both main dishes could have easily been split up for 4 people. The Calamari as well-- which is considered the smaller portion-- is absolutely enough for 2. They gave bread and butter, as well as a simple salad which is always appreciated. Yes, this place is BYOB and the service was kind enough to offer an ice bucket as well. The food was delicious-- I loved my seafood pasta dish, their muscles were soft and clams were cooked just right. They even put fresh basil on every pasta dish. Only con I found was the overstimulating environment -- it is also an antique shop so there's many bags, jewelry cases, and many other interesting items everywhere. Cool concept, but I think with more elevation, and a better location, this place can really get a kick.

Always excellent food and service. Cosimo our waiter provided professional service. His…read morerecommendations were perfect. Having been going there for years and will in the future.

The service was amazing we had a great server and host but the food was subpar we found a baby sea…read morecrab in our oysters and for my linguini and meatballs I found eggshell left over from the prep

Delicious food- unique Italian offerings, beautiful outdoor seating, charming staff…read more Will definitely be back!

Great food, Great ambiance, great service and great…read moremanagement. The owner has lots of experience in the restaurant and hospitality business. They have brick oven and the food was so nicely served And presented.

This company is excellent, excellent! Nobody packs in such a careful way. They really take great…read morecare and everything arrives intact. Before discovering their website I tried twice to buy pasta De Cecco in the internet : it arrived pulverized. I tried to buy in the internet jars of glass : they arrived broken. I give them five stars, only because it is not possible to give ten stars. Buy with confidence!

I ordered some drinks on about July 9 . I paid. The paying process even required a tip…read more July is gone and I have not received anything. I messaged and emailed them: no answers. Today , August 1st, I called : just an automatic answer. It looks like they are on a kind of vacation or something else and coming back around August 13 . Is the "shipping" in two or three days just a fairy tale to get money asap and propose for tips ? I do not know yet.

3 of us went last night and had a wonderful meal. It has its own plentiful parking lot, and it's a…read morebyob, Two pluses, you do have to walk up one flight of stairs. The place has very comfortable atmosphere. The food was terrific and the portions huge. We had a super big salad that two people can easily share. For dinner I had the chicken Scarpariello, the wife, chicken Pizzaiola and our friend had the chicken Picatta. Cindy, the owner has a careful eye on everything the whole operation I'll be going back and picking up some take out

We have only ever ordered from Pomodoro for take out and haven't dined in yet. The past few times…read morewe have gotten food from here, it has always been positive experience . We ordered two pizzas and an order of meatballs. I didn't see the meatballs order, however my husband said it was good. The pizza I had was delicious with chicken, penne vodka sauce, and mozzarella on the soft dough. Pomodoro is noticeable as you drive by the location down a broad street. Surrounded by a few other stores. Plenty of parking, wait take might take some time - check in from time to time in case your order is ready. All payments are accepted. Be prepared to be full from their food.

Another great meal. I love the grilled chicken salad here. I mix the balsamic dressing and Italian…read more Some grated cheese. Yum. And my friend says the cheese ravioli is delicious.

On a very very short list of regular favorite restaurants. I probably eat here, or do takeout…read moreorders, once every week. Service is great, vibe is relaxed, food is consistently good. Favorites? Pizza (anchovies, pepperoni, or mushroom), grilled chicken salad, sausage and peppers, and chicken parm. Yum! Also love the broccoli rabe, broccoli, and roasted potatoes as side dishes. Appetizers: fried calamari, mussels In marinara sauce, and breaded chicken tenders. Sandwiches: chicken cutlet, chicken parm, and meatball parm. Also awesome for parties! They have a large party room upstairs and a smaller one in the back.