Our order is a simple cheese pie and they do it perfect here! So glad we found this place.read more

Ordered: Regular Cheese Slice (~$3)…read more Aya's take: Perfect Pizza is definitely a hidden gem and I wouldn't have known about it if it wasn't for Dave Portnoy giving it an 8.5 on One Bite. As a born & raised New Yorker, I feel like I have high standards when it comes to pizza and this one did not disappoint. The Regular Cheese Slice had the right ratio of cheese to tomato sauce, the tomato sauce was mild and not too sweet or acidic which I appreciated, and the dough was perfect! The undercarriage was crispy with an even browning and I loved how thin the crust was. Check them out!

Best Italian place in the area. They have the best sauce. I love their bake ziti. Great delivery…read moretoo.

I ordered a large pie. It came to me burnt and hard as a rock. If I bit into the crust it would…read morehave broken my tooth. I called the store and they kept on telling me to complain to Uber. I asked them "Why" being yo are the ones that cooked the food. They couldn't answer me. $28 down the drain. WARNING - YOU WILL BE SORRY TO ORDER FROM THIS STORE.

Ordered a Philly cheesesteak hero on a Sunday night to enjoy while watching my favorite Netflix…read moreshow and it was WOW! First of all, this thing was HUGE! And it was made exactly the way I ordered it - perfectly toasted bread, onions and peppers, American cheese, salt & pepper, and just the right amount of oil. TBH, what could be better than ending the weekend with a hot, juicy, cheesy Philly cheesesteak made exactly the way you want it? That first bite was pure happiness. 10 out of 10 Sunday night comfort food! Thank you WNY Pizza!!!

Best pizza in West NY hands down! I recommend the buffalo, grandma, plain...it's all deliciousread more

Delightful place and great service. The staff was so attentive and provided great recommendations…read more Be prepared for nice, shareable portions. It's big, family style type servings.

Love this place. Never fails to please us. Great…read moreheartwarming dishes. The gnocchi sorrentina, the octopus carpaccio. I can go on an on with their menu. The only Italian for me and my wife. We have been going there alone and every time we have guest. They also live it. It does feel like home.

Good food love the place its clean the workers are so polite a lots Place enough to parkread more

Good food, excellent service, and a comfortable neighborhood atmosphere…read more I started with the Eggplant Rollatini, and honestly, it stole the show. It was flavorful, perfectly cooked, and easily my favorite dish of the night. I would absolutely order it again. I ordered the Chicken Parmigiana, which was cooked well. The breading stayed crispy, the cheese was balanced, and it was a satisfying meal. The sauce was good, although it wasn't my favorite part of the dish. Juliana provided wonderful service and surprised me with a complimentary tiramisu, which was a thoughtful touch. The tiramisu was good, but I've definitely had stronger versions elsewhere. There were a couple of small issues during my visit, a noticeable odor near the outdoor seating and a very loud child inside but neither reflected the quality of the food or service. One suggestion would be to replace chipped serving plates. Small presentation details make a difference. I'd definitely come back. It may not be the best Italian restaurant I've visited, but it's a solid neighborhood option, especially if you're nearby.

We ordered a pepperoni onion and olive pizza. High quality sauce, not too sweet or tangy. It was…read morecooked well, right amount of crunch to it and great crust. Only a couple of tables inside. Unbelievable service when ordering and took less than 15 minutes for our order to be ready. Would definitely recommend giving this place a try!

We ordered dinner - the shrimp parm was burnt to the bottom of the pan so all the sauce tasted…read moreburned the meatballs are frozen Costco tasting everything was bland and blah . Been there for years so I finally tried them. If u want real Italian this isn't it.

The pizza is always delicious ! And if something goes wrong with the order they replace it.read more

Don't go here unless your Elon musk, they charged me $16 for 2 pepperoni and some sausage wrapped…read morein bread. Food is ok but prices are up the ass

Ordered takeout... Calamari was rubbery and chewy -- tossed it right into the trash. Nonna's…read morelasagna must've been reheated because the bottom noodle was cooked so hard it was inedible (not to mention, it's a tiny slice for $20). The margherita pizza crust was also chewy and unpleasant... Sad to see the quality has fallen off here. Anyone can have a bad day but for $60 bucks I expect a bit more quality control. I don't normally like to dump on local businesses but I won't soon be ordering from here again. Very disappointing takeout experience.

My wife & I were here to celebrate her birthday eve…read more We were in search of an Italian restaurant that offered BYOB service (no corkage fees) and surprisingly almost all of them around where we live in Englewood Cliffs and the neighboring towns were not! We were looking for a nice sit down & nothing crazy expensive. We were a little concerned about being overly dressed up for this spot until we got here and were so happy to enter into this quaint little restaurant, beautiful small town Italian charm, classic Italian music playing. We were comfortably seated while watching the FIFA games, doing plenty of people watching & experiencing first hand the vibrance of guttenberg downtown! Think mini NYC We ordered the Linguine Fruitti Di Mare pasta & the Tropical Pizza . Couldn't have been happier! The pasta was rightly spiced, rightly sauced, rightly textured while the pizza was light & airy, just right amount of sauce, cheese and toppings! They treated us to a free dessert & we went with the chocolate mousse (think a multi-layered layered cholate cake) which was beyond perfection! They brought us champagne flutes (not wine glasses), as we had a bottle of prosecco to celebrate the special occasion Service was better than white-glove!!! Staff refilled our flutes before we realized, brought warm bread to the table without us asking for it, didn't charge us for the dessert without us even remotely suggesting it! Warm, friendly, attentive, impeccable service and reasonably priced Definitely going to drop in here again!

Are these the nicest guys in NJ? Is the bread here going to take your sandwich to the next few…read morelevels? Is the pepperoni a perfect chalice of grease and flavor? Yes, yes, yes! This is a classic deli, walls full of tomatoes, pasta, family photos, and citizen of the year awards. (It only takes one interaction to understand why.) you can sit outside in nice weather, but the chit chat inside makes you feel especially welcome. My only regret is we forgot to get cannolis on the way out. (Probably because the portions are huge.) Not far off the highway so you can keep dad feeling like we're still making good time. We'll be back on our next Northeast haul.

I ordered delivery from here on a Sunday, took about 45 min, not bad…read more But the food was below mid. I ordered the buffalo wings, garlic knots, a small cheese pizza with vodka sauce instead of marinara & mushrooms, and a cannoli. The wings were not Buffalo, they were a mix between Buffalo and bbq. If I had known, would not have ordered. Did not like the bbq sauce flavor. I also asked for ranch as I despise bleu cheese but alas, I did not get ranch and had to eat my wings plain. Garlic knots were perfect. The pizza tho. Ugh, it was so bad. They made a cheese mushroom pizza with way too much cheese and then put the vodka sauce on top after!!! Like a drunken grandma pie. That's not what I wanted. I asked for, "a cheese pizza with vodka sauce." It was so soggy that it soaked through the bottom of the box. Stayed soggy even after reheating in the oven. I ate half a slice and tossed the rest sadly. I won't be ordering from here again. The cannoli was fine but wouldn't order again either. The only thing I would eat again is the garlic knots. Very disappointing for Jersey pizza.

Stumbled upon this restaurant and the food was amazing! The bolognese is a MUST. Can't wait to go…read moreagain.

As some of the other reviews mentioned flavor was lacking - ordered a margarita pizza all you…read moretasted was the cheese, basil and tomato sauce flavor was underwhelming and the bread was not fully cooked. Server was not attentive and was lagging a bit for a slow night. Overall be prepared to be served food that will miss the flavor profiles and undercooked pizza