Service is top notch and food is terrific. Wings are real full chicken wings that leave little to imagination Love the ambiance, service and local feel. Give a shot if you are in area read more

The service was horrible we waited for 20 MINUTES before we could even get seated and then another 20 minutes just for a waiter to even get our drinks that we ordered and then on top of that they didn't have the drink that someone wanted so she gave us an attitude and rolled her eyes at us and the host was rude!!!!! read more

Love. Waited for a couple visits to review. The staff is amazing. The kid who was hosting on the Sunday afternoon we last visited was fabulous. Warm and engaging to everyone. While wings are why we go, the sandwiches are awesome too. Drinks are always cold. The people and bike-watching is fun too! Lastly, the drive to get there from the shore reminds us how beautiful our state is... read more

See all

My husband and I visited on a Sunday whim. Awesome food!! The salads were humongous. The sauce for the chicken was great!! We do plan to visit again!! read more

All you can eat wings Wednesday. 5pm to 9pm i believe. Great service every time. The only reason I'm giving the 4 stars is basically after the second round they rush the wings and they tend to under cook them. But next time I'll just ask for well done. read more

Pic-A-Lilli Inn - Buffalo wings - American Near Me - Shamong, New Jersey

Great food, great boneless chicken tails 10 pieces for $19, reasonably priced. Very moist and well prepared. Choice of sauces or you can get the sauces on the side. Nice place. The ambiance may look like a tavern, if you go in the afternoon you can be seated by a fish tank or fireplace. The waitress was friendly. Nice visit! Excellent boneless chicken tails , pleasant surprise. In the Shamong, NJ area. The photo has a little shade on the photo, the sun was coming in the window, so the waitress closed the blinds in order to enjoy our meal better. read more

Pic-A-Lilli Inn - Pic-A-Lillie Boneless Tails - American Near Me - Shamong, New Jersey

Went here in the motorcycle with my fiancé. This was my second time here. 1st time, I wasn't impressed...this time however, I was. The only reason I didn't give a 5 star was I reserve those for places that cannot be duplicated. It is Covid time but they really have it down pat. Lots of seating and everyone is very attentive to all their customers. We ordered the Tails, (smoker sauce was amazing) Cajun fries and corn fritter things. We got the filet mignon sandwich to go for my son. Everything was amazing! The boneless wings and fries were done perfectly as were the corn fritters. I will eat here again for sure! read more

See all

The food is alway great and the service is wonderful. We are always happy to go there even though it's almost an hour away.

Love the Pic, going today. Great pub food with a great variety and excellent quality. World's best wings. Also they support the local community with food and other donations for groups and schools. read more

There's so much I could say about this place, but I'm going to cut to the chase. BEST. WINGS. BY. FAR. NO. ANDS. IFS. OR. BUTS. It's the sauce. All about that sauce. Many nights were spent with my bestfriend as a teenager with an order of 50 wings to split... like challenge accepted and mission accomplished. Great memories. And now my husband is hooked, like he should be. Recently ordered during quarantine and branched out with a buffalo chicken cheesesteak. Yum! Seriously I think you could just douse whatever in the buffalo sauce and their blue cheese, and anything would taste good. read more

See all

Amazing beer and wings! I stop in every time I can for their incredible selection of wings. These are some of the best in south jersey.

My husband and I rode on his motorcycle there on a Saturday and it was crazy busy. Filled with bikers. The servers were stretched thin and running around doing their best. So of course the service wasn't great but it was understandable. I don't think people come to bars like this for the service to begin with. The atmosphere was lively and fun. The wings and cheesesteak were delicious. I'd definitely come back, just not if I'm starving since there's a bit of a wait. read more

Pic-A-Lilli Inn - Cheesesteak and wings - American Near Me - Shamong, New Jersey

Fun place to stop and grab a bite!!! Laurel was our waitress, she was super fun and she made this part of our trip to NJ memorable.

The beer was cold and good. They had Mad Elf on tap which is only the best way to drink that beer. We got jalapeño poppers, they were over cooked but somehow still cold in the center. They however are the cheddar ones which most places serve cream cheese (ick) The table was dirty, It had sauce on it from the last people. We could see into the kitchen and it was god awful disgustingly dirty. There's just no way this place can't afford to keep it clean. The grime build up and how dirty the friers were made my stomach kind of turn knowing I ate what came out of them. The staff there was very nice. Waitresses are awesome. The wings were good. No fat which is great, and a lot of sauce. Their sauce was sooooo good. We got the spicy sauce. It was nice texture and sweet and spicy. Over all I would go back. I however may never order food from them again. read more

INCREDIBLE SERVICE!!! Laura was AMAZING! Very attentive, great sense of humor, put up with rowdy group of 16 and totally rocked it. Food was delicious. Thanks for accommodating us with such short notice. read more

See all

We stopped here for Lunch today. We ordered a chicken cheese steak which was great. We also ordered the honey hot and mild wings - these were incredible. Perfectly cooked and some of the best I've ever had. The waiter was very friendly and attentive. A must stop if close ! read more

Pic-A-Lilli Inn - Mild and honey hot wings! - American Near Me - Shamong, New Jersey

Crab bisque is to die for!! The bloody maries... I'm still thinking of them. 1 more, please!! Wings were delicious! And everything we had was amazing. The staff was super friendly; thanks! Definitely coming back!!! read more

Go enjoy yourself at the Pic! Family owned for almost a hundred years! It's got it all. People. Product. Price. First let me tell you that I haven't been here in 45 years (maybe longer). So I told that to one of the owners, Uncle Brucie (who doesn't look a day over 70, am I right?). He said "oh. You're a regular!" He's the guy that could be a stand in for Groucho Marx. He'll be running around like his niece Bonnie making sure your every need is attended to. Our waitress was Angela who should be on the Young and Restless, just an absolute delight who exudes customer service and genuinely looks like she likes her job. In fact, they are all working hard for total customer satisfaction! Bruce told us when he started working there he was told that make it a family place because that glass of beer tastes the same down the road. Good advice. My point is that you feel at home here and totally welcomed! Now let's talk food! My brother in law and I got what's called Tails. You might see Tails and Ears on the menu and say ooooh, I better stay away from those! You'd be wrong. You can get 5 or 10 or 15 tails so we both got 10 each. Ok. We're both in our 60's and I could only eat 6. He ate 5 and we were stuffed. You may consider getting them "dry" and dipping it yourself in the sauce. This way if you take them home you can share with others. Everyone enjoyed their meals and all 8 of us agreed to meet there again! Price? Very reasonable! I don't want to let out a very special secret but they have what's called "Tail Tuesday." Each (huge) tail made of pure chicken breast is lightly breaded (coated) and fried then dipped in sauce if you wish. We got 10 tails for $10! Overall I'm giving this place 5 stars because it was such a deal and the food and drink was excellent. Not to mention the super nice people who work there. And I mean that. You don't realize how much we appreciate your hard work. PS. We live exactly 25 miles from this place. But it's our new go to tavern! read more

Pic-A-Lilli Inn - 4 Chicken Tails left from a stack of 10 - American Near Me - Shamong, New Jersey

Great wings. Great beer selection. Great service. Ordered 25 Hot Wings. They were excellent. I look forward to going back to try other menu items. read more

Pic-A-Lilli Inn - American Near Me - Shamong, New Jersey

See all

Friendly, clean, excellent service eventho always busy, amazing food. The fame for their wings is well deserved. Crispy, not greasy, great sauces. I love that they offer boneless choices (I always get the tails). The parmesan garlic sauce is fantastic! I would also recommend the fried sweet corn bites appetizer. It is served with maple syrup for a dipping sauce. Delicious! Some diners may be put off by the roadhouse, dive bar vibe. But it is very approachable, don't miss out! read more

Pic-A-Lilli Inn - Sweet corn nuggets, with maple syrup for dipping. YUM! - American Near Me - Shamong, New Jersey

It's just a roadside cafe, so don't expect much. Food is lower average, beer is okay. Price is not reasonable for the quality they provide. And music is shit! read more

Excellent wings...fun vibrant atmosphere and I always find the staff to be friendly and attentive. Looking forward to the next time I'm out in that area and making a stop read more

Best wings I have ever had in my life hands down. Nothing compares. At least a 45 minute drive but let me tell you WELL WORTH IT!!! Amazing! read more

45 minute ride for the best wings I've ever eaten. We ate them off their food truck previously, and they were good, but, having them at the inn was an out of body experience. Most people already know how good these wings are, but added to that, is the staff. Not one miserable person there. All said hello, kept an eye on our table, and the most personable people. Some of the customers we met there were just as nice.(bowling pin painter). Im almost glad its far ,because I'd eat here at least 3x's a week. read more

See all

Good service - good wings , great music that night by Shaun Doyle! We sat at the bar and had a great time with the female bartender who's name is escaping me but she was fun! read more

I went here for some years when I lived closer. When I went, the outdoor bar ran a lot in the spring, summer, and fall. When I first started going, there was a really nice pool table which last few times I was there, in 2021, it was gone. It was nice to see the biker families come and go. It was a heavy biker bar in the past, but that decreased unfortunately. It used to have more of a dive bar feel too. It is still a great bar. Good drink prices. The people are wonderful there, and I made great friends and memories. read more

Ever since Covid came full-swing and took everyone down a notch, it's been hard to find places that kept the same quality and standards. Sadly, The Pic seems to be one of those places that went downhill. Perhaps I've just been going on bad days? With my last visit though, meats were dry and mildly overcooked, and I found my stomach feeling queasy the following morning... Newer joints have also begun topping them on flavorful ribs, brisket, and barbecue chicken. We've all still grown up hearing the radio commercials. The old-timey tune of it still brings a small smile to my face. There's still plenty of memories in the walls, too. Hell, some of us have friends that took up a job at one point or another serving here. It remains a community-driven and family-oriented place with history, and it'll stay alive so long as people keep using it as a hangout hub. I still love it, and hope it never fades away... although I do hope that I come back one day to see that it's as good again as I remembered. Long live the Pic! read more

The fire truck outside said their wings are so hot they need their own fire truck. I wasn't too impressed with their "hot" wings. The sauce wasn't spicy hot imo. It was an okay visit. Nothing spectacular about it that would make me drive out to. We stopped cause we were at Columbus market and took the 30 min drive to it since we were already out that way. If you get the combo basket, blue cheese and four tiny celery sticks are extra. Not impressed. The onion bites were so-so. Not worth the $$. There is nothing that really stands out for me. Wings are tiny, albeit you get the full wing bit who eats that wing part? Is there meat even on it? Four adults, two combo baskets, two orders of six wings with fries, onion peels and a couple of rounds of beers came to over $112.00. read more

Pic-A-Lilli Inn - American Near Me - Shamong, New Jersey

See all

Went on a whim. What a great idea! Had the "famous" wings and they were great! Also had a burger which was a 10 outta 10. My wife had the meatloaf and she said it was very good. The atmosphere was terrific. Very laid back. Service couldnt have been better. We will definitely go back! read more

Always a great time at the Pic. Wings are the best! Staff is attentive and the vibe is chill.

What can I say about the Pic? I love all the food there the pigs ears, the wings, scallops, shrimp, all the entrees have not found something I didn't like from the menu. The service is always friendly and quick. Beer is always ice cold the ambiance is hole in the wall local bar feel very relaxing, bikes look sketchy but the three piece patches 1%ers keep to themselves and don't bother the patrons. 10 out of ten for me.... read more

Great wings, Great ranch, good price. Nice environment, good place to go for some quality grub.

I have been here twice and the food and service were GREAT! But both times I've gone it has been the same singer and she is unfortunately really bad. We definitely left earlier than we would've. Next time I'll check before I go read more

Been going here for 25 years. Wings tails ears shrimp scallops. All great but I especially like the wings. On the smaller side which I like. I can't review their other food because I never get anything else. The buffalo rolls are amazing! read more

Pic-A-Lilli Inn - American Near Me - Shamong, New Jersey

I cannot say enough great things about this place. My hubby and I go all the time on the way to the Jersey shore. I normally get wings but this time I decided to switch it up and get the cream of crab soup and Shepard's pie. Both dishes were delicious. The Shepard's pie was one of the best Shepard's pie I've ever had. Our waiter Anthony was amazing. He was very attentive and constantly checked on us to make sure we didn't need anything. He was courteous and made sure we had a great experience while dining. read more

Upgraded dive bar with the best wings and best bartenders to make sure you're taken care. Nicki and Brook made me feel like I was at home. Brook made a suggestion on the wings that was just perfect. I can't wait to come back. The 1hr trip is worth it. They forgot about me in the beginning but offered a free beer to make up for it. This place is great. read more

I recommend this because the food is phenomenal and you get to get up and dance and play bingo

Was down in the pines searching for the Jersey Devil and the kids called looking for wings. The Pic was right up the road so I figured I'd run In and grab a tray. Not for nothing, searching for the elusive Jersey Devil will make you hungry. The car was filled with the scent of hot wings and my mouth watered the entire way. Got home and cracked open the tray and the family dove in. The wings here aren't big and the sauce has a strange sweetness to it. These particular wings were awful. The sauce, as I said was strange. The wings were not meaty and were full of plenty of broken bones. Makes for some unpleasant eating. It was awful. So if you're out searching for the Jersey Devil, don't bother looking around the Pic. Even old JD knows good wings so he clearly wouldn't be caught here. "Best wings in South Jersey"? Um. No. Not even close. read more

As one of my fellow yelpers commented, this is definitely a hidden gem! I didn't think wings could get much better than the Jug Handle but I do think these may take the prize. We started off with corn nuggets which are basically delicious little bits of fried corn served with syrup. Fabulous combination! We ordered mild and garlic parm wings and both were great. I think the garlic parm was my favorite but I'm definitely going back to try the others. They have a great beer list too! It may not look like much, and for me it was about a 45 minute drive into the wilderness, but it was definitely worth it and I can't wait to go back. read more

Pic-A-Lilli Inn is a landmark in the Pine Barrens. We were so excited to go there. It's a fourth generation family-owned establishment, and you can tell how prideful they are. The fact that they have local N.J. beers is a huge plus. They even have Brotherton, which is made right in the Pine Barrens closeby. They also had Cape May Brewery beers. Keep in mind that they still have all the standard beers of brands people recognize, too. My mom ordered the special Pumpkin Martini, and she said it was delicious. $6 is a reasonable price for a specialty drink like that, too. My cheesesteak was just so so. I also didn't do my thorough research on Yelp before I went because I apparently should have gotten the wings. They even had wet-naps on the tables for that reason. The only other annoyance is that we didn't have just one waitress so that our order could be consistent. We kept getting waitress after waitress visiting our table asking us if we wanted anything, and it started to get irritating. They had a singer with a band playing outside on the day we went. The singer was really talented. But great place overall! read more

See all