I probably shouldn't have gone out, but......... If you mention John and Molly's, I will throw myself together and run out the door with you So far everything that we have ate from their menu has been beyond delicious and with being in the middle of lent, I decided to give up cheese, big mistake, but I wanted to do something hard. But the service that is amazing and all the smiling staff here make up for anything that I don't see on the menu. The place is really well put together and is a very handsome bar it's mostly very wooden and heavy duty. The ambience is something for everyone on the TV or you can just chitchat. They even have this little side room that is nice but beware and bring a coat or a sweater cause it does get chilly in there. They're always seems like a really great group of people there and our favorite waitress is KB/Kristen. She is truly amazing and very attentive, but not annoying. We love their chicken fajitas and steak fajitas, the Cheesesteaks are delish! But My Newest Favorite for the Moment..... is the "We Jammin Burger". It has bacon onion Jam on it and it is amazing! I didn't think that I would like it as Much as I do! But I Realllllllly Do! I'm not really a burger fan... like my husband Is, But THIS BURGER..... has been a Game changer for Me. Warning: Make room in your fridge... because You will definitely bring leftovers home. This meal can feed a family of 4 Easily!! Their Cajun quesadilla is delicious and it does have a nice little zing. Their traditional wings are amazing and their beef stew is delicious and very hearty. We have tried many of their specialties. The Hail Mary is a delicious Caesar salad on top of chicken cutlets and their Broccoli Chicken Cheesesteak is amazing. I recommend you get it pressed on the grill and that way it won't fall out as you bite each delicious bite. I would say 80 to 90% of the visits that we have had at this amazing establishment. We always bring home leftovers. So be aware that you were going to have lunch for tomorrow. You will get to the point where you will just think of something to eat that they have on their menu and your mouth will just start to drool. We definitely recommend going. I'm not a huge drinker so I really can't say much as for their drinks but everyone there seems very happy and the portions are huge. I definitely say try it, what's the worst that happens you have leftovers for the next day or two lol It is my husband and my favorite new place that's been around forever Hey, maybe we'll see you there read more

See all

Pros: Our waitress, Alicia, was an absolute sweetheart and made several great food recommendations, including the hot honey wings, Jammin' burger, and chocolate cake--all of which were very good. The portion sizes were generous; both my burger and the Cheesesteak Deluxe were large enough that we brought leftovers home from both entrées. Cons: Unfortunately, the drinks were not good. I ordered a Downeast Cider on tap and it tasted like the line may not have been cleaned recently. My companion ordered a cosmopolitan that was essentially undrinkable--extremely strong and not well balanced. We later learned the bartender is new, so hopefully that improves with experience. The wings were also served cold, and the Jammin' burger came out without the bacon jam that's supposed to be a key part of the dish. The restaurant itself is also very tight quarters. If you prefer more personal space or feel more comfortable in places where it's easy to move around or exit quickly, this may not be the best spot for you. Overall: The staff was very attentive and clearly tried to make things right after several mistakes occurred. They comped our soda, appetizer, and dessert, which we appreciated. However, given the number of issues during one visit, I'm not sure we'd return. read more

John & Molly's - Jammin' burger without the bacon jam - American Near Me - Eastampton, New Jersey

See all

Still great and Huge portions! Chicken fingers for the kids Cheesesteak was good, flavor was okay but could've used more cheese Corned beef open sandwich with colwslaw was great and slammin' the next day Thanks guys! read more

We had not been here in a while Still great food and service Will make sure we don't wait so long read more

Went for a quick lunch and a few drinks today. Tried the Drunken Chicken Parm off the lunch menu, I've had the regular, this was a nice switch up. Sandwich, just like all of their portions, was huge and delicious! Service was great as usual, often we get takeout, but sometimes it's nice to sit inside and enjoy the feel of the local pub. Really nice draft, bottle, can, and drink selections. Went before happy hour, so we had no wait, but their Happy Hour is pretty solid. If you are looking for something good in the area, this is your spot. read more

John & Molly's - Drunken Chicken Parm. Lunch menu...sooooo good! - American Near Me - Eastampton, New Jersey

I reviewed before I think. For a local pub the food is really good. It's a popular spot. Not cheap but I haven't been disappointed. I just had the soup for lunch this time but I've tried lots even the high end food is good. read more

John & Molly's - French onion soup. - American Near Me - Eastampton, New Jersey

I love John & Mollys and always stop by to eat here when I'm in town. The restaurant itself is pretty old and run down, but it has a lot of character. There is dining room seating and bar seating on the other side. I almost always get the chicken parm when I come here. The price and portion size can't be beat for how good it is! I love their wings too. They are not those scrawny wings you get at some places, they actually have meat on them. They do lunch specials as well but you have to dine in to get them, which is a bummer if you don't have time and want to take it to go. But really I don't have much to complain about. The food is consistently good and service is always good as well. read more

Oh my gosh. When people say the portions are large, believe them. When they say, "it feels like visiting a friend's house", believe them. Stopped by while in town on business. About 4 pm. The bar was packed and everyone really seemed to be enjoying themselves. The restaurant started to fill up too before I left. Plenty of parking though. It was tough to choose - food AND beer. So many options for both and everything sounded delicious. Opted for the Napoleon Burger and subbed mixed veggies rather than fries. I'm stuffed. Everything was cooked perfectly. My waitress, Kimberly was friendly and super efficient. My only "regret" is that there was absolutely no way I could save room for dessert. Tiramisu cheesecake? Four layer carrot cake? Yes please!!!! read more

See all

Orders the Swiss burger on rye. Didn't have much taste nor seasoning. The burger I make at home is much better. Calamari was decent but a little chewy. Lots of rings which is good. Service a bit slow. My wife ordered a crab cake which resembled a croquet. The waitress lied to me and said it was jumbo lump. The eggplant I got was a side was not good. Waitress took over 10 minutes to bring out boxes for our food. The cocktail was stiff but I had better. Shame a bar cannot provide a decent burger but will try their wings next visit. Yelpers let me down again. For the quality, price, atmosphere (very loud), lack of service this place is as mediocre at best. read more

Food is awesome. Service is quick. Ambiance is nice. Will always hit them up for dinner

I'm quite impressed by this dive bar-ish restaurant. The hospitality was pleasant and the food was quite decent compared to other bars... trust me, bar food can go in many directions and you'll find out sooner or later what you ate. That prime rib sandwich was humungous and a tasty treat, especially with the side au ju. The wings were good, not the best, and definitely not the worst. Nachos were flavorful and hit the spot to complete this night. I liked how the bartenders were always around and offering to be of service, accomodated quite well for a pleasant experience. read more

See all

This place hits on all cylinders. A very comfortable and welcoming atmosphere and excellent service. You feel like you're at a relatives for dinner. Our server Karen was amazing and very attentive to our table. The food is high quality and the portions are Very generous. The side salads served with dinner are of nice size and fresh! The Chicken Henley was amazing with a great Marsala sauce. And my NY Strip was cooked to perfection. (Pittsburgh (Black and Blue) Rare. Tender and a quality cut of beef. This is a gem of a restaurant that is worth the trip and we definitely will be back!!! read more

John & Molly's - Chicken Henley (Marsala) - American Near Me - Eastampton, New Jersey

See all

It's been too long as I moved over an hour away. Still freaking amazing taste and ginormous portions! So glad they haven't cheapened out! Service is prompt and friendly. Food is hot, fresh and generous. Worth the trip, period. Oh yeah, come hungry and expect a wait! read more

See all

Back again after a short hiatus and it's always nice to come back to a place where they know your name know what you like. Know what you like to drink and where you can just eat drink and enjoy with the company. This time we went totally different than our past trips and opted for some sandwiches tonight my wife had a French dip, provolone and had a side of sweet potato fries, and I had the Brooklyn Reuben and swapped in mixed vegetables. Both sandwiches were fabulous. Reminded us of another time And we even brought home half for another dinner so we'll get to enjoy it again. read more

See all

Where can I start, I travel for work and I will be in the area every quarter for the next 5 years and I guess I found my favorite place for the area. The bartenders are the absolute best here!!! read more

I don't know how John and Molly's has passed my radar and I haven't reviewed them. We have been here so many times over the past several years and have yet to have a bad experience. John and Molly's is a cozy little bar with a dining area. They serve typical bar food as well as entrées. However, I can't speak for anything other than the amazing chicken parm. This is what I get every. Single. Time. I go! A chicken Parmesan that rivals just about any Italian restaurant I've been to this baby is huge and spans and even hangs off of the plate. Crispy. Juicy. Zesty sauce and melting oozing delightful cheese served with your choice of soup or salad always fresh and tasty. The service is always on point and all of the staff work together to make sure you have everything you need and your meal is just as you want it They do have a 90 minute table limit, but I have never been asked to leave. They definitely fill up fast. That said, we have never had to wait long for a table. When you have a craving for some chicken harm, I cannot recommend John and Molly's enough. You will not be disappointed. read more

John & Molly's - American Near Me - Eastampton, New Jersey

Stopped by John & Molly's after work at McGuire AFB, looking for something a bit different and stumbled on this gem thanks to Yelp. From the start, their beer and drink selection stood out with a great range that offers something for everyone. I ordered the NY strip, which came out juicy and perfectly cooked, paired with a loaded potato and baked eggplant. The biggest surprise was the eggplant. I didn't expect it as a side, but it was baked to absolute perfection. Crispy edges, tender inside, and seasoned just right. Honestly, it could have stood on its own as a main dish. What really made the experience exceptional was the service. My friend ordered a drink that didn't hit the mark for her. We were just going to let it go and try something else, but when the waitress came by, she noticed and immediately offered to replace it. No hesitation, just genuine care. That level of attentiveness is rare and really elevated the experience. The portions are massive. You will definitely leave full or with a box to go. The environment is awesome and perfect for meeting up with friends or colleagues to catch up on work and life. Between the great food, welcoming service, and generous servings, this is a spot I highly recommend and plan to return to. read more

John & Molly's - NY strip with two giant onion rings - American Near Me - Eastampton, New Jersey

Went to John & Molly's for my bff's birthday and John & Molly's lived up to the reviews! Wow! Service piece is extremely well thought out - text for wait list notifications (15ish minutes at 630 on a Friday night - originally told 25), friendly wait staff that is consistently baton passing to cover each other's tables when needed, special (veg) requests accommodated. Wonderfully friendly crowd and our waitress was a gem. Beer list is a wish list of all of the favs and lots of discovery - especially the specials (thank you for noting which kegs were already kicked!). Frosted glasses a plus. Although we didn't order, spotted a delicious plate of nachos piled high nearby and agreed we would have to get that next time. Started with the most ginormous onion rings and petal sauce - yum! My friend got the country chicken which is her usual favorite - like sausage peppers and onions pasta dish with a kick. Definitely could make 1-2 more meals out of the generous portion. I ordered the NY Reuben and as a vegetarian subbed in the mushrooms instead of the brisket and ordered it closed faced (also generous portion!). The thickness of rye bread is really meant for open faced, I later discovered - still good, but maybe a little more grease/grilling of the bread to bring out that Reuben flavor! Fries were fresh cut from what I could tell and deliciously hot out of the fryer. We closed the night with a nice slice of carrot cake - mentioned to the server if was a birthday and we got the best birthday treatment ever - staff got the whole restaurant to join in singing happy birthday and cake was complete with a candle. What a special night. So glad we chose John & Molly's for a special birthday dinner! read more

See all

Stopped by for a late lunch on Saturday afternoon around 2-3 PM. We were seated right away in the porch area, which the hostess confirmed with us beforehand. While the porch offers a nice spot, it's a little tight, and it's easy to catch snippets of nearby conversations. Our waitress was on point--quick with drinks, attentive throughout, and made sure everything was running smoothly. My girlfriend is a big fan of their Chubby Chicken sandwich and sticks with it every time, skipping the bacon. I gave the Jammin' Burger a try, and while I was hoping for a rarer cook, it still delivered. The bacon was flavorful, and the fries were crisp, perfectly seasoned, and really rounded out the meal. read more

See all

Back again and the mussels were outstanding. The service was really good with multiple people taking care of you. read more

John & Molly's - Mussels - American Near Me - Eastampton, New Jersey

A pleasant place with good food. Stopped by with my friend to grab dinner the other night. We split the big papa wings along and I got a bacon cheese burger. The dozen wings were pretty big and very flavorful. The burger was well cooked and a decent size as well. Staff is very friendly and the place was very clean. My friend highly recommended this place and I'm happy we came. I will definitely be coming back in the future. read more

The food was great and our waitress Heather was fantastic. We had the fish and chips, Manhattan clam chowder, and lemoncello mascarpone cake. I would recommend all of them. read more

See all

John & Molly's has some of the best bar food I've had, located within a historic building. The wings are rated, seemingly independently, as some of the best in the state and they were addictive. They serve a breaded fried chicken-style wing that's properly crispy and juicy with a variety of sauce options. I had the sauce of the month, the mango habanero, which seemed house-made with a solid balance of sweetness and spice. Then the fried bar combo, only available during 4-6pm during the week, might have been even better: mozzarella sticks that pulled far with an accompanying marinara sauce that had depth and flavor, onion rings with thick-cut onions and a crispy exterior, chicken tenders that probably are the generic type, and potato skins that are loaded and pleasantly fluffy. This has the appearance and staff of a quaint neighborhood bar, where it's welcoming as if a patron is visiting a family member at their home. The kitchen also appeared to be clean, and they go further than average to have uniquely large dishes that would make me want to come back despite the restaurant being out of the way. read more

John & Molly's - Wings - American Near Me - Eastampton, New Jersey

See all

Food is very good , service is great Pricing is fair and food is on extra Side with food to take home. read more

Great portions for the price! Great local place to visit ...we'll be back soo. for sure

Excellent food with great service. Our waitress Kristen was awesome. Burger was delicious and my chicken Madeira was really good. Thin sliced tasty chicken and a huge portion. We will be back. read more

My new favorite place when I'm at Fort Dix. It's a quick 20 minute drive and worth it. The food is awesome and very friendly staff. read more

John & Molly's - Chicken Parmigiana Dinner - American Near Me - Eastampton, New Jersey

Unfortunately NOT as good as they used to be. Ordered a turkey reuben. Hardly any turkey, the coleslaw & cheese were fine, but they put this on extremely huge Texas toast type of bread. The bread is about 3/4" thick, giving the false appearance that you have ordered a large sandwich, but all you get is way too much bread. If you want a bread sandwich, with minimal meat, then order the turkey Reuben. Shame on them for even including the word TURKEY in this sandwich. About done with this establishment. Apparently, like so many places in this state in recent years, quality & quantity just don't matter. Customers notice and move on! read more

Food was very good much better than other local restaurants. Service was quick and friendly with a great atmosphere

Good good, good service, nice ambience. Generous plates, good vibes, fair prices. Go! read more

Wow!! Thank you Yelp!! We feel like we found a hidden gem!! But it's definitely not hidden. It was a pretty busy tavern. Service was wonderful! The food was delicious! The portions are huge!! I had the Country Chicken. So much flavor!! It is listed as spicy. You can request the level of heat. They add red pepper flakes. I asked for a little and it was perfect. My husband had the Spaghetti and Meatballs which is a Sunday special and enjoyed it. I definitely recommend this restaurant! We will definitely be back! read more

See all

Great overall experience! Food was very good and came in huge portions. Service was very attentive and the atmosphere was very friendly. Despite being very busy food came quick. Nothing bad to say about this place! read more

See all

Cute local spot great to grab a bite and drinks. This is a nice size space with a large bar. I went in on a Wednesday nite and it was surprisingly business. Since it was only 2 of us we just sat at the bar. The staff was really nice and very helpful. Both of the ladies working the bar that nite was great. They were also playing the musical hits from early 2000's hiphop and R&B which was a plus. They basically have the ultimate bar game day foods, in large portion size. This place is great for groups/families, you can feed an army. I got the pizza which was ok...had way too many green peppers and not enough pepperoni and sausage. The cheesesteak was also good. read more

John & Molly's - American Near Me - Eastampton, New Jersey

See all

Service was pretty decent. The Sunday funday menu had a lot of different options for the family. The restaurants serves big portions so you will have a lot to take home. read more

We were able to be seated right away on a Friday night. Our server Kim was so much fun! Started off with amazing drinks and very flavorful disco fries. Our salads were very fresh and main course was phenomenal. I recommend the mile high meatloaf. read more

John & Molly's - American Near Me - Eastampton, New Jersey

The restaurant was chosen for convenience sake as out of town friends happened to be in the area and this was a decent choice near their hotel. PROS: Nothing fancy inside, but staff were very friendly and welcoming. Food portions were huge. I ordered the supreme pizza but asked for more veggies and no pepperoni and it was very good. Bathrooms were clean. CONS: LOUD. As in so loud that it was difficult to have a conversation and I almost lost my voice trying to get heard. The iced tea had no flavor. Decent choice, just not my first choice for a future meet up. read more

Another delicious meal on Friday night! French Onion Soup was excellent as usual. My husband had the Seafood special and I had Chicken Wrap. Wrap was huge and took half home, however that's not unusual, there's always leftover to go home with the generous servings. Kim was our server who was courteous and attentive. She mentioned she's new and I hope she stays as she would be a good addition to their staff. read more

Large portions for the price! First time here and I'll definitely be back. Not too long of a wait for Friday. The French onion soup is to die for! One of the best I've had. Lots of onions. Exorbitant amounts of cheese. Not overly salty. Very filling. Didn't need a big entree after it. I also had the New York Reuben but took 1/2 home. Very large sandwich. The corned beef was fresh and tasty. The bread was a little thick for my taste. It wasn't the best one I've ever had but I'm partial to ones that aren't open faced. The rest of the table had the fried chicken and the rodeo burger. No complaints!! Everyone left full and satisfied. The service was quick and friendly!!! read more

John & Molly's - New York Reuben - American Near Me - Eastampton, New Jersey

See all

I mean not only is the food as delicious as the posts I see of them on social media and my return visit here is long overdue but I forgot how obnoxious the portion sizes are...A+ leftovers Very friendly staff, cozy neighborhoods atmos and the the owners are rock solid people @dionysioshalo Hope this place continues to stand the test of time and look forward to poppin out here time and again! read more

See all

Stopped by with a large group and was seated within 10 minutes on a busy weekday evening. I had heard about their portions and my pasta serving was huge! I took home leftovers and it was enough for 2 additional meals. Our waitress did a good job on checking in refills. Enjoyed the meal. read more

John & Molly's - Mussels in red sauce - American Near Me - Eastampton, New Jersey