Stopped by Petey's Eatey's twice after having menu items recommended to me on my video's. First time was to try the cheesesteak and then I came again to try a mammoth breakfast sandwich (the belly buster). Both of these trips were a little while back and I'm honestly due to stop in again and try something else out. I stopped in for the cheesesteak December of 2021 and I went back for the breakfast sandwich December of 2022. The cheesesteak had the cheese mixed throughout and it was on a pretty solid roll. There was less meat than I had hoped (trails off towards the end of the roll on both sides) and it honestly could have used more cheese too, but it was definitely something that would scratch an itch. At the time the price was excellent (like $8.50 or something in that range) but I am not sure if it's still around that price or not. This isn't something I would go out of my way to get again, but it wasn't something I was upset about at all. The breakfast sandwich was a beast. Pork roll (or whatever you call it), bacon, eggs, cheese, hash brown on a Kaiser. The flavor was good all separate and once I was able to actually get my mouth around it and get everything in one bite, it was solid. It isn't something I would suggest eating often, and I'm sure your cardiologist would agree. Either way, pretty tasty stuff. Going to have to check back in soon for sure, but for an economy steak I was happy and for a once a year breakfast or so, it did the trick. read more

See all

The best place around for a great portion. The price is fair but the wait can be a pain. Best ice cream too. But like all good things the party is over. They closed their doors for good a couple months ago. Going to it into a convenience store. Sad ! read more

A great place to eat. It is sad they closed. Really miss the food, prices and employees.

Was recommended to Petey's by a vendor in the area - shoutout to Bernie. This was by far the best cheesesteak I had while i have been working in the area. I'm pretty new to the sauce vs. gravy argument of a cheesesteak, and how they are assembled here vs. what one looks like in Michigan. The one i ordered had jalapenos, a healthy mix of savory sauce and flavorful meat. You order from a window like a drive-in, and it's attached to a gas station, so i wasn't really having high hopes. However, it was pretty solid. read more

Outside dining at Petey's is a thing. Stop in for ice cream or hot dogs or burgers but I was here for a cheesesteak. Order at the window and they'll call out your order. The young lady who took my order said 25 minutes but it ended up being 9. Bonus for me! I sat outside at their covered dining patio, unwrapping the sandwich and enjoying it with a can of soda I'd brought along. The sandwich was good, not great. Definitely served hot and properly stuffed with thin sliced steak and mushrooms. More cheese would have definitely done it and yes, because I'm not from around here, I would have added ketchup. Parking in their small lot is cool but will be tough during the peak summer months. I would have to imagine that this place is hopping on a Friday night when school's out. [Review 15142 overall, 644 of 2021, number 559 in Pennsylvania.] read more

See all

This hidden gem has the BEST breakfast sandwiches around! Nobody compares to Petey's! Great burgers, lunches also. Can sit outside too! Friendly staff wraps up the all around goodness of this place. read more

What a cute little place! The breakfast grub was pretty good! Loved their sandwiches. The people were nice too. But that parking lot, let me tell you about it: if you don't have money for a spare tire don't even bother rolling in. Park down the road. The common folk who dine there all look like typical Nazareth fare. Nothing exciting about the area. read more

The food and ice cream are amazing and delicious. The service and ambiance are wonderful too.

On a work trip today I was in the mood for a hot dog and to my surprise I found Petey's Eatey's and it was good. I ordered two scooby dogs-chili cheese wiz, mustard dogs very yummy I would definitely come here again!! read more

Petey's Eatey's - a chili cheese dog - Cheesesteaks Near Me - Nazareth, Pennsylvania

See all

Gas station take out? Hell yeah! It's actually a really good cheese steak and fried food place. The people are nice and the food comes out hot and quick. If you're looking for a Michelin star... not your place. If you're looking for some good fried sides and a really tasty big cheese steak, it's a really good spot ! read more

This place used to be great! Now it's just filled with arrogant teenagers that don't care. Waited 45 minutes for a hot dog and pork roll sandwich. Only one there waiting. All kids inside throwing food and talking. Zero supervision. I could see them burning my pork roll and laughing. Skip this place read more

Petey's Eatey's - a half eaten sandwich - Cheesesteaks Near Me - Nazareth, Pennsylvania

Good value for the money! Fully loaded Italian hoagie was filling even to share! Call ahead to avoid the wait- they're always busy! read more

Petey's Eatey's - Italian Hero - Cheesesteaks Near Me - Nazareth, Pennsylvania

Very disgusting food no love was put into this food it reminds me of high school lunch, ordered a cheese steak worst one I've ever eaten in my life looks like cat food read more

Petey's Eatey's - a plate of food - Cheesesteaks Near Me - Nazareth, Pennsylvania

Very disappointed in Petey's . Their service has gone down hill. The kids working there have a " I don't care attitude". I ordered a hot fudge sundae to go. It took them close to 15 minutes to make it. There was no other customers before me. In face the girls where just chatting when I walked in. And this is how I found my sundae. The fudge is to one side and it's not even hot. I guess I'll start going to Zanette's in East Lawn. They are farther away. But at least they have a friendly staff who knows how to make a hot fudge sundae. read more

Petey's Eatey's - A hot fudge sundae made wrong - Cheesesteaks Near Me - Nazareth, Pennsylvania

Food is normally good there. My go to favorite is the pork roll sandwich, however I do prefer it without the long blond hair in it. We called to tell them about it and they said sorry and you can come back for another one. My dinner was ruined, so I can get in my car and drive 10 miles one way, spend 4 bucks on gas, and a half hour of my Sunday, or how about hair nets. RS in Pen Argyl read more

Food was good but there was about 7 or 8 people working and we stood in line waiting to have our order taken for almost 10 mins. Not to mention it took over a half hour before we got our food while 3 people that were there who ordered after us got their food first. The girl said that it was almost ready, which it was about 5 mins after she told us that. The kicker is.. our food was sitting on the finished food tray for a good 10 mins before they packed it up after she told us that.they were all to busy joking around that they were oblivious to what was going on around them . I don't even know if the kid who took our order worked there.. I've never had a complaint with food or service here before so it's a shame to have that happen. read more

WOW - DON'T order hot peppers on steak sandwich unless you want your mouth on fire - they put jalepeno peppers on. And no sauce could be seen. Threw in the garbage because impossible to pick all the peppers out and very unpleasant to eat. This place used to be great - way downhill now. Won't order again. read more

This is my go to place for a cheesesteak. Two people can eat one cheese steak. The picture is actual size so bring on you hunger

Ordered from door dash so I've never actually been here. I got a chicken Cesar salad and a cheese steak. I was disappointed in the salad. First, no one puts onions on a Cesar salad. Second, the chicken was unseasoned. Third, I was given a packet of Cesar dressing. Who doesn't know how to make Cesar dressing? It's 3 ingredients! And you mix it in the lettuce! I unfortunately got sick after I ate this meal. I felt awful for the rest of the day. I'm hoping it was just the salad/chicken and not my remaining cheese steak that is in the fridge for lunch today... read more

Yesterday was the second time I took the family to Petey's Eatey's. Both times we were not disappointed. The food is all fresh with extremely generous portions and the prices are cheaper than what would be expected. The menu is HUGE. Don't forget to look on the wall to see their daily specials, as they are obviously not on the regular menu. This place is geared for takeout, but there is a small dining area attached, which is heated in the Winter. I am simply astounded at the variety of food such a small place has to offer. I definitely will keep coming back. read more

Petey's Eatey's - Outside - Cheesesteaks Near Me - Nazareth, Pennsylvania

See all

I prefer their breakfast over lunch. Breakfast sandwiches are out of this world! Cheesteaks are just meh.

This place is a Disaster. Malfunctioning gas pump. The parking is horrible. The the staff is rude. Peteys staff is under educated trash with hostile temperament. Obviously these people work here for a reason. That's not my fault. I will report the leaky malfunction gas pump to PA DEP. I paid for gas 6/5/19 went to my pump, picked up the gas nozzle and it began to spray gas all over me and my car. The handle on the pump was damaged and jammed I couldn't get it to stop. It finally stopped and I went inside to tell the cashier. I asked him to put my gas on another pump that was not malfunctioning. He did not know how. He called another woman for help and she proceeded to set blame on me for the malfunctioning gas pump? She screamed at me? I told both of them check your camera you will see what Happened. They then asked for my debit card and told me they refunded my money and would put it on a different pump. 20 minutes later I finally have the gas. Checking my bank statement I have been charged twice? They lied. Screamed at me and damaged my $45,000 BMW's paint. All DUE TO THEIR MALFUNCTIONING GAS PUMP. I live up the street for about 45 years and I will never step foot in this place again. I will be sure my neighbors know how the staff treats customers. I never raised my voice but the woman on the phone was horrid. Get gas at Texaco down the street. read more

Young kids not knowing that steak sandwiches get sause, who eats a dry steak sandwich? The place has changed, the amount of steak meat filled the roll in the past but not now. The past year the amount of meat is less and less every time, in fact I took a fork and pushed the meat from one half to the other and made a normal looking steak sandwich. 50% less meat, rip off. read more

Great steak sandwiches, milkshakes and ice cream!!!! The service could be better, though.

The food is average but the wait time is god awful. Plus the workers were kind of rude. I don't know why it takes 25 minutes to make chicken nuggets fries and a soda. read more

Great spot for ice cream or steak sandwich... workout at Jacobsburg State Park, then a snack!!!!! Great excuse to exercise!!!!!

my husband has been telling me about this place. He's from PA I'm a Staten islander .. Now that we're making the move to PA together we're constantly driving back and forth so today we finally stop at petey's and omg I regret not coming here when he first mentioned them! I got the Cali burger on a whole wheat wrap he got a buffalo chicken wrap and they were amazing. Milkshakes and pierogies also! I told him We need to try everything on this menu which he probably already has! But I def recommend it! For the price and serving size It's crazy read more

Petey's Eatey's - Cali burger on a whole wheat wrap on bottom .. Buffalo chicken wrap on top - Cheesesteaks Near Me - Nazareth, Pennsylvania

I love this spot. Great food and quick service! Plus everyone there is super friendly and helpful

My go-to take out place for amazing cheesesteaks, wraps, breakfast sandwiches and ice cream! It's always busy so call ahead. Portion sizes are excellent for the price. You will be hard pressed to find a better cheesesteak this side of the turnpike! My favorites are the cheesesteak hoagie (fried onions, not raw, and lots of mayo) and the chicken bacon ranch wrap. It is delicious and big enough to share! Mozzarella sticks, onion rings and pierogies are always perfect too. read more

Great food. Pork roll egg and cheese is a must. Crispy chicken sandwich is my go to. Kids cheesesteak is enough for an adult. Workers are always friendly that work there. read more

Great breakfast sandwiches. Convenient to Rt33 ez on/off. Call ahead for pick up. I had Peteys favorite western omelette with bacon on a Kaiser roll. They had Cheerios inside the convienence store for my child. Too early in the morning for ice cream, so we will get that next time. Good place to Gas up and get your feed. #supportsmallandlocalbusines's. read more

My, my, my, who would think , a small eatery , next to a gas station would produce such a fantastic array of sandwiches ? I have ordered from here several times . The steak sandwiches are very good,the Ribeye sandwich is excellent , it's the very fresh rolls , that brings it all together .The milkshakes , always very cold . On a hot day ,when you don't feel like cooking , give this place a chance , you won't go wrong read more

Ok food，extremely sloooooooow. I think next time I will place my order before I take my 5 mile jog at Jacobsburg.

disgusted! ordered cheesteaks thursday and the rolls had mold on them! dusty roads had no malt. been a long time customer and this place has gone down hill!!! gross! read more

I don't know why this doesn't have better reviews. The food has always been top notch-and the prices are very reasonable. The trick is to call your orders in ahead of time especially during busy hours such as lunch or dinner. We have had a wide variety of items from the menu & never been disappointed. They will generally also make something special request if they have the items needed to do so read more

This is probably one of my favorite places to go for a cheesesteak. They load it with meat and cheese. They can add anything you want on it. They have a variety of other foods that are really good also. But they only have an outdoor eat-in area and other picnic tables for you to enjoy eating your food at. Its almost like a drive-in atmosphere. Well worth the trip, Enjoy!!!!! read more

soo gross!! got 2 cheesesteaks & bone in wings and they gave us boneless chicken nuggets with no sauce!!- ordered through doordash. the cheesesteak was mushy meat and just tasted old ! read more

Great little drive in / ice cream / gas station joint. All the common drive in offerings. Great food and ice cream. What they do very well is quality and quantity. Cheesteaks are a must. You won't go hungry. Tip. Outdoor seating both covered and open. Tip. Parking is limited. Tip. Gets very busy during summer. read more

Definitely worth going to food is awesome. They are very friendly. Everything is good on there menu you will not be disappointed. They also have awesome milkshakes. And weekly specials. Definitely can't go wrong. read more

I love the cheese steaks and appetizers, the breakfast items I have had are great too. Make sure you call ahead, I have had long wait times for my food. read more