We have never been here and finally tried it. It's a hidden gem and a local favorite. The vodka sauce is amazing. I was super impressed with the service and the quality of food. The pizza is also great. read more

We have only been here twice but will definitely be a go to spot! The first trip my husband and I got the meatball and the sausage casserole! Both were delicious and the portions were big enough for us to have lunch the next day! We also had an appetizer that was more like a meal that we shared. It was fresh cut fries with Nashville hot boneless wings on top with cheese and pickles!!The second trip I had the chicken parmigiana and he had the Italian hoagie with fresh cut fries !The servers on both trips were very informative and attentive! They also have some nice draft beer options! You can sit in the dining area or bar area, very casual atmosphere! The menu definitely has something for everyone! read more

See all

Very friendly, welcoming place. Nice bar area and good restaurant seating as well! The food is great. Tons of options from bar food to pasta to pizza, they have it all. read more

See all

Nothing fancy but food is consistently good. Service can be slow at times (even when not busy).

We've been here several times now, and the food is always a delicious, cheesy, belly busting treat! My daughter LOVES that they give you popcorn while you wait. The stuffed peppers were absolutely delicious. I think that I'll probably always get their gyro from now on. The meat was very tender and it was large pieces rather than skinny slices. My daughter has also told me that this is now her favorite pizza. read more

See all

The food was fresh and excellent. And the restaurant was very clean. And all the employees I interacted with were very personable

I order from this establishment at least 3 times a month. Usually, it's pretty good. On this occasion, all 3 of my pepperoni rolls were burnt. I had also ordered pub fries, which were inedible. They were so hard, it's almost like they put them back in the fryer to reheat them. I don't believe they would have served this to anyone in the dining room, but I had delivery, so they went ahead and sent it. I mentioned it on Facebook on one of their posts, and they got offended and blocked me! They've lost a good paying customer. Oh, and they charge a "technology fee" if you order online. read more

Amazing food, never had a bad order and always come back wanting more. Service is fast in person and easy to order online. Great service overall. Personal favorite and go to is the NY style pizza Xl. read more

Pepperoncinis - NY Style Pepperoni i Pizza XL - Pizza Near Me - Oakdale, Pennsylvania

Would be 1 star if it wasn't for our waitress who tried to salvage the whole experience. Stopped in about 1:30pm for a quick lunch with two people, myself and my wife. We ordered 1 calzone and 1 buffalo chicken wrap. The calzone came out in about 20 minutes, but no wrap. Another 10-15, still nothing. Our waitress is communicative and trying to get us our food, but she says the kitchen is delayed. Another 20 minutes and we're still missing half the meal. The losers in the kitchen weren't capable of turning a chicken wrap around in less than an hour. Finally I ask for the check so we can leave. The wrap just came out and I asked her to put it in a to go box. I get home to eat it, and they didn't even put buffalo sauce on it. A+ wait staff F- kitchen crew. read more

I tried the ham and cheese hoagie and it was delicious.....I retract my previous review in sorry

If the juke box was louder I'd give them 5 stars ... we need more music in the bar area. Otherwise food is amazing keep up the great work read more

DO NOT SLEEP ON THIS PLACE! Every time I drive by, the parking lot is full, and for good reason. The bar and dining area (inside) are both dimly lit. The vibe is definitely neighborhood bar/restaurant. They have maybe 4 booths, a couple high tops, and a few tables outside. There are also a few barstools. We had the tossed salad, which was massive, 2 slices of cheese pizza, and the pepperoni rolls. First of all, the pepperoni rolls are INSANE. Completely blew me away. They come three to an order and they're huge, crispy on the outside, garlicky, a little sprinkle of parm, and a side of marinara. The inside is perfectly soft and cheesy. I will get them every single time I come here. Now, the pizza. The slices are also huge and only $2.99 each. I don't know where you can get a better deal. The slice is the size of two, the crust is crispy, the sauce has a great flavor, and the cheese is plentiful. The only thing that we didn't love was all of the popcorn on the floor The place does smell like a movie theatre and there's popcorn for everyone! Our server was definitely overloaded/busy, but she checked in frequently and was always friendly. read more

See all

I ordered the fettuccine Alfredo. It was excellent. I'm having a hard time eating certain foods and this was perfect.. I want to say thank you read more

I called them and they answered and they asked me what I want I told him what I want and then they actually got the order right I am very happy I would consider you ordering from this place cuz this place is busin read more

Pepperoncinis - Approved - Pizza Near Me - Oakdale, Pennsylvania

We had the BEST lunch at Pepperoncinis! We came in early on a Sunday and had the whole back room to ourselves. The staff was so friendly and accommodating and consistently checked in on us. The menu had something for everyone, even those with dietary restrictions (dairy-free & vegetarian). Our group of 7 all ordered different sandwiches and rolls, and there wasn't one complaint! I highly recommend the chicken parm hoagie (the buns were toasted garlic bread) and upgrading to the fresh-cut French fries... so much yum!! We were also very impressed with the portion sizes for the price; I had three meals out of my hoagie! read more

I've eaten here a couple of times and gotten take-out several times, too. The NY-Style pizza (for just $16.99) is delicious and can feed about 8 people. I've heard that the wings are good, and the wraps look great, too. There are daily specials and a fairly decent beer list. It's at a nice location in Oakdale, too. If you haven't tried Pepperoncinis, and you're in the area, give it a shot. Two thumbs up! read more

Pepperoncinis - Pick-up entry - Pizza Near Me - Oakdale, Pennsylvania

We recently moved to the neighborhood and needed some good food with timely delivery. Pepperoni's definitely satisfied both. We had wings and a wrap that were delicious and the delivery was 20 minutes earlier than the anticipated delivery time. We are super excited to try more of their food and go to the restaurant once we get settled in. read more

waited 2 hrs for food that was soggy when the place is 10 mins up the road will be the last time I order from this plave

Delicious meal, generous portions and excellent prices, enough to take home! The vibe is typical local neighborhood but you can't go wrong here! It was crowded yet our food arrived quickly and exactly as we had ordered, as we had a special request. read more

I love the pizza here. I have been going to this location for years and have never been left disappointed. The staff is always friendly and helpful, and I recommend this restaurant to everybody. It was a very welcoming and warm atmosphere. read more

Had a great experience ordering from Pepperoncinis yesterday. Ordered 8 XL pizzas. They were done right on time and were delicious. Thanks and we will definitely be back. read more

Always excellent food and service! Pizza and Calzones are great.order fish sandwiches on Friday early because they quickly run out.

The absolute PERFECT neighborhood restaurant! When you walk through the door you feel like you're walking into your best friend's house. The staff is warm, friendly and welcoming. The bartenders and servers HUSTLE! And the kitchen crew are fantastic because the food never stops coming out the door! And speaking of food...DELICIOUS! From the pasta dishes to the sandwiches to the tremendous variety of specialty pizzas, this place is in a different league. Enjoy your favorite beverage and satisfy your appetite surrounded by people who make you feel like you belong! 5 stars ain't enough! read more

I often stop in here when I am visiting Helicon Brewery, or riding my bicycle on the Panhandle Trail (which is right behind the restaurant). Since Helicon doesn't have a kitchen, they allow outside food to be brought in and/or delivered (they also have food trucks certain days). Helicon keeps a Pepperoncini's menu at the bar, and in between beer and pinball games, I'll call in my order, wait 10~15 minutes, and walk across the street to pick it up, then walk back to the brewery to eat, and have another beer. The food here has always been pretty good. I like this place ... Cheers! read more

See all

Greasiest fish sandwich and French fries I ever had in my life. Uncooked batter inside sandwich to boot. Horrible experience. Avoid!

The food is good!! The pizza is really good to get if you can't decide. The service is ok. When I went last I did have to wait awhile. My waiter only came to the table about 3-4 times. The place is really dark inside and out dated. read more

The wings and fries would have been really good if they were hot, or warm in any way. The drinks we got tasted good but that was because there was very little alcohol in them. Shame to pay for a top shelf Long Island with no kick. Philly chicken had great flavor and was nice and hot. read more

Pepperoncinis - Baker's bacon fries - Pizza Near Me - Oakdale, Pennsylvania

Decent food, decent prices. The sandwiches here were huge - and had tons of toppings. My wedgie was kind of disappointing - although it was an enormous portion, is was mostly bread. The "vegetarian wedgie" was mostly composed of shredded iceberg lettuce, which was disappointing. read more

Pepperoncinis - Italian hoagie + fries (upcharge for fries) - Pizza Near Me - Oakdale, Pennsylvania

See all

So I haven't actually sat down and had a meal since my original review but we have done take out multiple times over the last year which has changed my view of Pepperoncinis. I usually get their Steak, Egg, and Bacon sub. That was always my go to at Uncle Sams and Peps can definitely give it a rub for their money. Great sandwich. My wife has gotten various sandwiches or salads. Sometimes she and my kids get pizza. They enjoy the pizza too. The fries are kind of like shoestring that are like fresh cut. I'd like to try them fresh because I think they lose a little something on the take out end. Take out service is good. Great option if you are at the brewery. They will deliver there too I believe. Im glad my experiences have improved dramatically over the years and truly appreciate this local option. read more

Oakdale my old pal, home to one of my favorite places. Oh Pepperoncinis how I love your calzones, pizza rolls and pizza! The pizza sauce is so good and the crust is always good to perfection. Whenever someone in the area comes to visit, I always ask them to pick up a pie since I am not out that way too often anymore. A+! read more

First world problems alert!!! If you order wings, or really anything from Pepperoncini's Pub in Oakdale beware. We like to support local and have spent thousands at this establishment over the years. Ordered a treat today, wings for my husband I and they are expensive. Its ok, its a treat. We ordered two flavors, the website put it through but only the Buffalo came. No biggie, call and fix it... nope. They say you can't split it. Nothing says that when you put the order through, the receipt shows both flavors, but they refuse to make it right. They charge now for delivery, wings and a cheese calzone came almost $60 and they won't honor what we ordered. Spoke to the manager Kristen, she says "Next time you will know." Why not just call us and say, hey, we can't split the flavor. Bad customer service, bad look Pep's. read more

I won't be ordering from the local establishment again. I live 10 min max from their location. I ordered a delivery at 4;30 in the evening was told an hour for delivery. Driver shows up 20 min late which is fine and sort of expected on a Friday. Problem is, is that the the pizza was ice cold as if it was not even in a warm bag. When I called back and asked for a manager that managers advise was was to drive the pizza back to their store and they would look at it to see what to do. This was after being on hold for 15 min. Some one would pick up the phone and quick click to back on hold. No offer of a refund partial or full just an it what it is for a Friday night. Basically it was an fu we are busy. Worst customer service experience in North Fayette Township ! read more

Best pizza in the area. Specialty pizzas are particularly good. Friendly staff and delivery drivers. read more

Pizza is good. It was made fairly quickly from ordering. I liked the pizza my previous visit more. Previous visit would be given 4 stars. A nice takeout option for Helicon Brewing nearby. read more

Came here for lunch with a good friend during the work day. Had a Mediterranean salad (gyro meat, feta cheese, pita, spring lettuce, tomatoes and Italian dressing). Definitely a yummy place! read more

We found this establishment and decided to give it a try. Prompt seating and our server came over to give us drink options. A wide array of food options. My wife got a Steak Calzone and I got the Pub Burger with fresh cut fries. Both were really good. Our server was very pleasant and our drinks were always taken care of. Would highly recommend. read more

I'm visiting family for the holidays and wanted to grab lunch with my wife and daughter so we decided upon Pepperoncinis in Oakdale. We arrived around 2:40 pm and it took 25 minutes to get our drinks. We wanted fountain soda; however, that wasn't possible due to frozen lines. My wife ordered the chicken Philly with Mayo on the side and a side of fries, my daughter got a kids cheeseburger and fries and I ordered Philly steak rolls. My wife's and daughters food came out in a timely manner although incorrect. My food came out 25 minutes after my family's food. The food itself was average at best. The side of fries were extremely cold. My daughter receives a double cheeseburger with lettuce, tomato and onion and my wife never received her side of Mayo. One redeeming quality was my Philly steak rolls were very good although I wouldn't recommend this place due to the lack of service. It might've been a bad day but it shouldn't take 1 hour 45 minutes from start to finish. read more

See all

I really enjoy their food, especially their pizza. We also enjoy their chicken and steak salads. They have a good selection of draft beer. There's not much negative to say about this place. I have never had a bad meal there. read more

The servers paid more attention to each other, gossiping and smoking cigs but the food was pretty good. read more

See all

An Oakdale favorite!! I always look forward to my trips to Pepperoncinis. I came on a Wednesday afternoon so there was no crowd at all. The waitress was very attentive, kind, and welcoming. Everything we ordered came out the right way and tasted amazing! I'm a huge fan of the steak wedgie. There's always the perfect steak to cheese to topping ratio! They have a wonderful wing night deal too! Wednesday is there wing night so definitely give it a try! read more

Pepperoncinis - Steak wedgie - Pizza Near Me - Oakdale, Pennsylvania

See all