I always order the Greek salad to go... large so I can eat it for a day or two... well, I ordered yesterday (about 5 PM) and today the lettuce turned and is gross! Almost all my salad has been wasted. In addition, they must have new cook, as their Greek dressing is NOT as flavorful as in past 20 years! Same thing with their Tzaitki (SP) sauce... not enough garlic and the Feta is NOT imported... I guess I will have to drive down to the Greek Restaurant in Vineland! Long time customer (20+ years)... very disappointing, won't be back! read more

I expected much more from this quaint family run restaurant. The menu is daunting. (I think there were like three menus for entrees.) When it comes down to it, what should have tasted like a home cooked meal tasted like a frozen dinner from Costco. On a good note, the service is prompt. read more

the wife and I stopped in on a recommendation from a local. We thought the place had good service, prices and food. The salads were good, soups were tasty and I had the fried oysters which can be hit or miss. My wife had an open faced turkey sandwich that was very good. Definitely worth a stop in. read more

I have been here many times throughout the years, before and after the renovations. The prices were always on the high side. The Pegasus always had older clients, which is the main reason I stopped going, were made it depressing like a retirement home. The staff pretty much leaves you alone, if you need anything during your meal your s.o.l.. You can put a turd in a fancy box, but it's still a turd. That's exactly what Pegasus is. Malaga diner is cheaper, better food, better service, and all together better. read more

This place has THE most dank cheese steak I have ever tasted. If you're in the area you have to 100% go here and try their food

Used to be my favorite place for breakfast but they're just so overpriced for what you get if it was consistent I wouldn't mind the dinners are half-decent never said great and never said bad... I haven't tried everything so I'm giving it 3 stars I'm sure others will fix the Stars One Direction or the other but it's your basic Diner hope this helps read more

What happened to there cheese steaks? And there take out window had always something wrong or missing. Consistently cold soggy fries with there sandwiches. Ordered 3 steak hoggies only one sandwich came out correctly. I am so done with them. To bad used to have better quality and better prices read more

Great customer service. I will be coming back again. I highly recommend their pizza and their pancakes.

My favorite diner style restaurant! The specials are always good and the drive thru is great for those busy days. Best short ribs ever! When will they deliver? read more

It is what is it - one step up from a diner. We were there on Mother's day so I can't judge the service on one of their busiest days of the year. As busy as they were it was pretty good and I'm sure much better during normal times. The food is just OK. My Eggs Benedict were good and properly prepared but I'm guessing the sauce was a pre-mix. Everyone's breakfast was good. I've eaten lunch and dinner here over the years and find it quite average. read more

What great meal me and my wife had here . I had the ny strip steak and I usually don't like to order a steak from a dinner but the waitress said they were really good wow she wasn't wrong and made perfect. My wife had the fried shrimp dinner and it was fantastic. If you are driving by it a must stop dinner read more

Very good-for a diner. Waitress was friendly, helpful, and efficient. I wish they had more Greek specialties on the menu as Greek restaurants are getting scarce. My omelette with Feta and spinach was top-notch. Trendy Yuppies will have their sensibilities upset-stay away. Vegans and gluten-psycho's: beware of large servings of tasty meats and starches! read more

Their Creamed Chipped beef for breakfast is GREAT! Best in the area - friendly staff and timely service - good destination anytime.

I Get lunch from the takeout drive through window twice sometimes three times a week. Consistently great & always generous portion enough for a second meal-- wish I had more time for lunch or breakfast inside which is also amazing. read more

I can't believe this restaurant only has 28 reviews. It is always packed. My parents eat there, at least, two times a week. As a previous Yelper stated, it is a bit like lunch at a nursing home, maybe that what accounts for the lack of reviews. Most sandwiches come with a cup of soup and fries. I had the Louie Burger, a cheese burger with crab meat. My husband had one of the specials. It was a grilled sandwich with cheese, ham and turkey. Both were very good. Ask for some taziaki to dip your fries or upgrade to Louie fries; steak fries with feta, greek spices and taziaki. The staff was very nice. The price is right and the portions are huge. You won't have room for dessert, but check them out and get it to go. read more

This is a local favorite restaurant. It's a step above diner food, but with more variety than a regular restaurant, and better quality than your average diner. Staff is friendly, and portions are huge, with multiple courses served with your entree. My favorite dish is the chicken picante, but depending on the timing, each chef does it slightly different, and I always check to be sure they remember the capers. Otherwise, that's the definite go to dish, with e eruthing homemade, you can't go wrong with Pegasus as your local fall back. read more

My favorite restaurant! I rate 5* & would go 6* if permitted. It isn't fancy but friendly, great food, staff, always offer specials. Try it! It's very busy so, suggest going a bit off peak dinner hour or you'll have short wait. read more

If you order anything from the bar, expect to be served in very dirty glasses guaranteed! Food is good. Good portions too.

What I enjoy while dining at The Pegasus Restaurant is a warm , friendly feeling when I enter in. Whatever meal that I have had enjoyed there, has been tops. For the quality of food it is priced reasonably. The service has always been very good. If you are near this establishment, stop in and enjoy it. read more

Another over-priced, mediocre Jersey diner....I'm SOOOOO SICK OF THEM!! Order out from Sal's Pizza nearby. Better quality of food aaaaaand you won't be butt-raped in your wallet. read more

Went here for our Sunday night Family Night. Staff is very friendly and attentive to your needs. The food is delicious and the serve adult beverages without the noisy crowd. If it was closer this would be a regular stop for me. read more

I have NEVER had a bad meal at Pegasus! I've come here for years, and have especially enjoyed my dinners here recently. This isn't some dingy diner. It's a fantastic restaurant with a lot of heart put into it. I love to start off with the fried calamari. Pegasus is one of my favorite places for it. You really cannot go wrong when selecting an entree from their menu. I personally love to go for one of their meals that comes with soup and a salad because it makes it that much more filling. I love their pasta, especially the lasagna. But seriously, everything is good. Then, if you somehow have room for dessert, finish with some of their giant chocolate-covered strawberries. Yes, they do taste as good as they look in the cooler! The service is also exceptional. The people who work here are kind and helpful, always checking on you and making sure everything is going well. It's a great choice for a wonderful meal no matter who you are. read more

Have lived in Vineland for 13 years but tonight was our first time here. Food was great and the portions were huge. Service was really good too. Attentive and friendly. The room we were in must be the last one to be redecorated. Decor was a little dated. Other rooms looked brighter and more modern - more in line with the updated exterior. We will definitely be back! read more

We went for lunch and had soup, a gourmet seafood salad, and a California burger. The soup, which was luke warm, tasted like Campbell's right out of the can. The seafood salad had three shrimp that were steamed not grilled as stated on the menu, some artificial crab meat and a lot of bitter lettuce. The burger was obviously a frozen patty that was buried in a roll that was way too big for it, and on the whole, very bland. The prices were a little on the high side for what it was. All the patrons were very old and the ambiance was one of a retirement home, and that was while sitting in "the bar". The silverware and plates weren't the cleanest either. read more

I used to dine here often during my 20's with no complaints for the breakfast and lunch service. After having moved away for 10 years, I decided to try out my old haunt. The service itself was still quite good, attentive and friendly as I remembered. However the food quality suffered greatly on this visit. Knowing this place is Greek owned, I thought i couldn't go wrong with a chicken souvlaki which i've ordered long ago along with a recommendation of the Italian wedding soup. My soup at first was promising, steaming hot. However the meatballs tasted funky and rancid. The broth was over powering salty, more like a Campbell's condensed soup can where someone forgot to add the can of water. The chicken souvlaki was straight unseasoned chicken, very little or no seasoning whatsever. It was as if the chef just chunked up some chicken and quickly did a stir-fry and laid it into the pita. Very bland. read more

went to eat breakfast and told them a party of eight and two children they said it would be 35 minutes.and hour later we are still waiting and when asked for a fourth time they said they were waiting for the people to stop talking and then the table would be ready.they just lost business as we left and went else ware to eat read more

Since I have complained about my horrible experience here and on Pegasus' facebook page they have blocked me from commenting further and connecting with others who have also had a horrible experience with them, especially their management. Funny thing is, many of the other reviews, both positive and negative, have gotten a reply from the owner....me? nothing. They can't even defend themselves because they know there is no excuse for spoiled food and then bad customer service on top of it. Penny wise and pound foolish Pegasus. For those wondering, there are several other diners within 10 minutes of Pegasus with fresh food. Malaga Diner, Peter's Diner, and Elmer Diner are just a few. read more

Very disappointed. Have gone to and ordered from occasionally over the years. Food quality has been OK. Take out is made easy with a drive thru window. However the prices have gone way up while the quanity has gone way down. Ordered 2 gniocchi take out dinners, includes soup & roll for over $25.00. The gniocci did not even cover or make one layer on the bottom of the metal take out dish. Half the amount of soup they used to have. Soup is in the smallest container possiblel. The little bit of soup was mainly broth that appears to be thickened. This is a meatless and should be relatively inexpensive meal. Between this and recently being charged too much to substitue a baked potato for fries - never again. read more

Outstanding Greek diner! The place was spotless. Excellent service. HUGE menu, even for lunch. My husband and I started out with appetizers, I had clams casino and he had the spanakopita. His order was big enough for the meal itself! Crisp fillo, ample filling, served with additional feta cheese on the side, fresh tomatoes and olives. Outstanding! THIS is the dish that Greek diners are judged by! My clams were delicious. Our lunch order was an eggplant grinder, which we split. It was huge! Served with a pickle, coleslaw and incredible waffle fries. It was delicious. Deciding that this was going to be our one meal for the day, we ordered dessert. I had strawberry cake and he had baklava. Both were outstanding! This is NOT a place to dine if you are on a diet! But splurge anyway, you won't regret it! The waitress was very pleasant, also. Will definately stop by again when we are in the area! read more

I've only ever been here for lunch. They have specials everyday which includes a cup of soup. Their soup has always been delicious. Their dessert selection is pretty cheap. The burgers are not very good, tasting like frozen patties and are served on kaiser rolls. The white pizza is pretty amazing! They have a "drive thru" which has a weird shelf on the outside. When I've ordered take out they put cold items such as pickles and coleslaw in the same box as the hot items which results in them being warm, gross. Inside waiter service is hit or miss. A full bar is available. read more

The food is very good, the service is great and i love the specials they have in the morning, that's why we keep going back

We have been going to Pegasus since they first opened 20 years ago. We have always been satisfied with our meals. If there has ever been a situation that we weren't they have always made sure that it was corrected. If you go there and leave hungry it is your own fault, as they always give plenty of food with their meals. Prices are comparable to any decent restaurant as far as I am concerned. You get what you pay for! read more

Best food and service I have had in a long time. I travel all over the US on business and was lucky to find this place