Two favorites we order, pickup at side window drive up and or park and walk inside pickup area. We order the pepperoni pizza, we'll done crust- yummy! The other is Pegasus special salad, oh my is this delicious! We order the dinner size which will be our lunch for 2 days. But I do ask for extra chicken- soooo good! The folks who work the pickup area are great, friendly. We have also enjoyed having breakfast at the restaurant, quick service and delicious omelettes, yummy home fries and bacon or sausage. For lunch with a friend, cup of homemade soup and half a sandwich! Perfect! If I am really hungry, I'll order the Rueben open face sandwich. Amazing! Fresh, crispy rye bread toasted, sauerkraut, Russian dressing with a side of coleslaw. Oh my! read more

Don't know what's going on here. We have been coming here for years and it seems like the quality of food is going downhill. I actually got the cowboy meatloaf and it looks like they put the garlic from a jar on top. read more

Pegasus Restaurant - Looks like jarlic to me. - Pizza Near Me - Malaga, New Jersey

Scrolling sign outside and on door advertised an 11:30 close on weekends (Friday & Saturday). My wife and I walked up at 10:59 for a cup of coffee and dessert only to have the hostess announce they were closed. Really disappointed, was looking forward to trying. read more

I went here with two other family members. We ordered the Stuffed Peppers, a Philly cheese steak with fried peppers, onions and mushrooms with onion rings and a Ruben on rye with onion rings. We ordered it to go. It all came in a bag in three round spaghetti aluminum containers with plastic lids. I ordered the cheese steak with a non-toasted roll. I received no roll at all just a pile steak with cheese all stuck to the bottom with the onion rings all having a foul stench to it. I couldn't eat it. It would have made me sick. The stuffed peppers also had a foul stench and were inedible. The Rubin made by brother sick for two days and he only ate half of it till he started to get sick from it. Absolutely on of the foulest, most disgusting meals I've ever had the displeasure to be associated with. Avoid this place like the plague. I've eaten here before and it was always OK. This time was terrible. This was served in the afternoon of 3/6/26 at approximately 3:30 pm. Whoever was cooking that day at that time should be fired immediately as he poisoned my brother and almost poisoned my mother and myself. I'll never set foot in this place again. read more

Food came in reasonable time. I ordered chipped cream beef with wheat toast and "home fries". After two bites I couldn't eat it. Bland and off tasting. The "fries" are just hash. Service was good. Food.....meh.... Nothing to tell my friends about. read more

So very sad, we have been going here for years and even had a very bad experience a few weeks ago, but we talked it up as one bad experience so we went back again only to be extremely disappointed. We made a point to order our pasta just white not Italian sauce because they charge three dollars just to put Italian sauce on a side of pasta with a meal that cost $32.. not a cheap meal but they handled us like we were the enemy and we are faithful customers past tense was faithful customers it said because I wish that we could tell the owner how we were treated if you can reach us at 856-332-6730 A very disappointed older couple that's been going there for years. Your loss word and mouth is the best advertisement and I will also be the worst. read more

Pegasus Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Malaga, New Jersey

Amount of food is fine but the cost is way over the account I would say they are trying to gouge the customer their menu is very large maybe they should pare down the overhead and make the food more affordable if WAWA can make a 12 in hoagie for $6.00 WAWA is not losing money on it so can they read more

Local diner - serves alcohol - not too many options in town but idk if I can eat there again - I'm sure all restaurants are dealing with pests but this grossed me out. read more

so I generally go to this restaurant on my lunch break and normally services is great. But I've noticed a running issue. when I go for pick up sometime, I'm asked if I'd like to leave a tip on the card. It depends on the day and service if I leave a tip. Personally, I don't feel like it should be an obligation to tip someone who is not a waiter like that providing a service. Today I went and picked up and the girl was pleasant until I said thank you when she asked if I'd like to put a tip. When taking my card, she didn't say anything, but "mm" and rang me out. When she handed my card back still nothing and when she handed me my food, she all shoved it in my hands and shut the window in such a quick motion that I can tell that she was upset that I did not tip her Generally, I don't write reviews and let sit situations like that experience, but it was very offputting read more

Good food, good service, nice diner atmosphere. You should give this place a try you will not be disappointed

Food was amazing there was plenty of food so much I couldn't eat it all. The service was great

Service was excellent and food was good. We stopped expecting a small diner and typical diner food, it was better than what we expected. A very nice variety of food to choose from. read more

Huge dead bug with puss in my food Manager was young female, she didn't seem to really care. Just gave me my money back. Kinda made me believe this happens more than you want to think. read more

Pegasus Restaurant - A HUGE DEAD INSECT - Pizza Near Me - Malaga, New Jersey

The food is usually very good, service is knowledgeable with a smile, I never had a problem before. I've been a customer for years & will never return due to the owner disrespecting us horribly. Ordered the chef specials cowboy steak, medium rare prime rib & Tuscany seafood. The prime rib was physically burnt to a crisp, it was black charred. Being optimistic, cut into it. Well, It was dry & over done, not edible. Sent it back, The waitress responded with a message from the kitchen "it was all cooked medium to well done". Very confused requested the owner. He comes out angry with raw meat on a plate & asks "is this what you want?" My boyfriend didn't hear that, he was stunned at the raw meat in his face. Well he said yes & medium rare. At that point I was ready to leave. It did come out perfectly. The bill arrived, No apologies, no discount, just an owner loosing good customers from many years. I said good bye to my favorite Tuscany seafood special, never again. In the parking lot as we were leaving we watched the owner leave in his new black Porsche, obviously he doesn't need our $60. Bye read more

I have only ever been here for breakfast. Service and food is always good.

Good food, the empire meatloaf is a favorite! Pegasus is one of our regular take out spots!

OK we've been going here for years... always satisfied! All of a sudden tonight BAM we get our bill and were charged 7.50 for a lemonade?? Asked and they told us it's like a large juice!! What?? It's not homemade it's a lemonade-should be charged as a soft drink!! Do better! read more

Was really good flavor. Potions were nice. Sauce was a little thin but it was very yummy read more

Pegasus Restaurant - Louie crabby burger - Pizza Near Me - Malaga, New Jersey

See all

Now I remember why I stopped coming here the service here is horrible. If it wasn't for the fact that the food was decent, I would've only gave it one star. read more

I don't know why they're still in business. Second time here. First time was torture waiting to be acknowledged at the table. Short staffed? Ok. I'll go with that. Today at noon. Sat right away.....tick tick tick. 15 min? No one offers water, coffee, "I'll be right there"? Nope. They SUCK. Spend your hard earned $$ somewhere else. read more

The wait staff was extremely friendly and gave excellent service. The tables are close together and the chairs roll. The menu is large and there is a lot of options.... the soup tomato basil soup was delicious... the entree was just okay - the BBQ sauce tasted bland and over sauces. However everyone else truly enjoyed their meal (burger and Ruben sandwich) read more

First time here on the recommendation of friends. Started with a cup of chicken orzo, which does not disappoint. The cup is actually a little larger than a standard teacup. Could easily have a soup and salad for a light meal. The French Dip was ok, lean, but a little bland. Pickle and cole slaw, meh. The sandwich is served with a half plate of French fries. Service was friendly. Desserts look good (standard cakes, mousses, pies) in the refrigerated case but I passed. They look big enough to stand alone in place of a meal. read more

Pegasus Restaurant - Beyond belief. I'll stick to evidence for the resurrection of Jesus. It's Holy Week. This burger is not. - Pizza Near Me - Malaga, New Jersey

See all

Ordered a large Greek salad to go. Salad was so throughly washed, but not dried and was so wet and gross and impossible to eat. Also, many pieces were already brown and pieces were so large they're imposs to eat. Extra feta? I don't think so. Only two blocks on my large salad. That was the only thing edible, besides the 3 olives in that large tray. I'll drive to Olympia Restaurant from now on. Total cost was almist $30 for a salad, extra dressing, feta and its unedible. I have to also add that as a local and that I have been coming here for almost 30 years and the last 6 or so the food has always been consistently inconsistent and usually terrible. I will drive to Olympia. read more

Pegasus Restaurant - Brown water logged lettuce - Pizza Near Me - Malaga, New Jersey

I've always liked the Pegasus. When I was in high school, the Pegasus was a regular haunt for my mother and I. Unfortunately, it's quite a long drive from where I live now, so I rarely go. The Pegasus has three dining rooms. The first is very diner-esque, but the other two are regular dining rooms of which the last is the most attractive. The menu is an assortment of American, Italian and Greek-American food. I have always loved their chicken dishes because they're saucy and moist, which is my preference. As the previous reviewer mentioned, the menu is daunting because there's SO many choices. Although the food isn't knock your socks off, despite their massive menu, everything is well prepared. It's a good place for families because everyone will find something that appeals. The Pegasus certainly isn't a restaurant I would encourage out-of-towners to seek out, but for those of us that live in the area, it's a reliable standby for decent food. read more

Pegasus Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Malaga, New Jersey

See all

Took my aunt for her 80th birthday for a nice seafood dinner. This dish was delicious!! Well worth the money and our service was excellent. read more

Pegasus Restaurant - Shrimp , scallop, crab - Pizza Near Me - Malaga, New Jersey

See all

Great food friendly service Pizza and Stromboli are absolutely delicious I will definitely be ordering again read more

We have been coming to the Pegasus for over thirty years - almost since it first opened. I will never go back. The quality of food has been on the decline for some time; however, today was the last straw. We've been going there as a habit - it isn't Michelin star, but it used to be fine for what it was: a simple, South Jersey diner, part of a proud NJ tradition. I will provide you with the sanitized version. Louie Isihos, the owner, was unpardonably rude. I simply asked for the WiFi password. Long story short, the "open" WiFi wasn't working (contrary to his insistence); he insisted there were directions on the door (there were none, as confirmed by the hostess and the waitress); then, when it was pointed out that it wasn't working he just laughed and said, "It's down." Refused to give password to other WiFi. I know it isn't an Internet cafe, but had called on the phone earlier to make sure they had WiFi and it was working. They assured me, "Oh yes, no problem." Food was adequate, but not great enough to keep making the trip. Please note: I tipped the waitress. I'm not a hero, but sometimes people take it out on the staff. Nothing was her fault. She seemed like a nice, professional person, as was the hostess. Like most people, I work hard for my money. It isn't too much to ask for the owner of an establishment to treat his/her patrons with a modicum of respect. Louie Isihos is clearly unable to do that and he has lost my business for good. read more

The time it took for service to acknowledge my family was pretty bad. We watched 2 dinner rushes come and go before we were finished our meal. The waitress was hands down the rudest server I've experienced in my 40 years. I don't write these often so take this for what it is. She gave me and my family at least 3 of the dirtiest looks I've ever seen and when she realize I wasn't happy with how she was behaving she started with apologizing about how busy it was. I will never come here again. The food is tasty but it's not worth this extremely rude experience. Not to mention the place is outdated and every time the people in the booth behind me moved at all my daughter and I looked at each other because the whole back of the booth moved. Don't recommend and actually apologized to my wife for suggesting we eat there. read more

I have always loved my meals at Pegasus Restaurant. However, even taking into consideration that it's Labor Day today, the service was absolutely horrible. I understand you have a few new staff, but, have they been trained? I believe the answer to that question would be no. There were five of us for breakfast and every single one of us received our order and it was wrong or parts of it were missing. The food had to be sent back to the kitchen multiple times. I have never seen a restaurant think it's OK...to serve pitch-black toast. I ordered chocolate milk and it looked as if someone waved some chocolate syrup across the top of the glass and never poured any in it. Our omelettes were cold and we had to wait a long time for food especially since the kitchen staff was looking for cheddar cheese. and finally after ten minutes the waitress decided to tell me that there wasn't any. In addition to our problems, the two top table next to us left after 20 minutes of just being served a glass of water! Leslie our bill was wrong as well and to be redone! I am willing to Come back again in hopes that all will be well because I do like your restaurant. However, should I come back and have an experience like today you can rest assured we will not be back again!! Sadly, we will also tell the others not come either. So sad. No toilet paper anywhere in the Women's bathroom! Thank you for your prompt attention to these issues. read more

Doesn't smell well inside. Not very clean. Food is mediocre. Nothing special. Service is awful. Place is dated worn inside. Food was nothing special at all. Quality isnt the same as years ago. Very disappointed. read more

The food Was incredible. Really nice size portions. Price really good.the seasoning it's perfect. Cold beer. Fries were fresh; salad fresh. Nice waiters. Really cl an and cools ambiance. Definitely come my back. Oh; almost forgot !! The carrot cake it's amazing !!! read more

Pegasus Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Malaga, New Jersey

The Greek salad is one of the best I've had. Fresh dill, feta, and stuffed grape leaves! Homemade dressing as well- and I added chicken to top it all off. Would definitely visit again. read more

Pegasus Restaurant - Greek salad, with chicken. - Pizza Near Me - Malaga, New Jersey

Love the food and the service is always great. Pretty decent ambience for a diner but like most other places prices have gone up. The pitas are always a good choice. Burgers are fresh and the dinner meals are a lot of food read more

I am buying salads from this place for a long time few times every month when Lue was handing it was good but last time my salad was not good old lettuce, Bad eggs and more I call and complain about it they told me we will give you credit, Now they say we only give you few dollars off, and still accepting salad was bad. This place is not used to be like before, I usually do not write a review but this type of treatment not acceptable in a small town, People have to be aware read more

Came in for dinner tonight and it sucked. Service was horrible and the food was very bland. Our server forgot to put food in, she waited almost 15 minutes to bring out soups because she was standing talking to another table mind you it was dead only two tables in there... we asked for one of our dinners to have no cheese at all came out with cheese and she didn't take it back. Not once asked us how anything was, no refills no nothing. Night manager knew we were getting shitty service and messed up food took nothing off the bill. Only giving two stars because there breakfast is pretty good. Won't be back at nights at all. Didn't get our servers name but she had red hair. read more

besides the fact I found a long black hair in my pudding I also overheard waiters telling each other how they "recycle" the bread from the tables. so if you didn't eat it, the next customer will. this place is DISGUSTING and someone needs to report them to the state. read more

This restaurant has a pretty hard to pass bargain for lunch. Last week I bought a sandwich and fried mac and cheese bites. The meatball parm was really good and the mac and cheese bites were excellent. What I didn't realize last week until after I placed my order was that they had a lunch buffet inside for less than what I bought. So I came back this week for lunch. Sausage scallopine, roasted turkey, herbed chicken, mashed potatoes, roasted vegetables, mac and cheese bites, soup, salad, and desserts. The buffet menu changes every day. It's not a hundred items like most buffets. But what they do serve is all pretty good. read more

I've eaten here loads of times and the food is always very solid. Recently, I had there Buffalo Chicken Cheesesteak which was seriously on point. It had my favorite type of Buffalo sauce; not too spicy, very creamy, awesome flavor. Their breakfast is also always good. If you're in the area, there ain't much other places to eat, so Pegasus should easily be your go to. read more

Pegasus Restaurant - Buffalo Chicken Cheesesteak. On point. 5 out of 5 - Pizza Near Me - Malaga, New Jersey

First, let me start off by saying I've been coming to Pegasus since I was a little girl. As a local, I've always enjoyed the food here and usually place orders anywhere from 2-5x a month. Recently, they just bumped up their prices again. I find this to be ridiculous beings they were already slightly pricey to begin with for being a hometown restaurant/diner. I refuse to pay $13 for a turkey club and fries, so unfortunately I will be taking my business elsewhere. The ingredients they use to make their food are the same ingredients and sourced from the same places that ALL the decent restaurants/diners use in this area so it's definitely nothing special to have to increase prices by $1 or more on every dish. When ordering through the pick-up window, things are often forgotten. Check your order before leaving. read more

There are way better diners in the area. Prices are high for just average diner foods and the service is slow almost always. Your best bet is breakfast in the morning. read more