Had a great experience having a dine-in pie at Pavone's on a weeknight. We ordered a large cheese pizza and each had a few slices and had some to take home. They have the best cheese pizza in Syracuse! The staff were friendly and the dining area was clean. read more

Pavone's Pizza - Sicilian Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Manlius, New York

I've been going to Pavone's for over half a century and after having lived in the City twice, I can aver that it's still the most authentic New York pie in CNY. But it's not just a pizzeria! All their subs are great (and yes, I've had them all!), but their meatball sub is perfection on a plate. One nice surprise is their salads, which are always fresh, crisp, and tasty. Add in the fast, friendly service and the no-nonsense décor and Pavone's is a phenomenal 5-stars. read more

Staff was friendly. Service was quick. Slices were tasty and the typical ny style (thin, flower bottom). Cost was a little high (4 slices and a drink $18) but would definetly go back and understand why they have so many awards. read more

pizza is ok, but my preference is Stingers. Like both but Stingers takes it every time. food is better as is the wait staff.

Very good pizza! The best I have had around the area. Never been inside so I couldn't tell you what it's like but I have ordered from there a few times and every time it was perfect! read more

Pavone's Pizza - Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Manlius, New York

Very good wings and pizza! The crust was great. Easy to order and pick up. Liked bbq wings over the Buffalo.

Pizza was delicious. Had a great selection of different slices. Really good lunch and pretty affordable.

I will start as I always do by saying that I don't give out five stars unless I am really blown away. This has become my favorite Pizza place. The pizza is always good the crust gets just the right amount of crisp and the cheese to sauce ratio is always spot on. Also they have these golden wings that are awesome. They are like a Carolina honey must BBQ sauce and always cooked to the right crispness. Also the last time I was there I tried the pinwheels. I will be ordering them every time from now on. If you want pizza in Fayetteville or Manlius they deliver and it's always good. Give this place a shot read more

I'm from Pennsylvania, this pizza is the closest to a Italian pizza from my hometown! I go to the the Pavone's off Erie Boulevard. read more

I've never had a bad slice from Pavones in Manlius! Customer service could be better but it's a pizza shop!

We order all the time. Good guys, fast service and really consistent. Pizza - awesome! Hot wings - awesome! Salad - even my husband actually enjoys it! I don't like pasta with my chicken parm so the way it's served a-la-carte for a lesser price than a typical Italian entree is great for me. The calzones were smaller than expected (by at least half) so I'll stick to pizza wings and salad. read more

Good pizza. Good food. Very casual traditional Pizza shop atmosphere. Easy in or take out.

Above average thin crust (not soggy) NY style pizza place. Their wings were served buffalo style and delicious. Not much decor to cheer about so we always do take out. They do serve pizza by the slice too, if you need a quick pizza fix. It's our go to place every time we are craving NY style pizza when coming to Syracuse. read more

See all

One star, only because the pizza is good. I ordered a pizza from the Manlius location at 4:30 PM(40-50 minute wait time) and the pizza arrived almost 2 hours later cold. I called at 5:45 when I saw my order was out for delivery at 5:27, but had not arrived. The manager answered and took a look to verifiy that my order had not yet left, but assured me it would be in the next deliver and the driver was on the way back. I waited until 6:15 and called back asking about my order and this is where it went sideways. The very nice girl answering the phone politely said she would get her manager and she did. The manager took about 5 minutes to get on the phone and then proceeded to tell me he did not have time to talk to me. Actually said he told the girls to not answer my call, because I kept calling. I was able to get a few words in and expressed my concern of waiting almost two hours, to which he replied that the "CURRENT" wait time is 1.5 hours(I ordered at 4:30 for a reason). This all ended with two cold pizzas, me losing my cool, him telling me to Fu$&$&! off and me then hanging up. I will go back to the Bridge St location, but I will never be treated like this, or go to the Manlius location. read more

The food is very good, never a problem! However the problems lays in that witch we call the Pizza Nazi! There is a fellow who works there who is an exact clone of the Soup Nazi from Seinfeld. The buff little guy in his 40s is scary and always messes up the orders! He's a boomer who hates technology so ordering online makes you the demon millennial. So he purposely gets the orders wrong! He is annoyed to just tell you where the to go food is! Shame on you Pizza Nazi! read more

Twenty-two years a happy & loyal customer. Yet hating that I have to say Goodbye. Just picked up our usual 2 lg pies and 1 dozen wings. Couldn't help but notice that one employee rolling the dough had his mask tucked under his chin, while three others wore it below their nose. (As useful a preventative as wearing half a prophylactic is to reducing teen pregnancy.) So I quietly asked to speak to the boss, who very politely told me they remind their employees about masks, but declines to (at least) have the dough roller put the mask on. I left as I came, quietly and peaceably, seeing nothing done differently but for the youngest employee (who rang up the order) who pulled the mask over his nose. Twenty-two years yet politely blown off. And this occurring while millions of NY'ers remain unvaccinated. Goodbye. P.S. - Left a $10 tip. Never screw the line employees over a management misstep. read more

Strangest experience of my life. I called and ordered a large cheese pizza.. simple. I show up thirty minutes later and say my name and they look at me like I have ten heads and gaslight me asking if I called the right place. I even showed them my call log and I didn't get any sort of apology, they just made me feel like I was in the wrong. And to be honest, they seemed under the influence. read more

I live in Manlius New York where Pavone's pizza is located and I believe they have three others throughout the city in Syracuse. My business is in Syracuse New York and there's countless number of other pizza places there and on my way home. I had ordered a thin pizza last night which is Saturday and other things as well and I noticed that it really wasn't thin and mention it to the manager. He couldn't of been any nicer as he said let me remake it give me a couple minutes and for him to do that and not just push his pizza out of there was quite different then you would find in most places. 8 to 10 minutes went by came over showed me the pizza, it was a work of art. The pizza was a 10 out of 10 and the wings have to be the best wings in this whole county and beyond. I'm writing this review on Sunday as my family and I decided to have it for a second night in a row. Great staff and a wonderful articulate And super Fair manager. His name is Pete.Great great job!!!! read more

I'm from New York City (NYC) and like NY style better than any other kind of pizza. I like Pavone's pizza as well or more than any pizza I've ever had in NYC or anywhere. I don't know what makes it so good. I think it is not one thing but the entire combination-the crust is thin, the sauce could not be better ad the cheee is simply wonderful. But all together from the first to the last bite is unbelievable. The only thing I'd change is the closing time. Stay open til 10. People like pizza late. But Pavone's is great any tie. read more

It's ok. I'm not from these parts, so I feel bad having nothing else to compare it to, so all I can do is assume I could find something better, and probably something worse as well. We had a large pizza with mushrooms, onions and pepperoni. Nothing stood out as awful, but nothing outstanding. The dough seems a bit thick for my particular taste, and the crust was a little tough by the time I got to it. That didn't stop me from eating 3 pieces though! read more

NY Style type of pizza - thin and crispy crust. I hate when the crusts are soggy and can't hold the cheese and toppings. They do deliver but we do take-out orders since my brother's place is so close. Wish they put more pepperoni toppings as it was kind of skimpy portions. The wings were good although a little greasy. I do prefer Pudgie's wings though - maybe because I used to eat them a lot when I was at Rochester, NY. read more

Pavone's Pizza - Large cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Manlius, New York

See all

This is a top pizza place for the locals. It's okay and a little overhyped. It's not my first place to pick for pizza but if everywhere else is too busy, I'll buy from here. The pizza is super thin and overly greasy. read more

Good pizza - but not great. I have always loved Pavone's Sicilian pizza, and can highly recomment this, but for regular pies, they always seem to overcook the crust, which I am not a fan of. The wings at Pavones are pretty standard, so you can't go wrong there. I think there are better choices in the Fayetteville-Manlius area, but not many. read more

Very good local pizza. Good service. Easy online ordering with slice app. A staple in our takeout/delivery rotation. Very good wings.

Decent, but not great. Canned mushrooms, blech! The sausage was good. Sauce was good but the crust was a bit too done and was tough. Overall it was OK. I'd try it again, but I'm not in a hurry for an $18 two topping pizza. read more

Pavone's Pizza - Shrooms & sausage - Pizza Near Me - Manlius, New York

It's been 10 years since my last review on Pavone's and the rating has NOT changed! It's my favorite. I really love their cheese slice and was so happy to have the chance to try it again. We came in the afternoon and there were slices for us to get immediately. There was a steady stream of people entering and picking up pies and slices. The pizza is simple and really good. The wings were delicious too and my husband enjoyed them more after a day in the refrigerator, after the sauce settled into the skin. Please enjoy a slice in this old school pizza joint! read more

We ordered a pizza chicken tenders and a sausage roll. Took over an hour and a half to get the meal, which was cold when it arrived, and we only live about a mile from the restaurant. Also the sausage roll was advertised with red sauce and cheese it came with a piece of cut up sausage in pizza dough no sauce no cheese read more

Good pizza, though a little salty and with some low-quality ingredients. A lot of canned veggies. Prices are reasonable. The employees in this location are powerfully unfriendly. Don't know why, but I give up. There are enough decent pizza joints around, there's no need to deal with these sour bastards. read more

Cheese pizza is really quality! Also: garlic knots, fried ravioli, mozzarella sticks... YUM. They are all very very good! It doesn't even compare to like little Caesars or Pizza Hut. I feel bad comparing the to even in this review. Never been in just delivery so can't speak to being in shop. Delivery people are very nice. read more

Pavone's Pizza is the best New York style pizza and wings in the Manlius, Fayetteville, and Dewitt area. Their prices are better than other pizza delivery restaurants in the area. read more

We went there today for the first time. We're from out of town. We loved the pizza! It's a cute place with a lot of seating. I've read reviews about a gentleman behind the counter not being friendly enough, but we thought he was fine. Not everyone is having a great day, you don't know anything about what a person is going through or feeling. Great pizza and will definitely go back!! read more

Pavone's always nails it! Stopped in for just a slice w/ sausage. One pleasant guy working. Pizza was perfect and is just the way Pavone's has always made it. Consistency has been their reputation for decades. It was just before noon on a Wednesday and they a a large selection of pizzas ready to go. Great work Pavone's team read more

Possibly one of the worst pizzas I've ever had. It was undercooked and tasteless. The toppings included canned olives. We ordered a fresh pizza since the slices already cooked looked like cardboard. (They agreed with me). read more

Delicious! Thin, Crunchy dough, tasty sauce and great cheese. Spices available to put on, and reasonably priced. One of my favorite pizza places in the area. Highly recommend this place! (The other is Mario and Salvo's in DeWitt). read more

Great pizza and wings! Ordered food for pick up and it was ready on time. Price was reasonable.

duh it's one of the Pavone's restaurants. AMAZING thin crust pizza. Wings could be better, but I've NEVER had awesome wings and pizza from the same establishment before so I'll deal with that. Everyone knows that Pavone's make the best pizza read more

Pizza was ok, could have used more sauce and didn't like the crust. Wings had really good bbq sauce and were delicious. But probably won't come back because of the miserable and unfriendly staff. It doesn't feel good to go to a restaurant and feel like you're inconveniencing them. Aside from the "have a good night" didn't feel welcome at all. read more

I have been to this restaurant twice, a week before COVID closed everything down, and most recently a couple of days ago. On my first visit the staff person came across as fairly rude; on my most recent visit, I noticed that they haven't done much to address the welcoming attitude. I can look beyond that. It's a pizza joint. What I can't look beyond was the bearded person making the pizza walking around with no mask and most of the staff wearing their mask as chin guards. There is no reason for us to go back because there are many establishments just begging for customers to return. read more

Disappointing! Orders have been arriving late. Once our order was forgotten. By the time we got it, it was soggy and cold. Food is ok but pizza toppings are scarce. read more

I have been a long time fan of Pavones and I think they do a super job in all their CNY locations ! Keep up the good work for your pizza is tasty and fresh, your salads are deliscious and I love the family atmosphere. All stores are clean and fresh. read more

Pavone's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Manlius, New York

See all