We are visiting Eureka Springs for our anniversary. In the comment books located in our cabin, Pauly's was mentioned a few times as having good hamburgers. They were the smash burger style burger. You are able to order the Pauly's burger or create your own. You have your choice of fries or sweet potato fries. We enjoyed the burger and the fries. My husband got the regular fries and I got the sweet potato fries. A couple of things. The fries are a separate cost of $4.00 with a $1.00 charge for the sauce. At that price we thought the order would be more shareable, but the order is on the smaller side. I didn't find much flavor in the sauce for the fries so I may would avoid that extra expense. Overall, the employees were very nice and helpful, restaurant was clean, and the burger was worth another visit. read more

Pauly's Burgers is a must-try! The burgers are seriously good, the prices are fair, and there's plenty of seating both inside and outside. The staff were really nice and welcoming, but the gelato is absolutely outstanding! It's the perfect way to finish the meal. Great food, great value, and great people! read more

Pauly's Burgers - Burgers Near Me - Eureka Springs, Arkansas

See all

I'd give 10 stars if I could! I don't even like burgers or fries weird I know. So fresh and delicious. Cute patio too. They also have gelato but we were stuffed from lunch! read more

Pauly's Burgers - Double cheeseburger with farm beef. Fries made in beef tallow. Homemade garlic aioli and ranch! - Burgers Near Me - Eureka Springs, Arkansas

Good quality burgers. We each got the Pauly's Royale and split a side of sweet potato fries. read more

Pauly's Burgers - Pauly's Royale Burgers w/Sweet potato fries - Burgers Near Me - Eureka Springs, Arkansas

Great burger and fries! I ordered the single, but consider the double! Cute place, friendly staff - would go back. Did not try the gelato, but others came in and ordered it - good size servings! read more

Pauly's Burgers - Cheeseburger with hand cut fries - Burgers Near Me - Eureka Springs, Arkansas

Wanted a hamburger since it was July 4. The place we were going to for a burger was closed and I saw the reviews were great and thought we would check it out. Sweet potato fries were great as well. People were friendly when we came thru the door. Give them a try when in the area, you won't be disappointed. read more

Pauly's Burgers - Pauly's Melt & Pauly's Onion Burger - Burgers Near Me - Eureka Springs, Arkansas

Very quiet spot with good atmosphere and quality burgers. If you're looking for a good spot outside of the main downtown area read more

Pauly's Burgers - Build your own and the Pauly's Royal with sweet potato and regardless fries. - Burgers Near Me - Eureka Springs, Arkansas

Hands down this was the best burger I've ever eaten. I'm not a fan of french fries but theirs were great! The service was good and fairly quick. The ambiance was good as well it didn't feel like a fast food place. Will definitely be stopping there again. Only suggestion would be having ketchup that wasn't in packets. But that's a small and minor thing. Not a big deal at all. read more

Absolutely mystified why this isn't rated the #1 burger joint in Eureka Springs. Excellent service, super clean facilities, and the burgers are so good we ordered a second round . Nothing like a burger hot off the grill. Definitely worth savoring. Definitely will be back. read more

Pauly's Burgers - Double Farm Beef smashburger with Cheese. - Burgers Near Me - Eureka Springs, Arkansas

Delish Burgers and the Fries are the best I've ever had! The garlic aioli sauce is some kind of tasty! Treat yourself! Visit Pauly's. You won't be disappointed read more

The food was amazing. We had an onion burger and a Pauly's Royale. We shared an order of French fries. It was a weekday. Service was exceptional. The atmosphere felt retro to me. We will definitely be back!!! read more

Amazing flavors!!! Husband and I split the pauly's onion burger and sweet potato fries. Got the GARLIC AOLI dipping sauce. You cannot miss with this winning combination. Top it off with some Wild Bills craft soda and our day was made! Amazing view of the beautiful woods behind the restaurant. We could not get enough, we will be back for dinner LOL read more

Pauly's Burgers - Half of a Pauly's onion burger with Garlic Aoli added and sweet potato fries. - Burgers Near Me - Eureka Springs, Arkansas

Unfortunately this place just keeps getting worse and worse. Don't bother eating here. Go across the street to discos where the vibes are high and the food has flavor and your body is nourished from people who cook with love! read more

From the reviews I expected a great burger I would say it was good, but the hand cut fries were awful, my husband and I split 1 order and we didn't waste the calories on them, they had no taste neither did the chipotle dipping sauce, I will not go back. read more

Burger, gelato, and fries were a 10/10. We had the royal burger and mint chip gelato. We would definitely come back!

While visiting Eureka we made it a point to try out this new burger spot. The menu is limited but interesting. Burger cooked in Beef Talo and onions. Yum The buns are fresh, soft and grilled to perfection. The burgers are juicy and flavorful. The shredded lettuce and special sauce are the perfect topping to the burger. The fries fresh cut and just the perfect portion. They have outside seating and even dessert. We loved it and will return. read more

See all

I arrived right at noon on a Friday and only one other couple there. After an explanation of the menu I ordered the double Heritage Burger with fries. The burger was fairly large and very good. The meat is well seasoned and fresh, the bun was a nice soft fresh bun. The fries were done every well, firm and tasty. The food was all very good. The noise level was over the top because sound reverberated all over. It was very difficult to hear because of this and the constant banging in the kitchen. I would only return if I ate outside. Also, while eating in, the food was delivered in a paper sack similar to a McDonald's to go order. I don't get that at all. Must be a cost saving measure but for dining in at least provide a tray. The food was very good, the rest was not great, the facility was nice and clean. $27 for burger and fries is a bit on the high side, especially charging $3 for bottled water than cost $.10. read more

Pauly's Burgers - Burgers Near Me - Eureka Springs, Arkansas

New place just opened.This is a fast food feel but with quality meat. Service was good, they have lots of workers. A had working guy cleaning outside tables.. We ordered a single patty melt. It was just ok. I am sure hamburgers are the thing to order. We did enjoy the waffle sweet potato fries. They came out warm and salty. When you walk in , the first thing is the Gelato case. So if you get first, is it going to be melted...? read more

See all

GREAT staff, but OUT of the Great fries & OVER $20 each for a burger and mediocre sweet potato fries (OUT of the regular fries) and we drank water. WAY overpriced. not going back for those small burgers. P.S. NEVER a valid reason for a burger joint to be out of fries...NEVER read more

The food was absolutely delicious especially the french fries. The service was incredible and the noise was good. It wasn't that loud in there while we were eating. read more

Wowza! This is the best burger in Northwest Arkansas! We stopped in here(late but they were super kind) and had the best meal we have had in a very long time! Get the burger and fries and extra garlic aioli dipping sauce! Yummy!! Great service too! We will be back, maybe before the week is over read more

See all

Burger and fries were great. The place was extremely clean. The employees were very nice. I would definitely recommend this.! And no, it is not overpriced. Everything has went up in price this last year. Try going grocery shopping! I highly recommend this place! Oops, almost forgot to mention the dessert better check it out for yourself read more

We really enjoyed Pauly's! Burgers were great, dipping sauces were great, and gelato was great! Only thing that didn't blow us away were the sweet potato fries, but they were still good. Service was great, store was super clean. I would definitely be back, really enjoyed it! Thanks Pauly's! read more

Great burger! I got the Royale and regular fries. Fries are a 10/10, burger is a 8/10 (patty could use a touch more salt but that's just my preference). Cool atmosphere and fast service. read more

Best burger I've had in a long time!! The royale is perfect. Love the bun, the flavor of the patty and the special sauce!

Recommendation from a local business owner for the gelato, but we stayed for everything else! Cynthia was great in giving burger recommendations and allowing us to pick our gelato before heading out. The food itself was delectable and satisfactory, enjoyed our order--I would have really liked more onions on my Pauly's Melt though. Inside and outside, as well as restrooms well-kept. Eye-catching colors and comfortable seating. read more

See all

Great Fast-Food style dining. The burger was amazing and the garlic aioli fry sauce was icing on the cake!

Pauly's is very new to Eureka from what I researched. It's very chain style, but a great spot for delicious smash burgers! The French fries, both hand cut & sweet potato, were fantastic. The sauces to dip were wonderful. We tried ranch and chipotle aioli. The biker rally was in town for the weekend, so I'm sure they were swamped, but we stopped for Sunday lunch and staff were super kind! The food came out piping hot and fresh. It's clean and nice for indoor dining, and they have a great patio too. We didn't try gelato, but it looked amazing! read more

Pauly's Burgers - Dining and order counter - Burgers Near Me - Eureka Springs, Arkansas

See all

I stumbled upon this place after searching the What's Happening in Eureka Springs Facebook page. Lots of people raving about the burgers . Our family drove down from Kansas City and this was our first stop before checking in at our hotel. We parked and walked in. They were playing music and lots of people were sitting on the deck. It was very clean and the menu board was easy to read. The NICEST woman took our order & offered us samples of gelato. Our food arrived within 15 minutes and it was INCREDIBLE. My kids ate everything they ordered and it was the perfect meal. The burgers are juicy, the fries are fresh & crisp, and the dipping sauces are delicious. I had the garlic aioli and hot honey . Paid $80+ with tip - I will say it was worth the money. The portions are huge. This isn't some normal "burger" joint, it's an experience. 1 order of fries is enough for 2-3 people. Depending on how hungry you are, the burger could also be split. This place is worth the hype and price in my opinion. I visit Eureka Springs 1-2x a year and Pauly's will be on the itinerary going forward. read more

See all

Hidden Little Gem !!!!!!!! Really yummy burgers, and fries. Very clean and great staff. Plenty of parking and outdoor seating. I thought the price was right for the food you get and quality. Nestled back in the corner I definitely recommend and will be going back myself. They serve breakfast lunch dinner and craft beers all day long. read more

See all

Pauly's is a very innovative and unique burger restaurant. There smash burgers have a ton of flavor and there are several choices. There fries are always good and fresh. You order at the counter and they generally bring your order to you. The only complaint I have is there HVAC system which is very loud and it always seems cold in the seating area to me. read more

The burgers were excellent. Got double smashed BYOB. The fries on the other hand were SO greasy we threw away most of them. They had like no potato in the middle, just all fried grease. For the burgers alone, I'd go back. They didn't have any gelato out when we went so didn't try. read more

I had the build your own single burger. The meat is delicious. But, the gluten free bun was hard! It reminded me of a bun from the freezer. I was disappointed in the bun. read more

Pauly's Burgers - Build your own single burger with gluten free bun - Burgers Near Me - Eureka Springs, Arkansas

Best fries ever. Crunchy on the outside like we always wish for. Will definitely go back tomorrow for hamburgers.

Pauly's burgers are delicious smash burgers. We have tried all of them at different times and they are consistently good. The fries are definitely shareable. Service is great. Pauly's is a neat spot to get a burger and fries for sure! read more

I hate complaining but really? $26 dollars for two sing burgers and one fry? No drinks? This is not club 21. It's not Europe either. Definitely not worth the price. Ambience is no more that a fast food restaurant. Then to top it off they ask for a 20% tip for cooking your food then you cart it off to a table. I know they're not embarrassed but they should be. I was in the restaurant business for twenty years and I would never have the stomach to charge those prices. On a lighter not the place was extremely clean, Extremely!! Kudos. I would rate it as a little more upscale than McDonald's. David M read more

The best fast food I've had in a long time. Every single thing was delicious! Burger was hot and seasoned well. Fries were fantastic. I had gelato- one scoop of coconut and one scoop of chocolate. Both were scrumptious and they blended together nicely. The restaurant was clean and the kids behind the counter were doing a great job. read more

Pauly's Burgers - Entrance - Burgers Near Me - Eureka Springs, Arkansas

The gluten-free bun was wonderful and the fries were delicious. The staff were very friendly.

Food was excellent quality. Burgers simply delicious French fries were superb! I only wish we had a Paulys Burgers in Russellville AR

Outrageous burgers and fries! High quality top to bottom! Highly recommend to anyone coming into Eureka Springs!