An OK spot for pizzeria fare in WF. It's a big place, at least 25 tables. Decor is Americana-kitsch. (Think Cracker Barrel). Also features a prominently displayed political flag - guaranteed to antagonize 50% of the patrons which to me doesn't make sense. And could very well explain why it wasn't very busy on this Friday night. Service is fantastic. The young lady helping us was professional and efficient. Food came quick, order was correct and she made sure our glasses were never empty. Food is ok. Didn't order pizza, as was in the mood for other Italian specialties. The garlic knots were interesting. Reminded me of crescent rolls made out of pizza dough. They're served dry, with a cup of garlic butter dipping sauce. Tasty enough, but not really how I envisioned them, slathered in butter with chunks of garlic, served in a basket. Baked ziti was ok but bland. Pasta slightly overcooked so it was mushy. Sauce is good though, a little sweet. Similar experience with the fettucine. Fettucine cooked right, sauce didn't have any zest to it. Will give another try, next time to taste the pizza. Hoping that this place succeeds. read more

See all

Finally made our way to Patronies, we ordered onion rings, a personal white and a personal cheese. And mini cannolis! Restaurant is super cute and the employees were all very friendly and welcoming. Order was ready for pickup at the right time, no wait. Pizzas were good, we do tend to like our white pizza with ricotta (my fault for not paying attention) and it was not as garlicky as we like but good overall. Onion rings were scrumptious and the mini cannolis were very good! Plenty of parking and great location. We will definitely be back! read more

See all

Enjoyed coming here for lunch (& card games) with friends. GREAT staff , great food, many choices. Large dining room, great rest room. terrific location and plenty of free parking. Unfortunately they changed their hours and aren't open for lunch any more. Bummer for us. (And loved the American Flag on the wall!!) read more

I ordered takeout from here one night. Got pizza and wings. Was average for a pizza place in wake Forest. Decent sized pizza. I do like that we can eat in the restaurant if you want. Seemed pretty quiet inside. The front desk was very helpful and friendly. Would definitely be back for a night with my family! read more

I took my daughter here for the first time. This is such a nice, clean, and laid back local pizzeria. The pizza was really good, and the pepperoni they use is fantastic. What really surprised me was the garlic knots. I'm not the biggest fan of garlic knots, but these are different. They're baked fresh, and come out dry, but it's served with a side of their homemade garlic Parmesan sauce that you dip them in. It's so addicting. Can't wait to bring my whole family there. read more

Top notch pizza - kiddo friendly -clean inside and outside - out door seating - friendly service - yummy desserts-definitely try the pickle dill cheesy bread may not sound that great, but it was delicious-they offer salads, pick your own toppings on your pizza and classic Italian dishes _American flag was definitely a nice touch and love the memorabilia about New York and other trinkets on the wall read more

See all

It took me a couple of years but glad I found this spot. Best pizza in Wake Forest for sure! Their dill pickle bread is awesome too if you like pickles. Sometimes I'll ask them to make half a pizza the same way they make that bread. Best of both worlds. Highly recommend anything they have! Cool sit down spot too if you have the time. Great service read more

Patronies Pizza - Wake Forest - Pizza Near Me - Wake Forest, North Carolina

See all

Teetering between a 3 and 4, really more like a 3 1/2. The ambience is nice and clean, with indoor and outdoor seating. The service was definitely great, although it took awhile for our order to come out. Was pretty crowded as it's the newest pizza place to hit the area. The hours are a bit shorter than most places as it's open from 4-9 5 days a week. As for the pizza, let me preface this by saying I'm a New York pizza snob and that makes it hard to come close to my standard. They're story is that they are from Brooklyn. To me, the pizza was just ok, not mind blowing, not horrible, just ok. 3 star. It's a sauce thing to me. A bit too sweet and too saucy and needing more cheese. The dipping sauce for the garlic knots was very buttery and nice change from the usual marinara. The cannolis were perfection. They do offer several other pasta dishes and heroes so I might try those next time. read more

See all

High quality fresh pizza with a retro atmosphere I like it a lot hey it's from Brooklyn

We've given Patronies in Wake Forest two chances to show us its convenient location should make it the reason we dine in or order our pizza there. Unfortunately, Patronies continues to give us reasons to go elsewhere. Our primary issues is the dine-in service and the value. Patronies have a large dine in. Seating area with table service (not counter). However, they serve its customers on the thinnest one-ply paper plates available. My family does not appreciate going out for a sit down meal and being served on cheap paper plates. If I'm sitting down for table service with a server taking my order at my table, at least serve me on real plates. Price and quality is the second issue. First they only sell pizzas up to 14", but charge the same price that other local pizzerias charge for 18" pizzas. Unfortunately, the pizza itself is only mediocre, and they cut corners. As an example, we ordered garlic knots. We were served dry pieces of pizza dough (knotted), with a cold condiment to go container of what was supposed to be the garlic buttter - except it was cold and had a terrible chemical taste (clearly not fresh). While I do have high standards due to being from NY and having my own pizza oven at home, I do look at this through the lens of other pizzerias in the area, and the price point. If you can't take the time to serve dine in guests on real plates, or to toss garlic knots in the garlic butter, then you are telling you have no time or interest to delight your customers. And that means I have no desire to return! I wanted to like Patronies because it's the closest to our house, but I can't. It's just a high-priced, corner-cutting, pizza joint with low quality food. read more

Great pizza! Good staff!! We recommend the vegetable pizza and the pepperoni pizza at Patronies Pizza!!!! read more

Absolutely the best pizza in Wake Forest! Always great service, and love the family atmosphere.

Started with unsweetened tea got sweet tea. Ordered garlic knots. Received pizza dough cut in strips and folded over. Nothing on the dough just dry dough. Was under cooked and very doughy. Not hot see pictures. Pizza was a supreme. Toppings were sparse. See pictures. Crust was very thin and wimpy. Cheap thin Paper plates for food. Decor was nice but food was not worth my time. read more

See all

We ordered takeout, a white pie, and a regular cheese. It was cooked well and hot when we brought it home. I would go back, but prefer the flavors from other establishments. read more

Really wanted to order from this place but they don't deliver so we would've had to DoorDash. I wanted 3 pizzas, but you can't order a cheese pizza with the toppings you want because they are not listed even though they have them for specialty pizzas. Examples no choice for mushrooms, sausage. Won't try unless they change that. Kinda disappointing. read more

My review is based solely on Take out. We called once about 25 minutes before they closed to find out their hours. We called back at about 20 minutes before they closed to see if it was too late to order takeout. Madison was very pleasant both times and gladly took our order. We picked up our order a few minutes before they closed and it was hot and fresh. We had a pepperoni and extra cheese. It was cooked perfectly and had a good flavor. We will definitely order again. Sorry no pic as we were really hungry when we got it home read more

We tried this place tonight and was hoping it'd be real good but I was disappointed with the pizza. The service was excellent as she did a great job. We only tried the "garlic" knots and a cheese pizza, the knots were ok and came with a side of garlic dipping sauce. Not sure if I'd try this place again, considering they have strange hours for a pizza joint. Tue-Sat 4-9 Sun & Mon closed read more

Great service and great food. Friendly staff. We will be back! We had the wings, mozzarella sticks and the Classico pizza with bacon and chicken. read more

See all

Great tasting food and a very nice family restaurant. My only complaint with Patronies is we wish they were open on Sundays so we could visit after church. read more

I'm from upstate Ny and always looking for a great pizza! Patronies was awesome! Delicious and toppings and salads were great too! Great atmosphere too! Highly recommend! read more

Best pizza and food around! Salads are fresh and yummy! Great service and the owners are attentive to their patrons! read more

Patronies Pizza - Wake Forest - The ambience! - Pizza Near Me - Wake Forest, North Carolina

I really was so excited to try. "Born in Brooklyn" was what made us say oh awesome pizza from back home. A real NY'er never made this. I'm so disappointed. I was truly so excited.... read more

Patronies Pizza - Wake Forest - NOT a NY pizza... - Pizza Near Me - Wake Forest, North Carolina

Got a takeout pizza today, half veggie and half supreme. Incredibly good quality. Cooked perfectly. Will be coming back regularly.

Everything we had was tasty! The dill cheesy bread and marinara sauce was a great appetizer. The lemon pepper wings were crispy and delicious. The pizza crust is crispy on the bottom and soft on top. The atmosphere is a fun family friendly place. We will definitely come back! read more

Patronies Pizza - Wake Forest - Pizza Near Me - Wake Forest, North Carolina

We LOVE coming to Patronies Pizza! Excellent service, the "garlic knots" are great, the food is delicious, the atmosphere is terrific and the meals are reasonably priced. The pizza, sandwiches, fries and kid's Alfredo was really yummy! And their Carmel cheesecake is soooo good! Definitely recommend it! read more

Tried Patronies Pizza tonight and was disappointed on the food. We ordered a cheese and a pepperoni pizza along with a calzone. We thought the pizza was bland and had too much sauce for our taste. The calzone was good but was given the wrong dipping sauce that was ordered. I understand that everyone has their own taste. However, we weren't impressed. The staff was nice and the restaurant was clean. I couldn't decide on whether to give 2 or 3 stars so I went with 3 for friendly staff and a clean restaurant means a lot. read more

We love this pizza place! After countless messed up orders from our usual pizza place, we decided to give patronies a try! Their pizza is delicious-the sauce is sweet. We usually enjoy a lightly sauced pizza, but the heavier hand on the sauce has surprisingly been really enjoyable. Everyone who works there has always been kind and the service is always quick and wonderful! The interior is such a cool throwback. There are vintage items and signs everywhere; I find myself just looking at all of the cool stuff they have in it. We also ordered extra toppings and they loaded it up. My husband and I joked that it was the first time we have asked for "extra xyz" at any restaurant and actually got it! Found our new pizza home for sure! read more

Excellent Pizza. I like the "meat lovers"style pizzas and theirs was one of the best I've had. The crust on their pizza is exceptional.

We thought the pie was good, crust was somewhat sweet for our taste, but good. The pie was smaller than say that of Johnnie's or PTA.

Have gotten take-out several times and the pizza is better than most in Wake Forest. Ate inside today for the first time today and the pizza, calzone, and salad were quite good. However just above our table was a large banner for "Trump....2024." Petronie's manager is certainly entitled to his/her political views, however, it would be nice to simply be able to sit down for lunch and not have to be distracted by reminders of our political division. I would feel the same way were the banner for Kamala Harris. Given the everyday bombardment of election news. ads, and contentious discourse, I would encourage Petronie's to continue serving good food and leave the politics at home. RKP, Wake Forest read more

Pizza is so-so. Confused, do I order at the register or from my table? Never really provided clarity? Not a place I'll return to

Been there 3 times, service is ok, pizza is also just ok, they messed up our order, tried to make it ok but still was not correct.

I'm sorry to say that the food wasn't very good. It wasn't awful, but it just wasn't good. I'd call it below average for pizza around here (and that's not saying much), verging on Dominos or Papa Johns quality. The dough is just bad - that's a big part of the disappointment for us. Being from NY... this is nothing like NY pizza. On the positive side, the people were very nice and the service was good, attentive. Unfortunately, we won't be returning. There are too many other options for dining out around here. read more

We had a small group and we were able to order a variety of food from a surprisingly large menu. Meatballs were some of the best I've had. Try the cheese bread with dill pickles. I had the meat lovers pizza. It has been difficult to get pizza with a good crust in the area. Both the sauce and crust were some of the best. Highly recommend that you give Patronies in Wake Forest. Nick was friendly and service was great. read more

Food was really delicious, meatballs were very tasty, no problem getting a table and it was a Friday night. Enjoyed leftovers the following day and it was just as good as being there. Really liked the history and decor. Service was better than most. read more

Very disappointed is the first thing that comes to mind. This place claims to be Italian owned and from Brooklyn, NY. Not sure if that's an outright lie or these people only spent a few minutes in Brooklyn. The pizza is comparable to all the chain fast food pizza places (papa Johns, dominos, Marcos etc). The dough was too thick and had no taste or good crunch to it. The cheese was of low quality. The sauce wasn't terrible atleast. We got 5 mozzarella sticks that u can tell come out of a frozen bag and they charged $9 for a Caesar salad that was drowned in dressing and very small. This area is in desperate need of a real authentic NY style slice spot, and sad to say this place doesn't come close to that. read more

Ordered 3 pizzas online. Went pick them up and was impressed with the parking, the greeting I got, the friendliness of all the employees while they packed my order and of the manager (owner?) that made sure everything was as I wanted it. These people really take customer service to the next level. Better yet, the pizza was excellent! read more

Great pizza. Service prompt and friendly. Salads are also really good. Convenient location.

We went to Patronies for the first time. The staff was super friendly and helpful . And the pizza was amazing ! Highly recommend them!!!

Much needed option in WF but a 1 hour wait at 5pm for takeout on a Friday night needs improvement. A contender for sure and excellent service. read more