If you are in the Elizabethtown area this is a must do stop. Had lunch there today with a group of friends and everyone loved their food and super friendly staff. We ordered a variety of pizzas, which all had an abundance of toppings and were reasonably priced. The pretzel dough boli has a nice soft crust and generous amounts of filling. Don't generally order wings from a pizza shop but you have to give theirs a try. Both the the old bay and garlic Parmesan wings were perfection! Will definitely return the next time we are in town. read more

Stopped in near closing on Friday night. They brought me out a medium hamburger and mushroom pizza that was so good, I ate the whole thing. Kelly and Dallas were there that night. Also Adam and Jose. They were taking great care of customers and cleaning up the store for the next day. I recommend Parma Pizza Elizabethtown. read more

Ordered a large two-topping pizza that was picked up and carried out. We came home to taste nothing but burnt crust (see picture). Mistakes happen, so we emailed them with the email address listed on the company website. Any follow up? Nope. No one called or emailed back to contact us about the experience. read more

Parma Pizza - Carry out pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Elizabethtown, Pennsylvania

Fantastic pizza. I absolutely love their pizza. Yum yum yum. I crave their pizza now.

I ordered and paid. The same guy that took my order and handled the cash went back and took the toppings out of the fridge. WITHOUT washing his hands or putting on gloves, he stuck his hands into the topping bins and spread them on my pizza slices. After putting them in the oven, he then proceeded to mess with the drawstring on his shorts. Hands went inside a bit, too. Absolutely disgusting. He's the only one who was filthy. The people making cold sandwiches were very clean Before you tell me that I should have said something, nope. There were friends of the workers there and I felt like it would not have been a good outcome if I started complaining or criticizing. NEVER AGAIN read more

Love this place for takeout and eat in. The Margherita Pizza is my favorite pizza in all of E-Town!!! read more

"Have you seen this shit? Hawaiian Pizza? I cannot fucking believe it. Pineapple and ham."―Anthony Bourdain Brothers Pizza is a nice little local shop that's been serving E-Town since 1980. I popped in here for a quick lunch before taking the boys down to the Turkey Hill Experience to enjoy some Ice Creams. I ordered a cheesesteak and the lady asked if I wanted marinara and grilled onions with it, I said,"yes please!" Fries sounded good, but onion rings sounded better so I got an order of them, as well. Cheesesteak w/ marinara & grilled onions ($6.30) Little too bready for my liking but overall it was tasty. The beef was chopped up a bit too fine, and could'v used another few ounces to compensate for all the carbs. The marinara was a nice touch and probably wouldn't have been as good without it. 3.5* Onion Rings ($3.75) Standard onion rings you find just about anywhere. At least they were hot and fresh out of the fryer. 3* Service & Ambiance Not much in the way of ambiance as it was a pretty standard store with a few arcade machines and décor that hasn't changed since their inception. Service was fine, but there was a bit of a kerfuffle with the folks working in the back. Sounded more like a family squabble than co-workers fighting, tho. 3* Value Good prices for the chow and they have a daily lunch special that's almost unbeatable for two big slices of pie and a small drink for $4! 4.5* Nothing memorable, but nothing bad. Solid three star joint that would def be part of my lunch rotation if I worked/lived in the area. read more

See all

Best Stromboli and Pizza in Elizabethtown. I always get food delivered to my place and it's always delicious and well prepared

Food was swimming in grease. The pizza didn't have much flavor and the stromboli appeared to be undercooked with raw dough inside. Skip this place. read more

We ordered a cheese steak & meatball subs to be picked up. When I opened my sandwich, and saw all the meat in the very center, with just cheese folded at the ends. We will not go here again! read more

Parma Pizza - Cheese steak - Pizza Near Me - Elizabethtown, Pennsylvania

Was looking for late night food on a Friday, in the surprisingly quiet town of Elizabethtown. Our first stop was at a brew pub that was crowded, and we saw no one else having food, so we made our way down to Brothers. Well sized pizza place that reminded me of older ones from home, has a real late 1980's/early 1990's vibe with wood grain seating. Several arcade machines are also available, though their functionality was hit or miss. Brothers have an extensive menu of pizza and sandwiches. Went with The Works Cheesesteak, side of fries, and a Pepsi. Cheesesteak had tomato, something I was not expecting, and plenty of meat. It also had a heavy cheese flavor to start and sauce was a regular plain one. Really good fries, they were perfectly done. We ended up coming back the next night and I tried a Cheeseburger, which was also good. Only complaint I have was service was not the fastest. Overall, I'd call Brothers a 3.5, but I rounded it up to a 4 as they were open when we needed something to eat. If Brothers was in a college downtown like Bloomsburg, they would be full every night. I'd stop again to eat here. read more

Parma Pizza - Side of fries with ketchup. - Pizza Near Me - Elizabethtown, Pennsylvania

See all

5 stars for service at Brother's!! We walked in with 35-40 parents and kids from a soccer tournament. Each family ordered separately and the staff did amazing!! They took all of our orders and then went to work on food. It came out super fast, hot and delicious!! They killed it!! read more

They do have fairly good pizza. However, I would highly recommend avoiding eating there in person (over 45 minute wait) for 2 slices of pizza. Also, if you are ordering delivery be sure to do so long before you plan on being hungry. read more

I always say pizza is like sex... even when its bad, its still pizza. If so, consider this the awkward, fumbling, early sex that is over before it began. Ok so that analogy might not have worked this time, but the food was awful. The entire time i was there (on a saturday - at lunch time) NO ONE ELSE CAME IN. I should've taken that as a sign. Awful, freezerburned, premade crusts - this is the kind of pizza you'd get at a gas station. My youngest son got a fish sandwich - the fish was half the size of the bun, This place is dump. Drive on by. read more

This was the worst experience I've ever had. We ordered a pineapple pizza and cheesesteak... the pizza was a cheese pizza that had already been made which had pineapples thrown on and then reheated so that the cheese was brown and crust was a thick cracker. The cheesesteak gave me food poisoning and it took me three days to recover. I'd honestly have been a bit more understanding in some way if they were friendly but I've been there many times and never had a friendly interaction with them. I'm loathe to leave negative reviews but it just made a really tough week for my family that much worse... read more

This is my favorite place to get a cheese steak in Elizabethtown. All of the food is excellent and fairly priced.

Zero on everything. The front counter is not at ground level. So you look upwards, the place is filthy beyond filthy. All types of detergents and chemicals that should not be under the prep food table. The wall next to the oven full of dirt and dust. The owners of this place should not be serving food. This place is the most disgusting place I have ever entered. To eat here you must be trash. It is not fit to eat or to be served. Absolutely disgusting. It's so bad, that how have they not been shut down is beyond me. The health inspector who allowed this place to stay open is on the take and a call to the health department is due. I was not able to eat just because of how disgusting this place looked read more

This place always had provided good food. Their pizza sauce is great and they make good subs. Their subs generally are on the big side compared to other locations so you should have leftovers. read more

Best steak sandwiches in Lancaster County. They use Amorosa rolls and their sauce & meat have a hint of pepper that pushes the flavor up a notch. Pizza is ok, not really my style but still tasty. The wings were also good. I've always had great service though we usually pick-up. Delivery costs extra and can take a while so it's just easier to eat-in or carry out. read more

Super kind especially during a holiday and a hard time for our family. They are super kind only think I was sad about missing the honey mustard other than that 10/10 recommend. read more

Ever have New York style pizza in NY? This is not what you will be served, for sure. The staff is not engaging in conversation unless it is between themselves. Rather than cut lunch meat fresh, Brothers has it precut and wrapped in plastic wrap, like lunch meat in your refrigerator. There subs suffer accordingly. But they may be a better choice than the pizza, unless you are from Iowa. Why two stars? Not the worst pizza in town. What more can I say? You are not in Brooklyn, trust me. read more

I was refereeing in the area and decided I would stop in based off of previous reviews. Excellent food, very kind service. The inside is very clean and has an mini-arcade area. Parking in the back is very convenient. If I could rate over 5 stars I would. I will be sure to stop in again whenever I work in the area! read more

Ridiculously cheap! $8 dollars for a large pizza with several toppings! yowsers. Ordered a pepperoni pizza and it had its own topping of grease. My fiance actually had to blot the pizza (and we all know guys will refuse to because it's "girly) it was that excessive. After the de-greasing, it was pretty good. I wouldn't say it's like NY style pizza, but it's pretty good for the middle of Pennsylvnia read more

Love this place! They're pizzas are pretty good and the subs are huge! The half sub is enough to fill anyone up, and the whole subs easily make 2-3 meals in themselves. Has a nice small town pizzeria atmosphere and they're open pretty late (Till 11pm on most nights). Staff is always nice and quick to fill orders. Great place to stop in for a homemade sub or pizza. read more

Best place in elizabethtown very old fashioned, friendly service, amazing people, & great product. Never had a bad experience

SO GOOD! I love coming to this pizza place when I'm in Elizabethtown. They're alwasy friendly and quick.

Brother's is one of the best pizza places in etown - the owners and staff are friendly and fast. They will pretty much make any kind of pizza you want, even if it's not on the menu. My favorite is the Margherita pizza, which is phenominal. Their sauce has a nice spice to it, and the crust is very tasty. I often go here for lunch, and the subs, as well as the wings are excellent. Do yourself a favor and check 'em out! read more

I'm currently waiting almost an hour and a half for a delivery. All we ordered was a cheesesteak and a pizza. First, the lady taking my order argued with me about weather or not she could deliver to us because she thought we were too far away. So I then had to explain to her that we live 3.5 miles away from the shop and they have delivered to us previously the day we moved here. Then, she hangs up before I could tell her I wanted to pay with a card, so I needed to call back. We're new to this area, so I was really hoping to find a good local business to support, but I will most definitely be taking my business somewhere else. I'd love to comment on the food, but it still isn't here almost two hours later... read more

I have had pizza from Bros. 10-12 times. Service and deliver folks are great but quality of pizza is very inconsistent. While sometimes it's the best, but when we order many at once on a busy night (because we have company) sometimes some are burnt, others are missing toppings, and or are missing spices. :0( read more

Seriously disappointed with this place! I placed my order at 7:53 pm - 2 hours and 15 minutes ago and it still hasn't arrived! My children have fallen asleep without dinner because what was quoted as an hour to an hour and ten minute delivery was ridiculously understated. Really people - how slammed are you at 10:00 pm on a Sunday?! Still hoping to eat tonight - although my expectations are that my food will likely be cold by the time it gets here. Well - it just arrived and as I suspected the hot sub was cold!! Terrible experience. $25 wasted :-( read more

Haven't eaten here in years. I love pizza pretty much any kind...but you should never ever ever use American cheese on a pizza. Ever. Even if you use it in addition to mozzarella. That's why their pizza is cheap. Shame on you Brothers Pizza. read more

We ordered 2 pizzas today at 3:50 and were told it would be 45 mins to be delivered. An hour later we still had not received them so we called to check and were told they were ready and sitting waiting for a driver. Twenty minutes later we called and again and were told they just came out of the oven, apparently someone was lying. An hour and a half later we called back and talked to three different people (one of which was the owners wife). We were made to feel it was our fault and everything their employees told us was not true. We were told all they would do is put a "note" on their board that they would "credit" us two pizzas. In our opinion they should have just talked to their driver and gave us whatever credit they were going to give us then and there. We made it clear we would no longer be ordering from them anymore. Mind you the house we were at was 5 minutes from the restaurant. My brother, his wife, son, my Aunt, a friend of my Aunt and my husband, son and I were all thinking we were having a quick easy bite with my grandparents before heading back to Philly. Needless to say it wasn't quick or easy and in fact held us up. read more

Ate here today due to the reviews on Yelp, pizza was excellent and staff very friendly. I would highly recommend this establishment.

The food is standard local pizza shop stuff. The pizza is decent, better than most in the area, and the sandwiches/sides/appetizers are all pretty solid. It is a little pricier than what I would expect for some items, but I have never been disappointed. Definitely a good spot but nothing to write home about. If you want a standard meal that will fill you up, this is a good place to go. read more

A little higher priced, but you get what you pay for. Cheesesteaks, bolis, and salads are great.

Ordered a small stromboli from them for lunch and it was large for a small! I was surprised as to how big it was. It was a very good stromboli but the guy didn't give me any dipping sauce( marinara) at all or prob gave the them a 5 rating read more

The service may not be the fastest, but perfection takes time. The employees at Brothers are by far some of the friendliest I've met. The place resonates an atmosphere that feels welcoming. In the corner, old arcade games, that even I enjoyed. Space invaders, Terminator, And a good game of pinball. The above counter menu has a great variety, and good prices. I feel proud to call this place my place for food, and my haven for Friday nights with my friends. I would recommend Brothers Pizza To Anyone and Everyone. read more

Food was subpar after waiting an hour and a half for 2 pizzas that were quoted 45 minutes for delivery. We called an hour into the order (15 minutes passed the quoted delivery time) and they told us that the pizzas were sitting on top of the oven waiting for a driver. After another half hour and another call back to them, I spoke to both the manager (who told me it was not his problem because I placed my order before his shift started... REALLY?!? some manager you are!!!) and the owners wife, neither whom apparently had the ability to comp me the price for the pizzas (that's correct, even the owners wife was not willing to take blame and correct it). I expressed my concern about the freshness of the pizza (which I was told was sitting on the oven a half hour ago at this point) and she guaranteed me that was not the case and they JUST came out of the oven. So either I was lied to in my initial call OR it took a pizza place an hour and 20 minutes to cook 2 pizzas. Based off the quality once they were finally delivered, I can tell you they DID NOT just come out of the oven... Are you ready for the disappointing end to a long story... They said they would write our address on their board to be comped for a future order (it's funny that they think we're coming back and/or that was just an easy way out without them taking a loss on 2 pizzas). Lousy customer service, lousy business management/ownership skills and the food was not worth the headache. I would not recommend. read more

Being from the Philly area I know a good hoagie and this place by far has the best hoagies in the Lancaster area.

My personal favorite pizza around. Its not new york style but it is delicious. The italian sub is the best around too. Plus the staff is pretty friendly! :) read more