Go for the food; go back for the service. We live in an area where there is almost a pizza place on every corner. So when you can get a decent pizza from five or six different neighborhood places, you find other ways to define "your" pizza place. The food at Paradise is solid - we've had good meals every time we've gone there. The pizza is the best in Bellmawr, and the pasta dishes are homey, generously portioned, and delicious. But the thing that we keep going back there for is the excellent service and great, friendly people. They are the people who when your sick husband goes to pick up dinner while everyone else at home is just a little bit sicker, they make him up a fruit salad to boost his vitamins. They are the people who when your daughter tells you with 24 hours notice that you have to provide lunch for her 20 person robotics team, they work with you and with your budget to whip up an incredible meal. They are the people who always have a friendly smile, good conversation, and even the ability to put up with your husband's bad jokes. We can get decent pizza at a few places in town. But we can get great food, great service, from really great people at Paradise. read more

Our company recently moved to a new location, so we've been trying out different Italian and pizza spots nearby. After seeing a few great reviews, we decided to take a chance on Paradise for our Thanksgiving luncheon -- and we're so glad we did. We ordered lasagna, stuffed shells, chicken parm, and cannolis, and everything was gone within 20 minutes. The sauce was incredible, the chicken was tender, and the cannoli filling was perfectly balanced. Our team couldn't stop talking about how good everything was. I've seen a few reviews saying it's overpriced, but I couldn't disagree more. The cost per tray was more than fair -- and let's be honest, everything costs more now. Mom-and-pop shops don't have much wiggle room on pricing, and the quality here absolutely justified the cost. One of the owners, Linda, went above and beyond to make sure we had an amazing first experience with them. We'll absolutely be ordering from them again. Great people and great food -- and it's rare to find a place that nails both. Linda & staff -- thank you for the incredible food and outstanding customer service! read more

Best Home made meatballs anywhere!! I live in Egg Harbor Twp . Whenever I'm in the area Paradise Pizza iis my go to!! Everything is fresh and Home made. The Family Meals are Delicious I have tried everyone of them and they are excellent !! you can't beat the price and large portions !!! Everyone who works there are always Friendly epically the owners !!! read more

I heard a lot of things about this place some good and the bad ones are usually just about pricing. I don't think they are overpriced as people claimed and the food was actually really good. It's nice to find a place that has good wings and pizza and of course that they deliver !!! The delivery man was very nice and the food was here sooner than expected! This might actually be my go to pizza spot from now on. read more

Paradise Pizza - Wing zings - Pizza Near Me - Bellmawr, New Jersey

See all

2 stars for very professional staff. Food below mediocre which was pepperoni pie & mild wings. At best 2am low budget pizza stop from the college bar. read more

Paradise Pizza - a slice of pepperoni pizza and fried chicken - Pizza Near Me - Bellmawr, New Jersey

This is the pizza place that you order from when you've had a bad day, when you're watching football with friends, when you've just moved into a new house, when you want to celebrate a birthday...it's the type that is all around good. The dough is just right, sauce is exactly how I want it--slightly sweet, cheese isn't overbearing and it has that everyday style that doesn't hit 'wow' but does hit the comforts of 'so glad we didn't cook'. Ask for the price ahead. My large pie was a bit pricey but after having a basement flooding incident a delivery charge wasn't my top worry. The food made my situation a little easier though and arrived like it was fresh from the oven. read more

See all

Stopped in while in town for the weekend. Good thin crust takeout pizza and salad. The staff was friendly.

Was close to my hotel. Looked at reviews, wanted take out. This had good ratings and family owned. Glad I found. Delicious Italian salad. Pizza was yummy with a think crust, good cheese and veggies I ordered. Just what I needed after a long drive. read more

Ok... so the reviews said they were good. Either my idea of good is different from everybody else or something was just wrong... I got 2 pies. 1 sicillian and 1 red with veggies. In both cases the dough was actually a cross between rubber and cardboard.. huh? The sauce was good but overall the pizza at dominoes was better and that is pretty sad. I hope it was just an off.. not very busy Wednesday night and they were more interested in talking behind the counter and not indicative of pizza there. read more

Was driving from DC to New Jersey for a soccer tournament and found this charming neighborhood gem. We love to support family owned businesses and this was a great one. The owners were super kind as we came in close to closing but still welcomed us in. We had pizza, chicken nuggets & fries. All the food was cooked perfectly and was yummy. We will certainly come back next time we are in town. read more

My coworkers ordered food from there. Everyone's onion rings were BURNT and overcooked and there was hardly any meat on the sandwich. UNACCEPTABLE. We will never order from there again read more

Paradise Pizza - Burnt onion rings? Really? - Pizza Near Me - Bellmawr, New Jersey

See all

Pizza joints can be hit or miss... Who doesn't like pizza, right?? But not everyplace knows how to cook dough, sauce, and cheese well... I found this place late one afternoon after not eating all day... A tiny, old place that could probably use some current remodeling... The owner greeted me as I came in and ordered a couple slices (1 pepperoni, 1 sausage).... Maybe I was just starving, but this pizza was great. Crisp crust, not too much sauce, whatever cheese they used all places should use, and the topping were generous.. I finished my slices and head towards the door. The owner told me to have a good night and grab a drink on the way out.. (You don't see owners giving anything away at most places).. So I decided to stop in today to take a pizza home and also grabbed some soup, which he makes himself. Even after the ride home, the pizza was as good as the first slices I had a few weeks earlier. As far as atmosphere goes, it'll take you back a few decades.... But as far as the food goes, this place doesn't disappoint. Come for the food, and enjoy the genuinely friendly service. read more

Excellent spot. Food was cooked perfectly, the owners were friendly. They supported the front line workers. I would recommend there pizza turnover. read more

Love paradise pizzas food . Wings are great . Big portions. Always fresh . If you want something specific they will make it for you . friendly owners . Soups are sooo good . When im sick I always get there chicken noddle soup read more

Linda, the owner, is the nicest lady. We arrived with our two young children and she went the extra mile to make sure we were situated and taken care of. The pizza was delicious. We ordered a large with tomatoes, mushrooms, and spinach and it was delivered fresh and hot. Linda even cut up a few slices into small pieces for our kids. Last, they brought out complimentary slices of fresh fruit to end the meal on a sweet note. Make sure you stop here when passing through! You'll eat delicious fresh pizza and pasta and feel like you are family. read more

Paradise Pizza - Large pizza with mushrooms, tomatoes, spinach, and a dusting of parm cheese - Pizza Near Me - Bellmawr, New Jersey

We've driven past this place a million times and finally ordered delivery tonight. I wonder what took us so long, everything was great! The pizza was thin crush and delicious and the wings, so crunchy! Even the fries were amazing, not soggy like most take out fries! We will definitely be ordering again! read more

Stopped in today...first time ever. Very friendly small place ordered two slices ..one Mushroom and Onion the other Pepperoni . Both VERY good. Will stop again when in the area. read more

This is that spot for REAL pizza. I always get the to go pie special for $12. And yes, it is almost impossible for us not to eat the whole thing in one sitting lol. The owner is friendly and is always there. Paradise pies never disappoint! read more

Best Pizza! Homemade soups! Paradise pizza is family owned and ran by Michael and Linda, they are very friendly and I go out of my way to eat there. Its like a taste of Italy in Bellmawr. One, if not the first pizza shops in town. I hired Linda to cater my family Easter party and the food was outstanding! I couldn't say enough great things about Paradise Pizza! read more

My wife and I are new to area and we tried Paradise Pizza based upon their close location and good Yelp reviews. Let me be another person to add on to the sentiments of other reviews and say that Linda the owner is one of the most wonderful persons you will ever meet. You cannot be anything, but a fan of the place when you interact with her. We order a few sandwiches and a few sides and I will say that the food is solid. It is nothing spectacular, but you will be very satisfied and not have any complaints. We will be going back in the future. read more

This was my first time back at Paradise in over 10 years. I ordered a lg cheese pizza and a cheesesteak with fried onions. The pizza was lousy but cheesesteak was ok. My bill was $26. That's crazy. I went back because of the reviews. Their prices have always been high but $26 !!! It was like paying $13 for each item. I won't be returning. read more

Ate there pizza, chicken cutlet with angel hair and stuffed shells. Thought i bit into heaven Wow good food trust me

Husband and I recently moved to Runnemede and we were having a a hard time finding "our pizza place". Well we definitely found it here! They make the saying " any pizza is a personal pizza if you put your mind to it" true. Absolutely delish!! And the delivery guy who we've had is SO NICE!! Just a sweet guy!! This place is great and reasonably priced !! Love it here! read more

Paradise Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bellmawr, New Jersey

Excellent service. Friendly. And delicious food. Had the cheesesteak cacciatore and it was delicious. I work locally and we use them all the time. The best read more

We randomly went to this restaurant because it was the first one we saw coming off the AC expressway. The staff was very friendly and welcoming. All three of us ordered a paradise cheesesteak, and within ten minutes we got our food. Best cheesesteak We had in awhile. Thanks Paradise pizza and pasta for great service service and delicious cheesesteaks. read more

Great pizza and chicken parm. super friendly staff. Was a perfect stop on our road trip!

Best pizza in Bellmawr, and that's saying something because there is quality competition in the area.

Amazing pizza place. My family and I have been coming here since I was two. Always nice, not pricey, and wonderful pizza!

New to the neighborhood, and this place was recommended to me. It did not disappoint. I have had pizza, fries and a couple sandwiches and all have been great! Always friendly and delivery is quick. Would definitely recommend if you're ever looking for a pizza place in the area! read more

The pizza was excellent & super customer service..nice family place!! Prices reasonable and great variety in menu, also speedy service!We would definetely return many times if we lived in this area! read more

Found the place on Yelp. I really enjoyed the owner she was very warm and friendly. We ordered a regular cheesesteak, a paradise cheesesteak (which pretty much has it all), mozzarella fries and wings. The food was pretty good read more

They make cheesteaks the way they should be made. Melt in your mouth, cheesy goodness. read more

Paradise Pizza - a hot dog and french fries - Pizza Near Me - Bellmawr, New Jersey

Omg where do I get started? I drove passed this place on my lunch break looking for a quick bite, and I ran into this place. Some places you really get what you pay for, for cheap food but not this place. They have daily meals for $5 and up and u get full portions of quality food. I most definitely would recommend this place for eat in and take out. This place really owns up to its name "Paradise". read more

Right off exit 3 of the turnpike. You need to go. An amazing good 'ole pizzaria. The pizza is incredible and the service is so friendly. Will definitely go back next time I'm passing through. If you're in the mood, go! If you're not, go anyway! The minute you walk in the door the aroma will put you in the mood! And Linda will take great care of you! read more

Someone recommended Paradise Pizza to help out with a small gathering we were having and said to get a tray of the "homemade meatballs " , well after having them I can say we will be coming back! Excellent is the only word to describe them and also rave reviews from our guests , they went out of their way to help us with an extra rack and sauce and also spoons to borrow to serve , thanks so much to everyone at Paradise Pizza read more

By far the best pizza place within 15 miles. It's family run and the staff is very friendly and helpful and the food, there isn't words to describe. Once you've been to paradise, there really isn't anywhere else to go. read more

The good reviews must be the owner or their friends. People in town are loyal but their food is just not that good. you are charged a fee to use your credit card and the portions are not all that fantastic, just normal. nothing much to rave about. read more

Love Paradise Pizza! Great food, and wonderful people. Plus, supporting local business!

There are many pizza places in this town, we have tried all of them. Paradise is the one we constantly come back to. Amazing food and service. They are SO FAST. If they tell you 10 mins, food will be ready in 10 mins. We frequent here at least a couple times a week. Never a complaint. Friendly staff and service. You won't regret trying this place read more

Tried them for first time ans was more than happy. The pizza was excellent and the hoagie and meatball parm was also great. My new go to pizza place read more