We have always loved the pizza at Papa's, but now we have a new favorite from the menu. Papa's celebrated their 50th anniversary and sold $5 calzones. We ordered several different flavors and ...we loved them! We will be back to have them again. Thank you for the event that introduced us to your delicious calzones! read more

We've been loyal customers of Papa's for the last few years. The service has always been great and the food good. We've visited during summers, winters, holiday weekends, and everything in between. Unfortunately, our most recent visit left us so disappointed that we won't be returning. Over Labor Day weekend we dined twice--Friday was great, no issues at all. But on Sunday, we arrived at 6:30 pm, ordered nachos, two salads, a burger, and spaghetti. It took an hour just to get our appetizer, and after waiting two hours, I asked to cancel the rest of our food. I was told that I could not. Our server did her best to keep drinks filled, but each time she came back she repeated, "the kitchen said your food will be up soon." She eventually told us the grill was having problems and that none of her tables had received food. When I pointed out that multiple tables seated after us already had their meals, she explained they had ordered pizza. She then delivered the wrong food to us (steaks). It was the table next to us, which arrived about 15 minutes after we did. After this, I asked to speak with a manager. Katie arrived about 20 minutes later, visibly irritated, and immediately defensive. I explained my frustration with the long wait and inconsistent communication. Instead of apologizing or acknowledging the situation, she blamed the holiday weekend began telling us why kitchen process to justify why other tables got their food already. When I said, "Well, it sounds like you just don't care," she told me she wouldn't be spoken to that way and walked off. I later spoke with the owner, who was apologetic and explained they were short three people in the kitchen. I told her that if we had simply been told upfront about the delay, we would have been more understanding. I also shared that Katie's attitude was unacceptable. She replied that "Katie was under a lot of stress". In the end, we were there for over 2 hours and 45 minutes. This entire experience could have been avoided with honest communication and a little kindness. Sadly, we'll be choosing other local restaurants moving forward that value their customers' experience. read more

Food amazing, and service unbelievable :) pricing much lower Thanh the city I lived in definitely coming again if I had the chance to :)))

This is a great restaurant. The food is excellent. The service is unbeatable. The ambiance and setting is incredibly delightful.

Even though the service and atmosphere here is really awesome and had nice lake views, the food seemed to be where they forgot to add value. I went with the perch dinner and unfortunately had to take it back and we also ordered the chicken Parmesan which left to be desired from a professional cook. The salads were a hit! But the wings too were a miss as they were soggy. Skip this one for entres. read more

We've been going to Papa's for decades. They make a fair French dip sandwich, pretty good pizza, and very nice calzones. On our most recent visit, a family member was quite disappointed with the lake perch (soggy crust and possibly undercooked). But the walleye was fine. read more

I love the food and atmosphere here. I have been eating at papa's since I was a kid and I have always enjoyed my experience here and the food I eat. It is extremely overpriced though but worth it read more

We love Papa's! A wide variety of delicious food and consistent execution. Great burgers, pizza, BBQ chicken, and chocolate molten lava cake and ice cream! Friendly service. read more

Our favorite restaurant in Culver. Very clean, employees are always welcoming and helpful. The food is excellent!

Too much of anything is bad. They proclaim this as the best pizza in indiana. Further, best prime rib, and best...something else. Um...too much self-acclaim is a red flag. The pizza is a 7.0 out of 10 at best. WAY too much cheese. Who says that? I do, when it totally overwhelms the pizza. It's like extreme hot sauce on wings. Sausage was over baked. Pizza crust was also excessively "heavy". This is a 2 1/2 -star, and that's because service is stellar, and craft selection very good. It's not like I'm coming from a pizza mecca. Florida. It is not a mecca. This is nothing special. I'd like to also say that while craft beer selections are good, prices are outrageous. $9/pint for most beers. Wrong! read more

Omgosh, party for my tastebuds and tummy tonight. Thank you guys for my dinner plus ( a calzone lasts me 3 meals! ) The ingredients are so fresh and plentiful. Perfect as always. Love you guys, keep being awesome! read more

Must stop when you are in Culver. Pizza first. Then specials and seasonal ingredients. read more

Papa's - Great Wine at Papa's - Pizza Near Me - Culver, Indiana

The food is OVERPRICED and as a French Trained chef know that most of what they are serving is delivered frozen and reheated. Seriously...there is no such thing as calamari strips (beyond sad)!! Calamari does not come in strips! The manager has a HUGE attitude when questioned about authenticity of the food! Papa's simply ordering frozen food and reheating it for their customers, but somehow people are buying into this theory and paying +$18.00 for a frozen burger. No culinary ethics here....let me in the kitchen......... My response to Matt N. (owner) Your response to all of the negative reviews shows your true character. I've been to your restaurant 3 times (in 12 years) and each time it was a disaster. So please, don't worry about me coming back...my dog eats better than the food you serve. You can tout the freshness, but it's frozen, reheated and you know it! My god I ordered salmon and it was served ooozing with albumin and 15 boiled/unseasoned carrots that are sold at Aldi. Can you imagine a piece of overcooked salmon and carrots...... no puree/no garnish/no nothing/just salmon and Aldi boiled carrots. I was shocked and thought it was a joke! Don't expect Michelin star from you, but expect some level of "you care." Even the people we were dining with were like...what is THAT??? So please don't tell me that you have high standards. I've read many of your reviews and other than the pizza you food is horrific and your management skills even worse. Maybe your "lifetime" of cooking all over the country hasn't served you well. Maybe a management class, cooking class and listening to your customers and maybe, just maybe you could find some things to improve rather than insulting people who are reviewing your food. I always appreciate feedback and have NEVER insulted a customer!!! You're lucky you have little competition in Culver. Also, my name is Debra (written very clearly) not Deborah.....see.....attention to details is important... maybe another class is needed read more

Food was horrible, fish had more bones than meat. Overpriced for how terrible the food is. 10/10 do not recommend. I assume the guy we spoke to was the owner and he's incredibly rude. Will not be coming back ever again. read more

Don't take a birthday cake with you when eating here. My daughter-in-law made reservations for 10 people as we were going to celebrate my son's birthday. We get seated. The server takes our drink order. Then a manager comes out and informs us that no outside food is allowed. We have eaten here before and taken a cake before with no issue. The manager would not allow us to keep the cake on our table and took it to the kitchen. At the end of our meal, we asked if we could get boxes and cut the cake so we all could take some home since we weren't allowed to have any there. They would not bring the cake out. They gave us boxes and we had to cut the cake on the hood of the car in the parking lot to share it. Not a good experience at all. Do you even have cake on your dessert menu? I couldn't find any. I understand rules change. We didn't know they had. When someone makes reservations perhaps your employee could mention that if your large party is for a celebration that no outside food is allowed. read more

This is one of our go to places in Culver. Love their pizza (we usually do take out for that). Menu has a lot of choices. Have had delicious walleye and perch. Their lasagna is excellent. Wait staff is incredibly welcoming and helpful. Katie is the best! read more

Do not use this venue if planning to celebrate an occasion. They declined us brining in a birthday cake for my 16 yr. old. Despite tipping the waitress well and a dining bill for for 13... they wouldn't allow us to bring a cake in. read more

I'm not sure why they have 3 1/2 stars? The staff are friendly, food is good and atmosphere is inviting. They have a extensive beer list, variety of food, assortment of wines and plentiful desserts! I'll definitely come back next time I'm in the area. read more

Have had my last meal/pizza here! I had never been treated so rudely by a food service establishment in my life! First off Papa's is so overpriced but we had a family gathering and several people like their pizza. It was a Saturday and we understand they are slow but was told it would be an hour to hour fifteen. When we arrived an hour and twenty we were told by a lady who was suppose to be the manager "we told you it could be up to two hours. "This was not true as I placed the order. Then she said it will be another 30 just sit over there and wait! Well I don't know about you I was spending over $100 on pizzas could have been treated a bit more professional! We ate there as a family numerous times a month but never again! read more

Cozy place in Culver right on Lake Maxinkuckee. We had a pepperoni calzone, served with a side of marinara, The Hawaiian pizza was ok, but the crust was too thick for our liking. The crab cake sandwich is served great remoulade sauce & I had the caprese chicken grill with fresh mozzarella, tomatoes, basil and balsamic reduction. All were tasty & service was good, but thought it was overpriced for what it was. read more

See all

Love it. Great food and service! We have been coming here since it opened and it keeps improving year after year! This is the best pizza in northern Indiana - if not the state. read more

I had the pepperoni and sausage calzone. It was amazing! The crust had the perfect crunch, the ingredients were fresh, the marinara was amazing even by itself and it was all homemade! We will return. read more

Papa's - Decor - Pizza Near Me - Culver, Indiana

See all

Great food. Wide variety. I had the horseradish encrusted steak. It was great. Service was great.

Ordered their "famous" cheesburger medium. What I got after an hour wait was an unedible burger on a dry over cooked bun with only one slice of cold chedder cheese with a side order of cold onion rings. Waste of my time after driving for 30 minutes to get there. Server was great, drinks great and appetizers great. Been going there at least once every other week for about a year, never had issues until today. Not sure if there is a kitchen issue or what. Asked for manager, got someone who didnt seen to care or bothered to even apologize, got "so not cooked to your request, we will take off the bill" with a touch of attitude. Not sure if we will go back anytime soon. He'll, McDonald's would have been better. read more

i've been going to papa's for about a decade now... and i can definitely say i will never be going again. i assume the man i just spoke to was the owner... beyond rude. our food was horrible and completely overpriced for what they are serving. never again papas. disappointed. read more

The food is amazing but it's pretty expensive so I would but not consider it for mid income families.

Ordered pizza with sausage and onion. Very good and juicy. Will be back again soon. Wl be trying a steaknext time. read more

Papa's - Pizza Near Me - Culver, Indiana

I ordered the Prime Rib, a featured specialty of the house. I ordered the 10 oz, cooked medium. The order arrived and half of the cut was fat and grizzle, and the other half was well done. I shared my disappointment with my server, who apologized and said she'd inform the kitchen. When I got my bill no manner of recompense was made. I asked the server if the manager was aware of my situation and she said yes. I must say, that to have this dish as a specialty is suspect at best. Very disappointed. read more

We decided to try a new place. After the disaster of the Brass Rail, we were heartily impressed with Papa's!! We were greeted with smiling faces, seated immediately and our order was taken promptly. The food was excellent, our server was courteous and enjoyable. The reason for only 4 stars? It was a pain trying to get a reservation!! 3 phone calls, I a day for 3 days straight. The first day, put on hold no one picked up. 2nd day, told to call back the next day to talk to the person that makes reservations... really????? 3rd day, put on hold, no one came back on. The next day we stopped in after a meeting to make our reservation. Their phone etiquette needs a TON of work. read more

Papa's - The bacon wrapped filet was excellent!!! - Pizza Near Me - Culver, Indiana

Over priced, and rude. I was in the mood for some fresh fish. When I got my order the fish was riddled with bones and a little undercooked. I ordered chicken parmigiana, that was over priced and overcooked, in a previous visit! This place constantly disappoints. It's not worth the price, or the rude attitude. read more

An absolute must when you're within 50 miles of Culver. Quite possibly the best pizza in the state. It's perfect to take out on the lake, dine-in, or to grab when you're headed out of town. Very clean inside and the staff is always great. read more

The second we walked in, all 30+ of us, the boss lady looked more than annoyed and acted as if they were doing us a favor. You'd think if your party was about to drop almost $1000 at your restaurant, restaurant owners would at least be thankful.and show some hospitality towards the guests. Not this lady. Rude right off the bat and even the servers were ok at best. Food was meh and seriously bland af. Never again. Next day, most of us chose to go to Subway (at a frickin gas station down the block) rather than giving this place our money. Sad really because Papa's seemed cozy and the record covers decor was a nice touch but the boss lady's face and attitude was pretty tough to handle and food not good enough for me to overlook such flaws. Zero stars if I could... read more

Pizza had good quality cheese and sausage on it,but not my favorite stylr of pizza. Crust was bready, similar to Brunos. Caesar salad was really nicely executed but pretty expensive for portion. Side salad was huge and very fresh. Crabcake burger was really well done..with lots of real creab and was not deep fried, but flat grilled and crispy/ salty. Atmosphere was nice, and the service was very good. Drinks served were excellent. There was a bloody mary ordered at our table and it looked fantastic. Overall a good value...food quality was pretty high. Will definitely return. read more

Papa's - hockey party! - Pizza Near Me - Culver, Indiana

One of the few chances I've gotten to eat in Culver, but I'd say it's pretty good for a lazy weekend with a view over the lake. Their pizza was super yummy, and large went a long way. Had enough left overs to go for 2 days! I also got the crab cake special, which was large as well. The remoulade was so good, we threw some of that on the buffalo pizza! We left with full and happy tummies. It's a pretty nice establishment with friendly and accommodating staff, but prepared, it's a little pricey. read more

Papa's - Crab cake special - Pizza Near Me - Culver, Indiana

D dddddelicious! They're bruschetta is so delicious I had to come back to have it again! I had lasagna, friends had pizza pasta salads. Almost every sauces made in house, bread crusts in house delicious!! If ever back in this part of Indiana I will most certainly return! read more

Papa's - Pizza Near Me - Culver, Indiana

See all

My son attends Culver Academy, and we frequent it very often. The employees are great, and always acknowledge the regulars. Tonight my son ordered a Chicken Caesar salad, with a side of kids Mac N Cheese. Manager comes out and says " your not a child" at first I thought she was kidding. Then she says it again " your not a child" . You would think for the amount of money we spend here during the year, she would have made it for him. You would think that they would be more accommodating. Was the $6 Mac n Cheese really going to effect their bottom line on a Tuesday night? Come on folks !!! read more

Left in tears. Waiting for our to-go order, I kindly told our server that I am a recovering alcoholic (which I do not share, but was required on this rare occasion), and she was sweet enough to sit us by the window rather than wait for our food by the bar. Shortly after, Katie (her family owns Papa's) barges toward our table where we are the only ones sitting in the section, and kicks us out from our table to move us to the bar. This is my first time visiting Culver. My boyfriend's family have been living on the lake since the 1940's. To say I am shocked doesn't begin to explain how I feel. Inhumane and awful...I just hope no one ever has to feel the way Katie made me feel tonight. I share no animosity. Just wanted to share my experience in hopes to make this world a more loving and compassionate place to be. I hope the next time I visit Papa's it's a much better experience. I understand miscommunication happens, but this went beyond that. read more

Half the tables are reserved seated around very loud kids. Asked to move, told no, all other tables are reserved. There were 6 of us adults. No refills offered. Just bad service. Pizza was great and they have take out so I recommend that. read more

As usual, Papa's was wonderful. The food great and the service excellent. Thanks to Carla and staff for making our family gathering exceptional. read more

We are weekend lake people and visit Papas probably every other weekend we are up there. The staff is wonderful and acknowledges us every time we come in. Service is great. Pizza and cheesy bread sticks are always very delicious. We don't get anything else very often, but on occasion I've had the Creamy Artichoke dip, which is served with seasoned, toasted bread pieces SO good. I've also had the pasta once. It wasn't bad, but wasn't great either and way too expensive. I won't ever order the pasta again due to the price. If you're looking for a cocktail be sure to try the Pineapple Martini! All-in-all, a great place! read more