We are visiting relatives at the lake and got pizza here twice. It was very good. The vegetarian supreme is amazing.

Good pizza, fun restaurant, lively atmosphere, great for families. We visited on a crowded Friday night, but service was very good.

First time today getting pizza here (carry out) & it was good. Got a bbq sauce pizza with pepperoni & and small white pizza. White pizza is like cheese sticks. Needs a side of marinara sauce with it to take it to the next level. The bbq pizza was good. Just need a little more cheese & it would be great. Thank you read more

Photo is a black olive, green olive pizza, with mushrooms on half of the pizza. Let's play a game, it's called find the one black olive slice and the mushrooms (I had previously removed one slice with one mushroom on it so there are two more mushrooms to find). Very disappointed. I've eaten here many times before, and have enjoyed the food and the experience. BUT THEN TODAY happened, we came in and ordered the buffet. We made one trip to the buffet and most of the food was gone. We waited for more food. I asked if they were going to refill it and was told no because it closes at 1. I'm from out of town I eat here when I come to town, but I have never been here for lunch buffet so I wasn't aware it closed at 1. I ordered it at 12:50 and was told sure. If it was closing in 10 minutes I should have been told that it was closing in 10 minutes. They said they would see what they could do. They came and asked what we would want on the buffet. We said pizza and cinnamon stick dessert. They asked what we would want on the pizza. We said black olives, green olives, and (mushrooms on half). We got green olives, one slice of black olive, and three mushroom slices. (Photo attached) We waited on drink refills for 20 minutes, got one refill, our dirty plates sat on our table the whole time. We asked to speak to a manager. Unfortunately our waitress WAS the manager. We asked why they didn't put the black olives and mushrooms on the pizza. We were told they didn't put what we asked for on the pizza because they don't take requests. We asked why they asked what we wanted on the pizza then? They said there are mushrooms on it. I said to go count them then. She said, "that's because I haven't been to the store to buy mushrooms yet." (Really? By that time it's after 1 and you haven't been to the store to buy mushrooms yet?). We asked why there weren't black olives. She said we tried to make you guys happy. We said who would want only one black olive on a pizza. She mumbled around and said we just want you guys to be happy. Well, I'm not! I'm very unhappy. My sister said that we don't want to pay for it. She said that she didn't want to pay for eating at a buffet that she wasn't able to get full off of. She said she's leaving hungry and her daughter is gingery and now she will have to go somewhere else to eat to get full. I finally said I will pay for it but I'm posting a review on yelp and Facebook. I was typing this review, she looked down and saw that I was posting and she changed her attitude and she said we would get a discount. We didn't get what they said they were giving us. But I said again that I would pay for it. I did NOT leave a tip. I did NOT leave happy! read more

Mikey's Pizza Pit Stop - This is the black olive, mushroom, and green olive pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Rochester, Indiana

The pizza is way too pricey for what you get . They have no clue how to make a deep dish pizza. The wait staff also is subpar. read more

I often stop here while travelling US 31. Perfect for a classic pizza dinner - fresh salad, awesome breadsticks, pizza heavy with cheese and toppings. I drink craft beer and they always have a handful to choose from on draft and in bottles. Been many times and always had fabulously friendly service. The Mikey's crew makes this out-of-towner feel at home! read more

Great pizza and sandwiches I go eat here all of the time. If you like pizza you need to try them. read more

See all

If I can count the fries, it's not a full serving. Stromboli was decent. Otherwise, hit the sandwich shop across the street.

This is the first time I have eaten here at Mikey's. I was so thoroughly impressed with the cleanliness, the attentiveness of the wait staff, and how family friendly I felt the environment was. The food was AMAZING! The breadsticks are absolutely worth getting. My brain bent a little to the left they were so delicious, the Pizza was amazing as well. We had the mikes extravaganza pizza and it couldn't have tasted any better 10/10! I have traveled from Massachusetts to California from Montana to Texas and I will say this pizza and breadsticks are in the top three that I have ever eaten. read more

Mikey's Pizza Pit Stop - Pizza Near Me - Rochester, Indiana

See all

I understand when your with a large group you expect to wait for your food. But 1 1/2 hours is too much. Several tables came in after we ordered, got the food and left before any one in our group had their order. Food was good but off set by the service, or lack of ! read more

Nice sporty racing themed restaurant with take out available but no delivery. Great atmosphere for families and great pizza. Loved their fried mushrooms. Racer supreme is our favorite. Definitely worth your time. Clean and quaint. read more

Such a neat environment with the TV's, bar, decor & music. Plenty of room for a large party of guests. Our waitress was awesome! The food was average. Our pizzas were burnt on the edges, so we ate the middle, which was good. read more

My friend and I stopped in for lunch and to catch up since we hadn't seen each other in quite some time. The atmosphere was comfortable and relaxing and the restaurant was very clean. Our server was very friendly and accommodating. It took us quite a while to figure out what we wanted because we were too busy talking to look at our menu, however, she kept checking on us just to make sure we weren't waiting for her but didn't make us feel rushed at all. Once we placed our order we didn't have to wait long to be served and everything was fresh, hot and delicious. Our drinks were refilled as needed and we enjoyed a nice, leisurely lunch with fast and friendly service. read more

Good fried pickles and the pizza is ok. Pasta we ordered was pretty badly burnt but they took that off the bill. So overall experience was pretty good. read more

The chicken fettuccine is awesome. I always say I'll try something else but was disappointed when I did. The sandwiches are good but the pastas are best. They have a cookie and ice cream dessert that is soooo good but the pasta is so big I never have room for it. Good hours for the small tiwn read more

Very clean cute place to enjoy hand tossed type pizza. I ordered a tossed salad and it was very fresh - not out of a bag. The veggies on our pizza were fresh too. Getting harder to find that now a days. I recommend this place. For our first visit - very happy race fans. We will be back. Great job! read more

The mushroom appetizer was very good. My drink was watery, the salad was okay. Service was very average.

The service was good, friendly, prompt and accurate. The food took forever though. Their bread sticks were not very good, they almost had a play dough taste. The cheesy garlic bread was good though. The roast beef was a great sandwich option and the wings were also good. Overall a decent dinner option in the area but not a place I will be craving. read more

Wow! The pizza here made me blow my load. Got the pepperoni extreme and it was great with that spicy pepperoni. Also got the breadsticks and they were the shit. They were greasy like your hair when you haven't showered in 4 days, but delicious. Hot waitress with a nice ass, great pizza, and ambiance. Will for sure go back and get some of that dirty ass pepperoni pizza. read more

Never had a bad meal here.. it's a regular stop for myself and the kids and they have a pretty decent variety for a little "pizza" joint... read more

Mikey's Pizza Pit Stop - For the brave!!! - Pizza Near Me - Rochester, Indiana

Food is fantastic and sometimes well worth the wait. Free wifi is a bonus. My favorite is the chicken Alfredo pizza....yes pizza!!! Soooo good even reheated the next day! My husband loves the wings! read more

AWESOME Pizza!!!! I could eat this pizza everyday!! Great crust, and the toppings are all fresh! Love the decor and the people are always there to make sure you have everything you want or need. My 13 year old will not eat any other pizza now! read more

the food is great and prices aren't bad. the servers are friendly. my family believes that they have the best breadsticks in town. however, it is always really loud in there. i understand it is a family restaurant/bar venue; but i think that they would have more business and guests who hang out longer if the music was turned down a bit. especially since there are hardly any places in rochester to go grab a bite, a drink and have some conversation. i know that the loudness has stopped myself and others from stopping there on occasion. read more