I would say that this place is a tasty secret to a lot of people who never make it over herre to Division or Puerto Rico... We parked in the neighborhood and walked around a bit and I like how the people really celebrate their culture here, with all of the flags, decorations, huge murals, etc... There is an exodus of the younger generation leaving the island to go elsewhere, mainly the US mainland...So, when you find a place like Papa's, which is very authentic, come back here, again and again...I think the mainly Puerto Rican clientele shows how legit their flavors are. We started off with the following: - chicken salad, which was full Of flavor and very meaty - the steak Jibarito with garlic butter sauce was incredibly great, this was an awesome sandwich and I'll probably order double meat next time - Maduros - very sweet plantains and could be a dessert - pollo chon (chicken lechon), flavored just right, juicy, tasty and pretty huge The service was inviting and thank you Pana, who was talking with us as we were waiting for them to open their doors for lunch.... Hope to make it to Puerto Rico one day!! read more

See all

This is the best Puerto Rican food in Chicago. Our server was busy yet still fast onbher feet. The art in the restaurant is also great.

Vsited Papa Cache Sabroso hoping for a memorable meal, and while the experience was perfectly adequate, it didn't quite reach the level of "must-try." ​The menu offers a nice selection of classic Latin dishes. We got that the Papa's Medio Pollo Chon to share for a family of 3. The Medio Pollo Chon is the signature half-rotisserie chicken at Papa Cache Sabroso, and while it's certainly edible, I found it to be just okay. My husband compared it to a Costco rotisserie chicken. Don't expect a gourmet experience, but you'll get a decent plate of food for a fair price. It's an okay 3-star experience--nothing to complain about, but nothing I'll be rushing back for next week, either. read more

I'll start by saying this was a spur of the moment meal well after the 2026 Puerto Rican parade on Saturday June 13th had ended. A friend and I decided to hit the Humboldt Park area (Western/Division) and take in some Borinqueña atmosphere and sights. After walking up and down Division Street awhile we stumbled upon Papa's Cache Sabroso. The place was jumping! The weather was amazingly gorgeous and outdoor seating was packed. There was a line for seating and takeout. The friendly host was doing an amazing job of keeping it all organized. We chose takeout and ordered a steak Jibarito con arroz y gandules and a side order of plátano maduro all totaling $22.27. As another reviewer noted it is a tad pricey but not overly so. It took about 20+ minutes to get the food...but like their sign states, something on the order of, "this is not a fast food place and good food takes time, please be patient". The Jibarito tasted good overall like other Jibaritos I've had in the past, however my friend commented that although the steak was flavorful, it was a tad chewy and I would slightly agree. The mayo, tomato and garlic kind of brings it all together for me, but I would've liked way more garlic...and there was even a small container of garlic "sauce", but it was very light on the mashed garlic paste. Whenever I dipped my plátano maduro, I couldn't get any pieces of garlic on until most of the olive oil was gone. The rice was standard and flavorful and I really did enjoy the plátano maduro. I would probably return to try the garlic chicken. read more

Papa's Cache Sabroso - Steak Jibarito, Arroz con Gandules, Platano Maduro - Latin American Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

I had a great experience eating here while visiting Chicago. It is a very small place but thankfully there were open tables on a Monday evening. The wait staff were attentive and accommodating. The food was delicious- I had the bistec encebollado. The tostones were so magically garlicky that I'm still dreaming about them. It was great. I wish they had more variety on their menu but I understand it's a smaller restaurant. read more

Papa's Cache Sabroso - Tostones - Latin American Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

Cozy mom and pop type restaurant that was busy during dinner rush. Even though it was crowded and the wait time was a little longer than expected, the food was well worth it! My first time trying jibarito and I'll definitely be returning. read more

Papa's Cache Sabroso - Steak jibarito - Latin American Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

If you are looking for an authentic Puerto Rican spot this is a great spot. It is a smaller spot and fills up quick. We got takeout and it is a great takeout place. They were fast and efficient. They offer everything authentic jibaritos, chicken, and different types of plates as well. The staff is friendly and it is family owned. A great and cheap spot to grab dinner. read more

I placed an order three Steak Jibaritos online. The pickup process was pretty easy, just had to wait in line while other people ordered their food in front of me. The Jibaritos themselves were good. A little overpriced but still a decent menu. My only issue with them was the lack of garlic on top. I ordered two out of three with arroz con gandules for $2.50 more. The rice was pretty good definitely not the best I've had. Not exactly sure if I'd return anytime soon. $16.50 for Jibarito with rice is a tad bit much. I got my usually spot that tastes a lot better for a lot cheaper as well. Won't rule this place out, but I have my spot already. read more

See all

If I could rate Papa's Cache Sabroso a 6 I would. Everything from the food to the service was great. Got here right at open. My friend and I were well attended and given space as we were catching up. More customers came in after an hour or two and by the time we left the restaurant was packed. Very cozy, nice local Puerto Rican restaurant. Have been craving to come back after since I left. read more

Papa's Cache Sabroso - Latin American Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

My wife and l stop in for an afternoon dinner and it was amazing the food was off the chart and the service was amazing . This is the stop if you're looking for a Lunch or dinner l would recommend it . Stop in and enjoy!! read more

There is metered street parking in front of the restaurant. You walk up to a large outside patio and there is a smaller inside eating area. It is a little dark on the interior but the warmth from the service, the amazing food and cheer of other patrons makes up for it. The owner was lovely and the service was excellent. I enjoyed every bit. The portion size is large so you definitely won't leave hungry. I got the rotisserie chicken with white rice and beans and yuca. The garlic sauces was yummy and the spicy sauce had just enough kick. I was just sad I couldn't finish all my food. Definitely worth dropping in and checking out. read more

See all

Chicken taco 10/10! Seasoned to perfection and the hot sauce gives it a nice kick! Jabarito was good but the chicken was a little bit salty! read more

Papa's Cache Sabroso - Chicken Jibarito - Latin American Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Very memorable visit. It has a true mom-and-pop shop feel -- quaint, cozy, and welcoming from the moment you walk through the door. The jibaritos were the best I've had, with perfectly balanced flavors. Service was great. read more

Papa's Cache Sabroso - One of the photos on their wall - Latin American Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

Casual Puertorican cuisine in a neighborhood vibe. Thier specialty is the rotisserie chicken for its Great flavor and spice. If you happen to be in Humboldt park you must stop by. Try thier hibaritos, the rotisserie chicken is a must. read more

Papa's Cache Sabroso - Latin American Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

I live an hour away in Aurora. I was told to wait 25 minutes for Lechon. I sat out front in my car for 45 minutes. Went back in to be told that the lechon was not ready and they had no idea when it would be ready. I literally waited to drive over an hour home for no reason. Why lie?!? WHY LIE?!?!! read more

I had the 1/2 chicken and it was delish!! 10/10 The service was wonderful! It was a great experience.

Great food, great service, and it's BYOB! Their rice and beans are amazing! The place is small so don't be surprised to wait for a table but well worth it. They also have a patio that has heaters for some extra space. They have a small menu but everything we had was a hit. The chicken is juicy and well flavored. The tostones with the garlic sauce I could eat everyday. Their homemade hot sauce has amazing flavor and is definitely hot but not crazy hot. Can't wait to come back and try something new. read more

We did a catering order from Papa Cache for lunch and we all loved it. The chicken was so flavorful and the rice was bomb! Everything came so fresh. Would definitely go back and try at the restaurant. From what we tried, we would highly recommend! read more

Papa's Cache Sabroso - Latin American Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

I picked up dinner after 8 pm on a Monday evening. i wanted to try Chicago special Jibarito, and this was the only place I could find open after 8. I went with a steak jibarito. It was excellent. Fried plantains on the side was good as well. read more

See all

In the world of Puerto Rican cuisine Papa stands up to the best. I stopped in the old neighborhood for a quick bite and was drawn in to Papa's. It's not hard to do. Been here many times because it's tried and true. He's been around on Division street about 25 years and is usually around in the restaurant to meet and greet. The service is excellent with Johnny knowing the menu the neighborhood regulars and knows how to treat newcomers and walk them through the menu. I usually go family style with a friend for a whole chicken, arroz y gandules, and Yuca En Escabeche , yucca with onions, simple but insanely delicious. Now their chicken is off the hook. No one had chicken like this. Lightly spiced broasted to perfection. There's plenty of other menu options to choose from. Their Lechon Asado on Saturdays only is some of the best around. There's also plenty of outside seating so try Papa's out to get a true taste for Humboldt Park. read more

See all

I LOVE Jibarito's! This was my first one and immediately I fell in love with them! If you're visiting, I'd recommend trying these! I preferred the chicken Jibarito. The restaurant is small and is more of a spot for a quick bite. Service was great and fast. read more

Papa's Cache Sabroso - Jibarito - Latin American Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

Friendly service and good looking good. The garlic sauce was definitely the highlight read more

Papa's Cache Sabroso - Pollo jibarito lunch special - Latin American Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

Excellent sandwiches and appetizers. Fun atmosphere. Great crowd. Cute stretch just after a nice walk through Humboldt Park.

We ordered: Jibarto con Arroz - steak between fried garlicky plantains Papa's Pollo Food was all delicious. Both the rotisserie chicken and steak was well seasoned and tender. Jibarto sandwich was a great combo of fresh and savory flavors and textures. Rice texture and flavor is a tasty side. Employee was very enthusiastic and nice. Good service. I like the family vibe including the people photos on the tables. I'm going to recommend this to my Puerto Rican friends. read more

Papa's Cache Sabroso - Latin American Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

Overall Thoughts: Delicious, garlicky jibaritos; exceptional service and inviting staff (Papa himself gave us a warm welcome too)! Indoor seating is limited, but they have a toasty, heated outdoor space for cold winter days. Prices are reasonable too. Food I tried: - Ribeye Steak Jibarito: The steak was super juicy and flavorful, and the plantain was quite densely flattened. Adding their garlic sauce on top added a nice kick. The arroz con gandules on the side was also extremely good-- a little crispy, very flavorful and aromatic. - Shredded Chicken Jibarito: The shredded chicken was also tender and juicy with great flavor, but I think the flavor of the steak was more robust, which I preferred. -- Price (relative to peers): 4.4/5 Food: 4.7/5 Ambience: 4.8/5 Service: 5/5 Overall Value: 4.7/5 read more

See all

Best meal we had in Chicago and was the cheapest! The chicken is super juicy and flavorful. The jibarito was absolutely delicious. Can't recommend this place enough. read more

Papa Cache's has specials. Their rotisserie chicken is awesome. The staff are friendly and amenable to you altering your order.

Today the wifey & I treated my nephew & his wife to Papa's Cache!! When I tell you this is the best rotisserie chicken in the city, you better listen!! I had the 1/2 chicken w/ arroz con gandules. Some yuca (i have to have it) and some tostones. The yuca was 8/10 The tostones was pretty good 6.8/10 The star was that rotisserie bird! So flavorful, juicy & tender. You can taste the garlic in that bird and it pairs well with the rice. Great meal and the service was EXCELLENT!! Definitely a must try! Visit Humboldt Park and go have some of the best rotisserie chicken you'll ever have. Or check out one of their other dishes. Solid 8.8/10 read more

Papa's Cache Sabroso - Latin American Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Food was great service was a little slow but the food made up for it. Definitely coming back.

While vacationing in Chicago, I was told by my local friend that there's a "restaurant that I have to try"! We go the first day: They're closed. But we weren't discouraged: We went back two days later. And though they were closing early, they allowed us to order and dine in. So happy that they did! Authentic food. Savory flavors. Friendly staff. Joyful customers. The steak sandwich was delicious and tender. The rice and beans side was plentiful. The food was so good, we took a whole chicken meal home with us...and ended up eating it all that night! The hack: Add their homemade green chili sauce to your rice for a kick of heat! (You'll thank me later!) Next time I'm in town, I'll add this to my "must visit" list. read more

Papa's Cache Sabroso - Steak Sandwich w/Rice and Beans - Latin American Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

The food is very good, I always get their sandwiches. Service is adequate. Ambiance is a typical local restaurant.

Haven't seen the owners in a bit. Life changes fast. However I do order to go . Decided and with whole family at the festival. Music was on point! Food absolutely amazing. Service, as if I still go weekly, so humbling. Just perfect. Memories still shine! Love your family! Love baseball.. Stay humble. Heartfelt.. Nunez-Roman Family. read more

We keep coming back! Great food! Service is great. I suppose the ambiance could be better in some people's eyes but I don't care about the when the food tastes great! read more

The best Puerto Rican food..so far Checked in on a few occasions and their chicken is nice and tender. Staff are friendly and the service is top line! read more

See all

Good food good prices good portion sizes altogether good tasty PuertoRican food .Ive been plenty of times & actually gets bettr and bettr

Wonderful place! We've been here just once but will be back to enjoy more food! We got the jibarito and rice read more

Papa's Cache Sabroso - Jibarito - Latin American Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

I have been coming here for years since friends introduced me to this place back in our college years. It's a no frills spot with DELICIOUS Puerto Rican food. The steak Jibarito is a must have. If I even set foot into Chicago I bee line to Humboldt park to eat here. The tender steak topped with crisp veggies, sautéed onions, garlic sauce and crispy plantain...mmm. Thinking about it literally makes my mouth water. I can't wait until the next time I'm visiting Chicago so I can eat this sandwich again! read more

I'm gunna give them one star for when they're busy they have no seating system . A woman was waiting in-front of me for 30 minutes and a group of women with there kids about 7 of them just walked in front of us and sat themselves . While we had been patiently waiting . I think it's rude and disrespectful that the waiters watched us stand there and wait , while telling us it was going to a bit to be seated then just let the group sit themselves . Do better and have a system for when you're busy . read more

Delicious Jibarito, beans were fantastic as well. Lives up to the hype. Served with homemade salsa verde and garlic sauce. read more

Papa's Cache Sabroso - Jibarito - Latin American Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

Went there for lunch with my wife waited forty five minutes to get our food. The waitress said it was shift change. When I finally got my food I opened the steak jibaro sandwich there was one small piece of dry meat and the tostones were greasy and crumbly an indication of it being prefried then the rice was hard and tasted old when I told the waitress she got angry and said it wasn't yesterdays rice. I would not eat there again and advise anyone else to save your time and money and eat elsewhere. 100% disappointed. read more