Papa Johns Pizza

My go-to is the fungi madness with pesto instead of mushroom sauce. It is excellent! If ordering…read moreahead, it can take awhile--as good food tends to--so account for that. Never had an issue with customer service, though I always take it to go. It's a decent-sized sports bar in a convenient side of Pooler. I deducted a point for lack of consistency. Sometimes there's no cheese, other times my jalapeños are missing, sometimes it's kinda dry. But when it's done right, as demonstrated in this picture, oh my God...

We ordered a large cheese pizza, extra crispy to go, and chose this place because it was advertised…read moreas having authentic NJ/NY-style thin crust pizza. The pizza was honestly disgusting. We only took a few bites and couldn't eat any more. The crust was soggy instead of crispy, and the pizza was overloaded with cheese, greasy, and doughy. Not at all what we were expecting. We ended up throwing it away. If you're looking for authentic NJ-style pizza, I would recommend finding another place.

Cool stuff everywhere.

Garlic bread

See all

Burnt wings

The Brothers Pizza & Grill

4.1(67 reviews)

0.1 mi

Long Islander checking in here! I've lived in the area for a year and a half, and this is THE best…read morepizza I've found from Rincon, Pooler, Port Wentworth or Springfield areas! Runner up was Tommy's Pizza in Rincon. I've gone about 6 times already, and the whole family agrees easily! My two favorites are their sausage & mushroom pizza and the Sicilian pizza may be the best I've ever had! In fact, I know it is! Dynamite! I live 35 mins away, butt I work nearby and grab it on the way home. A few slices get eaten in the car every single time. And I cannot guarantee there won't be a mess by the time I reach my driveway! Please expand to Rincon!

The most mid pizza in Pooler. It's not gross but absolutely no distinguishable flavors on the…read morewings, garlic knots or pizzas. Also, the absolute worst ranch in town, bring your own hidden valley for better results. Put some butter and salt on your stuff man.

Lasagna

See all

Terra Mia Italian Bistro & Pizzeria

4.1(364 reviews)

2.3 mi

Still traveling! Currently in Pooler GA Nice area with…read moreLots of options for dinner! When a review states go early or wait GO EARLY We got there at 4:40- & there were only 3 tables available! Complimentary Garlic knots & Marinara were wonderful! Excellent crunch & tender centers !! Hubby ordered a Caesar salad, it was a lot for one person.... So I helped .... Tasted several times! All were great crunchy & dressed perfectly every bite had dressing and a bit of parmigiana! His Eggplant Parmigiana was truly delicious!(( of course I tried it )) He actually makes it when we're home... this was a true treat My spaghetti & Meatballs meat was superb ! Pasta was just perfect I've always loved Italian! This was wonderful - Clean, hot & fresh . Kinda wish this was closer to home !! Our waitperson Andrew C was sooo on point a fabulous, attentive, knowledgeable, positive fora truly wonderful restaurant!

Food was very good. We had Veal Saltimbocca and Veal Milanese…read more Service was very good as well. Ambiance was OK. A bit cramped and very loud. As a couple it would be nice to have a conversation without having to yell.

Magnificent chef

Spaghetti & Meatballs

See all

Caesar Salad

Mellow Mushroom Pooler

3.6(340 reviews)

2.8 mi

Loved Mellow Mushroom. I had never heard of this pizza place, so we decided to go give it a try…read moresince looking at the other reviews. The place has an inviting atmosphere, with super heroes set up throughout the restaurant. The service was great. Our waitress was very attentive, but sometimes a little too familiar for my taste- I thought I was her peer as to how she communicated with us. I guess that was the teacher in me. Additionally, the food was delicious but also costly. The price you had to pay for each add-on topping was a little too much. Overall, it was a great experience. Just know that it may be in the expensive side.

We were seated right away on this Father's Day Sunday, and beverages were soon to follow. They have…read morean open kitchen if watching the cooks is your thing and flat screens show various sporting events. Our waitress, Kailee, was on top of everything-refills, utensils, sauces, etc.- thank you! We started with Cloud 9 wings-winner winner chicken dinner! Yummy! The Special (basically a supreme) and the Funky Q pizza were hot, delicious and cooked exactly as requested by the dad in the group-thin crust extra crispy. There's no reason to give anything less than 5 stars. Good job!

Host Station Robot

Pretzel Bites

See all

Inside...hero themed

Lovezzola's Pizza & Sub

3.1(106 reviews)

2.0 mi

We enjoy eating here a few times a month! The food is always fresh, cooked to perfection and…read moredelicious! The staff are always courteous and welcoming. The decor is quaint and the entire place is spotless! We really like the Lovezolla Special Pizza-it has everything on it basically! The wings are so good and the garlic knots are the best!

Food was excellent! Had a cheese pizza, italian sub and garlic knots. We will definitely be back.read more

Three topping personal pizza

See all

The front counter

Rise Pies

3.2(72 reviews)

2.9 mi

Delicious personal pizzas, great for sharing. Grab a lunch special or build your own…read more The service is great, friendly people and the pizzas cook fast. Ambiance is chill, pizza spot with lots of seating, serve your own drinks, and enjoy type of place. Today I popped in after a little shopping at Tanger, to try the weekday cheese pizza special. The crust was light and the sauce was delicious, can't go wrong with a cheese pizza. Yum!

I took my family to Rise Pies yesterday. There was old Food on the table. Ask about getting it…read morewiped off, and the guy pointed at a tub with cleaning chemicals in it & a rag. I rung out the rag & wiped it down myself. Then another guy, after cutting the first pizza, flipped it over onto itself self. Then tried to separate it. The pizza looked nasty & was burnt. Drink machine was down. There was a time, b4 covid, when the pizza & service was GREAT. There was a line of people ordering. Picking up to take home. But it hasn't been that way in awhile. There was only 2 other people in there. I won't be going back.

See all

Marco's Pizza

3.1(47 reviews)

3.3 mi

Best pizza I've had since moving to Savannah. The staff is always friendly, sometimes a little…read moreconfused but the pizza makes up for it. Love their White Cheezy, Chicken Fresco, and Pepperoni Magnifico, as well as their Cheezy bread & their Italiano sub. My favorite pizzeria back home does NY style and has green olives as a topping, and so does Marco's! I have ordered the thin crust with just cheese and olives, it may not be the same but it sure does make me happy. I have not had any other chain pizza in the past 11 months! Marco's is always happiness in the box.

I placed an order thru their website for delivery. After being delivered, we noticed that our…read more$14.75 salad (after tax) was not delivered. I called the driver and he pulled over, checked his back seat, and said he had not been given it. (He was very helpful and pleasant.) I called the store and was told, "oh yeah... I see your salad here..." I asked, "Will you be delivering it or will I be refunded?" I was told they would not deliver it. But I couldn't get refunded. I could get a credit. Well, I don't live here. So I will need the refund, as a credit will not do me any good. I was told they could not process a refund and I would need to call the next day. I called the next day and was on hold for 20 minutes, during their business hours and no one ever answered! After this ridiculous experience, I would never order from them if I was local.

See all

Boston's Pizza Restaurant & Sports Bar

3.6(88 reviews)

3.2 mi

I ended up coming here after a long day of shopping and it was perfect! I sat at the bar and…read moreenjoyed watching the FIFA games which I appreciate it being on the TVs. I got a personal pepperoni pizza and it was perfect for a quick bite,

Visited on a Saturday night and just missed their happy hour. Our waitress Denise was amazing…read more Super friendly and funny. My group initially came just for drinks and to watch the games but I ended up ordering a chicken Caesar wrap which was delicious. It could have used a bit more dressing on the wrap. The seasoned fries were so good but a bit salty for me. I love the amount of tvs that are around the restaurant and they show several different sporting events at a time so you're able to follow along to whatever game you're wanting to watch. The outdoor seating is nice and one of the booths has a fire pit which is really nice.

Inside Seating

See all

Street View

Your Pie Pizza

3.7(84 reviews)

0.1 mi

Food, service and overall ambiance was lovely. Will definitely be back!…read moreThey have a great selection of draft beers as well!

I asked my husband and my 16-year-old, and both gave it a 4. Had it to-go and didn't pick it up, so…read moreI can't comment on the interior. But the pizza is good, especially when you're not in the mood for the popular chains. Love the menu and the custom options, the crispy crust, and the fresh toppings. We all get personals.

See all

Build your own pizza Pesto, feta, fresh mozzarella, broccoli, olives & pepperoni

Super Baked Pizza and Wings

2.7(6 reviews)

2.0 mi

Mark H. I try to be honest about what I've eaten. It's not on purpose that Pooler…read morerestaurants(majority chains) less than 5 stars from me. If that's even true. We're all adults so I'm sure people know to try things for themselves. Super Baked toppings are the best I've ever eaten anywhere. That's what I put in my review as well.

I noticed that Brokin who gives every restaurant a bad review has left several bad reviews to other…read morePooler restaurants. Ignore her reviews! Super Baked is the BEST pizza and wing place in Pooler. She also left a poor review to the Pita pit. It also is a great choice in Pooler! "Stay home and eat a tv dinner Brokin"

Pepperoni pizza, best cheese I ever tasted.

Buffalo wings. Very disappointing. :(

See all

The cookies were so delicious.

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

6 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Rachel G.

118

11 years ago

To whom it may concern, At around 8pm on Sunday May 11th, 2014 your delivery driver was delivering a pizza in our highly populated residential area full of children and pets. As she came whipping around the corner my husband was calling our 10 month old professionally trained german shepherd home from the neighbors. Your delivery car hit our puppy, and because she was speeding she dragged his body almost 4ft before she was able to come to a complete stop. He suffered a severe degloving injury and fracture to his right front paw, we had to rush him to the emergency vet and then he was seen and is still being seen by multiple veterinarians and specialists. He is finally walking again but it has taken a lot of patience, resources, time, and roughly $7,000 in damage that your delivery driver caused. On Monday May 12th, 2014 I contacted your general manager in Richmond Hill, Georgia about the incident he assured us he would look into your insurance policy and possible coverage for some of our veterinarian bills. I was told he would contact me on the 13th with more information, he never contacted us again. When my husband called on the 14th to follow up your shift manager stated "we are more concerned with the damage to our delivery car than your dog". We never heard from them again. If your delivery driver hadn't been speeding the damage to your delivery car and our puppy would have been non-existent. I am very disgusted by the lack of empathy, punctuality, and professionalism by Papa Johns. I find it to be a direct reflection on your corporation. My family and friends will no longer be frequenting your establishments, and will continue to share our story with people in the community so that they are aware of your corporations utter disrespect for a life. Accidents do happen but it is the way they are handled that reveals real class and ingenuity or lack there of. I will not be ignored and will seek legal aid if necessary. Regards, Rachel Beken read more

Ashley M.

8 months ago

Our pizza arrived after 2.5 hours cold and did not taste good. We could get no one on the phone to cancel the order or get any information on when it would deliver. Very disappointing will not be ordering from here again. read more

The Good S.

5 years ago

Love the pizza and the epic stuffed crust deal. They probably know me by name for having ordered so many epic stuffed pepperonis in the past month. It's just so good read more

Travis C.

393

8 years ago

Waited 2 hours for my order to be delivered. Called to check on it and was placed on hold for 10 minutes. Never again.

Thomas J.

5 years ago

Over an hour and a half and still waiting on just a single pizza........... ........... ........... ...........

Gopal P.

9 years ago

Don't give this people your credit card They are frauds Look like GM IS INVOLVED IN IT TOO read more

Papa Johns Pizza - pizza - Updated November 2026

People who viewed Papa Johns Pizza also viewed

Marco's Pizza

3.0

(2 reviews)

Great customer service to go along with the great food. My go to place for pizza and wings.read more

Unable to rate the food. I ordered before 9pm online. I arrived at my estimated delivery time of…read more924. The staff was hanging out. I was told they never received the order. Then the manager goes to the printer and sees the order had been sitting there the whole time. Then he proceeds to tell me he ran out of cheese. Not sure what other excuses I would have heard if I had stayed there longer.

Little Caesars Pizza

3.3

(23 reviews)

Pizza was great, ICB was great, customer service was incredible probably the best Little Caesars…read morearound this area overall 10 out of 10

So I had never had little Caesars until recently and I'm hooked!! I've downloaded the app and love…read moreordering on my way there knowing it'll be ready fast and it's so damn good! The crazy puffs, are a must!! Food is hot and good every time!

Kay's Pizza

3.2

(125 reviews)

This place fire AF especially after bar hopping. It was quick to get. $7 per slice too. A little…read moretaste of NY LOL.

4.5 Pizza 4, service…read morea 5+. Easy late night pizza by the slice, warm and good. Great vibes and service- best welcome and example of good people making work fun. Pizza by the slice- huge, and whole pies. We had cheese and pepperoni- both good and just what we needed for an easy and quick dinner. Thanks again for the music and laughs- will be back.

Costanzo's Pizzeria

3.9

(119 reviews)

I've been meaning to review this pizza spot for sometime now. For local good pizza this the place…read more Especially if you don't want to travel downtown. It's Jersey style as mentioned in the window but certainly is right next to NY style and glad I found something comparable. Service is great and there's a few tables to dine in. I do have to mention their delicious Stromboli. I got chicken and onions being it already comes with cheese, I added two toppings. Soooo tasty it's worth a try, not to mention filling and good for two or three people.

4.5/5. A very nice hole-in-the-wall vibe to the place that gives South Savannah a great pizza…read morechoice. The wings were a bit on the small side but had a great char to them. The Tomato Basil Pizza was delicious and with a side of marinara sauce for the crust. The crust seemed appropriate for Jersey style like they advertise as the crust was thin and on the crispy side. I did order online which said ready in 45 minutes but by the time I picked up, I think the order was ready a good little bit before that time so wasn't hot hot by the time I got home 10 mins away. Will most likely be back to try more options.

Papa Murphy's

3.9

(15 reviews)

First time at this place. This is a "to go" pizza place where after ordering and having the pizza…read morecreated, you take it home and cook it. I ordered the pan, with half of the pizza a meat lovers with red sauce, and the other half veggies with a white sauce. A generous amount of ingredients went on the pizza, and bake time was 15 minutes. The pizza was delicious, and the price for a large pizza and salad was about eighteen dollars. I will definitely be back.

Well, this was a bit of a surprise. We had a hankering for pizza and saw the reviews about this…read moreplace. For those of you who don't know, you walk in, order the pizza you want, watch them put the pizza together, and then give it to you to take home to cook in your own oven. It's a somewhat novel approach and the quality was good. Give it a try.

The Brothers Pizza & Grill

4.1

(67 reviews)

Green Fire Pizza & Sports Bar

3.9

(275 reviews)

Vincenzo's Pizzeria

4.2

(79 reviews)

Fast and delicious Italian food, with lots of variety to choose from. Pizzas are great with lots of…read morechoices. Top notch service and great prices.

Hit or miss, I guess they sometimes miss. My wife and I just got 2 large pizzas here and they were…read moreover cooked and super dry, like hurt my gums dry. Last time we got pizza is was really good but this time, if I wasn't super hungry I probably would have thrown it away. I did call to tell them to let them know thinking there might be a temp issue or something with the oven and I didn't get an apology or anything, just "ok I'll tell the owner" click. Guess it's back to ordering from your pie in sandfly.

That's Italian Pizza & Pasta Hinesville GA

3.2

(166 reviews)