I ordered a pepperoni pizza and Philly cheese steak sub. The sub was one of the best I ever had. Highly recommend it.

Ordered online and they wanted online payment that required an account setup with way too much personal info + tip. They want a tip after going through all that work? So rather than join the club, I called the East Lake store. Only it wasn't the store, it's a foreign call center and I was immediately barraged with sales offers. Do you know what it's like to know exactly what you want only to have someone try to push something else on you, plus add-ons? Way too sales-y. The worst part was my inability to understand the fast talking non-English speaker and the call was way too long and frustrating. They said it would be ready in 10-15 minutes - so I got up there immediately (it's a 15 minute drive). But I then had to wait 10 minutes more after arrival to get the order. Of course they wanted a tip again. No tip, and not returning to Papa Johns. Who ends all this stress and hassle just to get a pizza? I'm going back to Country Inn Pizza in Oldsmar. It's easy - I call them locally, talk to the actual store, no sales pitch, no clubs with personal info exposed, and I go pick it up, always smooth. read more

My pizza tasted fresh and delicious. Liked the tomato sauce and the pineapple topping I requested. I especially liked the well baked crust; it was crunchy even though it wasn't thin crust. They followed my instructions exactly and gave me a pie light on the cheese, with an appropriate amount of pineapple topping. I walked into the store at lunchtime on a Monday and my pie was ready for takeout in 10 minutes. read more

Papa Johns Pizza - Pineapple added to 10" pizza, light on the cheese - Pizza Near Me - Palm Harbor, Florida

We ordered a large works pizza. After delivery cost it was close to $30! We would been better off getting a frozen one or two from Walmart! Very little sauce that was not spread to the edge lacking about an inch or more of just crust! Toppings were far and few between. Pappy John's pizza at our home town in Indiana is so much better! This was very disappointing. read more

This Papa Johns offered new applicants to my apartments a discount on pizzas as well as deals to once in a while to everyone who lived in my apartments in Palm Harbor. They are active in trying to take care of Palm Harbor residence. The location is eay to find and very safe. Oh yeah the pizza is good as well and the staff are friendly. read more

Well it's Papa John's, so you should know what to expect. We got their jack-o-lantern shaped pizza for Halloween, because we're suckers. We ordered carry out, and it unfortunately took longer than expected. The other issue we had was that since it was a special pizza, it wasn't sliced. It was supposed to come with a pizza cutter, but we didn't get one. Maybe they were out? It was fine, since we have a pizza cutter at home. Unfortunately it was kind of frustrating, especially when our hungry family was ready to rip into that pizza. read more

Papa Johns Pizza - Special jack-o-latern Halloween pizza - Pizza Near Me - Palm Harbor, Florida

management is terrible lost order. didnt try to fix just gave me customer service in India told me the order confirmation number was as worthless ? said I could file alll the complaints I want too? I called India two hours later finally got money back ! Never ever ever order anything from here imagine the health violations that must be happening here if they treat paid customers like that also it was the general manager too that said all this occurred 12/16/23 at 545-6 pm read more

Papa Johns Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Palm Harbor, Florida

First time ordering from this Papa John's and I am well pleased. Ordered a large cheese with sausage and pepperoni. Sauce was a little spicy...will ask to go light on the sauce next time. But overall good pizza. Delivery was nice and friendly. Will order from them again. read more

Papa Johns Pizza - Cheese, pepperoni and sausage. - Pizza Near Me - Palm Harbor, Florida

I just ordered from this Papa John's tonight. I use the mobile app like I usually do. It took $50.01 from my account for three pizzas but they did not receive my order. I'm not in a position to charge my account again. The manager Collin wasn't able to help me in anyway. I expressed the Need to feed my children tonight. He agreed that the money was taken out of my account. He saw with his own eyes. I told him I'm trying to feed three children and I don't have the means to get recharged to my card. He didn't even offer to give me one pizza as compensation, so the kids could have something to eat. Horrible customer service. We will never order from here again. I'll be letting my family and friends know not to order from this Papa John's. So disappointed in the lack of customer service!!!!!!!! read more

I'm commenting on this post because everything at Papa Johns could be made better My wife and I went to Papa John's for the first time anxious to try the new pizza bowls and a papadi, just to start we would never go back , the veggie bowl was not hot and was very greasy not quite sure how they made a veggie bowl greasy , but they did. I asked if the papadia looked like the picture online and I was told by a very rude worker no. so I opted for a small cheese pie. The pie was so small I would never get another one spending $11 on a cheese pie that has almost no sauce. it seem no bigger than two slices of a regular pie which I can get anywhere for five bucks or so. so for anyone reading this, I recommendations and make it better on your own because they don't know what they're doing. read more

I worked for PJ Foodservice in the mid 1990's as a production team leader making pizza dough. Apparently, they never figured out why the pizza has a crunch in Louisville but not in Florida. I had a work's pizza this evening and jalapeño poppers and found the food to be outstanding. I read reviews from others regarding this particular store and found that after having received my food that the reviews that I had read were totally inaccurate. Delivery was on time and in less time than what I had been told on the phone. I used to order carry out from this store 10 years ago and I have to say that they are still making their products with fresh ingredients. read more

Received the wrong pizza and there is no remorse, no customer care or coupon to bring us back. Very poor establishment for a chain restaurant. read more

My family and I ordered $60+ worth of pizza. They forgot to put BBQ sauce on our BBQ Chicken Papadia. They also barely put any sauce on our $20 dollar specialty pizza and forgot a side of spicy garlic sauce. My 70 year old father was asked to physically grab the food upon delivery and then sign a receipt, even through the Covid scare. I don't blame the poor kid delivering - I blame the franchisee & management. Come on guys...help me add another star to one of my reviews. read more

Papa Johns Pizza - BBQ Chicken Papadia, no onion, add pineapple - they forgot the BBQ sauce - Pizza Near Me - Palm Harbor, Florida

As a person who has spent over 35 years in the restaurant industry, including pizza in NY and Florida, this was pretty hard for me to watch. Having that background and being on the other side of the kitchen door, I treat anyone in a service industry with respect, since I know the stress it brings and the behind the scenes bs. Everything from sanitation to customer service was sub par. To walk into a place that I'm giving my money to, and made to feel as if I was an inconvenience, was not good. I start observing out of curiosity as the associates make the pizzas and it's a mess. Then I watch the guy taking a phone order put the phone down, grab the dough, and start tossing a pie. No gloves, no hand washing, nothing. That's disgusting. I see another guy adjusting his hat, scratching his head, then goes back to rounding a dough. Then the workers are all talking inappropriately and loud as if no customers were even there. Now I'm no prude, I have a loud, inappropriate tone also at times, but not in front of customers, or strangers for that matter. There's a time and a place for that. I finally got my pizzas and the boxes looked small, I asked nicely, "is this a large pie?", And the person I spoke to replied in a condescending tone " this- is - a- large, The other is an exxxxtra large, this is large, other is big pie" using his hands to exaggerate his reply like I was 5 yrs old. I bit my lip, before things got ugly. The food was just ok, but what do you expect, it's Papa John's, not a 5-star pizzaria? But it was hard to eat after witnessing the process and lack of sanitation. If it wasn't for the Nifty Fifty promo I wouldn't have gone at all, and probably won't go back. read more

Will never eat this food again. Papa bowels two of them had barely anything in them. Pizza seemed like it had been sitting for hours before we picked it up. Called and spoke to the manager and he said that's the way it is. DONE NO MORE PAPA JOHN'S FOR MY HOUSE. read more

After moving to the Countryside area and deciding to order pizza, we were surprised that the "closest" location was this one on East Lake Rd, since a Google search indicated there was one closer in Dunedin. Regardless, we decided to adhere to the "wisdom" of the Papa Johns ordering site. After placing a rather pricey $65 order for two pizzas, a 2 liter of soda, and breadsticks, the waiting game began... Then the ominous "hey brahhhh, i'm lost lol" phone call. Not sure how it's possible to get lost during a 4 mile drive, especially when there are things like Waze and Google Maps to get you there. After 70 minutes, our food arrived from the sheepish delivery driver who scampered off just about as fast as he could. We brought everything inside, opened up the boxes, and the first thing we noticed? Room temperature pizza. Hooray. I was beyond upset. $65 to wait over an hour for cold pizza? Come on. So we begrudgingly ate our food, and the next day I replied to PJ's "how was everything?" e-mail with a livid response. Amazingly enough, I got a call the following day from the store manager, indicating that if we wanted to try them again, the next order would be on the house. So of course, we took them up on the offer. Guess what???? Same thing happened, almost identical to the first ordering experience from this location. Over an hour to get the pizza (we were quoted 35 minutes on the phone) and it arrived cold. Completely done at this point. The end. On to the presentation of the pizza itself, which ironically was pretty great. Too bad it didn't taste like anything other than sweet tomato sauce and doughy pizza crust. Every bite I took, I found myself wishing there was a Westshore Pizza close by. We appreciated the offer to make everything "right", but when you have the repeat experience (right down to the second driver having to call for directions...we're literally in the easiest place to find near the mall...) it's enough to make you realize it's time to look elsewhere when it comes to pizza choices. read more

Mark was such a sweet guy!! Definitely recommend him as a driver if you can get lucky! I didn't mind, but he stood back and waved and thanked me for the business and was so kind. Delicious philly cheesteak pizza. Thank you so much Mark!! read more

Papa Johns Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Palm Harbor, Florida

Ordered a large pepperoni, with garlic knots. Delivery took almost over an hour. Once we got it opened it up and this is what our pizza looked like. Luke warm too. Guess it was a tough day at PJs. read more

Papa Johns Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Palm Harbor, Florida

NY Style Pizza. Don't waste your money. For the first time, as a naive New Yorker we tried their Limited addition NY style pizza. It was not even close. Don't waste your money. It is just an original PJ pizza with a slightly thicker crust. True NY pizza is a thinner crust with a crisp bottoms and gooey top meant to be eat folded in half. I should have known better to NOT order it. Extremely disappointed. Other than that I have this Papa Johns on speed dial and order from them regularly if you are looking for typical PJ pizza. read more

We ordered pizza to be delivered last night! It was awesome!! We got the 2 lg for $25. We got the Works & The Hawaiian Supreme. They tasted just as good the next day for lunch! The delivery guy was awesome also, our new pup ran out after him & he kept him from running out in the road! Thank you for an awesome meal! read more

We ordered the Rays6 promotion tonight - when the Rays have 6 or more runs in a game, you get half off of pizzas the next day. The online ordering process was very easy. The driver was on time, actually early. The pizza was exactly as ordered and very delicious. Thank you! Go Rays!! read more

When we do pizza delivery - it's Papa John's! The delivery is always fast, and the delivery guys are pleasant. Papa John's ingredients are always fresh and hot. Love the little garlic butter dipping sauce for the crusts. read more

Papa Johns Pizza - Papa John pizza - East lake - Pizza Near Me - Palm Harbor, Florida

Late, again. Funny, because this was a discounted pizza because my last order was late. I don't know if it was three stops before me, or two, but the pizza was Luke warn to cold. Put it in the fridge, have it tomorrow, maybe. Now, off to make dinner . Not happy. Need to find great local pizza place, got one? read more

Great Papa Johns. Our pizza is always fresh and on time. They are super quick and the pizza is always delicious. I visit them a few times a month. Management is great. Staff is friendly. The place is clean and neat. I highly recommend this pizza place. Its delivery or carry out only. Very good. read more

We love Papa John's, and this location never disappoints! The pizza is always delivered hot, fresh, on time, and with a smile. Large cheese with pineapple pleaseeee! read more

Friendly and efficient Service. I (stopped in) ordered a pizza to take out and even though it was their busiest time I only had to wait a bit more than ten minutes. I'll definitely be back. The thin crust pizza was great! read more

Husband had gotten out of the hospital on Thursday and Friday he was craving a pizza. Well the closest one to us is Papa John's in Palm Harbor at the East Lake location. We ordered a medium pizza with tomatoes, mushrooms and sausage. We were charged $17.00+ and that was with AARP discount. We gave the young man a $4.00 tip when it arrived. Needless to say it was the worse pizza we have ever eaten. We only ate 1/2 a slice each. It was cold, not much sauce, tomatoes were awful and sausage was ice cold and the cardboard was like cardboard. It definitely was a terrible mistake for us to order from Papa John's we will never ever order from them again. read more

They have gone downhill very quickly. Skimpy on the sauce and cheese. Regular crust pizza is a big disgusting puffy mess. Extremely cheap on the toppings. Not sure what happened in the past six months but it's not good read more

Saw an add for cinnamon pull aparts on TV. Made a special trip just for those. They were delightful.

I do not order pizza too often, but when I do, its always Papa Johns. I placed an online order from this store a few weeks ago for a large pizza with several toppings. The pizza arrived a short time later, was hot and delicious, but was a small for the same price as the large. I am not sure what happened between my ordering and it being sent to the store, but I was not happy. I sent my concerns to the store and within 24 hours, I received a call from the store manager. I was told that he would take care of my next order. I called the store and ordered another pizza, the same as before. Once again, it came to our home in no time, and was hot and delicious. I am not sure whos fault it was that it was ordered incorrectly the first time, but what matters is the store manager who took responsibility for the error and made things right. read more

I will not return to this location. I contacted the manager in regards to a poorly made pizza I received, he replied to my online inquiry but never followed through on taking care of things. I even sent a photo to prove that the appearance of the pizza was not acceptable, and I never heard back from him. read more

Papa Johns gave me a great deal on pizzas for the rescue workers after the hurricane. The pizza was hot and fresh and everyone was thankful!

Used to be a regular Papa John's customer, ordering pizza from them probably two times per week. That was until I moved to Palm Harbor and ordered from this store. They not only didn't give me my correct order, they were rude about it and never resolved the issue. There are plenty of pizza options, this Papa Johns is no longer one of them. read more