Wow, this was a fantastic find! Pickle Pizza Cheesesteak Always bustling with happy customers, Madison Avenue Pizza delivers quality service and fantastic food, whether you sit outside or dine inside. We were so excited to the cheesesteak and it did not disappoint!! Delicious and just like Philly! The pickle pizza was a pleasant surprise on the menu and as always, pickle pizza is the best! The garlic knots look delicious, but they lack flavor, which is a bummer. Good garlic knots have garlic flavor from the first bite to the last, but this was not the case. read more

See all

A Masterclass in How Not to Welcome and Treat A Guest There are restaurants that disappoint, restaurants that offend, and then there are establishments so aggressively inhospitable that one feels less like a patron and more like an intruder who has mistakenly wandered onto private property. This pizza restaurant achieved the rare distinction of failing before the first slice, before the first menu, before even the faintest possibility of hospitality could be entertained. Having referred dozens of friends, clients and business partners to take the extra commute for the pizza I could not be more disgusted by the treatment I experienced. I arrived ready to enjoy a couple pizzas on a Friday afternoon. Instead, I was greeted by service so catastrophically poor that it rendered the food irrelevant. Whatever may or may not emerge from the oven here is beside the point; no meal can survive an atmosphere that makes leaving feel not only justified, but restorative. The welcome was not merely cold. Coldness has dignity. This was something more dispiriting: a total collapse of basic courtesy. The kind of service that announces, immediately and without ambiguity, that the customer is an inconvenience rather than a guest. In a profession built on warmth, timing, and care, this was hospitality performed as open hostility. I did not stay. I turned around and left, which may be the finest decision this restaurant inspired all evening. A great critic is often asked to separate the kitchen from the dining room, to give the food its day in court even when the service falters. But there must first be a threshold of competence, a flicker of welcome, a minimum acknowledgment that human beings have entered the premises. Here, that threshold was not crossed. It was not even visible in the distance. This place managed to strip away the joy before the first bite. That is not a service flaw. That is an achievement in reverse. I cannot recommend it. Not for dinner, not for takeout, not as a cautionary tale unless one is studying the precise moment a restaurant loses a customer forever. read more

Started with the tots tossed in the VIP sauce. Amazing! We ordered the Angry Margherita pie and it was outstanding. Food and service were spectacular. This is a fantastic spot owned by wonderful people. Advice: Don't park underneath the giant osprey nest. Trust me. read more

Madison Avenue Pizza - Angry Margherita pie - Pizza Near Me - Dunedin, Florida

See all

Was really hopeful that this was going to be as good as people said in their reviews, unfortunately not what we found. Pizza was burnt, sausage was like ground beef. Caesar salad dressing had little flavor. 14 inch pizza, 2 small salads (could have split 1 as they are pretty big), 4 cocktails with house liquor was $80. read more

See all

Ambiance is nice, pretty bar and seating area. Not a ton of tables indoors which explains why there are always people spilling out onto tables outside. James the bartender super nice, made helpful recommendations. The pie was wonderful. Best pizza we've had in Dunedin so far. Best of the Bay winners and we know why now! read more

Madison Avenue Pizza - New York supreme minus bell pepper. - Pizza Near Me - Dunedin, Florida

Enjoyed another Philly cheesesteak with tots! Service was excellent. Sat outside and our waitress was fantastic! I personal love the cheesesteaks and that they use coopers sharp. Cheesy and great! Very meaty. I'm only able to eat half and I take the other half home for the next night and heat up in the oven. Still need to try the pizza! read more

Madison Avenue Pizza - Cheesesteak with grilled onions & fries - Pizza Near Me - Dunedin, Florida

See all

Another great experience! We did another half and half with the New York Supreme (our fav) and the Best of the Bay. We also had a small Boss Hog ordered from the rest of our party. Our favorite continues to be the New York Supreme and the Old World cheese. We tried the Garlic Knots again and they are just not that great. Our server was great as always and the vibe is good! read more

Madison Avenue Pizza - 1/2 Beat of the Bay (6/10) and 1/2 New York Supreme added Banana Peppers (10/10) - Pizza Near Me - Dunedin, Florida

See all

My first time here and food was delicious. I have to say the pizza pie was amazing. Great service from when you enter to the service of the waiter, our waitress was Samantha she was very attentive and very courteous. We will definitely come back. It has a full bar, table tops seating and booths seating as well. Plenty of parking in the plaza. Great ambiance... Thank you for your service read more

Madison Avenue Pizza - Pizza pie with sausage on the entire pie and mushrooms on half of the pie.... Delicious - Pizza Near Me - Dunedin, Florida

See all

I've been trying cheesesteaks around pinellas county and I heard that this place was a must try. I loved the fun atmosphere and the bartenders were really nice. My food came out very quickly, and it was delicious! Definitely top 5 in the area. I could do without the fries though, they weren't well seasoned and were cold in the center. My only comments on the cheesesteak were that I wish the bread was seeded and was toasted a bit more. However the copper sharp cheese was melted to perfection and the meat was very tender. I will be back to try the pizza! read more

Madison Avenue Pizza - Cheesesteak - Pizza Near Me - Dunedin, Florida

Call ahead for a reservation! This place is amazing and packed! Young man at the door was super friendly- Samantha served us perfectly. The pizzas were fresh and so tasty- both the Sicilian and Weekly special of chicken parm were winners!! It's loud inside but there are tables outside as well. Glad we finally gave this place a shot! read more

See all

The pizza was absolutely delicious and perfectly well done, with the perfect amount of cheese/sauce. However, the cheesesteak was horrible. We explicitly asked for light cheese twice and it felt like extra cheese because that's all you could taste. Our pickup time was 40 minutes from when we placed it and we still waited 15 min past that, though that is not a big deal whatsoever as it's a kitchen and things happen, just expect you may need to wait a little longer depending on when you go. I also didn't realize they had SIXTEEN health code violations which is disgusting and disturbing, especially when they are consistent and don't get corrected after many inspections. I would definitely go back for the pizza, but the cleanliness needs to be addressed. read more

We have been here 3 or 4 times now and it just really is amazing! We first tried the Supreme, the 2nd we ordered half of what I wanted and half of what Ben wanted and the toppings from my side that I didn't like we asked to make sure they made it onto Ben's side. It doesn't make any sense when ordering a pizza and you want only have to have pepperoni that the other half of the unwanted can't just be put on the side that wants it. Our 3rd time I ordered the Stromboli without pepperoni and black olives. OMG, it is so good. I love love love Stromboli! The left overs warmed up just fine as well. For our latest visit earlier this year, I had a friend in town and wanted her to experience this amazing pizza. She also loved it. It was a great night of awesome food and drinks. read more

See all

This place is a perfect little gem when you're visiting Dunedin. When you walk in, you immediately see many different TV's to stay connected to your teams while enjoying the "winter". The menu is fairly straightforward but good luck making a decision. It all sounds so good. The pizzas all looked great but next time I go, I think I have to try a calzone. I ended up settling with a Philly and did not regret my decision at all. It was great. I couldn't eat the whole thing in one setting and definitely took it back to finish the next day day. The service is great. Our server, Sam, was amazing. She gave enough time to look at the menu and contemplate while also never being too far away. read more

See all

Service was great on a busy Sat night. Food was so good and I will be able to enjoy it again because the portion was so generous! We sat outside and it was fine with the oscillating fans and no bugs! Sweet! read more

Madison Avenue Pizza - Chicken Parm with ricotta cheese was amazing! - Pizza Near Me - Dunedin, Florida

Stopped in and this place once again proved it does not miss! Drinks: Tried the Apple Pie Old Fashioned and the Blackberry Margarita -- both were excellent. The margarita had a perfect balance of sweet and tart, while the old fashioned had that cozy, fall-inspired twist. Food: * Chicken Nuggies with the Five Boroughs sauce -- crispy, juicy, and that sauce is ridiculously good. * Mozz Sticks -- classic and perfectly fried with a great cheese pull. * Cheesesteak -- loaded, flavorful, and hits the spot every time. * White Pizza (added chicken on half) -- perfectly baked with great texture and flavor. Madison Avenue Pizza continues to be one of the most consistent spots around. Great drinks, great food, and always great service. read more

See all

First off, I want to talk about the aesthetics of the restaurant. Freshly renovated. It has a a classy laid back atmosphere with beautiful wall art. Kelsey was incredibly friendly & always wore a smile when we talked to her. The owner Sean was also very nice as he came to our table a few times to talk to us, and give us recommendations about what's the most popular pies. Had fun chopping it up with him! Kelsey was very attentive as our drinks never hit rock bottom & was constantly anticipating our needs. The Chik Fil A pizza was insane!!!! A one of a kind creation with everything made from scratch minus the authentic CFA sauce. The flavor was intense! Very much a Sunday craving, satisfied. Only available sporadically, btw The other pie we ordered was a Chicken Florentine on a cauliflower crust. Super clean, light & tasty. Low carb. Lower kcal. Delicious! Finally, the WINGS. Their signature sauce - Five Borough. Topped with diced garlic. Incredible. Top 3 best wing experiences I've ever had. Really!!! Overall I had such a good time visiting Madison Ave. 11/10. I absolutely recommend visiting if you're in the Pinellas / Hillsborough county areas! Signed & sealed, GTB read more

Madison Avenue Pizza - House made Five Bouroughs Sauce - wings. Top 3 wing sauces I've ever had. Juicy wings. - Pizza Near Me - Dunedin, Florida

See all

This place isn't just a pizza spot. Yes their pizza is some of the best around but they have so much more. Their wings are great. Id say top 3 wings ive ever had. The VIP sauce is awesome. Their blue cheese is home made and delicious. They bake fresh bread for their sandwiches too. Every wednesday they have 1/2 price Bourbon, 1/2 price wine, and 99cent wings. Meagan the bartender is so good at her job. She provides the best service! This place is a hidden gem. One of my favorite spots in Dunedin. read more

Ordered take out last night - been wanting to try this place for a long time . Outside very welcoming with outdoor seating and lots of diners had their dogs with them....I like that . Inside first thing I noticed was the big bar that dominated the space... very nice . Second thing I noticed there were too many empty dirty unbussed tables ....several waiters chatting with each other should have been cleaning tables....not good . Pizza was ready and waiting for me . Got it home and it was very good . I know pizza is a personal thing and to my taste the crust was a little too thick for my taste - I prefer a thinner crust . Ordered the meat lovers and it had a little spice to it ...very nice . read more

See all

6/18/25 Last night I had some of the best wings, that I ever ate, with a great sweet Thai chili sauce, they came with really good blue cheese dressing, not that bottled, or commercial stuff that a lot of places insult you taste buds with. We also ordered the Sicilian pie, this monster was saucy , cheesy , and delicious with a wonderful, pan baked, crispy crust, when I picked up a piece I could not believe how light it was for it's size, a definitely new pizza taste experience for me. Wednesday night is wing night, I'll be back with No 1 Florida cuz, for some more wings, and we want to try one of their famous cheesesteaks... read more

See all

Our friends took us to Madison Avenue Pizza on a Saturday night before a night out, and it was the perfect way to kick things off! The place was packed inside, so we grabbed a table outside. Honestly, it ended up being a great spot to enjoy the evening. I started with the Greek salad with balsamic vinaigrette (super fresh and flavorful), and my boyfriend had the buffalo wings to start. He and his friend loved them. We all split their special pepperoni pizza with chili oil, and WOW. Spicy, crispy, cheesy goodness. Definitely a standout slice! I also had a glass of red wine, which paired perfectly with everything. The two guys had the rum buckets which I wish I got a picture of them because they were so cute they kept the cups as souvenirs HA! Great food, chill atmosphere, and a fun way to start our night. Would totally go back! read more

Madison Avenue Pizza - Pepperoni special pizza - Pizza Near Me - Dunedin, Florida

Take it from someone who just moved from the NJ/Philly area....this is THE spot to go to for everything pizza, cheesesteaks, wings! The food is by far the best in town. The staff is super friendly and attentive. Cannot go wrong eating/drinking here! read more

Came in on a Wednesday night and had an amazing experience. We took our server's recommendations and got the cheesesteak, the old school pie and the .99 wing deal. Everything was great, the food, the atmosphere and the service, we didn't catch her name but she had blonde hair and was very friendly which is refreshing to come by. read more

Spoke to owners Dad, Mr. Ferraro, great guy, described the concept - Ben was the bartender, he was proficient, wings were exceptional.. It is definitely worth it, packed before 5, which is a great sign.. read more

We often enjoy dining at Madison Avenue Pizza, and this visit was no exception. We started with a small Caesar salad and their homemade meatballs with marinara sauce, then added ricotta cheese it was delicious. We also ordered the New York Supreme stromboli, which was outstanding. Everything here is consistently excellent. It's always a very busy place with a great vibe, and for good reason. Highly recommend! Cheers! read more

See all

I love that they have a specialist pizza that changes monthly! Plenty of parking in the plaza, not a super large place, but seemed okay and able to sit at bar with no wait. The pizza was crisp and the perfect ratio of sauce / cheese / dough. Service was prompt. Wings were pretty good too! Will be back to check out again! read more

Service was excellent, food was good. This place was packed on Saturday night. We went for Tampa Bay restaurant week, so it was a good deal and I've wanted to try them for a while. To be honest, it was good but not great, it's hard to go wrong with pizza tho. To be very picky, we wished that the garlic knots had more garlic. The sauce that came with them was delicious. Our pizza was ok, we wished it had the sauce that came with the garlic knots. It really didn't have any sauce, which technically I could've inferred from the menu description, so that's kinda on me. The pie was good, but it seemed like it was juuust thawed and maybe could've used about 5 more minutes. Otherwise, it is pretty cool they offer a full bar here-- that's not something I typically see at pizza places. And I think their speciality is more non-traditional pizzas, like I was eyeing their pickle pizza. Maybe that's what I should get if we come again. To top it off, our server Samantha was incredible! She was taking care of prob a total of line 30 people while we were there and kept our drinks full! read more

See all

Service was a bit slow in the beginning since there were a lot of people here. Judging by the crowd of people on a Saturday afternoon I would say that this place may have good victuals. We ordered Old-School Cheese Pie since the description says its 96-hour slow risen dough which is pretty interesting since my gf and I love sourdough bread. The flavor of the pizza was really good but a good pizza should make it easy for you to eat the whole pie without leaving the crust on your plate. In this case, the crust was lacking flavor. I was really impressed with the rise it has and how crispy it was. It really was like a sourdough. But I wish they had garlic butter on the crust or a side of marinara sauce that came with the pizza so that you have a choice to eat it with it. Btw, Samantha was our server, she was honestly delightful to have. read more

I've been coming here for years. Came in today with my 4 month old. The owners father told me I could sit outside only. It's 100 degrees mind you. There was a table open and no one else waiting and he refused to seat us since it was for 5 people. I've had their pizza many times and it was good. But honestly that's a no for me. You want me to sit outside with a baby when we could be in and out before a party of 5 even arrives?!? read more

I am from the NYC metro area, so I'm always looking to find NYC pizza near me here in Florida. I know of a couple places here, but most places fall short. I will say Madison Ave Pizza has a great following. The place was busy. We sat at an indoor table & the service was very good. Our order was for a pizza topped with cupping pepperoni. The first thing we noted was that the pizza was a bit burnt, & the underside was very hard & stiff because of that. Some of the bites we took tasted like char. Additionally the pizza was exceptionally salty. It's now been 5 hours since we ate, & we both keep taking drinks to try to quell the lingering salt taste. The sauce on this pizza was pretty decent though. And as mentioned the service was very good. So it was all in all a mixed experience. read more

Madison Avenue Pizza - Inside - Pizza Near Me - Dunedin, Florida

See all

After seeing Maddison Pizza blow up on social media and catching Dave Portnoy's review, I had to check it out for myself and I'm glad I did. I've been twice now, and each visit has been consistently solid. We started with the mozzarella sticks, which were crispy on the outside and perfectly gooey inside. As for the pizza, we've tried the classic pepperoni as well as a half pepperoni/half pepperoni with sausage combo. Both were excellent, great crust, flavorful sauce, and just the right amount of grease (in a good way). The place has been busy both times, but the service hasn't missed a beat, friendly, fast, and on top of things. It's clear they've got a good system going. I've heard great things about their cheesesteak, so that's next on my list. Maddison Pizza definitely lives up to the hype and worth the visit whether you're local or making a special trip. read more

See all

Our server was phenomenal! As was the food! It was my first time visiting and we sat on the patio. The mozzarella sticks are breaded and cut in house. All of our pizzas were amazing! I asked my server to surprise me between 3 different pizzas. She did not disappoint. The buffalo chicken pizza had a great spice and great flavor. I would absolutely be back next time I'm in town. read more

See all

Even though I love Delco cheesesteaks Madison Avenue is better. I guess they're more meatier and juicier and you cannot get better bread. Their pizzas are excellent also read more

Over priced and disrespectful staff Gave this place multiple chances and if they don't mess you're pizza up you will wait 45 minutes. Staff is always super stressed and disrespectful to customers acting like they are better than you when in reality they just over charge everyone and laugh behind your back. Id avoid coming here if you want to get treated with dignity read more

We actually hired the Madison Avenue Pizza team to come cater a pre-wedding gathering at our house for 80 people. We are so grateful to Sean and his team for working so hard to make our pre-wedding festivities so special, TASTY and fun!! From homemade meatballs, salads, a huge display of charcuterie with a wide variety of meats, cheese and dips, to non-stop, unlimited pizza made in the ovens built into a fire truck they brought on site, the food was just so delicious. Topping things off, they also brought a cannoli bar with so many fun toppings, piping them fresh right on the spot - it was such a hit!!!! Our family and friends RAVED both about the food and the team's service. We have to agree - they did an amazing job!!!!!! They set up, they cleaned up, they took out the garbage. And the staff were just the nicest people ever!!!! We are thrilled that we had the opportunity to work with Madison Avenue Pizza and we can't wait to come visit the restaurant in Dunedin when we have some time to relax. :) We are now looking for opportunities to host another party just so we can have them back!!!! read more

See all

I recently got to try the giant 32" pizza from here while at one of our volunteer projects, and wow--it was such a treat! Even after sitting a little while before we dug in, the pizza was still super tasty. My personal favorite was the Margherita--the tomatoes tasted so fresh and had a unique seasoning that really stood out. I'll definitely be back, though probably for a more "normal" size pizza next time, haha! read more

Madison Avenue Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Dunedin, Florida

See all

Very Good Stromboli! Good antipasto salad... meat could be a cut up a bit more. Very friendly delivery driver. read more

I waited to write this review in order to give them a few more chances. I live close by and have been going to Madison ave since they opened and were just a small establishment, before they expanded and got all hyped up. Let me start with they were all the hype! However, now it seems quality has gone down and prices are through the roof. This last experience (and probably our last for a long time), we ordered their krab rangoon pizza, which we have had before. The pizza was lacking all the fixings it used to. The creamy Rangoon filling topping, was so sparse that the pizza was dry. There were very few pieces of krab scattered on the pie as well. It's just disappointing at the price point of $42.00. I'm willing to pay $42 (which is insane in itself) if it provides the right amount of toppings. So for that reason, I'm out. I gave 3 stars for timing was good and the pizza was still edible. read more

Wide variety of menu items. I had the arugula salad, garlic knots, wings, and pizza. Salad was great I put too much dressing though whoops. The wings are well worth the travel to this side of the bridge. The pizza was a bit on the floppy side, sauce was good and cheese was good. We had a nice waitress and she was super helpful. The decor is electric. One half is black booths the other is green high tops with a pretty gold accent on it... it was too high for the family so we tried to cram into a booth. read more

See all

Fast and friendly service every single time for pick up orders! The food is also consistently deliciou, we would highly recommend for the cheese steaks, wings, and the pizza! read more

Pizza was burned but the flavor was decent. I been there a few times. It's usually good but they were busy , no worries but the food suffered. Will go again. I'll just check my order b4 leaving next time. No hate. read more