The pizza was delicious! We had the garlic chicken pizza. We will be back! It was a very pleasant experience!

I generally enjoy the atmosphere and the food quality is high. Unfortunately the service sets the number back from 4 to 2-we sat in the bar area and the bartender was absent for sometime then upon returning chatted rather than realize and provide drinks to the recent arrivals...then left again. My 8th time and the first 6 experiences were much better.... The last two all relate to service in the bar read more

I don't like the pizza crust. Just that kind of style. Too thin for me. I went with quite a few family members who spoke about it being a great place. They were quite happy with what they ate. I was not. read more

Great pizza and great service! Highly recommended!!! Pizza had a good amount of toppings and didn't take long at all.

Good food. Reasonable prices. Great service! Wonderful pizza and salads. Parking is sometimes tight when they are busy. read more

Another great lunch! The Mandarin salad and personal size sausage pizza for the lunch special was wonderful as always! And the staff is always exceptional! read more

lil taste of italy in milan!!!! service was 5 stars.... and the pizza chef kisses... best ever if you havent tried you are missing out best pizza in q.c. and da balded baker cooked da hell out of our pizzas read more

My wife loves it. If you get the right thing it's pretty good. It's different than a lot of wood-fired pizza that I've had. One of the better options in the QC area if you aren't a fan of QC pizza. read more

Stopped here for lunch while in town based on a recommendation and really enjoyed the lunch. The restaurant was very clean and modern with nice decor (see pictures), the workers were all very friendly and the place was quite lively. I ordered the grilled chicken pizza (see picture) and really liked the seasoning, crust and overall flavor. Unfortunately, I didn't save room for gelato after the pizza...so will save that for the next visit. Food: 4 Atmosphere: 4 Value: 4 Service: 4 If you found this review helpful, please click to show your support. read more

See all

They were packed when we got there, so we had to wait for a table, but it was totally worth the wait. They had so many delicious options to choose from that it was a little overwhelming. I got the Greek pizza, and it was SO flavorful. I loved all the fresh basil. My son enjoyed the gluten free pizza and even got to have gluten free cheesecake, an unusual bonus, which he LOVED. We would definitely return. read more

Pagalo's - Delicious Greek pizza. Mmmmmmm! - Pizza Near Me - Milan, Illinois

Brick oven pizza, mozzarella sticks, gelato, what else could you ask for? 2 adults, 2 kids and a baby. It was 4pm on a Saturday. Is this place a secret? There was one other table when we arrived, but hey stared to get busy as we departed. Mollie was our server, super nice! Everything was just so smooth. Drinks, refills, food came out PIPING hot, she cleared our plates for dessert. This pizza is the best pizza I have ever had. Crispy crust, buttery around the outside. None of that sourdough taste. The sauce was perfect, the cheese was solid, but gooey. Let's talk gelato. I had raspberry, with real seeds and all. Creamy and icy. The other flavors at our table were banana, cookies and cream and a vanilla bean. Not just vanilla, you could see the flecks of bean in the gelato. Bathroom as clean, basic like gramma's house. The dining area is so warm and cozy. Very inviting. They have a bar and seating in the bar area as well. This place is a gem! I'm so glad we found it! read more

See all

The margarita pizza was delicious, not overloaded with topping and it tasted great. The waitress was nice and made us comfortable. The restaurant also has a nice modern look mixed with some classic look read more

Food is very good. They great soup and pizza. The service is very friendly. You have a choice of ambience. You sit in a dinning area or a bar. Either one is great read more

Service was great but my pesto pizza was even better. Definitely recommend. Restaurant closes earlier than the bar - so be mindful of the hours. read more

Have dined there a few times, my family really likes the sausage pizza. It is cooked in a wood fire oven. They have many other choices on the dinner menu. They are also busy at lunch having homemade soups and sandwiches. They're salads also are enjoyed by many. i believe any group or individual would be able to find a satisfying lunch or dinner. additionally they have a bar in front and attached to the business. The bar has a nice selection of liquor and beers The barb-is very nice you can order food from the restaurant and they will bring it to you in the bar. i highly recommended Pagalos . its a hidden Gem. read more

The restaurant was not busy for a Friday evening. The staff was professional and efficiently worked our large party. Although this place was recommend for its pizza.... the pizza was not anything unique or amazing. I would not recommend this place if you are looking pizza. read more

Truly disappointed. Seeing the reviews I thought it would be great & how cute the outside building was... no. Inside was very Italian home like, that was nice but 1 out of the 4 staff members I saw wore a mask. 3 were cooks & didn't wear one. No social distance seating I ordered a sausage pizza & I think I was overall disgusted & disappointed that no one wore a mask or wore gloves & I lost my appetite read more

This little gem has AMAZING wood fire GLUTEN free pizza! I always get their margarita pizza...but there are sooo many options!

Efficient table service in a casual setting. The pizza is really good with a crispy and chewy balance to the crust and the Ingredients are fresh with a good selection from which to choose read more

Great prices on Thursday and the wait staff is excellent Food is good and the special are always good

Small family restaurant with local feel. Wood fired pizza. Convenient to Palmer Chiropractic Clinic in Moline

Checked this local place out on Friday night Since we were in town for a baseball tournament. The restaurant lounge area were very clean and the service was also acceptable. It's brick oven pizza so it has a nice flavor was a toasted crust. Portions we're very generous even with the appetizers. This isn't the best pizza I've ever had but it really is pretty good. It's not going to break your bank and it's a welcome addition to the small little town. I would definitely go back here if I'm in town for a baseball tournament again. read more

Pagalo's - Chicken Nuggets - Pizza Near Me - Milan, Illinois

See all

I drive by this place all the time, on my way into Rock Island, and have always wanted to try it. Today we had the opportunity to stop, and what a fantastic hidden gem! A great assortment of pizza combinations, I had the Sicilian plus mushrooms, and my son had the Grilled Chicken. Both were very tasteful, the crust was crunchy, and tasted good, the toppings seemed to be fresh and quality. Their menu for salads was also impressive. something that would seem to please multiple palettes. Would definitely suggest to anyone looking to get out of the cities, for something rather unique. Most certainly a well kept secret! read more

You can tell they are serious about their pizza as soon as you walk in and see the pizza oven. I had the Hawaiian​ pizza and so good. As a transplanted New Yorker, I can say this pizza is just as good as any I've had back home ...and dare I say, any that I've had in Chicago! read more

Pagalo's - Hawaiin Pizza at Pagalo's - Pizza Near Me - Milan, Illinois

Possibly the best pizza in the Quad cities. Woodfired oven, salad pizza base, good toppings, the pizza is top notch.

Absolutely delicious food & great atmosphere! We had the cashew chicken pizza that was fabulous. The Gelato is also worth the splurge. Kara provided the best service! read more

Fast service, nice selection of great food at a good value all in a nice clean atmosphere

The food at Pagalo's is good and reasonably priced and the service is fast and friendly. We went in with 4 people around 8 pm on a Sunday. We were seated immediately. They have a small but good selection of beers, including local options. I don't recall the exact brewery but we tried various styles - IPA, blonde, pale ale. All were good. Three of us ordered salads. We got half sizes, which are huge. Can't imagine the size of a whole order. I got the garden, which had romaine lettuce and a good variety of veggies. I ordered the house chipotle ranch dressing. I wasn't too impressed. It didn't have much flavor. Someone else got the Caesar and said it was pretty good. We order 3 medium pizzas - Hawaiian, a Spinach, and an Italian Stallion (a meat lovers pizza). The medium pies are 12" so we had a lot of food and ended up taking half of it to our hotel. The crust was fairly thin and chewy, which was good. Their tomato sauce was kind of bland to my taste, maybe needed some salt or garlic. The spinach was most bland and I hit it with lots of crushed pepper. The Hawaiian was the typical salty sweet. The Stallion was the best. The sausage had a decent amount of seasoning. Our waitress was very good. She was friendly and attentive but she pretty much left us alone once we had our food. I didn't pay the bill but prices seemed reasonable for all the food we got. All in all, I enjoyed our meal at Pagalo's. read more

I came to Pagalo's a couple of weeks ago for restaurant week and it was entirely forgettable. The service was as mediocre as the food. We sat near the open kitchen where employees complained about their lives and terrible coworkers at full volume. The restaurant week deal sounded pretty good: $18 for salad, pizza, and gelato. However, they were out of some of the stuff we wanted and, despite the fact that 'gelato' is part of the name of their restaurant, only two flavors were available. My caprese salad was really good, though, and probably the best part of my meal. The crust of the pizza was way softer and thicker than typical wood-fired pizza -- in a bad way. The toppings, while not bad, were very mediocre. With the vast amount of competition they have in the Quad Cities, I'm surprised that Pagalo's has stayed open for so many years. The next time I'm hungry for pizza, it will fall dead last on an incredibly long list. read more

The pizzas are great and we love the service and we love the location. Only issue we have is the price of the food ii's a little pricey but other than that the restaurant is great. read more

This is one of our favorite lunch spots! I have heard they are very good spaghetti for supper too which is on special two nights a week! We love the mandarin orange salad and the wood fire pizza. They have lunch specials that includes soup and a salad, personal pizza & salad or pizza and soup for $6.99!! Their food is just plain good... We have had excellent waitresses and they are fast and friendly! read more

Pagalo's - Pizza Near Me - Milan, Illinois

Best brick fired oven pepperoni I have ever had. Service was exceptional and atmosphere as great.. will dine here often while here for a year... read more

We absolutely love this place! Amazing pizza, great prices and it's normal! I've seen reviews people complaining about lack of masks and social distancing, that's the reason we picked to go there the first night! We are three years into this Covid crap and I crave normalcy and that's why we will continue to come here for our Saturday night date nights! Plus the pizza choices are wide! So far we've tried the Buffalo Chicken and Parker's Pie and both were perfect! We've never are such an amazing Buffalo chicken pizza before! read more

We are from out of town but seen the reviews so we decided to try the place . I had a pizza with lots of meat and onions and peppers... so thats just me . My wife had the barbecue pizza . We both loved our pizza . Actually better than our at home local favorites...wish we lived closer. O and the service was great/ as was the atmosphere. read more

There are times where a bad experience can be attributed to bad management, or an unmotivated employee. This was not one of those times. I received my order, it was missing a whole half a sandwich, and a soup. Both the employee and the manager tried to argue with me, stating that you get a soup or a salad with the lunch combo, not both, when we paid the $2 extra for the salad as well. I was extremely dissatisfied with the way this was handled. Not at all professional. read more

Great food,cold beer and good service Have been coming here for the last few years The wood fire pizza is some of the best read more

Pagalo's - Pizza Near Me - Milan, Illinois

I just called to order a pizza, Kelsey who answered the phone has the worst customer service. Pizza is great, customer service is awful.

Stopped here on way through town and glad we did. Pizza was excellent with crispy crust and lots of toppings. Ordered a medium and was plenty for two (actually too much). Service was friendly. I would recommend this to others and will stop by again when we come through again. read more

We really enjoyed our dinner here! We ordered 3 small pizzas so that we could try a variety. We ordered the garlic chicken pizza, the Sicilian, and the Thai chicken pizza. We enjoyed them all! The Thai chicken was pretty spicy (just like the menu said). I could only eat one piece but my husband loved it. The garlic chicken was also delightfully full of garlic. The Sicilian was chocked full of meat and was really delicious. We also ordered the toasted ravioli and loved them. This is unique pizza for the Quad Cities and it's done very well. We will be back! read more

Best pizza around highly recommended they also serve specials on a weekly basis. There Red Velvet cake is so delish