Update: they use pizza boxes now! Pizza is always fresh and still impressed by it years later. read more

I was there a couple years ago and it was excellent QC style pizza very similar to Harris read more

Long time Benny's eater, first time reviewer. Been coming here since I was a lad. Best pizza in the Quad Cities. Benny's will tuck you in at night and love you tenderly in the morning. Classic QC style. Great stop before Bingo nights on Wednesdays at the Milan community center. Benny's haters can refer to the attached image read more

Benny's Pizza - a man holding a pizza box - Pizza Near Me - Milan, Illinois

Excellent pizza! The pizza here is always consistent and runs heavy on cheese which makes it even better. Always seem to be fully staffed and orders have always been correct. I highly recommend Bennys! read more

Heard they had cauliflower crust available, so I had to try it. It taste like a thin chewy crust. Does not taste like cauliflower, which is a good thing. I'll be back for many more. read more

Benny's Pizza - BLT on a cauliflower crust. - Pizza Near Me - Milan, Illinois

When you have bennys pizza there is no way that you will forget the taste that is there pizza when me and when family order takeout we usually have time fighting on who gets the the corner pieces it's usually me!! The best part about the whole experience is the crust there's nothing like it definitely recommend read more

I always get gluten free pizza from here. It is great. Doesn't taste like a piece of cardboard. We also got regular crust pizza for everyone else. All said it was very tasty and wanted to know where we got it from. The high school girls that work there are friendly and pleasant. read more

A great pizza place! One I have to come and get every time I am in Quad Cities. Their calzones are just as good. My favorite is the sausage and mushroom. Their sauce is excellent. I love their pizza slices "long ways," too. Going downstairs into their basement restaurant is pretty neat too! Definitely recommend it. Worth the price! read more

Definitely not a good experience on several levels. The first is the website menu.. There were names of specialty pizzas with no description, available toppings not listed nor the price for each. Next, after ordering inhouse for carry out, we asked for a "party cut". Needless to say that didn't happen. Now for the pizza itself...... Not good. Every bite was terribly greasy and I like greasy pizza; but this was way too much!! I suspect it was the cheese which was abundant!! This is just a personal preference , but I prefer my pepperoni on top of the cheese as a last layer to get it a little crispy. Evidently they don't make Benny's in that fashion, so just another disappointment. Finally, the nail in the coffin, $30 for a 16 inch. I didn't mind the $30 charge at Frank's for excellent pizza; but this wasn't even good. We went there once before 2 yeas ago but couldn't remember why we never went back....NOW I remember!!! read more

One of my favorite pizza places in the Quad Cities. The atmosphere is relaxed and comfortable for dining in and the service is usually good. If I don't feel like dining in, I'll order a pizza for pickup. A large bankers is my go to order and although it is more expensive than some places it is worth it in my opinion. It is large enough that you'll have leftovers even with a family of three or four and the pizza is very good the next day, reheated or cold! read more

After seeing some positive buzz, I decided to check out Benny's pizza. My first impression was that the parking lot (a modest one) was full and vehicles were parked on the frontage road about a half block each direction. The actual restaurant turned out to be the basement of the building and the total for my pizza was a small amount more than I was told over the phone, though for whatever reason this did not surprise me. The actual pizza had good tasting and fresh toppings though i found the sauce to kind of resemble tomato soup. The appearence of the pizza was good though the crust was relatively tough, though not as much as Fields of pizza. Overall this did not meet expectations though was in no way bad or overpriced. read more

Its the best pizza in town and I'll always come back for more our daughter and her softball team have their parties there every once in awhile the people that work there are very friendly and great the food is like I said absolutely excellent it's in a great location couldn't ask for better Pizza nothing really beats Benny's Pizza and I'm glad they're back read more

We found Bennie's about nine months ago, and we've found it to be pretty much the best pizza in the quad cities. The only thing close to it my own home made , and then Godfathers and then HArris. We like the bankers special, its more than we like to spend , but when they get it right 6 times in a row , we won't bark about an extra three bucks. Seems like everyone is always moving in there, doing stuff, and thats good to see, if you want to loaf around go find a back room. thanks to those who make our visit to Bennies a good one, time after time. read more

Just brought one home and gotta say that's some damn fine pizza. Can't wait to go back!

Outstanding pizza. They pull the dough right when you are ordering your pizza. The also are very generous with toppings. New favorite place. Prices are also very reasonable. read more

I love Benny's! Great Quad City Pizza! Just as good as the others! Fun kids that work there!

Great food. Enjoy it everytime. I love this place it has the best food and I love to go here read more