Cancel

    Search

    P&J Roofing

    5.0 (1 review)
    Closed 7:00 am - 7:00 pm

    Get a quote

    You can now request a quote from this business directly from Yelp

    Services - P&J Roofing

    Gutter cleaning

    P&J Roofing Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - P&J Roofing

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    3 years ago

    A pleasure to work with. Efficient, honest and reliable. Helped us out when we needed quick repairs. Bravo!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - P&J Roofing

    You might also consider

    MCAS Roofing & Contracting

    MCAS Roofing & Contracting

    4.2
    (17 reviews)

    NEW STEEPLE EXTERIOR MCAS did a terrific job replacing the…read moreexterior of the steeple on our church. We are so pleased with their solution and it was a pleasure working with them. We don't know of any other company in the Westchester area that has the experience needed to perform this kind of work. The steeple, which dates from the original construction of the church in the 1970s, is made of plywood. The exterior had been coated with a thick, rubberized, highly water-resistant paint. Because it was only paint protecting the plywood from the elements, it required a new paint job every 6 or 7 years. And because the steeple is so high and hard to access, any painting had required either building scaffolding or renting a bucket truck. A rather expensive bit of upkeep. MCAS helped us analyze other easier-to-maintain options--either traditional shingles or metal sheathing. We decided on metal sheathing because 1) it would have a cleaner look and be more attractive, and 2) it would last longer. Yes, the installation would cost more, but long-term it would be a simpler and more elegant solution. MCAS gave us a great price on the install--around 20k. And despite equipment hassles (the rented bucket truck kept breaking down), they got the work done in 10 days. There was only one actual installer who was an expert with aluminum sheeting. He approached the work as an artist and did a beautiful, impeccable job. On top of that, he was a super-nice guy. Our new steeple should last for 50 years or more and continues to be a bright spot in the Tarrytown community. Michael Casolaro, the owner of MCAS, has a documented history of high-quality roofing work (customized copper gutters to standard reshingling--the gamut) and we are so glad we went with him on this project. P.S. MCAS also reshingled our roof at the same time they resurfaced our steeple, and they did an excellent job with that as well. P.P.S. Please note, this job was done in spring, 2019. We then lived in Westchester, NY, but have since moved.

    I have worked in construction my whole life. MCAS did a nice job in a timely and efficient manner…read more It came down to two comparable bids but I chose MCAS because it's a family run business and I could call Mike, the owner of the company, any time and he would answer. You also have to admire a roofer who breaks off and starts his own company. I have a soft spot for those with an entrepreneurial spirit, improving the US economy. Justine was also exceedingly pleasant to deal with. Responsiveness ranks as my top priority when dealing with large home projects and Justine get full marks, always getting back to me within minutes. They didn't try upsell me or talk me into any extras, they did exactly what I asked for in a quality manner and at a competative price. The crew was friendly and fast. I only had to do some minor yard clean up after they left, which I was happy to do considering the scope of their work. Mike pays them a good wage and that makes a difference in both attitude and craftsmanship. However, the high wage can backfire on the homeowner if additional work is involved. Inquire beforehand about their additional work rates. When I was surprised with the price of the additional work (they had to replace a rotted section of the roof), Mike was happy to explain the math behind the numbers and worked with me get the price down to an amount that I felt comfortable with. Be warned: NYS has very expensive insurance and companies like MCAS have large overhead costs to cover that are added into the price of additional work, so if you think they may uncover a lot of additional work, consider doing it yourself if you have the time. Regardless, Mike was pleasant and willing to work with me. Moreover, they were honest in the scope of additional work performed and did not magically find more or extrapolate. All this is something you can only get from a successful, family run business. A corporate company would never do that. I recommend MCAS. They get full marks on everything.

    Roof-A-Roo

    Roof-A-Roo

    1.0
    (1 review)

    When I called on 7/1, the agent was super stoked to talk to me and was eager to send a guy out. He…read moreknew the objective fix gutters or install a new system, as well give a quote for a shed roof. Mike called me on 7/11. In a very awkward way he was making sure I was "only" looking for gutters. I asked if that was a problem. He told me that they were a roofing company, I said that did gutters and the guy I spoke with on 7/1 didn't seem to think it would be an issue. After telling me he shouldn't show because he damaged his reputation, but requested he did as I took off work to meet with him. He showed. Mike was nice he was thorough. When asked about the roof, said he would clean and repair the gutters for free if I commit to a roofing project. I told him I didn't need anything fancy on the shed. He told me all about metal roofs. I said I wanted the less expensive option. Mike was pretty confident this was the cheapest option. His quote came in quadruple every other quote. When I asked if he would consider other options besides metal to get a better comparison, Mike told me he doesn't like working with anything but. Last time I checked, I'm the customer - so I think we should work with what I want and in the price range I want. As a hail Mary, he tried to kick me a bargain quote to do both new gutters and a roof, both came in double to triple compared to other companies. It must be so expensive to pay for their silly wrapped vehicle and polos that looked stained because of all the graphics.

    From the owner: Premium Roofing Serviceread more

    P&J Roofing - roofing - Updated August 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...