Free estimate appointment was done immediately however, there was no follow up. Price is a little…read morespeed compared to other roof installers. The catalog shows quality.

Never heard back from an internet, phone call and text request for an estimate. I did request a…read morequote for siding but chose not to use them, so I am curious if that's what the lack of follow up is for when asking for gutters or a roof estimate.

Hudson Valley Roofers did an excellent job! Randy and his crew were professional and efficient!…read moreThis crew works HARD!!! I would recommend them to everyone...Randy was on top of everything and clean up was great!

UPDATE: If I could give more than five stars, I would! Randy has gone above and beyond, coming out…read moreon a Saturday morning to assess a new minor problem, realizing it was a quick fix, and taking care of it immediately, efficiently, and without concern. If you're looking for a reliable company that takes pride in its work, look no further. ORIGINAL REVIEW: Nobody ever wants to have to deal with a roof leak, but if you find yourself in the same position I was, do yourself a favor and call Randy with Hudson Valley Roofers. He was quick and responsive, answered all our questions and came back on more than one occasion when storms knocked our tarping off the roof and threatened to increase our water damage. Once we scheduled, the work was done in less than a day and done well - we've had no problems since. Highly recommend!

In April I was looking for an estimate for both siding and gutters. L&G was reasonable on the…read moresiding however their gutter cost was absurd compared to 5 other reputable competitors. I really wanted to use L&G so I questioned the gutter cost that was near double the lowest price point, as well I asked why we had to remove my current wood panels to install the siding when 5 other contractors felt it was better to install over the wood. Basically I was told my house would not look right and that the gutters were the lowest without them losing money. I reconnected with the other contractors and questioned the removal of the wood as I was curious if they were trying to save me money to win the bid and if that was actually best for my home. All 5 agreed it was actually better to install over. Fast forward, I went with a contractor who did not do gutters - so I waited to call gutter professionals when the siding was done. I collected 4 estimates as well as some to roof a barn shed. Ironically all these quotes were half of L&G's gutter quote which is what I found with the other siding contractors. One contractors who didn't do roofs suggested I reconnect with L&G. I did. I explained why I didn't use them and told them I was looking for the cheapest solution (product) to roof the shed. I asked if they would consider coming out for a fair estimate without any fluff or unnecessary add ons. The shed is nothing that need a spectacular metal roof and precision shingling. L&G declined coming out to provide a fair estimate and related they would not be the cheapest.

I would highly recommend this company. They did an excellent job very professional. The workers…read morewere excellent. Knew exactly do. And clean up afterwards left everything in perfect order. all our neighs were very impressed with the work they were doing. Highly recommended. It was well worth the price of the work.

I first used Brodie's Roofing about 15 years ago when, on a cold 20-degree day in February, my son…read morenoticed the roof leaking in his room. I remembered this company as it advertised in our local West Milford newspaper. I called him about 11 a.m., and he was there with 2 employees within an hour. Again, it was a Saturday in February! A 4' X 4' section of the roof was replaced within 2 hours. He gave me an estimate for the replacement of the entire roof and said it did not have to be done immediately - that was a relief, and his honesty struck me. The roof lasted another 5+ years and never leaked. When it was due to be replaced, I called back. As I live on a major road, his response was that he had been watching the roof for years and concurred it was time to replace it. I knew the previous estimate was obviously no longer valid as it was 5 years old. I requested a new estimate and was shocked to see that he didn't want to simply go over the roof with a new layer but recommended the removal of the old roof - at substantially more effort. I trusted this man so much that I never even sought another estimate. The job was performed by his employees - 3 men and a woman! The work and clean-up were meticulous. The roof is now 10+ years old and has never given me a problem. He promised an annual roof & gutter cleaning and said it would be unannounced. He would just show up and do it. I was shocked to say the least. True to his word, every year - and sometimes twice a year! - Rudy shows up and cleans my roof and gutters. He never charges, but I always tip his employee. It's money well spent. Two months ago, one of my two 37-year-old skylights began to leak - not at the roofline, but the seals on the skylight themselves where the glass meets the plastic/metal trim. I called Brodie and he advised I was fortunate as skylights generally last about 25 years and he recommends replacement then as preventative maintenance. I guess I was fortunate to have gotten 37 years, and the leak didn't cause any major damage. The sheetrock just had to be replaced. He replaced both skylights and, as with the roof, I've had no issues whatsoever. He even recommended another contractor to replace the interior trim which was done meticulously. I've recommended Brodie's Roofing to many friends, and they have all had similar experiences. I wouldn't use nor recommend anyone else!

We were in need of a new roof and many of our neighbors recommended Brodie's Roofing. Rudy and crew…read moredid an excellent job in a timely manner and at the price quoted . I found Rudy and crew to be professional and courteous in all phases of their work. I would highly recommend Brodie's Roofing to anyone in need of roof repair or replacement.

Very responsive ... did roof repair job for a good price and when I called about a problem came…read moreback promptly and took care of it

I did not hire them. BUT they gave me a quote for gutters on my small house. They came promptly…read more Their price was very high.

They did an amazing job on our roof. They were professional, thorough and got the job done quickly…read more They explained everything and answered all questions from start to finish. We are impressed and would definitely recommend their services

NEW STEEPLE EXTERIOR MCAS did a terrific job replacing the…read moreexterior of the steeple on our church. We are so pleased with their solution and it was a pleasure working with them. We don't know of any other company in the Westchester area that has the experience needed to perform this kind of work. The steeple, which dates from the original construction of the church in the 1970s, is made of plywood. The exterior had been coated with a thick, rubberized, highly water-resistant paint. Because it was only paint protecting the plywood from the elements, it required a new paint job every 6 or 7 years. And because the steeple is so high and hard to access, any painting had required either building scaffolding or renting a bucket truck. A rather expensive bit of upkeep. MCAS helped us analyze other easier-to-maintain options--either traditional shingles or metal sheathing. We decided on metal sheathing because 1) it would have a cleaner look and be more attractive, and 2) it would last longer. Yes, the installation would cost more, but long-term it would be a simpler and more elegant solution. MCAS gave us a great price on the install--around 20k. And despite equipment hassles (the rented bucket truck kept breaking down), they got the work done in 10 days. There was only one actual installer who was an expert with aluminum sheeting. He approached the work as an artist and did a beautiful, impeccable job. On top of that, he was a super-nice guy. Our new steeple should last for 50 years or more and continues to be a bright spot in the Tarrytown community. Michael Casolaro, the owner of MCAS, has a documented history of high-quality roofing work (customized copper gutters to standard reshingling--the gamut) and we are so glad we went with him on this project. P.S. MCAS also reshingled our roof at the same time they resurfaced our steeple, and they did an excellent job with that as well. P.P.S. Please note, this job was done in spring, 2019. We then lived in Westchester, NY, but have since moved.

Set up two appointments. The first one they didn't show and they told me I had the wrong day. The…read moresecond one they didn't show. Sometimes things come up, but no one called to update or provide info. On both occasions I waited around for an hour then called them. No idea if they have a good price or good service but if they can't show up for the appointments as scheduled, I don't know how you trust them to do the rest of the job.

After having a hard time finding someone to do the skirting on our mobile home, we found Luna…read moreroofing and siding.  Dave came to our home to look at the skirting and to take measurements.  We also found out that Luna did decks, which we needed done and then found out that our roof needed fixing.  Luna came and fixed all three of these projects in two days.  I could not be happier with the workmanship, the professionalism and the price.  I highly recommend this company to anyone who needs work done on their home!!  I just wished that they did other type of work like flooring and then some because we need that done also next spring and I would have used them for that as well.  Thank you Luna!  You are a life saver!!!!

In April I called for an estimate, Andrew was fantastic. He was available for all my questions and…read moreshowed he was invested. I went with a different contractor for pricing and warranty reasons. I reached out again the end of June to see if they would like to take a job for gutters and a new shed roof. I have called three times, waiting for someone to call back to set up an estimate. The third call, I even said - if you aren't going to entertain the job just tell me. I was promised a call by the afternoon. Nothing.