I hired The Brothers That Just Do Gutters in Fall 2025 to replace my existing gutters with seamless…read more6" gutters. The estimator was professional, took measurements, and provided what I felt was a fair quote. The installation crew completed the work using roof straps rather than attaching the gutters to the fascia board. This immediately raised concerns because my previous gutter system was secured to the fascia and tied into the rafters. When I contacted the company, I was told roof straps were used because I supposedly did not have a fascia board. Less than three months later, during the winter, approximately half of the front gutter detached from my house and snapped in half. Initially, I was told this was an "act of God." However, after the company inspected the installation, they discovered the roof strap spacing was significantly wider than New York recommendations, roughly 40 inches apart when spacing should have been approximately 18-24 inches. At that point, they replaced the damaged front gutter, added additional straps, inspected the rear gutters, and assured me everything else was fine. Unfortunately, a few months later I noticed one of the rear roof straps had completely detached, and the strap spacing in the back did not match the corrections made to the front. Around the same time, I contacted another local gutter company with nearly 50 years of experience for an estimate on gutter guards. During their inspection, they questioned why roof straps had been used at all because my home does, in fact, have a fascia board available for attachment. My biggest disappointment was not the initial failure itself, but the inconsistent explanations and quality concerns that followed. After spending thousands of dollars on a new gutter system, I expected an installation that would provide long-term reliability and peace of mind. Based on my experience, I would recommend homeowners thoroughly research their options, ask detailed questions about installation methods, and obtain multiple opinions before moving forward with a gutter replacement project.

Prompt, courteous, professional service. Highly Recommend. Excellent price and quality product and…read moreinstallation.

Very professional, friendly and efficient. Very good price as well for gutter cleaning and dryer…read morevent cleaning.

Great service, honest and reliable. Professional and definitely knows his gutters! Will definitely…read moreuse in the future again.

After calling gutter and roofing companies, I found Newburgh Seamless Gutter, and Jason called me…read moreback in under ten minutes. I have to be honest...it is unfortunate that I never expect a call back when I leave a message. Just personal experience. He came out to my historic home in the heights in Newburgh, and immediately corrected my thinking on my existing yankee gutters. He went up on the roof when I wasn't there, and cleared the leaves that were likely causing the water build up in them. I have an unrelated roofing issue that he explained in great detail via video and photos to my email. Being in construction myself, I was very, very pleased with his response, explanation, and overall professionalism. As an aside--he gave a friend of mine doing a new construction project an EXCELLENT price on new seamless gutters. This is clearly a conscientious owner of a well-run business.

Jason is a gentlemen and a skilled professional. He was great at keeping in touch and keeping us…read moreinformed. His prices are fair and he works quickly and neatly. We love our new gutters.

There is no one better than Jim. We had a hole in our roof that turned out to be three and storms…read morecoming in a couple of days. He fixed our leak promptly and with ease and taught us valuable information about the health and life of our roof. He is reliable, professional and incredibly educated in his craft. Beyond all of this, though, he is an exceptional human being. It felt like finding long lost family and instantly feeling taken care of. I would give Jim every project in our home if I could, and we recommend him to everyone we know. You'd be hard pressed to find anyone better, as a roofer and a person.

Jim was nothing short of amazing! We are first time home buyers and we were having some leaking…read moreissues. Jim was prompt, professional and friendly. He came over and assessed the problem. He sent pictures of the issue with the roof and where it was leaking. He fixed the problem on hand and checked in with us multiple times during a rain storm to ensure that his work was withstanding. He came back to assess the work and took more pictures to send to us so we could see what work he had done and also how it was effective in no longer leaking. He ensured us that we had another 10 years until the roof would need replacing! We will be using him for our new roof and any other issues!

Very responsive and great value. Very happy with Nesbitt Gutter Solutions. I would definitely…read morerecommend.

From the owner: Locally owned and operated full service gutter company in the Hudson Valley. Small company…read moreproviding affordable prices and quality work