We had a nice time here! Large bar was full but you could still talk at the side tables. Server was…read moreawesome, would love to have her again. Food was good although a tad greasy. We had a smash burger and a chicken burger. The chicken was huge! Onion rings and tots were really good. We will be back for sure!

It's worth the travel. The food was good. Love the ambiance with all the TVs and sports going on…read more The service from Tanya was great. We tried 4 different meals and two sides. If I could suggest their hamburger to be molded on to the delicious garlic bread, that would be a winner! Their garlic bread was excellent.

We usually place our orders by phone and do pickup, and the service is consistently spot-on. The…read morestaff is friendly, efficient, and the pizzas are always ready right when they say they will be. The quality never wavers. This is still the best pizza in Dover, hands down. The New York-style extra-large pie is a standout every time, perfectly cooked with great flavor and texture. Reliable, delicious, and always satisfying.

Got take out, white buffalo wood fired pizza. Really good! Good presentation, crust was on the…read morethinner side but not over cooked/burnt. Not flimsy even though was takeout.

After asking around to see who has great bone-in fried chicken this place came highly recommended…read more We stopped by on a whim, person in front of use bought the last in the case but they told us to wait about 15 minutes and we'll have fresh hot fried chicken. We ordered the 6pc all white which consisted on 2 breasts and 4 full wings for $19.99. They did not disappoint.

Been a loyal customer for a long time. If you haven't had their meatball sub yet, you better try it…read moreout. 5 stars on that sub

Just got the house pizza, so good, great crust, so good had to write a review. Recommend it.read more

Well, our first time in a long time, and probably the last…read more We ordered pizza for delivery, expected time was an hour in which we got the order on time. Our issue is the delivery driver. We clearly stated the apartment entry code, and we also clearly stated to knock on door and leave at door on the receipt...that was ignored completely. This was ignored by the delivery driver who had the balls to tell us to "go pick it up next time" at the end of our call because we said we would tip later. Might as well order from Strafford House or La Festa

there food is awesome and I know the owner very well and he is extremely nice I like him they make…read morereally good food like the fat mikes b or there Roger's house special pizza

Stopped in for a steak sub on Friday 4/24 at around 11:30. First time here. The steak subs were…read moreawful. The meat and the cheese were tasteless and rolls and meat were over cooked and with one sub there were burnt. Google the best sub shop in Dover and they are not on any list. If you are going to charge the customer $30 for two subs you should be on the top of your game. Never again.

Wow!!! Hubby and I…read morestopped here since we received a gift card and had been meaning to go. He made a reservation in advance We were seated promptly and greeted by a lovely server who took our orders. I had pizza and hubby got a pasta dish with meatballs. The pizza sauce was perfect! Not too sweet and the crust was perfection! The meatballs were obviously made with love and care Highly recommend and we will be back

Based on reviews, I decided to try Cartelli's this past Saturday for Pizza takeout. The place was…read morepacked with no seats available while I waited. Wait staff were all professional and friendly. I had called in an order for a Large PMO's, and after arriving home, the Pizza looked wonderful. Unfortunately, it was undercooked, and horrible tasting. My wife and I decided to put it in the garbage to go out on Monday. I had been hoping for a new go-to place. I may try this place again next month.

Love it here, one of the best places around…read more Wish they would play more Christmas Music during the holiday season.

Great food, staff, and atmosphere. The pizza is always a great call. Brunch is a must!read more

The best pizza and steak and cheese in Dover! Also love the tenders and Italian subs!read more

These guys know how to cook good food! The pizza is some of the best around, but they have so many…read moremore great things! You will not be disappointed.

It's New Years Eve, the service is top notch. They were very busy, they knew the names of some of…read morethe people picking up pizza. I got a tuna wrap, bag of potato chips and Water. The two people with me got the spaghetti dinner--great stuff! I read the review about the babysitter who did not know her address. I don't think it's fair to give a company grief if you want pizza delivered and DON'T FREAKING KNOW the address. My Dad has ordered from here for ten years, because they are good.

Worst pizza I've ever had, dough is terrible , cheese is terrible, it's not edible, the service was…read moregreat, polite , pleasant but the pizza was terrible it was a small pizza for $15 dollars and it was the WORST pizza I've ever had.