We absolutely love there garlic bread we do pizza night at least 2 x a month and come from Ashland…read morejust to get pizza

A great small town pizza place with great recipe and fresh ingredients. I enjoyed my pepperoni and…read moremushroom pie.

Food was amazing! Quality ingredients, unique flavors. I decided on the Texas brisket pizza and…read moreStromboli for later! If you driving through or staying the night. The taste is seriously legendary.

I was driving back from Pennsylvania and after a week of watching different "best of pizza" shows…read moreon YouTube, I wanted pizza! As always, I pull up Yelp recommendations. Two show up and both rated the same. I ordered a large with half pepperoni and mushroom, the other half onion and pineapple. Also garlic bread sticks with marinara. On the drive home I dove in and devoured the bread sticks. I really liked the marinara! I had 2 slices while driving and it was pretty solid. Pizza is subjective and one person's holy grail is another's meh. This was solid in the middle good. It scratched the itch I had for pizza for sure. Solid 4 stars.

We ordered online, which I would say was the best online ordering experience I've ever had. The…read moredetail that went into their website, you can edit everything so well and customize your order down to a T! They thought of everything. They are very busy, so pick up was like an hour and 20 after we replaced and then we still had to wait 20 minutes when we got there. But it was very much worth it and I would just plan for the wait. The French fries were bomb. Good fries, cooked well, great toppings and well distributed so you didn't get a bunch of naked fries. The cheese was good, not some crappy cheese sauce. It was like shredded. The pizza was delicious. It was a thicker crust and it had great flavor. Even the smaller pizzas you could split in 2 so you can try 2 different specialty pizzas. We got half Romeo (but switched out the sauce for white olive oil sauce) and half right primo pepperoni. The Primo was the bomb. The red sauce was so good, pepperoni cups were plentiful. The Romeo was different since it was a seasonal, had pistachios on it so had to try it. I thought it was good but didn't compare to the Primo. Also ordered garlic parm boneless wings that would be a problem if we lived here. The tiramisu was good, but I'm a connoisseur so I'm a little more picky. I thought it needed more espresso flavor like a wet layer at the bottom. I would 100% come back here. Great take out to go back to the Airbnb!

First time trying this place. It was on a Saturday afternoon. I'm guessing it was considered busy…read more We ordered a small pizza for $17. My wife also ordered a chicken sandwich. We said water for our drink and they wanted to charge for water so we decided against that. We dined in. My wife's chicken sandwich came out pretty quickly. About 40 minutes later my pizza was delivered to our table. The noise of the place was terrible. The steel chairs on the hard floors echoed throughout the dining area. The pizza was delicious! Definitely one of the best pizza pies I've had. Little soggy in the center but overall it was great! My wife liked the chicken sandwich but the dressing was a little heavy, which made it a little too salty for her taste. We're excited to try different items next time! Pros: Food was great. Cons: WAIT TIME Noise Price

The wings were awesome. I was excited for the pizza but it was gross. Bland pepperoni underneath…read morecongealed cheese with sauce that tasted like stomach bile. I actually woke up in the middle of the night because I puked pizza sauce into my mouth at 3am. Would 100% get the wings again. The delivery driver was awesome too. I don't like leaving bad reviews but I would rather eat a dried dog turd from my yard than eat another slice of this pizza.

Traveling through the area and ordered delivery. Picked Fast Eddie's based on strong reviews…read more.. Yikes. Ordered meatball sub, shrimp Alfredo, and boneless wings. The shrimp was was very good. Well seasoned and tasty. The pasta was an overcooked Home Ecc project. The sub was a disaster. An epic piece of bread smothering tiny meatballs which were halved, dry, and cheese-less for $15.95. The boneless wings were well above average. It was a two star meal but the service on the phone and with the delivery guy was very good and worthy of a star. My guess it was just a bad choice on what we ordered so if you give them a try choose a different path.

It was a pick up order. The loaded tots looked like dog food, the bacon looked liked it had turned…read moreand they used it anyway, and tasted like it too- not edible. Total waste of money. The kids bbq boneless wings were just okay. The Philly cheesesteak was also just okay. No utensils or napkins were given for the to go order either. I will not go back.

The menu was promising and the food was tasty but not extraordinary. I was happy until one of my…read moredinner mates received a nearly red burger when asking for 'no pink'. Server asked if she wanted a new burger. She accepted. The server came back with the same burger, now overdone. When she questioned it and asked about the new burger she was told 'the kitchen said no.' The server offered to remove it from her bill and she agreed. When the bill came They charged her for the onion rings that came with the burger because 'she ate them'. This interaction made me realize that they don't value return guests so I will not be returning.

My wife broke her ankle so it was my turn to cook. I…read morehaven't had this pizza in a while. All of my kids worked here (first jobs). I've always loved the pizza there. Today was no disappointment!!! They knocked it out of the park!!!!! Thanks!!!!

We found this pizza joint on Yelp. We are visiting the area from Michigan. The pizza was so…read moredelicious and well worth the 8 miles to pick it up. The cheese is amazing and the sauce is great. Definitely will be back on the next trip.

Good pizza and the waitress/owner could not have been nicer. Probably good takeout, but not much…read moreof a dine in place.

Absolutely delicious! Solid 8/10. Sauce was yummy and…read moreseemed to be an average amount to me. The garlic bread was very garlicky which I liked! Will be back in the summer.

I have only ordered pizza from here which is good. I like that they have two choices of sauce. You…read morecan get a spicy sauce or regular sauce. Each time I have ordered, I get the spicy sauce, which I really like. Service is OK, nothing outgoing about it.

Great owner and super good pizza and wings!! The new ownership has stepped it up and the pizza is…read moreeven better

Such a cute place! The town is adorable and the food is delicious. Very friendly staff, too!read more

We ordered a pizza to take home because we had our dog with us. It only took about 20 minutes to…read morereceive our order. We got a pepperoni and sausage medium pizza. It was really good! There was plenty of cheese, almost to the edge. If we are traveling through Milan again, I would definitely eat at Jim's Pizza Box.

The bests pizza I ever had! The toppings were super thick and weight a ton. I could only eat 2…read moresmall pieces and I was stuffed.

Definitely delicious!! Friendly staff! Every time my sister comes to visit me from Akron she's…read moregotta order her a Besta Fasta Pizza!!