Great customer service! This was my first time coming to this location as I've always gone to the one in Astoria. My nephew's favorite cake is their tiramisu and I called to check if they had it available. No one answered but 15 minutes later they called me back. The lady told me that unfortunately they did not have the whole cake but would be able to order one for me for later in the day. I explained that I needed the cake right away and she told me that they had 5 individual slices available. I told her that I would come and pick up the slices. She was super friendly and put the slices together so they looked like a whole cake. It's just so refreshing to have such great customer service nowadays! read more

See all

The coffee is excellent! The service is very friendly and all the desserts and gelato are mouth watering goodness read more

This place is ideal if you are looking to purchase pastries . The cakes are also good. The bakery associate was knowledgeable and was able to go e me an idea on how some pastries tasted. The customer service was wonderful and friendly. When you walk inside the business you immediately see some blue china on the ceiling making the small cafe feel grand. read more

The baklava cheesecake was incredible. Really good combo of great things. The top didn't really stick to the whole pastry. I got it to go and ate it the next day. read more

Omonia Cafe - Baklava Cheesecake - Cafes Near Me - New York, New York

Absolutely the best service & foods/pastries here! The environment is very friendly, welcoming & the staff are just great! I personally love ordering the Chai latte & the Ham & Cheese Croissant. The pastries are also so so so good. I love the fruit tarts & tiramisu. If you are also looking to place online orders, it always comes on time & organized. read more

See all

Stopped by after class and tried the baklava cheesecake--so many options to choose from! The staff member was super sweet and helped me decide. Seating is limited, but things move quickly. Definitely worth a visit for a sweet treat. read more

I'd never been to a neighborhood bakery before, so I was excited to try it after dinner. I was surprised at how late it opened and how many people were there. Unfortunately, I think the food was a bit too sweet despite how beautiful it all looked. We ordered a Fudge Cake, and we couldn't finish it because it was way too sweet. The cake itself was a bit wet, but I'm not sure what it was soaking up, and the ganache itself tasted like straight sugar. Not sure if I will come back again but the idea of a neighborhood bakery/deli is very cute indeed! read more

Yum! Everything I've eaten from Omonia has been delicious. And the staff is very nice.

Everything Ive tasted here has been so delicious. They have the best almond cookies in all of New York City. The staff here is extremely kind and always welcoming every time I come in I write this place a 10 out of 10 I come here every time I'm near Cathedral Parkway. Although I wish they had a little bit more gluten-free options. read more

Have been coming here since it opened and it's been a great addition to the neighborhood! It's more like walking into your family's house, the staff are so friendly the pastries and sweets are delicious they also have fantastic Gelato and coffee. I personally love the Berry Napoleon its the best I've had and the almond cookies too (my small son is a big fan) read more

Omonia Cafe - Almond cookies, small son - Cafes Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Love coming to this bakery! They have many delicious treats to select from. A few of my favorites, which always have us coming back for more include, the vanilla gelato, walnut cookies , and decadent dulce de leche cheese cake! Workers are always friendly and greet us with a smile :) 10/10 would recommend read more

Random, but have searched the city for authentic portokalopita ("orange pie") and can safely say that this bakery does it RIGHT! As authentic and tasty as the treats I had in Greece and Turkey read more

Omonia Cafe - Portokalopita - Cafes Near Me - New York, New York

Admittedly, some of the cakes can be hit/miss depending on what you ordered. The Galaktoboureko and the chocolate fudge cake have been delicious. I've had the 7 layer cake two times - the first time it was amazing and the second time, it was a bit dry like it had been sitting out for too long. I've also had the baklava cheesecake and it wasn't anything special in my opinion. There's usually not a line - quick service. Overall, good place if you know what order. read more

Omonia Cafe - a slice of chocolate cake - Cafes Near Me - New York, New York

Best iced coffee on the UWS! while I haven't tried their beautiful baked goods their iced coffee is next level. Served with a smile! Highly recommend! read more

It's really a wonderful place. The pastries are delectable. The coffee is sublime. Lovely staff . Sony is incredibly helpful and sweet, but I've never had a poor customer service experience here. HIGHLY RECOMMEND read more

Lovely place - perhaps the best baklava I've had... wonderful connoli... Kind generous friendly people and a very wide array of desserts -- not one short of excellent so far... read more

I'm always craving their Berry Napoleon Cake. Haven't found anything as good as Omonia's!

I got the chocolate cake and it was very good. Rich frosting, large slice for $8. Service was fast and friendly. They have a lot of different options and they all looked amazing. The store was very cute, just what I wanted for a birthday treat for myself. I would definitely go back and try another kind of cake next time. read more

I felt the need to write a review after coming back home to visit and stopping in for a coffee. My receipt said my server was John, and he made the best coffee I've ever had from here! He was very pleasant and nice as well, and I really appreciated him. I don't normally write reviews, however, it just hit right coming home after so long and having it! read more

Stopped by to take a look. They have a pretty nice selection of cakes and desserts. I did come here while I was hungry and wanted to buy multiple items. I ended up getting two slices, total came out to $16. They are rather large but still insane pricing for two slices of cake. The staff wasn't particularly friendly. All business. Got in and got out. They asked me if I wanted the slices packed separately or together. In the name of conservation I opted to have it packed together. They put the two slices in one of those square transparent takeout containers that snap together in two corners. I was careful all the way home so that the two wouldn't fall over and touch each other 4/5 Tres leches slice - yum!! I really enjoyed this slice. There was a layer of fruit and cream between the cake layers. The cake was already moist but the fruit made that even better. Fruit pieces tasted like and had canned fruit texture. 1.5/5 Rice pudding cheesecake - havent seen this anywhere else before so i decided to try it. Could not taste rice pudding from this, neither did it have a cheesecake flavor either. It was grainier than traditional cheesecake, not great. Quite disappointing, I didn't finish this slice. Fun concept, poor execution. Would not return or recommend. read more

I am so thrilled this opened in the neighborhood. Incredibly friendly staff, of course excellent baked goods, great coffee and fabulous gelato. Has a couple of tables outside which seems to be sufficient for the traffic and this location. Have as yet to try anything I didn't automatically love. read more

Cakes are OK, but more mousse than cake in most instances and quite sweet. Gelato is good, but flavors vary a bit from batch to batch. Cheesecake is good. Haven't had the savory items. read more

Hair in my cheesecake. After one bites I asked for my money back. They argued and said it wasn't their responsibility. They said I can exchange. I just wanted my money back. Finally agreed to store credit. Disappointed. All they had to do was handle it better. I understand things happen. read more

Omonia Cafe - a strawberry cheesecake in a box - Cafes Near Me - New York, New York

A small cafe but with a great selection of Greek and other kinds of pastries and cookies. They recently added a few seats. I've been a few times and each time I have loved what I've purchased. Employees are friendly and helpful. A great addition to the neighborhood. read more

Established in 1977, Omonia has locations in Queens and Brooklyn, and is best known for its Greek and Italian pastries. The baklava and baklava cheesecake are amazing, and go great with a cup of frappe. read more

Great staff! I haven't been here before and was walking by finding a place to cool off and charge my phone. I asked the girl behind the counter what she recommended and gave me a few, i went with the baklava and i loved it! Will be coming back in the future read more

It is not a bakery where they bake their cakes and other goodies themselves. They just sell them here. Quality is below average but price is above average. First we were very excited to have a bakery win the neighborhood, but soon got disappointed after trying it. Don't recommend. read more

Cakes are delicious, woman manager makes it easy to order. Very good cappuccinos. A welcome addition to our neighborhood!

baklava cheesecake. everyone is super nice again baklava cheesecake ... but everything is good read more