I've been coming here for a while so I'm not sure why I hadn't reviewed it yet lol the pizza is always good. Only one I really like in the area as it's thin crust but still soft and tasty. Like I'll actually eat the crust which most place forget to season. Only issue is they don't have AC so it's boiling in the hot months. Only issue was one time they gave us moldy garlic knots! That wasn't cool so we'll never get those again. So stick to the pizza and salads. read more

I ordered 2 slices ($3.50 each, 1 vegetarian, 1 pepperoni sausage). They're thin crust NY style and they reheat it when you order. 5 regular style buffalo wings and a small salad w/ Italian dressing. It was a pretty simple meal but everything tasted good. If you're looking for something quick and easy this is a good spot. I will be back again read more

I've been eating Omar's since they were in the shopping center on the Monrovia/Arcadia border and Omar would deliver the pizzas. Things change, location, ownership, even the pizza a little bit, but to me it's still excellent NY style pizza. If you want consistency go to a place where they stamp out the dough, put it in an oven with a timer, and use canned everything. Otherwise expect a good thin crust pizza to vary a little from time to time. In all the years I've never had a bad pizza here. My go-to is the Bronx special, add mushrooms. read more

Best pizza in the town! My kids love the fresh and yummy pizza! The staff are amazing and friendly too!

This place has great ziti! We also had the pizza and it was delicious as well. I love the fact we have decent Italian food here in the land of Asian food! read more

Decent pizza, unfortunately their website and "quality control" need improvement. We've had mixed up orders a couple of times, and tonight I tried to order a Calzone on their website but in order to add it to my "Cart" I was forced to select from two options. 14" for $16.95 or 18" for $22.95. This was for an $11.95 Calzone but their website would NOT allow me to add it to my cart without selecting one of these two other options. Of course when I selected the 14" option the price of the $11.95 Calzone jumped up to $28.90. It was impossible to add just a Calzone to my online order, I HAD to select either the 14" or 18" before their website would allow me to add the Calzone to my cart. And so I called them to place my order instead. I ordered 15 piece BBQ wings, the Calzone, and a Bronx pizza, and I confirmed with the gentleman who took my order that the Bronx was the meatball, sausage, and pepperoni pizza. I confirmed this because I tend to get the Bronx and the Brooklyn mixed up, but tonight I know that I ordered the Bronx and I also confirmed its toppings with the gentleman who took my order. When I picked up my food I discovered that in spite of confirming that I was ordering a Bronx, they had still made me a Brooklyn. At this point it was 8pm, and as I'd been told 35 minutes when I'd placed my order I did not want to wait another half hour for them to make me the pizza I wanted and had originally ordered. We got home and my son reluctantly ate the pizza after picking off the olives and green peppers, but he did not enjoy it because he said he could still smell the peppers. In spite of them having messed up my order (more than once), and in spite of having a broken website that tries to charge you $29 for a $12 Calzone, I still think they're an OK pizza place. Unfortunately the only way to contact them is by phone, or via a proxy email address (they do NOT have an email listed on their website), and so instead of being able to contact them discretely about these issues I'm forced to air their dirty laundry in public in the vain hope that someone with authority will see this review and work on fixing these issues. Because I really want Omar's to be a GREAT pizza place, and not just an OK pizza place :( read more

Omar's NY Style Pizzeria is on the smaller side but very clean and has a couple TV's in case you want to watch the Dodgers lose....... #VivaTomateros! It's one of those order and pay up front, they give you a number to place on your table and food is then brought to you, food was ready pretty quickly, I'd say wait time was much less than most pizza places, based off my one visit. Garlic Knots - https://www.yelp.com/biz_photos/omars-pizzeria-arcadia?include_review_link=True&userid=mXl8GMozjLoraG7PyFHWkg 8 knots I believe was just under $4, I liked the dough and thought they did taste good, my only slight issue https://www.yelp.com/biz_photos/omars-pizzeria-arcadia?include_review_link=True&userid=mXl8GMozjLoraG7PyFHWkg they are called "Garlic" yet it was more Parmesan cheese than garlic flavor. 4-Stars Pizza 1/2 Ham & Pineapple / 1/2 Sausage & Jalapeno - https://www.yelp.com/biz_photos/omars-pizzeria-arcadia?include_review_link=True&userid=mXl8GMozjLoraG7PyFHWkg I love my wife but as you can see we differ when it comes to pizza toppings, pineapple just wrong... Ham & Pineapple - https://www.yelp.com/biz_photos/omars-pizzeria-arcadia?include_review_link=True&userid=mXl8GMozjLoraG7PyFHWkg Nice dough on the thinner side "NY Style" and had a nice crunch, my wife gave it two thumbs up Sausage & Jalapeno - https://www.yelp.com/biz_photos/omars-pizzeria-arcadia?include_review_link=True&userid=mXl8GMozjLoraG7PyFHWkg Nice dough, marinara sauce had good flavor, plenty of toppings, not the greatest sausage but overall a solid pizza. read more

See all

My brother recommended this place and since it's only a few minutes away, I decided to give it a try. The pizza was on point so next time I will try the sandwiches. Not to shabby. read more

Omar's Pizzeria is a small hole in the wall pizza place. They pride themselves on making NY style pizzas. Walking inside it was empty except for an Asian dude working the cashier and another dude making the pizzas. They had a number of pizzas displayed behind the counter but they looked like they've been there for a while. Those pizzas behind the counter are for if you wanted to order pizza by the slice. Wanting a whole new hot pizza we decided to order a whole 18" pizza with pepperoni and mushrooms ($16). We were told it would take about 15 minutes. I saw that the dude tossed around the dough made from scratch so it was nice to know that their pizzas are not made from premade doughs. They only offer one size pie which is 18" unless you order by the slice. A whole cheese pizza starts at $14 and each additional topping is one dollar more. They have a variety of pizza specials that range from $15-$19. They also have buffalo wings, sandwiches, calzones, pastas, and some side orders. Out of nowhere they offered us a complimentary slice of pizza. They offered a slice of the Whitestone pizza which had ricotta cheese, mozzarella, provolone, parmesan, and fresh garlic. It was super cheesy. The pepperoni and mushroom pizza arrived like a minute after. Nice thin crispy crust and the toppings were fresh. The pepperoni had a bit of spice to it and the mushrooms were quite thick. The cheese and the marinara sauce had great flavor. Quite the superb pizza. Definitely quality stuff here. The service was good. One of the dudes added on another table to our table to fit the whole pizza onto there. I thought that was pretty nice. He was also the same dude that offered us a free slice. Hours from 11am to when they run out of dough. Overall, great pizza! I'll be back to try more pizzas! read more

See all

I wouldn't recommend dining in here because it's kind of dark and not very dine-in friendly, but their take out service is great. They guy was super nice and made sure my order was packed up neatly to go. I was craving a calzone and got their ricotta and mozzarella and added onions and peppers. It was huge, the size of a paper plate and came with 2 containers of marinara sauce. Hot and plenty of filling, but wasn't too crazy about the crust, it was slightly dense. Otherwise it was good. The also have ready to go slices (to be re-heated) for 2.99. I saw the worker put out a hot tray of Sweet and spicy- Pepperonis, jalapenos, and pineapples. Great amount of toppings, but the bottom of the slice was slightly burned. We've gotten delivery a few times in the past and it has been a mix of on time and a few minutes late, but overall great thin crust pizzas! read more

Omar's Pizzeria - Calzone...size of a paper plate! - Pizza Near Me - Arcadia, California

We celebrated Halloween early at my office since a lot of people commute on Fridays. So during lunch we had a pumpkin decorating and costume contests. For lunch, we had a pizza party. I think we ordered about 18 pizzas from Omar's. Our Social Committee was debating on Costco pizza or Omar's. Although Costco's pizzas are only $10 each, they didn't have as much variety and we would have to pick them up at Azusa. Omar's delivers and are closer to our office. The pizzas seemed to be a hit with everyone and we also had some cheese-less pizzas. I personally tried the Garden Fresh House Salad (the yellow tomatoes were really sweet), SWEET & SPICY (Pepperoni, pineapple and jalapenos), BRONX SPECIAL (A hardy offering of meatball, sausage and pepperoni) and GARLIC CHICKEN (Savory chunks of chicken breast, fresh garlic, olive oil, red onions, fresh cilantro and sliced Roma tomatoes). Since the pizzas weren't piping hot by the time the party started, the crust became a little tough, but had good flavor. You can also order online (EAT 24) which is easy and convenient and there's a 10% off coupon for first time customers. 186/100 Reviews for 2014 read more

Omar's Pizzeria - Pizza party at work - Pizza Near Me - Arcadia, California

See all

This was on my bf's bookmark list for a very long time. I was pretty skeptical about a new pizza joint surfacing; I mean it's just a pie, right? Omar's Pizzeria proved me wrong... there is a decent local pizza place! And so what if the decor is no frills and there is not a lot of seating, but it doesn't really matter because their pizza is amazing! We ordered #11 - White artichoke pizza http://www.yelp.com/biz_photos/omars-pizzeria-arcadia?select=s9Qb0grwY7vJZ-K6JLbKlA#s9Qb0grwY7vJZ-K6JLbKlA (mozzarella, parmesan, plump artichokes, mushroom, fresh garlic and some tomato sauce brushed on top). I liked the simplicity of the fresh ingredients and you could really taste the difference. Things you should know: 1) it's thin crust pizza 2) only comes in 1 size (18") 3) they don't skimp on the ingredients! 4) you can get your pizza half & half! 5) there's a check-in offer for a free slice of pizza! Suggestions: 1) maybe offer a free can or soda instead of a slice of pizza 2) get a permit for outside seating like Subway? We didn't get a chanced to tell Omar how awesome the pizza was, hopefully next time. Yelp 100 Challenge 2013 - 27 of 100 read more

Omar's Pizzeria - white artichoke pizza (mozzarella, parmesan, plump artichokes, mushroom, fresh garlic and some tomato sauce brushed on top) - Pizza Near Me - Arcadia, California

I tried NY cheese pizza, and it was delicious. Very simple, but it was perfect for me. I already went three times, and they were all good. Only complaint is that they never answer the phone to order in advance. read more

As New Yorkers, we have pretty high standards for good pizza. Those standards aside, the pizza we just got from Omar's was completely awful. Had me craving for frozen Digiorno pizza while I was eating a slice from Omar's. I'm not even gonna talk about the $4 dollar box of lettuce + croutons that they call a caesar. I just had to laugh when I asked my wife if they charged us for them lol Skip. read more

The pizza has completely changed some time in the last year and now the dough quality is quite different -- on the level of college cafeteria pizza. The dough used to be thin and crunchy with natural air bubbles, but now seems dull and maybe machine pressed. Sad that things have changed because I really liked the old recipe. read more

Got this pizza the other day (Thursday evening) to get me through finals... was super impressed. It's just a little hole in the wall place but the pizza is HUGE. I got half white pizza and half chefs special. The white pizza is out of this world. Staff was also friendly. Will definitely be back, grateful I live close! read more

Omar's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Arcadia, California

Tried Garlic Chicken pizza today and it is so good. The combinations of toppings are just right to please your tastebud.

This establishment far exceeds my expectations. The Alfredo is creamy and delish. Lasagna is great as well. Pizza slices served with New York style sizes. The Omar's special is great tasting with more bang for the buck! read more

Omar's Pizzeria - Omar's Menu - Pizza Near Me - Arcadia, California

Cool place to get pizza by the slice. Comfortable, old school, neighborhood feel. Everyone has their opinion on pizza. Try it for yourself. I had slice of pepperoni and a slice of sausage/jalapeño. Solid flavors. Foldable. Great customer service. Love having a place like this in town. Support Local! read more

Omar's Pizzeria - Sausage jalapeño pizza - Pizza Near Me - Arcadia, California

See all

I can still remember my first visit here ... the owner (Omar) was actually running the cash register when I walked in. He was a very friendly dude, shook my hand, and introduced himself. It was very nice to meet an enthusiastic small business owner who seems down-to-earth and genuinely devoted to establishing a positive relationship with all his customers. The food here is tasty and filling. The prices are affordable. Their pizza and baked ziti (with sausage) are excellent. The service is attentive and friendly. Make goddamn sure you drop some money in the tip jar for the good folks working here, because although it's technically not a "full-service" restaurant, I found that they'll still take surprisingly good care of you *after* you have paid for and received your food. (I've never used their delivery service, so I can't comment on that.) The restaurant interior is austere, but clean. You should be able to find a parking spot in the lot during most days/times without *too* much difficulty. I wish Omar, his staff, and his restaurant a prosperous future, they really deserve nothing less. read more

Omar's Pizzeria - Baked Ziti with Sausage. - Pizza Near Me - Arcadia, California

Not what I expected for the money. Had potential to be a pizza king but the sauce just tasted off to me and the dough had a not so doughy texture. Wings were small typical heavy sauce. Salad was good. For 50 bucks it looks like a lot of food. But once your done you realise how much you just spent for not that much. Honestly. I really wanted to say good things. But this site is about honesty right. read more

Fast and delicious pizza. Thin crust. Lots of toppings. Super flavorful. Ordered through Postmates and got it within 45minutes and was still warm on arrival. read more

See all

An update to my review from some months ago. I got pizza for dinner, and my son would not eat it, specifically referencing the time that my wife ordered pizza from them. I dont care if their pizza tastes good, they are thugs, and I am honestly pissed off at their treatment of customers, when THEY got the order wrong. I would not order from here if they were the last pizza joint on earth., which is sad, because it wasn't bad pizza, they are just bad people serving good pizza. read more

There are better pizza options in the SGV. Tried it out based on the good reviews, but ultimately the pizza was not memorable. It's hard to mess up a pizza and it taste like pizza, but it just wasn't that good? Pizza was kind of hard. Crust was bland. Cheese wasn't gooey. Meats were whatever? Maybe I came on a bad day, but if I'm going to waste my calories on pizza, I'd rather go somewhere that I know can make a good pizza. read more

Really tasty pizza. HUGE, loaded with toppings and just $16. I was stuck in my hotel room and Omar actually delivered my pizza and refused a tip since he's the owner! I picked up lunch from here my last trip to this area, and this is added to my favorites list next to Din Tai Fung. PS - I got an order of the elusive garlic knots! Mmmmm .... SO good. Don't miss them if they're available. read more

Omar's Pizzeria - Half and half puttanesca and Omar's special with red onion added. So yummy! - Pizza Near Me - Arcadia, California

Decided to give this place a try tonight (10/22/20), I always see it come up on Yelp and it had some good reviews. I ordered through Yelp and I guess it's delivered through GrubHub. I ordered the garden salad no tomatoes or onions with ranch. It was supposed to come with croutons but there was none. I ordered mozzarella sticks with ranch (you have the choice between marinara or ranch) it came with marinara. I don't know if maybe they weren't able to see these notes. See the pics for proof. read more

Omar's Pizzeria - My receipt for the order. - Pizza Near Me - Arcadia, California

See all

Not happy. 3 times in a row where I'm unhappy. First my pizza was burned, second they forgot part of my order. This time, they got my order wrong and I got something else than what I paid for. Not to mention the pizza topping were raw. Looks like an afterthought they threw on there once the pizza was already made.....I guess I'm going with another place next time. read more

Omar's Pizzeria - Raw peppers thrown on afterward - Pizza Near Me - Arcadia, California

Best pizza in town. I'm serious. Calzones nice and big also. Hard to choose a pizza because they're all so good. I keep going back to the Whitestone plus sausage, red onion, etc. Delivery to work is good! read more

**3.5 stars for Omar's** I found this place on yelp and couldn't wait to try because of the almost 5 star rating. I went with my sis and we got the daily special: 2 slices and a drink for $6. I got the Hawaiian and farmer's market (veggie) and she got the whitestone and margherita. My favorites were the Hawaiian (high quality Canadian bacon) and the whitestone which was full of flavor (mmm garlic and ricotta!!!). Overall, food and service were good and I liked how the pizza crust was crisp and not greasy. The place was nothing special as it was super simple. However, I still think pizza in NY is better. read more

Omar's Pizzeria - Margherita and farmers market pizza - Pizza Near Me - Arcadia, California

See all

This place was great, food, service and all. I read a few bad reviews about the wings, sandwiches, and calzone. However, the name of the restaurant is "Omar's Pizzeria ". You don't go to a pizza place for any of those things, you go to a pizza spot for pizza. If you want a sandwich go to subway. The pizza was great, the sauce was fresh and toppings awesome. It also included an abundant amount of cheese! The pizza was ready in less than 15 minutes and was taken to our table (see photo below, we couldn't wait to dig in!). The place was a bit small, I expected it to be a bit roomier. Also, it was hot in there (granted we went on one of the hottest days of the year). There are fans but I think ac would be a little better. There are also two TVs. All in all, we enjoyed our time here. Definitely would recommend to a friend. read more

Omar's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Arcadia, California

See all

I came here because the Santa Anita Little League has a discount card which offers 10% off your entire order. I used the card without any hitches. I also saw that the Yelp reviews were almost uniformly fantastic. Let me say now that the pizza is definitely a cut above. My wife and I ordered the slice + salad + drink combo for $6. Great deal for quality food. My younger son ordered the calzone, which he immediately proclaimed was bigger than his head (also $6). My other son ordered the ziti ($6 , which he did not finish due to its ample serving size) and garlic knots. What sold me on this place is the friendliness of the owner, who was more than happy to share his story about how he came to open a pizzeria, and how his mother taught him how to make a calzone. Those personal interactions are always important in creating a neighborhood feel to the place. read more

Omar's Pizzeria - The calzone that my son said was bigger than his head. True that. - Pizza Near Me - Arcadia, California

I ordered pizza, wings, and mozzarella sticks through the yelp app. When I arrived my food was ready as soon as I walked. It was very convenient, having already paid to just pick it up and go. Everything was cooked well. The mozzarella sticks were crispy but not over cooked the pizza and wings were also top notch. I would recommend if your looking for good New York style pizza. read more

Surprisingly pretty good pizza at a decent price of $2.50/slice. You also get a free slice when you check in. We got: -Omar's Special: Not my favorite, but the meatball was interesting. Kind of reminded of gyro slices on my pizza. -Farmer's Market: We really liked this one. Bell peppers, zucchini, mushrooms, onions and broccoli. Mmmh. I love broccoli on pizza for some reason. -Margherita: I actually really liked this one. Fresh and tasty with a fragrant garlic smell. -BBQ Chicken: Good taste but not my favorite. It looks pretty ghetto, but if you dine in, they take it to your table. After 2 cans of soda and these slices, it was a little over $10, which was decent. More of a 3.5 stars for me, but I think I'll be back at some point. read more

Omar's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Arcadia, California

See all

Stopped in for lunch today, this is by far one of the best calzones I've ever had!!! Great fresh food and great service!! read more

Omar's Pizzeria - "The work" calzone - Pizza Near Me - Arcadia, California

Kept driving by this place from my route, and decided to stop by for lunch. It was delicious! The cheese is cheesy & the crust is thin. Great compliments to each other. Also the Parmesan cheese & peppers on the side are great on the pizza. Ordered another pizza to go read more

Omar's Pizzeria - Pepperoni & Cheese Large 18 inch pizza - Pizza Near Me - Arcadia, California

Not good. I got a 2 pizza deal they had but Pizza was very hard and had a cafeteria taste. The crust was hard as rock. I seen who I thought was the owner in the back and wanted to say something but unfortunately was on a lunch break and didn't. read more

The first time I ordered from here about 6 months, despite being an Arcadia resident for 21 years LOL But since the first order, I think I have ordered at least once a month (Definitely more often than that during Covid-19). If looking for a good NY style pizza, I think this is the place. I wish I would've tried this place a long time ago! I usually don't bother with all the different places that say "NY Style" because they always disappoint me. Then one day, I was craving it and said "why not?" I'm so very glad I did. I'm SO glad we had garlic powder in the house the first time we ordered from this place. We get the 2 large one-topping pizzas family special all the time. I like just the cheese pizza because there's something about it for me when I go NY style, but we'll do mushroom and pepperoni on occasion. This is pretty much the family's go-to spot for NY style pizza and usually the first place anyone in my family will mention if I ask, "Want pizza?" I have to be specific if I'm ordering pizza from somewhere else. read more

This is my second review for Omar's Pizza . They deserve 10+++ stars!!!! I ordered 17 pizzas for employees who really deserve a break-they work long hours with protective equipment. Since I had such fantastic luck with Omar's the first time when I ordered 10 pizzas, this time I made sure I covered the entire crew and ordered 17. The pizzas were delivered on time, were HUGE, and so delicious!!!!!!! And the staff at Omar's cannot be any nicer. I will always use them. They are such an asset to our community!!!! If I could give them 25 stars I would!!!! read more

Wings were you can tell were recooked, garlic bits we ordered were cold. Pizza was ok parts were very undercooked

Hopefully, my 4 star will not drop Omar's average down. This place was at a 5 star avg. at over 50 reviews. That's impressive, and the reason why I wanted to try them. So we placed the order for "the Works" online. Very convenient! When we arrived 20 min. later, it was ready and Omar, the owner cannot be any cooler. He introduced himself and we had a brief chat before we hurried back home to devour his pizza. It's always nice when the owner chats with his/her customers, exchange names & shake hands. This is something so many businesses fail to do, yet it's so easy and costs them nothing! They need to learn from people like Omar. The pizza itself was truly good. The crust was thin, crispy and slight salty by itself. It held all of the generous toppings without getting soggy. That's also because the pepperoni and sausage didn't form a pool of orange colored grease on top like all those chain pizza places: Pizza Hut, Domino's....etc. I prefer not to have so much cheese on my pizza that it pulls like an extension cord, and Omar's pizza had just enough cheese for me to taste it w/o having to pick extra off. Don't expect any decor. The tables and chairs look dated, the place looks bare, but somehow, I feel better that he only knows how to make pizza and not spend time on other things. Seriously, we're there to eat, right? So we will definitely go back and perhaps enjoy it there once it comes fresh out of the oven. Why not 5 stars? I would have to say it's because the best pizza I've ever had was in a restaurant in Sorrento, Italy read more

Omar's Pizzeria - "The Works" - Pizza Near Me - Arcadia, California