Cancel

Open app

Search

Olde Liberty Tavern

4.5 (2 reviews)
Closed • 12:00 pm - 2:00 am (Next day)

Order Olde Liberty Tavern Takeout or Delivery

Olde Liberty Tavern Photos

OLDE LIBERTY TAVERN ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?
Moderate noise
Casual
Good for groups

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Olde Liberty Tavern

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

4 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Olde Liberty Tavern

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Bars 2,492 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

Verify this business

1600 Bar And Grill

1600 Bar And Grill

4.0(13 reviews)
0.6 mi
•$$

Stopped in with my wife before hitting NJT to New York. We sat at the bar and at first felt a…read morelittle unwelcome. The gentleman didn't greet us or ask for our drink order so we took it upon ourselves to order. Two regulars sat in the bar and conducted conversation with the man behind the bar. The coffee was good and strong. My only complaint was there was no real creamers, only mini moos. Our meals arrived after about ten minutes. Two over easy eggs, hash browns, buttered rye toast and a side of bacon. The bacon was flimsy and greasy--definitely needed work. The eggs were cooked to perfection and the crisp delicious potatoes complimented them perfectly. After our meal it seemed like the staff opened up to us and we really enjoyed our meal. Very affordable at about $13-$14 for two plus a tip. I would come here again solo on my day off.

It had been more than a year since my last visit to Marty's Place. Time flies!…read more I was driving by this morning after court, having skipped breakfast at home in order to get a jump on traffic going into the city. I saw a new sign out front on a Bud Light white board that breakfast was now being served 7 days a week! Hot diggity! I parked out back and walked in to a mostly empty bar (2 customers who looked like they were regulars). The bartender approached and we engaged about their breakfast menu. It was pretty wide open if my desires had anything to do with eggs. They did. I opted for a sausage, egg and cheese on Kaiser roll, and mug of java. While it was being created in the kitchen I watched a show about exotic car auctions. A Borgati opening at a cool million bucks was an eye opener. Another black transport used by John Lennon around London was also put up and sold. Pretty cool entertainment. The sandwich was great! Double patty, fried egg, American cheese and a fresh, quality roll, made for a tasty and fun meal. The side of homefries was likewise excellent - hot, crisp and spicy with sautéed onions in the mix. Coffee, strong and kicking. The only shortcomings were the lack of a joe refill offering, and lack of utensils. Luckily, I had a spoon from the coffee, which was fine as a shovel. Afterall, Marty's is still a wonderful corner dive. It was made for comfort, not for speed, nor etiquette.

Photos
1600 Bar And Grill - Welcome to 1600 Bar and Grill

Welcome to 1600 Bar and Grill

1600 Bar And Grill - Every dish with quality ingredients and love.

Every dish with quality ingredients and love.

1600 Bar And Grill

See all

Flying Pig Tavern & Tap

Flying Pig Tavern & Tap

3.8(168 reviews)
4.8 mi
•$$

Have driven by so many times and finally decided to stop. They have little pigs that you can take…read morewhen you get to the hostess stand. Service was a little slow but it was the bartender who was tending bar and taking care of tables so it was a bit much for her. We started off with the whipped ricotta with honey. It was good but I think if there was just a little heat added to it, it would have brought it up a level. I had the grilled cheese which was not what I was expected. It's basically a triple decker sandwich with cheese on top. I got mine with bacon. I ordered a side of onion rings which were very good and not overly greasy. Hubby got the chicken sandwich special which had grilled chicken, cheese, arugula and blueberry jam. Sounds weird but it works. He had French fries which he said were good. We were told everything is made fresh in house. Got a chicken Cesar salad to go for our daughter, which was good and took banana pudding to go, which was almost like a banana mousse and the peanut butter explosion which was delicious and very rich. Would definitely go back again

There is an outdoor patio outside the front door, where you get an incredible view of rt 130…read more Inside there is a central square bar, with stools all around and tables of various sizes all around it in a u-shape. The kitchen dominates the back of the restaurant with a huge pizza oven and white tiles all around, and a clean bright fresh look, as you pass by to use the restroom. Overall it was fine but not incredibly memorable. We were seated at the strange 6-top table right inside the front door. Like people almost have to shimmy past you to get inside. The service was okay but not great. On the plus side, when we ordered something it came on the quicker side and also later in the meal the manager came by and checked on us. On the meh side there were long periods without being checked on by our server and I feel like I knew a bit more about the menu from reading it than they did. The best thing we ordered was the pretzel. The rest of the food was just alright. Bang bang cauliflower was crispy but battered in what actually tasted like a more dense funnel cake batter and had a twang of fryer oil that was on the cusp of needing to be changed. The sauce was flat. Cheesesteak egg rolls were not good. Soggy (again the fryer oil) and the prevailing flavor was green peppers. (Where I come from a cheesesteak guarantees shaved ribeye, American or Cooper sharp cheese and possibly fried onions but green peppers I would say crosses a line) Mozzarella sticks were mid. Truthfully the extremely long and skinny plates the apps came out on were just annoying. I'm sure the dish and kitchen staff can't stand washing them and plating the food on them either. Just buy some oval or round plates bruh. The cocktails were fine but uninspired. I ordered a peach old fashioned... Bulleit was the brand of bourbon and there was supposed to be peach bitters, peach syrup and "fresh peach" but it came out again a little on the underwhelming side without much peach flavor and the "fresh peach" nowhere to be found. (I expected perhaps a slice of fresh peach?) I didn't take a picture of the cocktail menu but I feel like it many have been like $16 for a subpar drink. Don't mind paying even $20 for a cocktail if it's executed correctly. We tried a blueberry mule off of the mocktails menu but asked to have Tito's added. It was good and properly served in a copper mug with a sprig of fresh mint. There was some live music, a guy singing and playing a guitar which was a nice touch. I appreciated that we could still have dinner conversation and the music wasn't dominating the room- it was more complimentary to the dining experience. In fairness our time there was all apps and some cocktails. We did not try the entrees. I wonder if they would have been executed upon at a higher level. The bathroom was spacious and clean. Had some neat (copper?) sinks with waterfall faucets. In a day and age where things are expensive, you gotta be firing on all cylinders to stand out as a place for folks to drop their hard earned money for a night out. It was alright here... But I don't know if I would choose to come back over other options. It landed between two and half stars and three stars for me.

Photos
Flying Pig Tavern & Tap
Flying Pig Tavern & Tap
Flying Pig Tavern & Tap - This is a godfather cocktail on the light up bar !

See all

This is a godfather cocktail on the light up bar !

Olde Liberty Tavern - bars - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...