Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Olde Gotham

    1.9 (7 reviews)

    Olde Gotham Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Olde Gotham

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    11 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    11 years ago

    Helpful 4
    Thanks 0
    Love this 3
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Joy M.
    59
    4
    1

    11 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of D C.
    0
    14
    1

    11 years ago

    Helpful 6
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Teve' U.
    0
    361
    68

    11 years ago

    Helpful 3
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    11 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 2
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Olde Gotham

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Lounges 361 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    B2 Bistro + Bar - Spicy tuna roll

    B2 Bistro + Bar

    3.9(517 reviews)
    0.7 mi
    $$

    My husband and I were in red bank and decided to try out this branch. We frequent the branch in New…read moreBrunswick and love their happy hour. There is a parking lot across the street you can park at so no need to worry about street parking. The first thing I noticed was that this location was much smaller than the New Brunswick location and had a more chill vibe. I thought the happy hour menu had less selection as well. I was low-key disappointed there were no clams or oysters on the menu considering we are much closer to the shoreline. My husband loved his smashburger, it was very juicy. He also enjoyed the sweet potato fries which he normally doesn't like. My wings have the perfect amount of sauce where it didn't drown the wing and it was still a big crispy. We were in and out within the hour so service was fast on a Tuesday night. But I think we are going to stick with the New Brunswick branch.

    We chose B2 Bistro in Red Bank to enjoy their Tuesday Taco night. Despite the fact that this…read moreSpecial offering is listed on their website, we were told that those prices were no longer in effect and would not be honored! (Is that legal? It's certainly not ethical!) We were charged approx TWICE as much for the Website listed 'Special' tacos! They certainly were special-E'special'ly expensive! We asked to speak with the manager who indicated that she didn't even know that this 'Special' was still on their website. At that point (and in good faith), she should have offered us something as compensation! When told that they do not carry a common beverage-BLUE MOON, the waitress suggested giving me a similar beer and offered a 'taste test'. I could not tell if I liked the sample cause the shot glass had SO LITTLE beer in it-offering me NO TASTE at all. We also ordered chips, plantains, and salsa as an appetizer. For the cost of $14.00, I assumed it would contain enough chips for three people and might even be an unlimited supply. There were approx 15 chips on the plate and 6 plantains-which were tasteless. But think about it!? 15 taco chips for three people to the tune of $14.00?! They should be embarrassed! By 7:30, this restaurant was almost empty. We have been there several times over the years, but this place has deteriorated, in many ways, and we will no longer patronize this establishment!

    Photos
    B2 Bistro + Bar - Dining area

    Dining area

    B2 Bistro + Bar - Burnt margarita pizza

    Burnt margarita pizza

    B2 Bistro + Bar - Burnt Margherita Pizza

    See all

    Burnt Margherita Pizza

    Le Malt Royale

    Le Malt Royale

    5.0(6 reviews)
    0.1 mi

    This venue is one of those places that must be visited and seen to believe how exceptional it is…read more This is a members only club that has gives you 5 star service with attention to detail in every aspect. The moment you walk in, you are greeted with a smile and the experience starts. Members get to have a private locker where you can store your own cigars and alcohol. Yes, this is a BYO place, so all you have to pay for is the food and cigars if don't bring your own. Speaking of food they have an amazing chef just for Sushi and a really nice food menu comparable to any high end steakhouse. As a member I was able to bring 3 friends with me to come and enjoy an evening. We started with Sushi/Sashimi which was exceptionally good. Afterwards we ordered lamb chops, which were some of the best I've ever had. For dinner we decided to share a Tomahawk and a chicken. As expected, the Tomahawk was huge, Flinstones style! Fred would have been proud, lol. The chicken was very different, flavorful and juicy. After dinner we went to the other room for smoking cigars. They have two rooms. One where you can eat, and another where you can eat and smoke. I guess this is done so if someone was not interested in smoking, you have access to a smoke-free room. The smoking room is beautifully decorated and has the best ambiance of any cigar club I have been to. They have a good selection of cigars you can chose from and they are kept in a great humidity condition to keep them fresh. The night we went, there was also a live Jazz singer, which definitely added to the ambiance. In closing I'll just say, that this place doesn't feel like it's in NJ. Once you enter and start to enjoy, you feel like you are sitting in a 5 star luxury venue in Dubai or Hong Kong. There is nothing that comes close to Royale on the East Coast!

    5-Star Class? Yes. Decor? Yes. Food? Yes. Service? Yes, Yes Yes! How is it possible a place like…read morethis exists in the middle of New Jersey. Can't understand that the owners would build an oasis in the middle of crowded same old type of restaurants in Jersey. Not only is this a restaurant, they have a separate cigar lounge with some crazy ventilation system that sucks out all the smoke. The different rooms and parts of this club are quite spacious and offer something unique: Sushi bar, the dining room and the cigar lounge. All under one roof. After my first trial visit, I couldn't wait to become a member and now I can't wait for my locker to be custom engraved. The Royale Cappuccino with 23k edible gold flakes was enjoyed in it's full entirety while signing the paperwork for membership. Thanks for bringing this experience that you would find in some major cities around the world to the heart Jersey.

    Photos
    Le Malt Royale
    Le Malt Royale - Smoking lounge

    Smoking lounge

    Le Malt Royale

    See all

    Buona Sera - Swordfish

    Buona Sera

    3.5(583 reviews)
    0.3 mi
    $$$

    We have not been here for quite some time, and when friends decided collectively to have a…read moreget-together, we were so glad we came here. The food was impeccable, and I must say, they truly do their meats extremely well. Here are some of the things we ordered. Please bear in mind that we had it family style, and the portions are humongous. - Antipasto - They truly had a sublime selection of Italian-style cured meats, which included Prosciutto di Parma, Soppressata, Mortadella, fresh Mozzarella Pearls, Red Onions, salad underneath, and balsamic glaze drizzled over the top, providing a sweet-tart contrast. It was a very nice high-end charcuterie platter. 5/5 Stars. - Fried Calamari - They lightly floured and fried it. Personally, I preferred it to be fried a bit more. 4/5 Stars. - Eggplant Rollatini - stuffed with ricotta, topped with marinara, and melted mozzarella. The eggplant was sliced thinly and was generously stuffed. 4/5 Stars. - Penne Vodka - They were in a light tomato pancetta cream sauce. I personally preferred a little spicier. 4/5 Stars. - Orrechiette pasta served with fresh tomatoes, garlic, and sausage, broccoli rabe, and basil in garlic & oil. They overcooked the sausage, but regardless, it truly was exceptional. 5/5 Stars - Shrimp scampi - It was overcooked. 3.5/5 Stars. - Boneless Roasted Chicken Cacciatore - the chicken was so tender and juicy. 5/5 Stars. - Pork Loin Giambotta - They grilled it to perfection, and it was still juicy. This dish was accompanied by mushrooms, onions, and peppers. 5/5 Stars. - Mashed red potatoes - Creamy and smooth. 5/5 Stars. The service was impeccable. They constantly came over to see if there was anything we needed. Plenty of wine and beer flowing, exchanging of dirty dishes for clean dishes, and ensuring we have everything we need.

    We've been there many times. The service for NYE was excellent. We were seated right away with our…read morereservation. We both had a drink to celebrate and started off with our appetizers. We had a wedge salad and lobster bisque soup. The portions were HUGE. I took home 1/2 of my soup I had the eggplant parmigiana with penne. I asked it to be served heat hot but it was more on the cool side. The eggplant had too much breading on it so it took away from the taste of parmigiana. My husband had penne with sausage and broccoli rabe. His dish was hot and he ordered a 1/2 portion but was overflowing. Both portions were very large and we took it all home. The decor was tastefully done for the holiday theme. Sorry to say I wasn't crazy about my dinner. But in another year, may go back

    Photos
    Buona Sera - View of the open kitchen

    View of the open kitchen

    Buona Sera - Mussels Marinara

    Mussels Marinara

    Buona Sera - Aperol spritz

    See all

    Aperol spritz

    Nicholas Barrel & Roost - A must have burrata dish - You will thank me!

    Nicholas Barrel & Roost

    3.9(538 reviews)
    1.1 mi
    $$

    Comfortable Contemporary Decor, subdued Lighting elevates the vibe in this warm and welcoming…read morerestaurant. Attentive Service who know the menu and ingredients as well as the drink specials and beers. The wine list is well rounded and concentrated to a carefully selected list. The beer offerings however are limited and they only offered one IPA Craft option. Could use more attention here. Servers could have a little more enthusiasm as some of ours were a bit sedate. Dinners were a tad delayed coming out, but nothing horrible. The Menu was assembled well and had some interesting options for starters which we did not partake in; the Raw Bar oysters are very fresh and cleaned well. Our salad we shared was good and could have been shared by 3-4 people as it was plentiful and $23, which was on par for most of the starter menu. The Strip Steak is prepared with a minimalist approach allowing the natural flavor of the beef to shine. Perfectly cooked, perfectly seasoned and with a beautiful aged nuttiness. A simple Rosemary sprig on top and you have a delicious meal. The Crispy Halibut was another dish that was well worth it. Delicately cooked fish in a beautiful sauce accompanied by some Bok Choy and Mushroom sauté. Impressive. Ending with Dessert, the S'mores Skillet rounded everything out. Overall easily could be 5 stars but subtle things subtracted just enough to land at a 4. Nonetheless; highly recommended!

    We chose Nicholas Barrel & Roost based on the menu and an almost 4 star rating on Yelp with over…read more500 reviews. The halibut caught my eye immediately; I'm a sucker for a perfectly prepared piece of halibut or a great pork chop, and since my partner doesn't eat meat it made for an easy share. Earlier in the day, a couple of women at our hotel bar mentioned the chef had trained at Jean-Georges in Manhattan, which only added to our anticipation. It wasn't until we got back to the hotel after dinner and did a little reading that we learned just how decorated Harary really is; his Restaurant Nicholas held Zagat's top spot in New Jersey for 15 consecutive years and earned a 4-star New York Times review. That context made our middling meal sting just a little more. We started with the bread service and the beet salad. The bread itself was baked beautifully, but the butter and ricotta accompanying it were completely flavorless. My partner and I are not salt-at-the-table people; we trust that seasoning happened in the kitchen. This was the first time in recent memory that we actually reached for the salt shaker. Not a great sign. The beet salad should have been a showstopper. Beets, when done right, can carry an entire dish on their own. Instead, they were buried under an avalanche of arugula. Don't get me wrong, arugula is one of my favorite greens; that peppery bite and beautiful texture are hard to beat, but here it was doing all the heavy lifting while the beets sat underneath doing nothing. We'd eaten most of the salad before we even noticed the sunflower seeds and a smear of mascarpone hiding on the bottom of the bowl. That mascarpone, gently flaked on top with the seeds scattered over it to catch in the folds, could have made this dish genuinely memorable. The gorgeous candy-striped radishes were a lovely visual touch, but they were raw, undressed slices with no seasoning, no acid, no pickling. Beautiful to look at; an afterthought to eat. The whole salad felt that way, honestly. For our main, we shared the Panko Crusted Halibut with bok choy and smoked shallot velouté. The sauce was the star; the smoke level was dialed in perfectly, present in all the right ways without overpowering everything else. The wild mushrooms were lovely, but the dish needed something to break up the texture. The bok choy brought good flavor, but it mirrored the mushrooms so closely that each bite started to blur together. Something crispy, something sharp, would have elevated the whole thing considerably. The fish itself was cooked well; firm, flakey, and not dried out. The panko crust was gorgeous to look at but could have been crispier. Based on its beautiful golden color, it looked like it had more crunch than it actually delivered. The cocktails were a genuine highlight. An old fashioned made with 1792 and a Black Manhattan, both well-crafted and the clearest bright spots of the evening. The three people behind the bar were another highlight. Expedient, attentive, never rushing anyone, and willing to make easy conversation without being intrusive. That is exactly what you want from people working a good bar. The ambiance, though, was confusing. The space seemed to pull in two directions at once; it wanted to feel upscale but also like a sports bar, and it never fully committed to either. Three small TVs tucked into the corners would have been fine. The oversized screen mounted prominently on the wall was intrusive and clashed hard with any sense of elevated dining. The music was classic rock, which I enjoy, but it read as wrong for the room and was a tad too loud. The music for this type of setting should be something to just add some ambiance, not for people to shout-sing too like you've had too many beers at a dive karaoke bar, which I love by the way, this was just not that kind of place. Those same women from the hotel bar had also warned us it could get loud and obnoxious in there. We figured we'd take our chances. We probably should have listened. With the legacy behind this place, the potential is clearly there. The bar staff gets it. Now the kitchen and the room just need to catch up.

    Photos
    Nicholas Barrel & Roost - Decor

    Decor

    Nicholas Barrel & Roost - Banana split

    Banana split

    Nicholas Barrel & Roost - Great wines

    See all

    Great wines

    26 West on the Navesink - Pork chop special

    26 West on the Navesink

    3.7(387 reviews)
    0.1 mi
    $$$

    We cannot say enough incredible things about 26 West on the Navesink. As an older couple…read morecelebrating our second marriage, we knew we didn't want a traditional wedding reception--we wanted something meaningful, personal, and full of joy. What we got was beyond anything we could have imagined. From the very beginning, Michaela and her team went above and beyond to bring our vision to life. Every request--big or small--was met with enthusiasm, creativity, and genuine care. I had collected so many unique and whimsical pieces to incorporate into our celebration, and Michaela placed every single detail throughout the restaurant with such thoughtfulness and style. It truly felt like us in every corner of the space. The atmosphere was warm, intimate, and beautifully personalized. Our guests are still talking about how special and different the evening felt--it was a true celebration, not just an event. And the food... absolutely outstanding. Every dish was delicious, beautifully presented, and served seamlessly. The entire experience felt effortless, which allowed us to fully enjoy every moment. We are so grateful to Michaela and the entire team for making our day unforgettable. If you're looking for a venue that will honor your vision and create something truly special, this is it. With heartfelt thanks, Helen and Paul Pricoli

    Went there for Mother's Day place was very pretty but we all left hungry the portions were small…read moreand the prime rib my husband had was all fat and at 72$ even that was small I had tuna which was delicious but it wasn't enough the food was good but for the price I will go elsewhere I would go for a drink but I don't want to leave a restaurant hungry so I dont think I will be dining there again

    Photos
    26 West on the Navesink - View of the Navesink while dining

    View of the Navesink while dining

    26 West on the Navesink
    26 West on the Navesink - Upstairs room

    See all

    Upstairs room

    The Robinson Ale House - Pretzel sticks with cheese

    The Robinson Ale House

    3.5(437 reviews)
    0.0 mi
    $$

    My family and I just had dinner at Robinson Ale House, and I have to say -- we were pleasantly…read moresurprised. We almost didn't go because of the 3.5-star rating, but the space looked promising and the menu caught our attention. I'm so glad we trusted our instincts. The decor is beautiful -- calm, cozy, and upscale without feeling stuffy. It has that warm, polished vibe that makes you want to settle in and actually enjoy your meal instead of feeling rushed. Our server, Devin, was fantastic. He was attentive, friendly, and genuinely kind. He checked in at the right times, answered all our questions, and made the whole experience feel easy and relaxed. And the food? Absolutely delicious. My family and I are pretty picky about our meats, which is one of the reasons we usually prefer eating at home. Everything tasted fresh and well-prepared -- flavorful without being overdone. You can tell care went into the quality. Overall, it was such a great experience. Definitely exceeded our expectations, and we'll be back.

    Classic spot in downtown Red Bank! Great to hangout and catch up with friends. Service was friendly…read moreand prompt and the overall vibe was great (even better in the summer). The food was average/ good, just about what I expected! I got the rigatoni vodka and I wish it was a bit more flavorful, but you're probably better off getting a burger at a spot like this. Will be back to try more!

    Photos
    The Robinson Ale House
    The Robinson Ale House - The Casey Burger

    The Casey Burger

    The Robinson Ale House

    See all

    Catezza Italian Kitchen + Bar - Calabrian tuna, pistachio & beat crostini

    Catezza Italian Kitchen + Bar

    3.8(31 reviews)
    0.0 mi
    $$$$

    There are quite a few nice restaurants in Red Bank. This one is in the top 4. From ambiance,…read moreservice to food...excellence prevails. The menu is small so, what does one choose. Obviously a matter of preference, but you have to try the meatballs...soft....wow can't say enough. Bread service is excellent. Their salads are above par. We did not try the Crostinis ie appetizers on toast. You can only eat so much. Onto the main course Branzino and Chicken Marsala. If you like seafood and chicken, there you go. Judging from the next table, the 12 inch pizza pies look really excellent. Cocktails made from an excellent barkeep keep the meal aplomb. Violet our server was very attentive. Parking as us locals know is sometimes a headache in Red Bank. Leave for your reservation early cause you will pay to park. Just think Asbury Park if you get the gist.

    Visited Catezza with a group of 8 for Jersey shore restaurant week…read more Jersey shore restaurant week is a fantastic opportunity to try new restaurants at a reasonable fixed cost. Catezza accommodated a table of 8 The restaurant is beautiful with a good size bar at the front of the restaurant Lovely drink menu with some high end bourbons at a reasonable cost. We sat near the open kitchen which was an absolute treat I enjoyed the meal, the desserts are stellar. Disappointed that the kitchen ran out of a few items. The spicy tuna over crispy rice with Calabrian chile sauce was very good. I prefer the tuna diced and mixed, this reminded me of poke. The meatballs were a huge appetizer portion of 3 and they were excellent The short rib over saffron risotto was very good, loved the crunch from the rapini. Their gelato is excellent as was the limoncello bread pudding. Michael took great care of us. I look forward to dining with Catezza again.

    Photos
    Catezza Italian Kitchen + Bar - Bar area

    Bar area

    Catezza Italian Kitchen + Bar - Headless Branzino w/ sliced almonds and green beans

    Headless Branzino w/ sliced almonds and green beans

    Catezza Italian Kitchen + Bar - Downstairs dining room at Catezza!

    See all

    Downstairs dining room at Catezza!

    Falcone - Cannoli

    Falcone

    4.3(42 reviews)
    3.2 mi

    What an absolutely delicious dinner. The hospitality from the moment we drove to the valet, to the…read moreproper entrance with the hosts and throughout the entire meal was purposeful and thought out. The employees here care about your experience. My wife and i have only lived down here since January. We've explored restaurants from Red Bank through the shore. This was #1 so far, I would actually look forward to dining here again. Alan, our server, you're very good at what you do. Thank you for that. Get yourself a nice bottle of wine, head here. Order anything and sit back and enjoy the experience. It was absolutely beautiful inside for my 45th!

    Falcone in Lincroft is basically what happens when someone spends 95% of the budget on interior…read moredesign and 5% on the actual food. The restaurant itself? Beautiful. Gorgeous lighting, trendy aesthetic, romantic atmosphere. If your goal is taking photos for Instagram or pretending you're dining in Manhattan for the night, this is your place. The food, however, was wildly underwhelming for the prices. I ordered the "short rib" bolognese and spent half the meal trying to locate the short rib. It looked and tasted more like regular chopped meat sauce than slow-braised short rib. I've honestly had pasta dishes from local pizza places with more flavor and authenticity. And the candles... there are approximately 47,000 candles in this restaurant. So many that at one point a waiter leaned dangerously close to one and I genuinely thought his vest was about to catch fire -- meanwhile he had absolutely no idea. That pretty much summed up the overall dining experience: chaotic but aesthetic. Also, why is there forced valet in Lincroft? Even when you self-park, they still ask for your keys like you arrived in a Bentley instead of a Honda Pilot. Another strange touch: it's BYOB, yet they keep your wine bottle off to the side somewhere instead of leaving it at the table. The whole point of BYOB is being able to pour your own wine whenever you want without having to flag someone down every time your glass is empty. It felt unnecessarily pretentious for no reason. The biggest issue was that the restaurant never actually felt authentically Italian beyond the decor. For a place charging premium prices and branding itself as an upscale Italian dining experience, there should be a stronger sense of Italian hospitality, personality, culture, and presentation throughout the service experience. Instead, the whole thing felt more staged than genuine. Communication around the specials was difficult, nothing was written down, and the service lacked the polished confidence you expect at this price point. Ironically, the teenage valet outside gave more authentic Italian restaurant energy than the dining room itself. My suggestion? Lean harder into genuine hospitality and authentic Italian dining culture instead of just the aesthetic. Right now it feels like a beautifully designed movie set where the food and service never quite match the image. Overall: probably a nice place for cocktails, dessert, and ambiance before or after a night in Red Bank. But if you're going specifically for an amazing Italian dinner worthy of the prices, save your money and hit a really good local pizzeria instead. I promise if you change the wait staff to people who have a little more command of the English language... the word on the street would probably improve.

    Photos
    Falcone - Beautiful space!!

    Beautiful space!!

    Falcone - Save room for tiramisu

    Save room for tiramisu

    Falcone

    See all

    Olde Gotham - lounges - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...