Cancel

Open app

Search

Old Pueblo Grill Cantina

4.1 (16 reviews)
Open • 12:00 pm - 9:00 PM

Order Old Pueblo Grill Cantina Takeout or Delivery

Old Pueblo Grill Cantina Photos

Business Info

OLD PUEBLO GRILL CANTINA ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?

You might also consider

More like Old Pueblo Grill Cantina

Recommended Reviews - Old Pueblo Grill Cantina

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Wow! The chips and salsa really hit the spot!
Gianna T.

This place is a hidden gem! The decor is colorful. The menu was a bit daunting but our server was very helpful. We both ordered chimis. Wow! Huge! Flavorful! Presentation was wonderful! Try this place but come hungry! We will be back - often!

Enchiladas
Regina P.

The food was great and they gave pretty hefty portions. The salsa has a kick which was such a nice surprise because Mexican restaurants out here usually don't serve spicy salsa. (I'm from SoCal so I know my stuff haha) The elote bowl was my favorite We sat at the bar and the service was so fast, it's a pretty big space and the music fit the vibe. We'll definitely be back!

Red and Green Salsa, Guacamole, Queso
Scott W.

We are huge fans of Old Pueblo Grill downtown, so we have been anxiously awaiting its opening here in Webster for what seemed like forever. We started with salsa, guacamole, and queso with our chips. The salsas were both spectacular. Guacamole was super dreamy. The queso, however, was odd and something no one in our party enjoyed. We do love the queso downtown, which is what we were expecting but did not receive. Switching to entrees, we were very excited to see Enchiladas Montadas -- stacked enchiladas as we've eaten in southern New Mexico. We found the red sauce one to be really great. The green sauce version was very tasty, though the sauce had broken and/or seized up. Our additional companion ordered Enchiladas Suiza with green sauce. Again, the green sauce had good flavor but was not good consistency and they didn't end up finishing their meal. We are still giving the review a 4 star because this could be some bumps in a new opening. We will definitely return. We will definitely try the green sauce again, however, we will be avoiding the queso.

Classic margarita and Prickly Pear margarita
Harrison G.

I went to the Victor, NY location and recall not being blown away by the food, however, I thought I'd give it a shot with full service experience. We started with chips and salsa and the birria eggrolls. As others have said, the salsas are great. The birria eggrolls were amazing. The eggroll is a great vessel for birria. Great flavor, texture, and presentation. I ordered the "Cali Swag" burrito. The overall flavor was great, however, the carne asada was a little fatty and the fries were kinda soggy but it was still an enjoyable item. My companion ordered a carnitas taco, carne asada taco, and the elote for an entree. She had the same complaints about the carne asada being fatty. But the carnitas were spectacular. Really flavorful and tender. The elote had good flavor but the corn was overcooked and lacked good texture. Service was a bit slow, but I don't blame my server for this as, as far as I can tell, she was also the primary bartender. The restaurant is a bit noisy and they played a weird mix of NBC Nightly News and World Whiffle Ball Championships but it also kinda worked so I can't knock it. This is a new place so growing pains are expected and I will certainly come back to try it again!

Queso

See all

6 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

9 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 1
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Gianna T.
16
15
21

1 year ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 1
Love this 1
Oh no 0

8 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Kristin G.
25
61
110

11 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 1
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 1

1 year ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 1
Photo of Paul R.
0
125
0

1 year ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 1
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 1

Ask the Community - Old Pueblo Grill Cantina

You might also consider

Mecate Mexican Restaurant - Burrito

Mecate Mexican Restaurant

4.0(22 reviews)
0.2 mi
•$$

I had to try Mecate after they opened in Webster, and I'm so glad I did. I used to go to Monte…read moreAlban a lot, but this is now my favorite Mexican restaurant. The interior is decorated with a nice Mexican flair, and there's plenty of seating with both booths and tables. The chips and salsa are so good! They also have a great selection of alcoholic drinks, although there aren't many non-alcoholic options. My friends always enjoy their drinks. One time we visited, they were even passing around samples of margarita ice cream they were testing, which was a fun touch. I always order the birria tacos--they come with rice and refried beans, and they're delicious. I also love that I can usually walk in and get a table right away.

Mecate has become our favorite Mexican restaurant second to Monte Alban in Webster. The waiters are…read morealways friendly. The drinks are delicious and they offer happy hours. As a group, you get two basket of chips and salsa for free. Any additional is $2 per basket after. For drinks we ordered a pink passion, la grandeza margarita, and a frozen house strawberry margarita. For our entree, we ordered enchiladas suizas, fajitas texanas, and a traditional burrito. Everything for the most part was delicious. The areas we thought were lacking were the burrito and beans. The burrito was a bit bland, could use a sauce on top. The refried beans were gross. They tasted like they had some unnecessary spice in there. For my gluten free folks, many of the dishes are made with corn tortillas, so there are options such as enchiladas, fajitas, tacos. However, not safe with those with celiac disease due to cross contamination. Included is some pics from a previous visit.

Photos
Mecate Mexican Restaurant - Dining area

Dining area

Mecate Mexican Restaurant - Taco Salad

Taco Salad

Mecate Mexican Restaurant - Birria tacos

See all

Birria tacos

The Easy Sailor - Huge selection on rum

The Easy Sailor

4.4(19 reviews)
4.9 mi•East Avenue

If you're looking for a unique and fun dinner/bar in Rochester for a date night or group event…read more... This is PERFECT. It's almost like a speakeasy, where the front is set up like a travel agency and once you're checked in you get transported into this hidden gem tiki bar!! The food was delicious! I came here with my bf and friends. They were able to accommodate our allergies as well (I'm gluten free and my bf can't have dairy, eggs, nuts, fish, and they were still able to give him lots of food!). They had lots of fun drinks on the menu too. Definitely coming back here!

Made a reservation per the website recommendation and it is small inside so if you want to be sure…read moreto get a table, I'd agree. It's a fun little spot. The outside is decorated as a travel agency and the host walks you in. Our server was friendly and answered our questions about the drinks and food. Their menu is a "sharing menu". I will say that I think the best value are their family style platters. We tried the Mahalo pork which was good. Likely enough for 2-3 people. The Duck Spring Rolls were good but I didn't ask how many came in an order. It's 2 rolls for $18, which is not a great value. The Yaki Skewers were good. We got the shoyu chicken but again it's $15 for 3 skewers so not a great value. Drinks average $18 but they were good and came with fun umbrellas etc. Overall we'd return for drinks and maybe the pork platter. 4 stars for service and theme but 3 stars for overall value. They are right next to the paid lot and do validate but be aware you can get towed if the validation doesn't process for some reason. Yes, we've seen it happen

Photos
The Easy Sailor - Cool Tiki tunes jamming from the travel agent's desk

Cool Tiki tunes jamming from the travel agent's desk

The Easy Sailor
The Easy Sailor - Great Tiki Bar

See all

Great Tiki Bar

Avvino - Flat bread: onion, gruyere, and mustard aoli.

Avvino

4.5(424 reviews)
5.8 mi
•$$$

Our family was visiting Rochester from out of town to celebrate our son's college graduation. We…read morebooked the private room at Avvino (Meyer's Den), which turned out to be a great choice. While planning our dinner party months in advance, the communication from Janine was excellent. She helped us develop a 4-course menu that was sure to have something for everyone, including vegan and allergy friendly options. Amy was our server for the evening, and she ensured we had everything we needed to enjoy our evening. The chairs in the Meyer's Den are wide and comfortable, the decor is dark and classy, and being in the basement away from the dining room made it very quiet and easy to converse with family. The room is rather spacious for 12 guests, but could also accommodate a few more people without feeling cramped. Out of the appetizers we selected, the Charred Octopus was very popular and everyone enjoyed it...even those that had never previously eaten octopus. The baby cauliflower dish was also a beautiful presentation, and quite large and enjoyable. The salads, particularly the Charred Hurricane salad, were nice light courses before the entree was served. As for the entrees, the filet mignon was a little on the dry side, but we really enjoyed the light and crispy spinach fritters that accompanied the beef. The salmon was a generous portion of medium rare fish, and there was lot going on with that dish - spicy cauliflower and za'atar potatoes that had some mixed reviews. Folks who ordered the duck breast seemed to enjoy the complex preparation, which had asparagus, green beans, and two pureed sauces - cauliflower ginger and cherry-rhubarb. The doughnut bread pudding with apple pieces and vanilla ice cream was a delicious, decadent way to end the meal. We left rather stuffed, and delighted with the overall experience that allowed our family to celebrate together.

I'd say I had a good experience dining here. It was my birthday and I went in with a few friends…read more We were promptly attended to. I ordered a mocktail to start off and it was pretty good. For appetizers, we got the roasted beets and the bone marrow. Both were good. I got the duck breast for entree and my friends got the carrot cavatelli and lobster bucatini. We all enjoyed our dishes. The duck was succulent and roasted just enough. The Brussel sprouts that came on the side were a disappointment though. For dessert, I ordered ricotta pine nut tart with lemon sorbet. The tart was very subtle in flavor but good. My friends ordered the bread pudding which was great as well. Overall, very satisfied with the food and service. Can be back!

Photos
Avvino
Avvino - Filet mignon and spinach fritters.

Filet mignon and spinach fritters.

Avvino - Decor

See all

Decor

La Bola - This  Seasonal Ricotta Toast was delicious! It featured a Blackberry Marmalade, Marconi Almonds, Madonna Salt  and Black Pepper Honey.

La Bola

4.6(21 reviews)
5.8 mi•Center City

Well this is a gem of a restaurant in the city of Rochester!!!! I just left La Bola with my family…read morecelebrating my nieces graduation and I cannot praise this place enough. From our hostess Jenna being so kind and accommodating to the table placement and the food was lick your fingers clean. The beautifully decorated seating area and bar is very inviting. We had the shrimp scampi, lamb kabobs Focaccia and basmati rice. We ordered a second Focaccia cause it was damn good the first time. All cooked to perfection. Well seasoned and the perfect portion size. If I'm ever in Rochester again I'll be back. Our thanks to the chef..... just delicious.

I had high expectations for this place based on the reviews, but boy I was disappointed with the…read morefood! The ambience was more like an open food hall meets bar venue but somehow it didn't click with me. We were the only other occupied table for a weekday dinner. Service was prompt but that's probably the only good thing. I got a mocktail which was watery and patatas bravas for appetizer. It was good but a bit saltier for my palate. I got the duck confit which was deplorable. The duck leg was scaly and dry and the sauce and the cauliflower didn't make up for it. My friend got the house burger and she said she liked it. I'm glad we didn't order dessert, it may have been another disappointment. Overall, a meh experience.

Photos
La Bola - Open Bar area with several overhead TV screens for sports game watching.

Open Bar area with several overhead TV screens for sports game watching.

La Bola - Mafia Rita

Mafia Rita

La Bola - This is one of the Signature Coctails made with pears. My guest said it was very unique and delicious.

See all

This is one of the Signature Coctails made with pears. My guest said it was very unique and delicious.

Old Pueblo Grill Cantina - mexican - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...