I rented the Parlor Room for my husband's surprise birthday party and this place was PERFECT!! The food was delicious and the service was exceptional!! I would recommed this place over and over again. Kelly was incredible and provided all the necessary information I needed and then some! Our waitress was absolutely THE BEST. I believe she was made just for our special time!! read more

Old Mill Brew Pub- Lexington I've been a customer here several times over the years and feel as though this particular review is in line with previous experiences. In short there was nothing above average. Not the service, the food nor the atmosphere. We sat on the deck as we had dogs with us. Props for allowing dogs. ( They didn't supply water , we had to go get our bowl. I'm not dissing for this but I do tip heavily for servers who bring water). There's an empty pond to look at and the flies were noticeably present. There was a large fan that supplied a breeze that kept most bugs away until the table behind us complained and the staff turned the fan off. What should have happened was that table be moved so the rest of us didn't suffer. With the fan off the bugs were horrible- to the point I just quit eating. The service was average. The waitress wasn't particularly friendly nor attentive. Once my drink runs dry I'm unhappy. The food was a mix of good & disappointment. Two guests had the lobster ravioli and were not impressed. The sweet potato fries were excellent and the BBQ was unexpectedly delicious. Overall it was average & I'd patronize again if I had dogs with me or someone in my party wanted to go- with one caveat and that would be bug free weather. read more

See all

We absolutely love eating at this place. Killer food!!! Personal favorites are the burgers, nachos with chicken, anything that's a pretzel because they are fresh and so freaking good, the cocktails specials are always delicious. We usually visit at least once a week. Taco Tuesday special is probably the best! $8 for 3 tacos and a $5 margarita. Enjoy the pictures! read more

See all

This was an unusual visit. Service was a bit slow and I understand about labor issues these days. The food came out and looked good. I ordered the Cuban missile crisis and collards. The collards were fantastic. The first bite of the sandwich was amazing but the second bite was into plastic that had been cooked into the meat. It took for ever to get anyone to come over to the table and then there really was not an apology just do you want another one. Everyone else had finished eating and were ready to go at that point. I was left hungry and a bit pissed. Everyone else enjoyed their food so that's why I can give 2 stars. read more

My husband ordered take out from here to feed our family of four during the Covid-19 pandemic. We are very happy to support local during this time because the struggle is truly real with all of these businesses. In terms of food, I ordered the brew pub burger with sweet potato fries and my husband ordered the mac attack burger with fries. My littlest had the kids cheese pizza and my oldest had the kids mini burgers with cheese and bacon. Both of my kids cleaned their plates with no complaints. As for my husband, he did the same. As for me and my brew pub burger, well it was a little challenging to finish but I did it! I enjoyed every bite. Their burgers aren't served with mayo, ketchup, or mustard, just the fixings that are described on the menu. I appreciate that! If I wanted all the fixings that came on a burger, I would go get my fix elsewhere for that. Their burgers here are somewhat unique in that sense and very flavorful! After eating their brew pub burger, I have officially decided that a fried egg (sunny side up especially) on top of a burger is one of my favorite food combinations. Their regular fries are delicious and so are their sweet potatoes fries. Excellent work, chefs! Keep up the good work! read more

Old Mill Brewpub - Mac Attack burger - American Near Me - Lexington, South Carolina

See all

I'm going to start off by saying the BEER is 5 stars! Let's get that straight. My issue was with my meal. It was just lackluster and didn't live up to my expectations. It was supposed to be a ribeye with peppercorn sauce and parmesan rosemary fries. I ordered my steak medium rare. They nailed the internal temperature but the sear on the outside was more of a burnt char. The peppercorn sauce was a cold pat of butter with peppercorn in it. The fries were crispy shoestring potatoes, but there was no parmesan , almost no salt, and one sprig of dried up rosemary that wasn't really edible. I ate some and took the rest home to be repurposed. I'll give them another chance because anyone can have a bad day. I think I will try a burger next time. read more

Visited here for dinner and drinks Friday at 5pm. The place was very slow, although it took ten minutes before we were seated. Drinks came quickly and were good. Dinner and appetizers were extremely slow. 30 minute wait from ordering to receive Pretzels and cheese. 45 minutes to receive our meals. Pretzels were good and fries good. Burger was over cooked, dry and hard. Server was a very nice lady but the kitchen here is terrible. Will not return. read more

We like going here every so often. The food is good if you stick with the sandwiches and salads and I love the atmosphere. There really went through some tough times, and here they are, still chugging along. I admire that. The owners must be really good business owners and good people. Our experience last night was the best yet. The service was terrific as usual. My husband had the french dip, which he really liked. But the main reason I came here was to praise the southwestern salad I chose. It was quite simply, the best salad of this type I have ever had. And I have had quite a few. I love tex-mex type food. This restaurant has moved up the list of places we will choose from when have our weekly dinner out, even though it's more of a drive than we usually like. read more

The service and the atmosphere were great. I just wasn't a fan of the menu. It seemed like it needed something more on it.

I had the Brisket Melt, and I substituted smoked gouda for the Swiss. The sandwich was really tasty, just wish there had been a little more brisket on it. But all in all, it was very good. Washed it down with a cold PBR, yum. read more

Staff - 5 stars Beer - 5 stars Ambiance - 5 stars Burgers - 1 star This place certainly has potential, but they have no earthly idea of how to make a burger patty. They clearly use a burger press to smash a burger patty as tightly as possible, which leaves you a dense hockey puck with no flavor. Let me educate you on how to properly make a burger patty. First get yourself a 5 to 5 1/2 inch metal ring. Next take a half a pound of 80/20 ground beef and put it in the ring. Gently push down with your hands until the meat spreads evenly in the ring. The less you touch it the better. Take the ring off and put it on a griddle for about three to four minutes per side. Whatever you do, don't smash the patty with a spatula as it will lose all of its precious juice. I'm happy to show you if you want a demonstration. read more

Enjoyed our evening out for dinner at Old Mill Brewpub. It was a nice evening and sit outside. Service was great, food was good and overall will be going back read more

Brewery, food and atmosphere are all top notch!! They have different rooms and places to eat/drink so it's all around place.

It must have been a bad day for the restaurant! We waited over one hour and thirty minutes to be seated. My hamburger was fairly good. Not much taste. Our waitress needed help! The restaurant smelled musty the carpeting was tattered and appeared to be very dirty next to my table. This was not a good experience. read more

I had a burger and onion rings. It was alright. It could've benefitted from more seasoning and it wasn't that hot, temperature wise. The bartender, I forget his name, was amazing!! We were able to get seated right before the giant party that was starting outside. There were a couple more parties in the dining area and that made our wait for the food quite a while. What I do really appreciate is that they actually let us know that food was going to take a while because of the parties they had BEFORE we were seated! It was nice of them to be upfront about the time. I would go back and try something else from their menu to give it another shot. read more

Food was great and service was wonderful. Great atmosphere too! They are short staffed, but our waitress was so friendly that the wait time was not an issue! read more

What a gem!! Such great food, beer, and service!!! Definitely stop if you're in the area or passing through! read more

Old Mill Brewpub - American Near Me - Lexington, South Carolina

We love the Old Mill! We live in the apartment complex just down the road, so we can sometimes walk to the Old Mill! Their food is great and their service is always great! Today we brought our dog and they served her water and several waitresses came out and petted her. It was precious! read more

Old Mill Brewpub - American Near Me - Lexington, South Carolina

The " brisket" sandwich was bottom round and tough as leather. Misrepresented and over priced for what it is. I've been butcher for 45 years, so I know. Also water refills are warm. No more cold water served ??? Don't think I'll be going back read more

Me and my husband came to have lunch we sat outside cus it was to nice outside to not to, I got a raspberry margarita, while he did an old fashion. Hands down the best margarita, so good I had 3. For lunch I had a Philly cheese, it could if used a tad bit more sauce on it but overall was good! read more

Old Mill Brewpub - Raspberry margarita - American Near Me - Lexington, South Carolina

I have been here before. But I live on the other side of town and haven't been in a while. We wanted to try Matt's brewery out and this restaurant was perfect since it's in the same building. The food was very good I got the hamburger with coffee rub. It wasn't bad. I also go the sweet potato fries. (There wasn't but a few sweet potatoes fries) my wife love the food she got also. The waitress was very friendly. We sat outside on the deck. Later thinking that was a bad idea. (There should be a sign. "Your kid much be on a leash" yeah they were that bad. And I had two daughters and a son. ) That wasn't the restaurant fault. Like I said the food was great and the restaurant was nice. read more

We ordered the Old Mill burger with sweet potato fries and the Hella Gouda burger with onion rings for takeout. I could have done without the pepper gravy on the Old Mill burger. The burgers and sides were good and they were cooked properly. read more

See all

Decided to give Old Mill a try! Place was packed so we sat in the bar! Had a couple delicious IPAs that were recommended by our bartender (who was awesome). For dinner had the Masters Flatbread. If you haven't tried this then you are missing out. Absolutely amazing! read more

Stay away from this place. It might look nice in the outside, but you're in for an adventure. We were sat outside. As we sat there for 15 minutes waiting for someone to wait on us. The best fun was everyone that's running or walking on that trail pushes their way through to go use the bathroom. They don't care that you're sitting there and they're squeezing by everyone and then racing back out. So you're sitting through a cut through for everyone to take a leak. Let's get to the food we ordered two items. They were dried out overcooked and to be honest, it looked like old frozen food when you ripped it apart. Chicken was a gray color and the pork chop was well. I don't know. Just don't get it if you go there. but the best part is that the table behind us had people there that had their dog sleeping on top of the table. After they left, no one came out to clean the table. They ended up sitting another family there. Outrageous that the staff will allow animals to lay up on top of their tables .they don't even bother to clean anything. It was a terrible place six months ago when we were there, we tried it again and it was even worse. Maybe they should try some fresh food instead of some frozen crap that they get out of the freezer and fry until you can't eat it. Avoid this place I guess go to McDonald's at least you know what you're getting there. read more

The Old Mill Brewpub arranged an catered a Rehearsal Party for 80 in the historic Old Mill. Kelly and her entire staff , especially Kelsey and Doug couldn't have made it any better on every aspect , especially concerning COVID restrictions. Kelly was extremely professional and catered to our questions and concerns. Great job setting up the venue and execution of the Food and Beverages. Couldn't have been any more pleased and would suggest anyone who is looking for such a size event to have it there. Heard many compliments from our guest and thought it was worth every penny . Would definitely trust them with another event. read more

Old Mill Brewpub - American Near Me - Lexington, South Carolina

Brisket. sandwich. Get it! I wasn't sure if I'd like the horseradish... but I'm not sure it's even there. Just a great sandwich. The fries and spin dip are , too. Panini, although good, is a touch heavy on pesto - and not the traditional smashed sourdough recipe. Nice pub... clean... and welcoming. read more

Great place to take family and friends or do you have a big family gathering? They have a large table in the back

The staff and owners are amazing and the food is always tasty. Even in the midst of storms, they jump in to provide for our community!!!! I can't say enough about the Old Mill Brewpub. read more

Every now again I venture to Lexington to visit with to a have few beers. This is one of the spots we meet up to a drink hazy IPA or some new sour that just landed. Joey is an older man who is always attending to us getting us food and clean glasses if we need them or nachos. The restaurant manager will always come by to see us every visit. Plenty of parking and clean restrooms. We always enjoy their fries with beers please order the ranch to dip them in as that is the best way. I'm sure there's a lot more to say about The Old Mill but for now that is all I have to say, so keep up the good work and give your staff praise. read more

Old Mill Brewpub - fries - American Near Me - Lexington, South Carolina

See all

Good food, beer and service from Joey at the bar. The she-crab soup was outstanding and Taco Tuesday was a winner. Cozy environment. Will definitely go back again. read more

We showed up and told there was a long wait but bar seating was first come first serve. After standing at an open, dirty table for over 10 min I asked the waitress serving the able next to us if she was able to clean off this table so we could sit. She was more than happy to help as she was training a new staff member. The male bartender comes around the bar and pulls the dishes from her arms and says" thanks but you don't need to clean this I'm gonna have to wipe it down still "as he gives us attitude. As she walks past the bar he stops them again and says "they are young to have to wait a while anyways since I'm busy and I wasn't ready to get to it" . I have never been to a restaurant where I was as so off putted by the rudeness of a bartender. Completely non-welcoming! We walked right out of there as I wouldn't be caught dead spending money in an establishment that continues to employee that kind of person. read more

The Old Mill Brewpub is a quaint, rustic, local down-home place that is constantly getting better over the years. Actually located in an old textile mill adjacent to a mill pond, it is known for its delicious She-Crab Soup, although all other entrees are first-rate. There is an emphasis on fried fare, which will please those raised in the South but may leave some disappointed there aren't more healthier options. This said, the salad offerings are creative and fresh, and food is served piping hot, fresh, and by friendly staff. Burgers are large and the sandwiches loaded. The separate bar area is a comfortable place to unwind with a great selection of beer and wine and appetizers. The Old Mill is where the locals eat and for good reason. Be prepared not only for down home hospitality with an abundance of fine food. read more

Horrible food & service. We've given them 3 tries on 3 different visits & it's always the same. Don't waste your money.

The ambiance was nice server was very courteous and met all of our needs. It goes downhill from there. The food was mediocrely ordered mashed potatoes with my meals and it was ice cold the nachos that we had as an appetizer with some old Velveeta dried-up cheese with some old tortilla chips. read more

Great place to eat. The service was perfect and the food good. Rarely do I get perfect service. The shrimp and Grits were wonderful and recommended. The nachos were ok. However, there are several other choices available that sound great. I hope to try them soon. There is a dining area inside and out, and also a bar area. I'll be back. Coupons are available, download the app. read more

Old Mill Brewpub - Nachos - American Near Me - Lexington, South Carolina

See all

My husband and I went to the Old Mill Brewpub today for lunch. it was DELICIOUS!!! My husband had the Missile Crisis and I had the Brisket Melt. the food came out quick and hot. we shared the Mac N Cheese!! Very good. They were busy and short staffed (there was a sign at the entrance asking patrons to be patient). The owner got our drinks and placed our order. Everyone was so friendly and professional! We will definitely go here again!! read more

The environment was nice and understand it was nicer before the damage. Glad they were able to open back up. The food was good and the waitress knowledgeable about the menu items and beer. We got Happy hour prices for our beer. Service was slow. I know they were busy and could of used more help. read more

Excellent food and fantastic service!! The bar makes amazing cocktails and they have a huge variety beyond their menu.

We celebrated my daughter's 17th birthday last night. We were in the party room and it was great! Our waitress, Ashley, was wonderful! The service and food were an A+! Burgers were great and the fish and chips were perfect. read more

Food was disgusting, I got the chicken panini and the chicken was rubbery and nasty. The Mac and Cheese was stuck together like a brick, they didn't even take the time to microwave it long enough.... Just hoping I don't get sick from the chicken. They took my sandwich off and charged me full price for the sides.... Awful experience read more