I love steakums and we were working out of town in COlumbus. I have had it three times twice in row, and let me tell ya it was one of the best steaks I have ever had...And I know good steak. Dont let the looks fool you this place Crushes it which is probably why they've been there 53 years. read more

The place isn't fancy, but the steaks and service are good! My boys and I were headed to a weekend getaway, and this place had many good reviews. They were right. One of my sons and I both got filets. The other one got the T-bone. read more

Great Steak! Tender, well seasoned and cooked to desired term. If looking for grill steak on charcoal this is a place to take in consideration. Be aware it is a very simple place. Non elaborate food type of restaurant. Dining room area is very modest with just what it needs to function. It is what it is. Steak, salad and bake potato. Salad is simple served: Lettuce, a tomato edge and desired dressing. Same with the stake. Your beef with bake potato (butter and sour cream as an option). That's it. read more

Old Hickory Steak House - 11/15/25 - Steakhouses Near Me - Columbus, Mississippi

A great local place with plenty of ambiance. The service was fantastic. Baked potatoes were spot on. Ice cold beer. The steaks are not prime or choice but tasty. Loved the character of the place. read more

See all

Old Hickory Steak House is the kind of hidden gem you almost don't want to tell people about. Tucked inside an old-time shack, it keeps things simple with a small, no-nonsense menu, incredibly friendly staff, and steaks cooked absolutely perfectly every time. It's cozy, unpretentious, and full of character--the kind of place where the food speaks for itself and you leave already planning your next visit. read more

Old Hickory Steak House - Ribeye and baked potato - Steakhouses Near Me - Columbus, Mississippi

See all

Couldn't have been happier to eat a meal prepared at this steakhouse. It was Valentine's Day and they opened 30 minutes early to let a long line of patrons inside. The ribeye steak, salad, baked potato, and bread were delicious and cooked to perfection! The staff, especially the waitress, Whitney, was an absolute joy as our waitress. Service was efficient. We were in and out of the restaurant within an hour! Highly recommend this establishment if you want a wonderful meal with a down home environment. read more

Old Hickory Steak House - Steakhouses Near Me - Columbus, Mississippi

Perfection!!! Filet was cooked spot on with the best flavor tasted. Baked potato cooked just right with butter and sour cream. Will be back when town. read more

Awesome little place!! Simple menu done brilliantly!! Great flavor, great old school feel. Had the sirloin steak and it was perfection read more

See all

May be the best steak I've ever eaten, and I've eaten many. I used to my business travel around passing through Columbus so I could eat here. Love the hole in the wall feel, simple menu, and service is always good. If you're in the area, you have to try this place. This is one of my all time favorite steakhouses. read more

Best steaks in Columbus ! Been eating here since I was 13 and nothing's changed except the chef, sure miss Mr.Bobby but Miss Marty's still going strong and the steaks are almost as good as I can remember ! Can't wait to come back and eat again. read more

Old Hickory Steak House - 2 large ribeyes, baked potatoes & Texas toast - Steakhouses Near Me - Columbus, Mississippi

I'm a huge fan of this place. I always get the large ribeye and no potato or bread. They are always happy to substitute an extra salad which is great for my keto diet. Service is always great. This is about as basic a steakhouse as you'll find anywhere. Nothing fancy, just delicious steak. My kind of place! read more

Old Hickory Steak House - My steak - Steakhouses Near Me - Columbus, Mississippi

See all

I had the ribeye and it was incredibly flavorful. Cooked medium rare just the way I like it, with a nice sear on the outside and juicy in the middle. The seasoning was simple but spot-on, letting the beef speak for itself. My mashed potatoes were creamy and buttery, a perfect side. The server was polite and gave me a great wine suggestion. The place was cozy and had a warm atmosphere. Will definitely be back. read more

Old Hickory Steak House - Steakhouses Near Me - Columbus, Mississippi

I've ate here a few times since my review and the last was this weekend. They still have great food. The garlic bread is great. I wish other steak houses would go back to this. The brown chocolate looking or better yet turd looking loaves you get at other places are disgusting. This weekend, I decided to try the 16 Oz. Sirloin. I've never ordered it here and it was the best I've ever ate in a restaurant. I have my doubts that it made the full 16, but it was great. I believe I could've ate the Sirloin for 2. The only thing I hate about this place is that I keep getting Marty as my waitress. I hate to be mean, but when you're paying 38-44 dollars a steak, you should get refills on drinks. Getting a refill from her is like getting the truth from a Democrat. It's virtually impossible! I don't know what her problem is, but I wish I could get someone else when I visit. Then it would be 5 stars. read more

This was the best steak dinner I've had. No need to put anything on it. The steak was so flavorful! The service is amazing and during the week, there's no wait! read more

See all

The ribeye steak was awesome! And cooked medium rare, just the way we requested. It's so hard finding a place to get it just the way you want. Very simple menu with basic salad, baked potato and garlic Texas toast, but really nothing else is needed here. Service was also great. Very rustic place, but well worth it! read more

Old Hickory Steak House - 14oz ribeye - Steakhouses Near Me - Columbus, Mississippi

Best steak I've had in the GTR. I love that they keep it simple, charcoal grill it and the service is awesome as well as the price. Definitely was my favorite meal this trip! read more

Old Hickory Steak House - Menu 9/2024 - Steakhouses Near Me - Columbus, Mississippi

Absolutely loved it. Cute ambiance and the food was absolutely delicious. I had the Filet with a side salad and baked potato. Yum! read more

Old Hickory Steak House - Steak, steak and more steak! - Steakhouses Near Me - Columbus, Mississippi

Don't get me wrong. Been going here for years, and the e steak is one of the best I've ever had. But now looked at your menu, and $74 for a steak for 2 is a Lotta much. Yall gonna charge that much you need to at least update your salad and potatoes. Need to at least have the potato available loaded and more veggies and croutons available on the salads for that price. Don't know that I can afford to come back soon for those prices. ​ read more

Steaks are great as usual just ask for Martie when ya get ya get there Love it when we go there read more

No need to dress up here - I love the casual ambience I ordered the filet medium - it was cooked perfectly You get a simple salad and you choose your dressing, you can add cheese on your salad or baked potato for a very small extra charge Garlic cheese toast is simple but good Waitress this time was rather unfriendly but typically they are over the top attentive and friendly so I am still giving five stars based on past experiences, and there were six of us so not as easy to serve read more

Great service better food! Steaks were perfect. A 10 min wait but it wasn't bad at all. We will be back!

Went over the weekend with my sister-in-law who lives nearby. Got there at 5:45 which was a little early for us, but it fills up fast so we didn't want to wait. I had the large ribeye thinking there would be a little fat to remove --- there was not .. the 14 oz is 14 oz. Was perfectly grilled, tender and seasoned well. Great place for basic no frills night out with delicious food at reasonable prices... Go if you get a chance! read more

Everyone says this is the place to go. We tried it out. To be honest I wasn't impressed. The food was ok and the service was mediocre at best. I felt the cost was way too high for the quality of the food. Probably won't return. read more

Want a great steak, loaded baked potato and salad? This is your place! I would call this a no-stress express restaurant: get in, eat, leave happy. The service is speedy and polite. The place is small, very casual and relaxed - not a white linen steakhouse. read more

See all

Y'all know Kim prefers sirloin steak, and the charcoal grilled sirloin here is just what she was looking for. I prefer the filet, and the one they offer is larger than my nutritionist allows so I had leftovers. The sides are salad and a potato, simple! The atmosphere? Ummm, this sure is delicious steak, right, honey!?!?! read more

Great steak! No complaints. The ambiance and setting isn't the fanciest, but food was great, service was good and very affordable pricing. If you don't like steak, this is not the place for you. Not much else on the menu. read more

If you gave this place anything other than 5 stars....you are obviously not a steak lover. I am from NC and traveling for work. I asked the locals where to get BBQ and they told me that but also said, I needed to check out Old Hickory. Boy did they steer me in the right direction. Being from NC I am not into steaks and now I get why-NC does not have a place (that I have found) that makes steaks this good. It's an old, dark dive that screams old school restaurants in the country. The very best steak I have ever had and dagumit it's 9 hours from my home. I talked to my customer and asked that they request my services more often so I can eat here again. Oh and the service was awesome too. Don't forget them. They can make or break a good food joint. read more

Old Hickory Steak House - 14 oz Ribeye - Steakhouses Near Me - Columbus, Mississippi

See all

If you want to eat a good steak this is a great choice. Only 2 side options salad and baked potato. Menu is very simple and straightforward. Service was ok... read more

This was a blast from the literal past! I haven't been to a steakhouse like this since I was a kid. My husband had been coming here since he was a kid and this was the first opportunity to dine here since we live in California now, but are about to build in Starkville. The menu is pretty simple, with quite a few items to choose from. We went in the late evening, so it was dimly lit. We were seated and our server was very friendly and attentive. She brought our drinks right away. I ordered a rib eye, my husband a TBone, and I have to say both were done to perfection. The seasoning used is exceptional and delicious! Our meal came with a baked potato and salad. The pricing is very reasonable, which is why their customers are regular and frequently return. I don't know how long it has been here, at least since the 70's, but I plan on coming back for many years to come. We will definitely make this a staple when we return to the area. read more

As good as it gets! Great food and people. It doesn't look like much from the outside but their steaks are second to none. read more

Old Hickory Steak House - Sirloin for one and baked potato. - Steakhouses Near Me - Columbus, Mississippi

Listen, if you like steak, eat here. If you want a whimsical deconstructed salmon croquette or whatever, go elsewhere. I had the filet. It comes in one size, 8oz. It was a high-quality cut of meat, it was seasoned thoughtfully so that the flavor was predominantly the flavor from the meat, and it was cooked exactly as I ordered (medium rare). My wife had the sirloin, because that 's the only kind of steak she likes, and we had to drive 40 miles to get one (since 44 Prime in Starkville stopped serving their su vied sirloin). It comes in one size, 16oz. She said it was delicious, but I think sirloin is icky so I have to take her word for it. It looked and smelled like a person who knew what they were doing had cut it, seasoned it, and prepared it. There are four items on the menu; we had half of them. The other half is T-bone steak and tenderloin steak. Each steak is served with a potato and salad and a not-mentioned-on-the-menu piece of Texas toast. Your potato options are butter and sour cream or butter only; your salad includes lettuce and a tomato wedge and one of five or six dressing choices. Did I mention appetizers? No? That because they don't need 'em. How 'bout a dessert? Better bring something from home or go by the yogurt place next to Sweet Peppers (#shoplocal). Don't eat cows? Enjoy watching your friends and neighbors living their best life -- no pigs, birds, fish, or New Age protein alternatives are available. Next, ambience and service. The parking lot was full on a non-game-day Saturday (locals know what I mean) at 5 p.m. We walked in and the person at the counter said "sit wherever." We didn't see an open table, and she explained there were more tables in the back. Following a serpentine labyrinth past a diner setup, sketchy-looking booths, another diner setup, past the server hallway, and the back room was a cinder-block-and-ceiling-tile space with additional tables. The tables were typical diner, covered with plastic red-and-white-checked tattered plastic tablecloths. The chairs were vinyl covered late '70s diner style. Dare I say, unpretentious? We sat at a four-top and quickly met our friendly and attentive server who gave us menus (we learned from listening to other diners that few need to see a menu, seeing as how there are only four choices, but it was our first time) and took our drink orders (free refills on water and tea, but sodas and beers are sold by the can). When she came back with the drinks Kim ordered the sirloin, and the server surprised us by saying "honey, don't order that." We explained that we drove 40 miles to get sirloin, but we were interested to know why she didn't recommend the sirloin. She explained that people in the region don't know sirloin like Texans know sirloin, and they are often taken aback by its distinct flavor and lack of tenderizing fat content. Kim was like "that's exactly the way I like it; make my medium well!" The server sent the order back, brought our salads, and kept our drinks refilled until she brought the steaks and cleared the salad plates. She confirmed we were pleased with the steaks, and once we were done she brought the ticket and told us to pay the cashier on the way out. It was about $75, we tipped another $25, and carried home 8 ounces of sirloin for sandwiches tomorrow. read more

Great food and service! A local hidden gem! We were in town visiting and decided to give it a try and had nothing but a great experience! read more

Old Hickory Steak House - Grill as you walk in. - Steakhouses Near Me - Columbus, Mississippi

See all

Wonderful steak perfect place to stop for a delicious steak paired with a salad & potato. They keep it simple without losing the flavor! It doesn't look big when you first pull up, but there's more room towards the back. read more

Old Hickory Steak House - Steak & potato with salad on the side. - Steakhouses Near Me - Columbus, Mississippi

If you happen to be in Columbus, Mississippi and are looking for one of the absolute best steaks you've ever had, then make your way over to Old Hickory Steak House. But be warned, you DO NOT need to dress up for this dinner! This is the real-deal, old fashioned, only 4 steaks to choose from, the sides-are-the-sides, place. Fancy...no. Delicious...YES! When you get there just start walking back and find a clean table and have a seat. They'll bring you "a" menu. Not one per person, just "a" menu for the table. There are 4 steaks to choose from: Sirloin, Ribeye, T-Bone & Filet. All come with a salad, baked potato and garlic break. The only choices you have to make are: 1) What type and size of steak 2) If you want butter and/or sour cream on your potato 3) What dressing you want in your salad 4) What to drink That is it. Then just sit back and wait for the best steak hove had! I always get the Ribeye. It is perfectly cooked and so flavorful. I'm telling you, you can't go wrong with this place. You need to load up the car and go...you can thank me later! read more

Old Hickory Steak House - Ribeye, baked potato with sour cream and butter and garlic toast! - Steakhouses Near Me - Columbus, Mississippi

Dined here twice now. Expectations were too high the first time. The menu has steak, and that's it. Steak comes with a salad and a baked potato--that's it, no other choices. Expect to be mocked if you order your steak well done. Beverage choices are canned soda ($2 each) or canned beer ($2.50). This is not a fancy place. In fact far from it. But they do cook a good piece of meat. And they keep the plastic tub full of ice at your table full of beers if you ask for it. Great place for a bunch of guys after golf or fishing or a business meeting. Would not come here on a date. Area in the back has tables for big groups ( we had 12). This area is accessible by walking through the dish washing area, so watch your step on the wet floors. Several large families also in attendance. read more

See all

Perfectly seasoned and cooked steak. No frills. Friendly service. Cold jar for your beer and decor that hasn't changed since the mid 20th century. My kind of place. read more

No frills, best cooked steaks, loaded baked potato, homemade salad dressing & garlic toast. Perfect.

Best steak you ever eat Ate there 20 years ago and I thought then that was the best steak ever Hasn't changed read more

Beef Steaks Garlic Toast. Loaded Baked!! Simple and perfectly delicious !!! Would highly recommend. read more

Old Hickory Steak House - Steakhouses Near Me - Columbus, Mississippi

See all

This is a top notch steak house! Small hole in the wall but you will not be disappointed. Very good!!!! read more

Old Hickory Steak House - Front window of restaurant is the steak grilling spot - Steakhouses Near Me - Columbus, Mississippi