Three must-try menu items: The Stuffed Meatballs. Fire-roasted wings. Arugula Salad (throw the chicken in)! We love it here. The quality is consistent and the variety is abundant. Don't go there without an appetite. Oh - and leave the calorie counter home. This will be your cheat day meal too good to pass up. read more

This place had barely Acceptable pizza and burgers. The staff seems nice but is quite unschooled in proper table service (someone asked what specifically: a cute but preoccupied hostess plopped a handful of silverware and napkins, strewing it across our table, with no comment, and darted off to confer with the other individual at the hostess station) . For Valentine's day, I went, to hear a band my lady likes, (it's always a done deal when we see VX) and the management cancelled the show!!!! MANAGEMENT, YOU SUCK . Ps I am not a member of the band, just someone who went out of my way to see some live music. read more

Saw that a restaurant was opening here back in August. Finally got a chance to go with a friend tonight. The restaurant is beautiful with the long table seating and Americana filling the room. Very contemporary look but not as loud or overwhelming as other new restaurants that have opened up. As for the food, there were at least 7-8 things on the menu I was debating between, everything looked so good from the wings to all the pizzas and appetizers too. Ended up with a bison burger. Great flavor, great steak fries, and it was cooked perfectly. They also bring out delicious baked bread and olive oil to start the meal, and they even let my friend bring some extra bread for her family. Definitely coming back to try some more dishes from Old Glory, great addition to the area!! read more

Old Glory Kitchen + Spirits - Bison Burger w/ bacon and frizzled onions - Pizza Near Me - Keyport, New Jersey

Friends of ours posted on FB that they recently went to this place and enjoyed it. We decided to give it a try and took the 45 minutes drive to get there. A busy, sunny, 57 degrees spring day. Crowded, but they put us on the waitlist, said it would be 20 to 30 minutes. We got called in about 20. We were seated inside (we asked for the first available) directly in front of the kitchen area. ATMOSPHERE: Charming and patriotic. Taphouse style. This is an old church and they have kept many of the arches, windows, etc. 2nd floor is accessed via a stairway near the back of the first-floor dining area. The bar to the left takes up that wall. Seating extends to the outside patio near the parking lot and upstairs. FOOD: We ordered: crab dip - very good. Served in a bread bowl - but while the idea is to cut and eat the bread bowl with the dip - some veggies (carrot and celery sticks maybe) would be nice. Texas BBQ Wings - they are charred on the open grill. Nicely done, crisp, and flavored just from the grill, then add the sticky-sweet-spicy bbq sauce - nice touch. Big wings, not the cheap little ones you get at some places. Served on a sizzling platter. Pan-Seared Teriyaki Salmon over garlic mashed potatoes with vegetables. My husband said it was plentiful - a large portion, cooked well with a nice, but not overpowering sweet sauce. The mashed potatoes were heavy, not a light whip, but flavorful. Veggie was steamed broccoli. Cajun Catfish with rice and veggie, served with mango salsa. The Catfish was cooked well, but the ends were a bit dark and hard. The seasoning was very good, with little burn factor that you might expect with an overdone cajun spice. The rice was simple which rice, nothing special. Steamed broccoli - steamed well, not mushy, but not hard either. The mango salad however was terrible due to the kitchen not knowing enough to not use unripe, rock-hard mangos. That could have been so much better with a bit of attention paid to the produce used. SERVICE In a word, terrible. Once seated it took a full 10 minutes before anyone even thought to ask if we were being helped. And we were right in front of the kitchen with people passing us! A woman asked if we were being helped, finally, I said no and she kept walking without another word. She came back out and passed by us again, followed a moment later by a young waitress. She took our drink orders and left. The first woman showed up 5 minutes later to ask for our drink order. We told her we ordered from the young lady, so she took our food order. And there we sat - another 8 minutes for drinks to arrive. Another 12 before appetizers came out. The runner literally took them from the service window, turned, took two steps, and put them on our table - it isn't like we were across the restaurant! We ordered bbq wings - no extra napkins were offered. I had to flag down the first (manager maybe) woman and ask for napkins - she barely grunted at me, then came back and dropped a stack of napkins on the far end of the table as she walked by. Halfway into our appetizers, the entrees show up! The runner gets all confused like we're supposed to stop eating those and dive in. He walks to the other side of the table and puts our plates down and walks away. By the time we finished appetizers, our mains were cooling considerably. No one ever asked us how things were if we liked it if we needed anything. My husband had ordered a beer, the mgr did swing by, grab his glass, and say "another beer?" I ordered the drink special - I even pointed at it - "Malibu Watermelon Mojito". I got a regular mojito. I was charged for a special, not a regular (wish I had noticed before we left, but I just wanted to get out of there) No one ever asked if I wanted a second. And here is the final kicker - 3% credit surcharge for paying with a card!!! Not kidding! Who the hell does that? Who pays with cash at restaurants nowadays? And why weren't they upfront about it? No signs, nothing on their website (which I scoured for the information) . BOTTOM LINE: Won't be back. Cool place, food is decent - but service and underhanded charging rules this place out for us. read more

If I could give this place a 0 I would. Such a shame that the management is so terrible. Enjoyed the food but never again. Clearly the manager is on some type of power trip. Decides to kick someone out because they do not like them personally. I witnessed the whole thing. Owners should be ashamed and embarrassed to have hired someone like this. Manager REFUSED to speak to the individuals. Do not give this place your time or hard earned money. Such a shame. read more

Amazing food, atmosphere and prices! I had a great salad. My friends had the old glory pizza which was over the top fresh and delicious! My other friend had the meatloaf with mashed potatoes , string beans. Took a bite of his meatloaf and couldn't believe how good it was! The building is unique and once you step in you have a smile on your face because the ceiling that has a huge flag painted on it. Very cool place! I HIGHLY recommend Old Glory! read more

See all

Quick service, great food. Clean and comfy environment. I ordered crab dip and it's absolutely amazing. Really taste the crab chunks. There are other dishes that look great. Would definitely come again. read more

Old Glory Kitchen + Spirits - Brick-Oven Maryland Crab Dip - Pizza Near Me - Keyport, New Jersey

Absolutely incredible restaurant!! We frequent Old Glory for lunch and dinner but recently I held my husbands 60th surprise party here and there are not enough words for how INCREDIBLE the experience was!! The service we received from planning to the end of the party is unlike service I have received at other events!!! The atmosphere is stunning and the food was amazing!!! The passed appetizers were hot and plentiful and the buffet was always full!! I highly highly recommend Old Glory and their entire team and truly look forward to having future parties there! read more

See all

We were driving through town and decided to stop by to get a drink and food. We were promptly greeted and the staff was very friendly. Our drinks arrived quickly and the bread we were served was very good. Our server (i believe his name was Ryan) was very attentive, informative when we asked about the area and very respectful. We will be back! read more

Old Glory Kitchen + Spirits - Pizza Near Me - Keyport, New Jersey

Great pub, food, and service. Love the American flag on the ceiling of the second floor. Oh, and Megan the bartender is awesome!

I am done with this place. I've dined in and picked up dozens of times but the food is always cold and the staff is rude. I've reached the end with them today, when a pickup was 30 minutes longer than their estimate and the girl running the window gave me an attitude. read more

So after three attempts to eating at Old Glory, they were able to sit us right away. Previously there were 30 to 45 min waits. So getting a seat right away was positive. Great ambiance and from our table at the window, we were able to watch the country line dancers in the outdoor bar area. My wife and I started out with drinks: me a $2 dollar PBR, while my wife had a Hawaiian Joe Vodka drink. I took a sip and it was totally weak. For $9 a pop, you should smell the vodka when raising it to your mouth. Lol. The oven baked bread, out of this world. The melted butter helped. Orgasmic. Roasted clams apps. Ok. Clams small but the garlic juice added a nice flavor. So let's chat about the main courses. I read on yelp about the great reviews regarding the crabby Mac and Cheese ($18.00) so my wife ordered it. So disappointing. The portion size was rather large but she only found 2 - 3 chunks of crab inside. It was basically mac and cheese with a seafood flavor. My Memphis Ribs ($18.00) were delish but the fries, flat. They seemed dried out. Service was fine and the timing between courses perfect. It will be awhile before we go back and give it a second try. I've been to numerous places in NYC and paid $9.00 a drink. I dont mine paying for a good quality strong drink, but this Hawaiian Joe was a rip off. The crabby mac was a rip off as well. At 18 dollars, there should have been a crab piece every 4 - 5 fork fulls. read more

Great food- garden state salad is the best! Most servers are great! Love the inside/outside choice!

Service was very good - friendly and prompt. Food was tasty but very small servings. Had the Cajun Catfish which was tasty but hardly enough to use as bait. Brocolli was okay but, again, not much of it. Rice Pilaf was bland with nothing added (carrots, peas, etc.) and took up most of the plate. read more

We came here on a Wednesday evening I believe, at the recommendation of our banker at Bank of American in Aberdeen. She couldn't stop raving about the specials that're offered, and vary evening to evening. So we came with my father and sister in-law! Our server could have been more attentive, as he forgot small items here and there- drinks, additional sides, as requested etc. On the other hand were very fond of the bread they brought to our table! We got the artichoke dip, which I appreciated. Could've done without the Bavarian pretzel as the bacon cheese dip, just had a piece of bacon on top, and was chunky in consistency. My wife and I both savored our Cobb salad with grilled chicken (which we had to remind waitstaff to bring). My father in-law didn't feel well later in the evening after his crab cakes. Lastly, my sister in-law loves her burger! I have mixed feelings about returning for food, but may come back for drinks. As I loved their rum bucket, outdoor seating area, and the fun-fact that the venue itself is a revamped church!!! read more

I attended an engagement party here today and it was awesome. Great ambiance, space is really good for large groups, service was friendly and attentive, and food was great. This is actually a former church that has been converted to a really cool restaurant and venue. Try their wings, pasta, and short rib. Those were the standouts for me. The staff also did an amazing job of bringing the food out and making sure everyone had drinks. Shoutout to Sheridan the best server in the biz! read more

I have been here a couple of times. Once with friends for lunch and another time to celebrate my birthday with my girlfriends. I really enjoyed this place. The food and service was GREAT!!!! read more

I had a small dinner celebration for my wedding, it was amazing, the food was perfect and the service was outstanding! One of my favorite places! Congratulations to the owner and thank you for a great event. read more

Awesome time at Old Glory Kitchen & Spirits in Keyport. Shout out to Jaclyn, our event planner for Doug and Taylor's Rehearsal dinner. Great food, extremely pleasant staff, and very cool venue. read more

Old Glory Kitchen + Spirits - Pizza Near Me - Keyport, New Jersey

See all

Can't wait to return! There was a small waitress mix up but Victoria came in and saved the day. She was awesome! Super sweet and attentive to all our needs! The restaurant is absolutely beautiful! Huge selection of beers. The bread, omg!! To die for! Absolutely loved it! Our meals came out super quick and they were absolutely delicious!! We will definitely be back when we are in town again! read more

Do yourself a favor and give this place a try. I always go for the Big Lou which is a burger topped with bacon cheese candies jalapeños and short rib. Amazing! read more

waited forever for a table. 90 minutes for the wrong orders. food was left in a hot plate before coming out. two of us never got our order and they said "we'll put it in now". we said forget it. as we're leaving all the workers are standing around having a great time. they forgot ALL about us with 2 young ones and a baby that lost his patience too. we had to go to Wawa right after to feed those of us that were flat out ignored for about 3 hours. Bill still cost a ton. Bad food, terrible experience, and looked very understaffed. until we saw many employees that kept saying someone else was handling it. we interuppted happy time by showing up. we thought they went on strike.​ read more

Thank you for the amazing service always!! I am absolutely obsessed with the burrata salad! Every-time we come here the service is phenomenal! I don't remember some of the servers that we had but Julian and Ricky are wonderful! And thank you to the manager, forgot his name but Cowboy fan and all he was wonderful! (From a very happy Giants fan) read more

Awesome a great time and great meal. My fiance and I went for the margarita testing. We sat upstairs, had ryan as our waiter and bartender. He was awesome, we knew him from Matawan HS, he was very attentive and a great help at helping us decide on drinks to have. Our wings came out hot and delicious, we devoured them quicker than Ryan could come back and ask how they were. We also ordered a bar pie and loved it just as mush as the wings. Like i said always great food, great place, and awesome staff. read more

Old Glory Kitchen + Spirits - Got engaged at old glory.. Great staff that helped set everything up. Thanks old glory!!! - Pizza Near Me - Keyport, New Jersey

Old Glory has a spacious outdoor seating area that offers full sun full shade and tables with umbrellas to choose from. The dining area and the inside ( what little you can see theses days) was very clean. We were told the start getting very busy at 4:30 but at 4 we had no problem getting a table for 2. We got a table right away but because we were kind of out of the way our server didn't realize we were seated until we were there a solid 10-15 minutes. We ordered a pitcher of Red Sangria to start with and even that took a while to get to our table. The Sangria itself was really good though. For food we ordered 3 appetizers, Buffalo wings, Thai Calamari and short rib sliders. The calamari was very tastey but just a touch chewy. The wings were fantastic and the buffalo sauce was sneaky spicy, not too hot up front but the heat builds up in your mouth. They are served with the usual blu cheese dip but also had very tastey blu cheese crumbles. The short rib sliders were good, I'd order them again but i won't be calling my friends to run over and try them. All in all a nice experience but some things could have been better. read more

See all

I recently threw a 40th birthday party for my husband at Old Glory and could not be happier! Planning the party with Jackie was so simple and our waiter Chris was awesome and attentive. We had a semi private party upstairs for about 15 people. Our guests are STILL talking about the food a month later! We can't to plan another party hear. I can't recommend OG enough for its food and service! read more

Love this place. Food , service and atmosphere are all great ! They no longer accept reservations or do call ahead which is a bummer. Best short ribs Around ! Pizza and mozzarella sticks are amazing too read more

My family was lucky enough to find this gem of a restaurant after going to Air Trampoline. Old Glory Kitchen setting is in a former church. The ambiance is really cool. It's a big open space with a DJ booth spinning all the greatest hits in the center of the space. The waitresses were very good and accommodating. We had a kids pizza, buffalo wings, Cesar salad with shrimp, and a bunch of drinks. The place serves mostly American food. We will be coming back here when in NJ. Thank you! read more

Really cool spot a few blocks from the water. If you go at a busy time parking might be tough. There's another busy restaurant right down the block that's doing outdoor dining as well. Ordered the arugula salad with grilled chicken , good size salad for the price too. Would definitely come back. Service was great read more

Not going back! We went on a Tuesday night. Not really crowded. After we were seated, it took about 10 minutes for someone to come ask if we wanted something to drink. When they finally came to get our order it was much later. They were not short staffed at all. When the server brought us our food he dropped half of it on the floor. No apologies. They replaced on meal later, then another when everyone was finishing their meal, and I had to ask for it! They said they would com us one meal and never did. The food was definitely not worth it. read more

Nice and fast service and really good food Their chicken wings are nice and sauces I would come back

The food is always AMAZING!!! The staff is super friendly and you might have to wait a little longer for your food but patience pays off with consistently excellent food and service. The pizzas are delicious and now I see on their Instagram that they're bringing Calzones to the menu!!! If you're looking for great food, great service in a cute Bayshore area town then you can't go wrong at Old Glory. read more

I would write more but no words I can use besides the following. "A beautiful old church transformed in to a place for people to eat, love and pray under the old glory." read more

See all

They're awesome a must try, I took my family the second time and they were just as satisfied. Food is absolutely delicious

Great place! Great food,and atmosphere! Outdoor patio and deck are great! Pizza,wings,chicken parm are must do's

This place was a great place to go as a first time outing since like March lol. Went for beers and ended up with pizza and some picky items. Got a table right away out of harms way with an impending storm. Good selection of beer and a great view. Manager offered us a round of drinks for moving outside for a party and once it started to pour immediately got us an indoor table for safety. Staff was friendly, fast and so accommodating. Will definitely be back. read more

I went to old Glory a few days ago trying to support local businesses and what I witnessed at Old Glory was a disgraced. When I walked up to the takeout window I witnessed one of the managers screaming at the workers and throwing what looked like people's cellphones and Keyes and screaming at them as I waited for my order. I would not recommend anyone to go here if this is the way management treats there workers. I never felt more uncomfortable at a place then this and there is a right way to deal with workers and a wrong way and this was definitely the wrong way and I hope nobody supports a business like this. read more

A little more pricey than my family and I were expecting, but the food was really good and we love the atmosphere! Really great for friends and family to get together read more

What a great place,good food,fun environment...my family and I had a blast in the St.Patricks parade,the service was impressive. Thanks to the bartender and the servers. read more

Great food, great atmosphere and friendly service. We had coconut shrimp, fried mozzarella , cheeseburger eggrolls and drunken clams....the burgers were terrific. Mike was a great waiter. read more