Place was super cool. Relaxed setting upstairs with family style eating downstairs.. they have an outdoor patio & the drinks are amazing!! "Jenn" upstairs bar made the best COSMO ever... took me back to Sex & the city days.. read more

Old Glory Kitchen + Spirits - Pizza Near Me - Keyport, New Jersey

One of our all-time favorites in the area for dinner and outstanding drinks. Love that they serve their draft beer very cold, which sounds odd but a lot of places don't. When the weather allows, they have a very nice two level outdoor seating area, and the indoor space is great as well. We've never been disappointed in a food order...wings are great, they are grilled not fried and are crispy charred and the sauces are really good. Love their large and varied apps menu, the spinach artichoke dip is great. Pizzas are outstanding too. Will continue to go here. read more

I hosted my boyfriend's surprise 25th birthday here and there is not a bad thing to say! The food was amazing, drinks were plentiful and the service was excellent. I planned the party with Jaclyn, the event planner at Old Glory and she made the experience very smooth and was helpful on all accounts. The day of, another woman Kristin, helped set up the décor and was around all night long if we needed any assistance. She was also great!! Overall, everyone had an awesome time and didn't stop raving about the food. 10/10 would recommend! read more

See all

I just moved into Matawan a month ago and have been searching through the area for good spots to hit up and unwind. Old Glory was fantastic with a great beer selection, the cocktails were delicious on a hot day, and the food selection was perfect. The one thing that separates them from others though was there acceptance of my Golden Retriever Tucker. He is always uninvited, but at Old Glory everyone absolutely loved him with open heart and open arms. For once, my whole family could come out together and enjoy the day. I never do these reviews, good or bad, but Old Glory is the exception. Four different bars including a basement lounge, a loft bar, and a patio setting. Everything one person could need in one spot! Well done! read more

Old Glory Kitchen + Spirits - So happy to have found my new watering hole! What a great place that accepted my whole family! The scene was perfect. - Pizza Near Me - Keyport, New Jersey

Just visited for the 1st time. Awesome building! The food is great! We got cheeseburger egg rolls (yum!) And rosemary garlic parmesan wings also amazing. Got a spinach artichoke pizza to take home. Waitress was friendly & service was fast. We will definitely be back! read more

See all

My husband and I had dinner at Old Glory last night with friends. We ordered the calamari appetizer. The menu states that it is served with cherry peppers but there was very little calamari and almost all peppers. When you order calamari that's what you expect to get. We spoke to the manager, Kevin, who said he would speak to the kitchen about it but did nothing else. A little disappointing! Otherwise, my chicken cutlet sandwich was really good and I think everyone else liked their dinners also. read more

Absolutely love this restaurant! Great indoor/outdoor bar area. The food is always delicious and the drinks are great! Highly recommend. read more

Absolutely terrible experience. Our food all came out at once, no staggering appetizers and entrees. We were never given spoons for soup despite asking several times. The waitress put the wrong thing in for my son and was annoyed when we mentioned it. As if we messed up, but the bill showed that she did. We waited to be seated, waited to place orders and ultimately my husband had to find them to pay the bill. I would not recommend this place to anyone. So incredibly disappointed. read more

All I could say when I walked in was wow!! This place decorated head to toe American flag, golden eagle and even Uncle Sams outfit. It was tastefully done and I really liked it. Now I'm sure this place is bumping in the warmer months with the outdoor seating it doubles its square footage in seating . We ate upstairs and the entire ceiling is the american flag. And the tables give you a nice over view of the 1st floor of the restaurant. Also they have a lounge area at the bottom that has a separate bar and some tables and benches for waiting . Now everything on the menu sounds good but we tried a few pies and a burger and salad this trip and everything thing we ordered was delicious. The spicy Joey was my older daughters favorite. The millennial was my Hubbies favorite. I enjoyed the Cheyenne Burger special and the Cobb salad . My little one who's plum Jane enjoyed her pasta with Marinara. This was our first time here and we definitely plan to come back. Oh forgot to mention the staff was super friendly and manager/ owner ( I think) kept the restaurant flowing so guest could be seated quickly . The food itself did not take long at all so that's always a great Plus when you want a fast turn around . read more

See all

Great food , great drinks, great atmosphere and wonderful staff. Sharon and Rich are terrific Managers! Would recommend Old Glory to anyone visiting Keyport this summer! Rob Doelger read more

Bartender was very nice, wasn't sure what we wanted and he was so patient and helpful. My friends and i went to get a bunch of apps and drinks and this is a great place to do just that. Such a large space, there's an upstairs that is open air on a nice summer day I would love to go back and sit up there. I wouldn't go there to eat a 'fancier' sit down meal, but to hang out and grab drinks it's perfect. Parking isn't too bad there's a lot in the back, gets filled up but we found a spot on the street. read more

My family and I have been to Old Glory at least a dozen times. Big and small groups. Generally everything has been great. The food is always good and the staff is great too. We love their Pizzas and wings. My wife orders the Chicken Milanese every time. Yesterday we had a party of 9 and a baby. It was a Monday so it wasn't super busy. nothing went right...We had a straggler so while we were waiting for the last person in our party to meet us we ordered some drinks, bread and some apps. Half the table got drinks the other half did not. I personally asked for the bread 3 times before it was then brought up cold. Nothing was done with out asking a minimum of 3 times. To the point where the manager and bar tender were bring up our waters and drinks. They were always kind with an apology but when you have a large group including a small child its frustrating to have to ask repeatedly to have simple things done like get a refill of water. I also had to change my baby on the floor of the bathroom. Being a family friendly restaurant I was surprised to see they didn't have any option for diaper changing. We will definitely be back and hopefully the little things can be fixed because we really do love it there. read more

Great food, service, and ambiance. The best place to catch up with friends for lunch or dinner!

Food is very good and the place has an easy, fun vibe. Menu selections are a bit limited but they are super nice and very appreciative of veterans and first responders. Love summer nights with their open-air feeling and live music or DJ. read more

I don't know what's better, the customer service or the garlic shrimp. I just wish that I could buy the garlic shrimp broth by the bucket full. I'm happy to support this business during this trying time! read more

My husband and I ordered from Old Glory for the first time today. We are new to the area and are starting to venture out a bit. We ordered pizza and sangria today and I spoke with John on the phone who was incredibly polite and patient with taking my order. I tried online but had issues with the app but he was more than gracious to help me on the phone. I picked up my order and we came home and the food was hands-down the best we've had in a very very long time. Also the sangria was fabulous. I can't say enough about just this one time with this restaurant. The food and beverages are fabulous. The service is excellent as well. Great place with great people. Highly recommend! read more

So my wife and I were in the area and took a flyer on this place for lunch! Man are we glad we did the calamari is pretty good but the crab dip bowl was amazing as were the fire roasted wings! And the drinks were excellent my wife had a margarita and I had a mojito (although we both liked her margarita more than the mojito) our server was super nice too! Food came out fast and hot! It was our 1st time there but definitely not our last!!! read more

Great place , family friendly delicious food! Emily was an amazing server. We will definitely be going back read more

I really like this place, I came for lunch on Monday for the first time and then came back Tuesday for dinner so I guess that's pretty obvious! To start, this place is beautiful! It's an old church remodeled and the woodworking is absolutely stunning. Everyone who works here seems really nice too! Our waitress Amelia, (I think) we actually had her both times, was especially nice. Ok so for Monday lunch we had a kids pizza for my daughter which surprised me with how good it was, usually kids meals are nothing to run home about but their kids pizza is only slightly smaller than their regular pizza and doesn't have any toppings on it. I had their French dip special, which had delicious thin sliced roast beef and came with fries for like $8! Such a great deal. We then came back and had wings pizza and fried calamari for dinner the next day. They have great food. The pizza is really great it has so much flavor big chunks of garlic and basil so yummy!!! My husband loves it! It's a really great place to have a nice meal! Definitely one of my favorites! read more

A perfect night in NJ, sitting outside under the stars with great music, people upstairs and outside and the smell of delicious food. I was a little late and just made last call but was so glad that I did, craving some pizza! I ordered a margarita which came out good and started off with some buffalo wings, with a heavy debate on which pizza to get with my date. There was an option for a special pie with sausage that was so appealing but instead we decided to go with a vodka pie (always the right choice) with some meatballs on it, extra crispy- extra delicious!!!! Also heard there is a speak easy down stairs, along with a bar upstairs. Great place to bring the family and eat out, perfect spot in town to walk down by the water. read more

Old Glory Kitchen + Spirits - Pizza Near Me - Keyport, New Jersey

Why are they charging a CREDIT CARD FEE when we are paying cAsh and claim it cannot be removed....Is this even legal?...Poor service upstairs...stay downstairs. read more

The food and atmosphere is great. Good service. Our waitress was Capri, the best, great personality, read more

Awesome atmosphere being an old church. The Thai chili wings are amazing. The service is pretty good. Seating is interesting as you will potentially be sitting next to people you don't know. (Could be a good or bad thing) Overall it made me go back 4 days later and had the wings again! My girlfriend ordered a French dip that was amazing as well! read more

The place is very nice the food is really good they have a wide valid options to choose from also have a very good beer selection and good mixed drinks the only issue I have is they rush you out just as I took my last bite of my appetizers dinner had arrived I noticed they same thing was happening to the tables around me I would go back again and ask them too slow things down read more

I came here just to get out w some friends. I was really surprised how people on line were NOT wearing any masks, but I have to say that the employees all were. Our server was Sheriton and she was amazing, on top of things. She was great and I would ask for her again! I was really turned off by a server (that must have known someone) by eating off their plate. That just rubbed me the wrong way. We got the meatballs, (Loaded Meatballs Homemade & stuffed with fresh mozzarella, served with marinara, herb-ricotta, basil & Parmigiano-Reggiano) BBQ wings and 2 pizzas. Old Glory Classic Fresh mozzarella, roasted garlic, cherry tomatoes, tomato sauce, basil & Parmigiano-Reggiano and then we got one we made up. I do suggest coming here for sure!!! I saw the owner going around to all tables, but guess he was busy, would have been nice to meet him. It was just so nice to get out. My friends and I are all first responders so we NEEDED this! read more

See all

Been trying to get here for a while life gets in the way. Ordered the Bacon wrapped meat loaf which came with mashed and Broccoli all came out hot and delicious, was enjoying a J& Coke my wife had fish n Chips the only negative I could mention was the gravy was a little light our server immediately brought a bowl of steaming Hot gravy to finish. My wife stated the fish was a bit oil soggy so the cooking oil wasn't hot enough. Our cocktails were spot on our server Samantha did a great job, she was pleasant friendly and efficient. We will definitely be back. read more

Great food, fun for family, friends or date night. Bar is nicely stocked with hard drinks through local brewery selections. And the food is great! Pizza, yes! Wings, yes! Salads, yes! Delicious food, doesn't break the bank and always a good time. read more

The crab dip and wings were good... Sat at the bar, my wine glass was dirty- I told the bartender, she poured wine from dirty glass to clean glass... ugh. I look down - the bar counter is filled with crumbs, like it's been there for years! Even under the plexiglass in bar. The atmosphere is awesome even in the winter so I can imagine during the summer - a place that would be even better but, The cleanliness... yuk!!!! The bathroom is disgusting- you share with a man- ladies you know where I am going with that. And overall it's just plain dirty. read more

Old Glory Kitchen + Spirits - Upper dinning area - Pizza Near Me - Keyport, New Jersey

See all

There is such an excellent atmosphere inside and outside of Old Glory. Food is enjoyable and prices fair. As an added bonus, you feel like your have been blessed since you are spending time in a converted church building - LOL. Definitely recommended! read more

Stopped in today and had the cheeseburger egg rolls for an appetizer.. delicious!!! Caesar salad and Margarita pizza, also delicious!! Great beer selection. Our server Mike was great !!!! Can't wait to go back to enjoy the outside patio read more

Old Glory Kitchen + Spirits - Pizza Near Me - Keyport, New Jersey

Visited Old Glory while in Keyport. If you've never been to Keyport it is worth a visit. Small town environment on the waterfront with a few bars, restaurants and antique shops. Old Glory opened about a year ago and we had to check it out. Built in a renovated old church, this place is beautifully decorated with cat walks inside and out above a patio. They have a patriotic theme serving only American beer and tasty brick oven treats. The pizza is excellent and they serve you a complimentary bread that's so good we had to ask for more. While waiting for our seats we sat at the bar and enjoyed the Loaded Meatballs. They were fantastic, and tasted just like my grandmothers! They were stuffed with mozzarella and melted in your mouth. Pizza wise we tried The Old Glory and Vodka Pie, both were equally delicious. My boyfriend tried the Braised Short Ribs and loved them! They were served with mashed potatoes, veggies, and topped with potato sticks! The service was truly fantastic and atmosphere was awesome. We will definitely be coming back for more! read more

We have always been a patron of old glory, and enjoyed sitting on the patio drinking their famous sangria and their wings and pizza. During this pandemic, they have continued their excellence with delivery and food quality. Cannot wait until the patio opens back up! read more

I was not impressed by the food. It was dry wings ever. . it was the slowest service too. The service in the kitchen was terrible and super slow. waited forever for our food. I had ever encountered a place on a Saturday during lunch time to be so disorganized. The place had a cool ambiance but not enough to recommend or try it ever again! read more

Food is so good and the service is great the ambiance was just amazing this place is just great

I am very satisfied that we chose Old Glory for my colleagues retirement celebration! The setting upstairs was perfect! The food was delicious and plentiful. The service and staff were helpful and pleasant. The evening was a blast for my colleague. If you need to hold an event this is the perfect place. The entire staff is awesome! Lunches and dinners are excellent as well. read more

If you're looking for a different type of restaurant, then you should add this place to your list of "must trys." Hidden on Broad Street in Keyport, NJ is this bar and grill type of restaurant located in a remodeled church. You can't get any more patriotic than their American flag painted ceiling - I mean, who wouldn't want a picture with that as a background? We enjoyed this place so much during our girls' lunch, that we went back for dinner another night with our men. Great pizza, appys and drinks - all at reasonable prices...can't wait to come back in the spring to take advantage of their very outdoor seating area next to a conveniently located municipal parking lot. If you're looking for a nice place to hang out with your friends - or just want to impress your 1st date - Old Glory is the place for you! read more

See all

Ambiance: I went during COV-19, so the ambiance may be different when everything is back to normal. I absolutely love the decor inside and the atmosphere. It's homey, fun, alive and welcoming. Food: to be honest, I thought I was going to get diner food. I expected ok burgers and entrees. However, I was blown away by the food. I got the Bayou burger, which, if you like blue cheese you are going to love this burger! I asked for a medium burger but got a medium well. If the burger wasn't so good I would have sent it back but it was delicious! Fries were also delicious! My husband got chicken, bacon & ranch pizza and I didn't think much when I looked at it but it was actually pretty good. The crust was crunchy and everything on the pizza was so yummy and fresh. read more

My wife and I love this place. We went there for the first time on Monday. The atmosphere is casual, kid friendly. The interior is beautifully done. Especially since it was converted from being previously a church. Looked very clean. Carlos our server was very attentive and the food moved out quickly. Even on a Monday the place was busy. Good sign. Appetizers were great. Had garlic shrimp, and coconut shrimp. The bread they serve to accompany is amazing. The dinners were also great. We had a chicken sandwich and bacon wrapped meatloaf. Meatloaf in a restaurant usually doesn't go well but it was amazing. The sides were great as well. The place was so good we returned on Thursday. Again our server Kacey was great, food moved out quickly, and was delicious. Appetizers were the same as Monday. The dinners were the Old Glory classic pizza and the crabby mac and cheese. Again didn't disappoint. In addition everything is reasonably priced. We'll definitely be returning repeatedly. read more

We were EXTREMELY disappointed with our recent visit. We made a reservation for 12 over a week in advance to celebrate two important family birthdays. When we arrived for our 7:30pm reservation, we were told to hang tight while they put the tables together. 45 minutes later they still had not seated us. We spoke with the manager who said she could sit 8 out of our 12 and that they were just waiting on a table to finish dessert. Turns out that table hadn't even ordered their dessert yet! Needless to say, we left and enjoyed a WONDERFUL dinner with GREAT service at BURLEWS down the street. We will NOT be back to Old Glory or McDonaghs. read more

Food was spectacular. Got the New York Strip. It was cooked to perfection. Arrived steaming hot. The best was the delivery guy. I missed him, so he left the food on my doorstep. He called me to confirm I got the food. He was extremely personable over the phone. Will definitely be ordering from there again! read more