Had lunch here Thursday and was very pleased. Our waitress was very pleasant and helpful and provided drinks and took our order within minutes of us being seated. Our salad was generous and tasty as well as our pizza. The establishment was clean and the restroom was as well. Would highly recommend this restaurant. read more

It was okay I mean the pizza was WAY TO GREASY and the wait was 2 hours!! I guess I know it was the day before thanksgiving but still if you don't have enough staff just close the store until you don't have the whole staff gone. One thing that wasn't huge but still made me a little uncomfortable is that the only had about 3 really big tables so we had 2 other families sitting with us and we were having fun but then we were told we were disturbing the other families. read more

The white pizza was absolutely delicious, we also got the simple pizza as well and it was good. But our waiter never once had a mask on, the other staff either didn't have a mask on or it wasn't covering their noses. COVID standards for masks were NOT followed here and I most likely won't be coming back. read more

This place is so cute , and the food is AMAZING !! This was our first time here and we WILL Definitely be back . We ordered the meat pie , delicious .. and very impressed that the owners Mike and Jesse took the time to stop by our table and check on how our meal was , great owners , great staff .. Thanks again for making our day trip Great !! read more

Great spot. Food is really good. Be prepared to just slow down and take your time. Buffalo chips, Italian Chopped Salad and the Meat pizza - all delish and great cocktails made by Summer. Sit on the patio and watch the folks roll by with pines in the background! read more

Legit. I am pretty certain this is the best pizza place I've tried. I've been to award winning places in big cities. I've worked at over a dozen pizza places myself in various cities. I have tried probably 60-75 others. This place is awesome. Beer cheese: Effin amazing. Calamari: one of the best I've had including gourmet restaurants in beach towns. The pizza: unique and awesome. Seriously, this place is awesome. Great service too. read more

Loved the food! Arizona greens salad was perfect! Dressing delicious. Pizza just right. Service just the right amount of attention. Cast iron cookie one of the best I've had! read more

Omg! This place is fabulous!!! Christie is an awesome gal. The food is Scottsdale worthy. The drink menu is sophisticated. The atmosphere is delightful! read more

We took the motorcycle up this past weekend. The weather was great in Pine as was the food here. Started off with the meat and cheese board and an awesome Bloody Mary. Next came the special for the weekend, the chicken parm pizza. We've driven from Phoenix several times and I always look forward to eating here. You need to have the time to spend a leisurely lunch or dinner as all pizzas are made from scratch and it takes a while. Sit back and enjoy the appetizers and Bloody Mary's! Bonus: many times, while eating on the patio, you can see the elk walking through the pines. The first time I saw them I ran out with my camera (like a tourist). Now they are part of the awesome mountain atmosphere. read more

Fun time Saturday, enjoyed the oyster bar along with wings and a cold beer! Food and service top notch!

We had some friends recommend the pizza's here, so we figured we would give it a try- they will never be getting business from us again. We called and placed a take out order. Gal on the phone wouldn't tell us the price for the pizza because 'they are based on size' so we asked what sizes they had and she said 'they are all medium'. So if they were all medium, then the price shouldn't change ‍ so we finally ordered 4 pizzas the total was $75- for 4 medium pizzas they said it would be ready In 30-35 minutes. So we got there 35 minutes after we placed the order, we're told it would be another 20 minutes or more before they would be done. Very inconvenient, disorganized, and outrageously expensive. read more

This is the cutest little bar! Small town vibes where everyone knows each other! Great live music! The Brothers Too played tonight, keep booking them because they are amazing! Brought their mom and dad up to sing with them! It was so cute! Amazing local beers to drink too! Will definitely be back! read more

Old County Inn - Pizza Near Me - Pine, Arizona

See all

What a great find! We decided to spend one night in Strawberry after a long hike at Fossil Creek Springs and didn't expect much in terms of food for dinner in a small town. Decided on this place in Pine and what a pleasant surprise!! Great local wine list, local beers, and great food. Everything was made there, including the sauces and desserts. Had the veggie roasted wood fire pizza and fried chicken...both very good. Best part about the restaurant was the atmosphere - great staff, and met the owner, Michael, who was super friendly and the whole experience felt like an episode from Cheers where everyone was genuinely nice--including the Pine/Strawberry residents there dining and listening to live music. A must go when up in the Payson area. read more

The pizza was great and honestly that was the only good part. We waited forever to get any type of service and then only saw our waitress twice. Once to take our order and one to bring us our check. The cooks were not wearing masks. The waitresses wore masks around their chin. We watched 3 people leave because they were not even acknowledged at the hostess stand. Good food but bad service read more

The food was good. The green chili cheese dip was my favorite part of the meal! I will definitely be eating that again! There was definitely a miscommunication between the woman that took my order and the kitchen so the white pizza had to much cheese and I never thought I would ever say that. That definitely could have been my fault by asking for goat cheese and how she had to ring it in. She mentioned she add to ring in as extra ricotta for $2. We also got the simple pizza and it was very good. Unfortunately we did do a take out order and instead of keeping it under heat lamp it was just sitting out while we waited in line to pick up so it was barely warm when we got back to the airbnb about 3 minutes down the road. I will say that simple pizza even hours later in the fridge when I ate it cold was definitely flavorful and you could tell the quality of the ingredients used. I will definitely give them another chance, but dine in next time. read more

SLOW, inattentive and horrible service. My son and I arrived about 3:30 and weren't able to leave until about 5:15. We were seated in a corner near the bar and served by about 5 different people. I had to ask for our food after waiting at least an hour. And then it took another 20 minutes to get our appetizers and pizzas all at once. My son's pizza was overcooked and looked burned. There was no mention of the long wait, no apology, and no discount on the bill. The food is good, however, I am not certain it is worth all the service inefficiency. read more

The pizza is AMAZING! Also, the meat and cheese board is to die for. The drinks are well served and delish. A hidden gem for sure

so coming back here. we were hungry, hanging out in payson, and on our way to meet some goats and llamas. old county inn was on the way, has great reviews, and one of the only things our 3-year-old nephew will eat is pizza. we pulled into the dirt lot under cloudy skies, answering the call of hungry bellies. we were seated immediately on an early saturday afternoon. 3 adults + 2 kids, not exactly knowing what to expect. we chose outside seating, because the weather in rim country is much more pleasant than phoenix (especially during the summer). found out this place is dog-friendly upon entering. made me smile. a couple dogs were contentedly laying beneath tables with water bowls near them. our server took a few minutes to get to us. i ordered one of the local beers on tap, a prickly pear ale. nice & fruity with a small hint of hops. i did ask our server which brewery it was from, but she never got back to me on that. we ordered the buffalo chip appetizers...twice. thinly sliced potatoes (potatos?) lightly fried with a hint of salt & pepper. so freaking good. they come with buffalo sauce and ranch. the buffalo sauce was on point. normally i'm not a big fan of buffalo sauce, but i may have kept dipping my chips in it. i couldn't stop. after about a 30 minute wait, our pizza pies finally arrived. and they were absolutely worth the wait. the meat pie arrived first. delectable. carnivorous joy perfectly baked into some of the best pizza sauce i've tasted in quite awhile. definitely house made. the crust is thin, so you're calories aren't wasted on the dough...which was perfectly crisp. our pancho pie arrived a few minutes after the meat. how did they do this twice? so good. the green chiles melted in my mouth. the pork was a great addition to the pie and as i sit here typing this 36 hours later...i need another. with all this raving, why the 4 star instead of the 5 star review? a couple reasons. the first, their pies only come in 1 size, a 12"-13" 8-piece pie. as i mentioned, my nephew is a picky eater. we hoped they had a kids' size, because he also only eats pepperoni pizzas...without the pepperoni. aka cheese. we ended up picking meat off meat off a couple pieces of the meat pie so he would eat. he still ate both pieces, which is a lot for him. the other is the service. our server was either new, overwhelmed, or not good at her job. she was slow at getting our orders and didn't know the menu very well. we will be back. the food at old county inn is too tasty to pass up. i do wish they listed which breweries they get their beer from. on to the llamas and goats! read more

I initially started this review as a 2 star review, but it ended well so I landed at 4 stars. There was no sign an no one at the front to let us know where to sit so we just picked a table. Once we were noticed quite a while later we could hear the waitresses talking about, "I can't believe they sat there, We may need to move them. I don't know what we are going to do." As there were quite a few open tables at this point it didn't seem like it would be very difficult to move but no one came over to talk to us. It was almost 15 minutes before one of them actually came over. She started with, "You weren't supposed to seat yourself, we thought we might need to move you but we'll figure it out". umm, ok. I mentioned they had no sign and no one was up front. I was moderately annoyed and VERY hungry at this point so I'm certain I wasn't pleasant so I shouldn't have been surprised our visit went south (sorry, I should have locked it up). Quite a while after we were seated another group of 5 guys were seated next to us. The chefs came out to speak with them and apparently the wait staff knew them. So, no surprisingly despite ordering our drinks well before them their drinks came out first. We then put in our order for wings, a salad, and pizza. While the wings came out in a reasonable amount of time we had to eat them on napkins because we never got plates or silverware. Then it was well over an hour before the pizza arrived, and of course despite putting in our order well before the table next to us (and a really long time before the other table there) we were served last. I inquired as to why and the waitress said, "I put their ticket in before yours." when I asked why she replied, "I don't know why I did it". You don't know? Really? Well, we got there at 2:30 and didn't get our food until almost 4. Apparently since it was a saturday afternoon and they filled up after we got there they were telling people it would be 45min-60min for pizza but we were not told this and it wasn't busy when we first arrived. So after we finally got our pizza another waitress came by and said, "Christina (apparently our first waitress though she never introduced herself) wanted me to drop off the check. Do you need to-go boxes?" I'm not sure if they were trying to rush us out because people were now waiting or if Christina just passed off the duty on the poor other waitress who didn't know we had just gotten our food. It was just a exclamation point and an exceptionally poor experience. I initially wasn't going to say anything but I figured I was going to leave a review so i should give them an opportunity to fix the situation. I asked for the manager who offered to comp the WHOLE meal before I even told her half of what happened. She said that she had heard about the pizza issue and was unaware of the boys next to us getting special treatment but that, "no one gets special treatment here because we value all of our customers". She came out to the table and apologized to every one and refunded our ticket. She invited us back and even offered a gift card, but I said it was unnecessary. She said they would look into what happened, and I actually believed her. So, really great service recovery. And now onto the important stuff. The food here is AMAZING. The wings are actual whole wings and the flavor is to die for. I can't think of a better wing i've had. It seemed like more of a rub rather than a sauce so it wasn't messy to eat. Even the ranch seems homemade and was delicious. I had the salad which was a unique blend of small spears of veggies rather than just lettuce and the dressing and toppings were all outstanding. I really enjoyed it. Once we got the pizzas they were excellent as well. My boyfriend loved the "Meat Pie" (psa its a pizza pie...apparently some people don't get that?). It was loaded with sausage and pepperoni. We also had the chicken, artichoke pizza with balsamic glaze. I overheard the manager telling another table it would "change their life", well I can attest it was on point. The crust was woodfired to perfection and had great flavor. The price was reasonable; their pizzas are $14 for what would be about the size of a medium pizza elsewhere. I can easily see why this place gets such great ratings as the food is really something. I hope they figure out the flow and staff a little better because this place has a ridiculously good product. We have family in pine so I will definitely be back. read more

Best owner in town. Michael is a real PROFESSIONAL. He has the experience and knowledge to run a TOP NOTCH RESTAURANT. He cares about the customers and ensures that everyone has a great memorable experience. Michael is not afraid to spend money to make money like having bands and awesome decor. No dirty floors and tables in this establishment his employees show the pride because he is a top notch boss. I love to see the loyalty Michael inspires. The food is awesome Michael has years in the business and doesn't skimp on the number of menu items. read more

Alrighty, so I feel a little weird giving the 5 stars for a place I've only done to go orders from, the wait is just a little crazy the times we've gone down there, but to go works out great. Pizza is just fine, more heavy and cheesy than I prefer my wood fire pizza to be, but still not bad. But HELLO! The cheese and sticks is soooooo good. I want to drink that cheese! They're very generous with the cheese so I always try and think of what else I can eat it with!!! For like $2 you can get more bread sticks, which I recommend, just so you can eat more cheese!! Then we got the chicken tenders and pickles and my goodness, that seasoning is so good. Nice and light and crispy--not greasy at all. And bigger than the picture looked. I'm so excited to have this yummy place in pine!! read more

I love this place. The food is amazing - this is a farm to fork restaurant.. nothing canned, all fresh ingredients. They have wood fired pizzas, amazing fresh salads, homemade pickles, among other dishes. The staff are so friendly and fun. They offer live music (check their calendar) and you can bring your dog. They have corn hole set up outside. The spirits are really good. We sat outside and saw Elk grazing across the street while we dined. I can't wait to get back up here. One of the best restaurants in Arizona. read more

My wife and I were spending a few days in Payson and took a drive through Pine. We stopped here after reading positive reviews and found the best pizza for miles. They have a great beer selection and beautiful views of the mountains on their patio. My new favorite place near some good hiking trails. read more

The food is great. It does take a little while but worth the wait. The seating is limited but the Staff is very friendly and do there best to accommodate. Tap room is very cool. read more

Amazing pizza! We were in town from Phoenix for a couple nights and planned on eating at Old Country Inn because it offered a dog friendly patio. Unfortunately it was too rainy, so we ordered 2 pizzas to go, we were not disappointed at all. We got the meat lovers pizza and Pancho pizza. I normally don't care for unique pizza toppings, but I absolutely loved the Pancho Pizza! The Meat lovers are as delicious too, but the Pancho was my favorite. It did take 30 minutes for the pizzas to be ready, but they had told us up front, which was nice. We will make this our favorite dinner stop any time we are in the area. read more

We were without a place to eat upon arriving into town around 8pm. This restaurant was kind enough to open up their kitchen and serve us anyways. We were helped by two separate servers, a female and a male (can't remember names sorry guys!, but a brown hair female and a younger guy with some tattoos). Both of them were very kind and accommodating. We had a BBQ pizza and some wings, food was good. Nice selection of good quality beers, we chose Scottsdale Blonde and sipped a couple of those to drown out the kids after a long drive . Jk but seriously great service and we appreciate the staff for helping us out on 6/17 around 830pm. Jay read more

LOVE this place! My husband and I own The Strawberry Inn just up the road from here and we always come by to see Chef Mike and enjoy pizza! Awesome staff, great food- even GF options on the menu. Fun atmosphere with live music and games out on the patio. Everyone who works here has a smile on their face and a welcoming attitude. Recommend the beer cheese and breadsticks and their special on glasses of rosé. If you're lucky you'll get to see our local herd of elk across the road at dusk- what a sight! A must visit location!! read more

Everyone there was very friendly and the food was amazing. Make sure you save room for the cookie in the skillet they have.

Good eats. Good service. I'm the asshole that came in 30min til close and they still hooked it up

Best Bloody Mary I've ever had!... Best Bacon I've ever had!... Best Hawaiian Pizza I've ever had! read more

Old County Inn - Best Bloody Mary Ever - Pizza Near Me - Pine, Arizona

Great fresh homemade food. Everything is made in house, including the pepperoni and their amazing olives. We were visiting from TX and the hospitality we received was spectacular. Ordered multiple orders as there were many people in our party. Everything was special and delicious. read more

We made our first visit here tonight based off of the great Yelp reviews. I must say, we were pleasantly surprised that it met all our expectations and them some. We ordered a micro brew beer and a cocktail along with Buffalo chips and a Pancho pizza. The chips were made fresh in house with blue cheese and hot sauce dips and were very tasty. Our pizza was ridiculously delicious! Pulled pork, fresh tomato sauce, pesto, green chiles, and melt cheese. The crust was so soft on the inside and crisp on the outside. We agreed it was the best pizza we've had in ages. We finished it off with a skillet cookie with melted ice cream. The cookies were coconut and macadamia nut and I'm not a huge fan of these, but it was so good. The manager Sabra was very attentive and making sure our dinner went great. Sarah our waitress was great. She was always smiling and she was working her butt off taking care of a full bar and the dining room. We highly recommend and it's now our go to spot when we visit Pine. read more

Old County Inn - Pizza Near Me - Pine, Arizona

My wife and I stopped in at this place on our way out of AZ. It was incredible!!! The pizza, salad, and home made chips were out of this world. The bartender was a little out of it, I had to ask him multiple times for everything but I was blown away by the food and the owners were the nicest ppl! Everything was impeccable. I really recommend this place. Prices are great too. read more

Fantastic pizza and great live music. For dessert, cookie with gelato was amazing. Will definitely come again. Elk were grazing across the street. read more

On a trip up to Payson, we were looking for some good food (which Payson is not really known for) in a casual atmosphere. Saw Old Country Inn on Yelp and decided it was probably worth the 15 minutes drive north to try it out. It most definitely was. The menu was so robust with yummy sounding items that we struggled to narrow down what to order, and ended up with a variety of appetizers. The beer cheese, homemade chips, and salad were all excellent. But the highlight was the warm olives in pesto. It was so good. We came home from our trip and attempted to recreate the dish...to no avail of course. Bloody Mary's were scratch made and top notch. Patio vibe was casual and up beat with big evergreens in the back drop. If we lived nearby, there is no doubt we would be regulars here. Loved it! read more

All I can say is amazing pizza. Highly recommend you try this place if you up in Pine, AZ.

Ok at best. Food about average. Prices above average, but Holy Cow can they be slow. Definitely don't go at a busy time and plan on long waits and delays all the time. Our first time there in a weeknight it was over an hour to get our food and this week, on a Wednesday when only half full, it took an hour and forty five minutes, to get two pizzas. We gave up and just took them to go. read more

I have lived in Pine for about 3 yrs. Finally gave this place a try. I very seldom go out to eat because I am a very picky eater. The combination of ingredients on this pizza about made me gag. Has to be about the worst pizza I have ever tasted. Was no concern to the owner when I said after finally getting one slice down that I did not want a box to take the remainder home. I have worked in the pizza industry for over 10 years and have put out some of the best pizza in the west Texas area. If I had a customer leave all but one slice of a pizza untouched, I would have been very concerned and checked with that customer if there was a problem. Then I would have corrected that problem. Seems like people in this area take mediocre food and list it as great. I see why they serve alcohol. Deadens the taste buds. Won't ever be back. read more

Definitely my new favorite restaurant! The Arizona greens salad is simple, but amazing. It's got these light, crunchy pieces of corn and sun-dried tomatoes -- such a nice difference from regular house salads. They also have gluten free options. The entire staff is incredibly nice as well! read more

Dog friendly patio!!! Someone knows what they are doing here! Friendly and attentive service. The ingredients and flavors are something you might expect down in the valley- it rivals some of our favorite pizza spots! We started with the greens salad - fresh and perfect to share, dressing with obvious fresh herbs from their garden on-site was a bright spot. We had the east coast clam pizza (give it a try seriously great flavor!) and I forget the name but a red pizza with their roasted pork and green chili's (that pork though!). Great beers and wine selection! The atmosphere is perfect - you WILL likely have a wait (which is always a good sign) but a cold drink from the tap room (bartender was so great with an excellent music play list) and those views will keep you occupied! We will be back - and next time I will try their craft cocktails - A hidden gem in the mountains - great vibes- give it a try for sure!!!! read more