Cancel

Open app

Search

Old Barn Indian Restaurant & Bar

5.0 (1 review)
Closed • 11:00 am - 10:00 pm

Order Old Barn Indian Restaurant & Bar Takeout or Delivery

Old Barn Indian Restaurant & Bar Photos

You might also consider

More like Old Barn Indian Restaurant & Bar

Recommended Reviews - Old Barn Indian Restaurant & Bar

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

3 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

Get access to customer & competitor insights.

Verify this business

Smiths' Boathouse Restaurant

Smiths' Boathouse Restaurant

4.1(175 reviews)
47.5 mi
•$$

It's been some time since we last came here and we decided to try it again. They have really kicked…read moreup their game! It's certainly worthy. Now given that, it's not your Taco Bell. Expect to pay more when the food is of this high quality and this well prepared! We started with the Caprese salad. Delicious! Burrata cheese, greens, prosciutto ham and a wonderful basaltic dressing. A+ on this! Then we both had the Maryland crab cakes. Lump crab cakes on asparagus. Just delicious, easily the best crab cakes I've had anywhere in Ohio, maybe the best I've ever had! A+ again! Service was fast and friendly! The setting is on the Great Miami River with a wonderful overlook! Everything was perfect! As Arnold said, 'I'll be back!'

Finally made time to pop in for dinner--unfortunately it wasn't on Lobster Roll or Cluster Crab…read morenight (guess we will just have to return at least two more times lol). The dinning room is nice, low light and low music playing. It seemed to get a little smokey in there but it wasn't bothersome. Our server was so lovely! And another lady that was floating around checking on tables was very sweet and fun! We really struggled with our ordering and "locking it in"...therefore we ended up ordering what felt like half the menu. For appetizers, we got calamari and the baked crab dip. The calamari was pretty light and delicious. The crab dip was heavy and but had a great flavor. I wasn't a huge fan of the chips but it was great with the bread that came to our table. The bread basket came out steaming and the butter was amazing we had to ask for extra. The butter is whipped and has green onions in it. Hubby and daughter each got clam chowder--it was different from what they are used to (and they are both clam chowder connoisseurs) but they still thought it was very good--just thinner and a lot more meaty ingredients. Daughter loved the halibut with risotto. Hubby really enjoyed the boathouse burger--bacon jam was new for him but he loved it. Though the burger was messy--he definitely cleaned the plate. My seafood platter was pretty good, I ate the scallops and coconut shrimp first. Then came our next dilemma...dessert!! So we each got one! Crème Brûlée, Highlander Grogg Chocolate Cake and Chocolate Chip Cookie Skillet. Everything was a hit!!

Photos
Smiths' Boathouse Restaurant - Dining area

Dining area

Smiths' Boathouse Restaurant - Buckeye cheesecake

Buckeye cheesecake

Smiths' Boathouse Restaurant

See all

Captain D's

Captain D's

2.4(11 reviews)
2.1 mi
•$

This is a LONG overdue review of what might be the best Captain D's I've ever visited. Seriously…read more My partner and I were returning home and passed through Lima when I saw the sign for Captain D's and had to stop. Who can resist a 2-piece with fries, a breadstick, and extra crunchies? From the moment I walked up to the door I could tell this was a very different kind of Captain D's... 1.) anyone who frequents Captain D's knows they're not usually in the most desirable locations, and as such, the staff isn't always that fastidious about the outside appearance of the establishment. Not here. No trash rolling around in the parking lot, empty (rather than overflowing) trash cans, and a generally tidy parking lot. Good sign #1. 2.) anyone who frequents Captain D's knows when you open the door a wave of seafoody-antiseptic-like aroma HITS you in the face. Not here. It just smelled like a restaurant, not a seafood restaurant. I never imagine such a thing could be possible at a Captain D's. Great sign #2. 3.) anyone who frequents Captain D's knows the average employee is not is excited to be there, and it shows in the effort they put forth. Not here. These (clearly overwhelmingly high school) employees were on their game: I was greeted upon entry, folks were smiling, they were communicating clearly and politely with each other in front and behind the counter, the (young) manager was hustling just as much as the staff, and the dining area was clean. Fantastic sign #3. I actually enjoyed (rather than dreaded) waiting for my to-go order. The manager double-checked it before sending it out the door (a brilliant 1-second step that saves a mountain of potential issues on the back-end), and I was on my way. Everything was perfectly cooked, my meal was delicious, and I'm actually considering a special trip back through Lima in the coming months just so I can visit this particular Captain D's again. Y'all have something special here. Whether it's the training, the small-town solidarity, the youthful exuberance (LOTS of eager high school folks doing great work!), or just a general sense of pride in your jobs, Captain D's lucked out to get a crew like you.

We were in the drive through for about 45 mins, 4 cars ahead of us. They changed their food. Fish…read morelooks like long processed fish sticks that are processed into a long block then battered. It was chewy and not typical captain ds battered fish. The Mac and cheese came from like a Gordon's food service kind of situation and the coleslaw was bitter. Hush puppies were burnt. I've never had good service at captain beyond circa 1999 but at least you could count on the quality of food. Not anymore....

Photos
Captain D's - Two dining rooms

Two dining rooms

Captain D's
Captain D's

See all

Jolly Roger Seafood House - Perch Platter: Perch sandwich, Coleslaw & Onion Rings!

Jolly Roger Seafood House

4.2(437 reviews)
84.3 mi
•$$

As a Pescetarian in Northeast Ohio I have meaning to try Jolly Roger Seafood House for a while,…read morewell I finally got there and the big question is why I waited so long. Jolly Roger is located in Port Clinton right on Lake Erie; I was expecting something ordinary or just a bit dated and boy was I wrong. The building is very modern and clean from the outside, white and angular with big windows. Inside white walls, rough hewn wooden tables and just the right amount of decor makes for a modern seaside feel, casual but also classy. The setup is fast casual, you order and pay up front at the counter, get a number for your table and then get your own drink at the service station. The menu is understandably very heavy on fish and seafood with a couple of other items. While there are the expected fried fish meals, but also oysters, shrimp and salmon, salads and even some tacos. The reason I came was of course for the fried fish, I decided on the Perch and Chips, which is $18. I grabbed some water, hot sauce and lemon and settled onto a table. The meal was brought out fresh and hot by a food runner in a couple of minutes. The meal was 4 nice sized perch fillets on top of a generous portion of fresh waffle fried potatoes with a side of tarter sauce. The fish were excellent, fresh and perfectly fried with a nice crispy cornmeal crust around the delicately fish; moist with a slight sweetness and perfect texture. The waffle fries were exceptional, fried to a crisp outside and tasty inside; usually fries at a seafood place are an afterthought, here they actually are well worth getting and eating. Even the tarter sauce was very nice, nothing special but creamy with a nice pickle contrast to add a little extra flavor. Usually when I see a place that has been around this long and has great reviews I am a bit let down when I give them a try; Jolly Rogers Seafood House exceeded my expectations in almost every way. Although set up as a fast casual restaurant with a typical fried seafood menu, the actual restaurant feels more upscale and modern with a great inside and a very nice patio looking out onto Lake Erie. The food is not cutting edge, but it is expertly prepared and delicious. Prices are moderate with large portions for your money. Some of the best fried perch and waffle fries I have had. I will be back any time I am in the area, a very high recommendation as long as you are looking for fish or seafood, go and enjoy.

Really, really good food! The Perch was some of the best I've ever had. Mushrooms were great too…read more The only knock I have is the waffle fries were like warm. I LOVE waffle fries, but they have to be hot. It was also nice to see they had a selection of beers. Food came out fast. I would not hesitate to return.

Photos
Jolly Roger Seafood House - Walleye Dinner with Onion Rings

Walleye Dinner with Onion Rings

Jolly Roger Seafood House
Jolly Roger Seafood House

See all

Kai's Crab Boil

Kai's Crab Boil

4.4(565 reviews)
75.1 mi
•$$$

Best seafood boil I've had in Columbus!…read more Kai's Crab Boil is hands down one of my favorite seafood spots in Columbus. The gumbo is fantastic and honestly some of the most authentic I've had here in Columbus. It's packed with flavor and really stands out. Their shrimp and crab with the garlic butter sauce at a medium heat level is absolutely incredible. The seasoning and spice are perfect, and paired with their cornbread... OMG It's SO good! The service was great, and the ambiance was really nice too. Everyone was friendly and welcoming, which made the whole experience even better. If you're looking for a seafood boil with authentic Cajun/Creole flavors, I definitely recommend Kai's. Everything we had was delicious, and I can't wait to go back!

So this was the Goog apology for literally being asked to leave after spending $300 at this place…read moreAWFUL CUSTOMER SERVICE I make a bad Review and this is the Apology ‍ If you don't have space on Major occasions then You Should not take large Parties and make that plain You certainly took the money and the 18% gratuity tip. AWFUL SERVICE AND A EVEN WORSE EXCUSE We deeply apologize if this policy was not clearly communicated to your party by our hosting staff upon your arrival. It is never our intention to make our guests feel rushed, and we regret that the reminder from our management came across as harsh or selective. This limit was applied to all tables that day so we could honor the reservation times of waiting guests.

Photos
Kai's Crab Boil
Kai's Crab Boil - Lobster Roll Slider

Lobster Roll Slider

Kai's Crab Boil

See all

Old Barn Indian Restaurant & Bar - indpak - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...