Cancel

Open app

Search

Odd Cookie Bakery

4.9 (88 reviews)
Open • 11:00 am - 10:00 pm
Updated 1 week ago

Order Odd Cookie Bakery Takeout or Delivery

Odd Cookie Bakery Photos

Business Info

You might also consider

More like Odd Cookie Bakery

Recommended Reviews - Odd Cookie Bakery

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

fun display
Lizbet R.

I love this place! It's one of my favorite spots on the way back home when I'm out of town I love the themed cupcakes they have different ones for every season and their cookies are amazing! I love the small and quirky interior and the prices are very fair

Interior
Jodi T.

Stopped by this super cute dessert shop, and I'm so glad I did!!! The inside is adorable, and the owner did it all by themself! It was hard to pick what to try as there were so many options!!! We ended up getting one cookie and one cupcake. S'moreo - 4/5 stars - it's HUGE and THICK, not too sweet, great texture with the chunky chocolate in the cookie, the marshmallow was the only part that was ok Harry the Hunter - 5/5 stars - tiramisu cupcake with a sugar cookie on top, both were so yummy and not too sweet, the cupcake has coffee cake vibes The owner is super nice and friendly and passionate about cookies!!! It was fun chatting with them! Highly recommend if you're in the area!!!

Valentine's cupcakes :)
Jenna M.

Odd Cookie is anything but ordinary! What a great little bakery nestled along the main street of Penngrove. I actually discovered this business on Instagram and was super intrigued by the creative and fun flavor combos. The owner recently tended to my custom order for Valentine's Day. I loved how decorated each cupcake was-- such attention to detail and truly delicious! Odd Cookie provided a wonderful experience from the initial DM to the last bite of cupcake. I wish their business the very best.

Cute interior
Luciente G.

This lil bakery has been on my list for a while although for some reason I kept thinking about it on Sundays which is the only pecans day she's closed. So finally made a date with a girlfriend to go here on Saturday! Whew so many cookies to choose from. Owner Baker is so incredibly creative! I almost felt bad starting with classics. Oatmeal raisin for hubs and oatmeal chocolate with pecans for me. My friend got the circus animal cookie and she was on cloud 9, it has a cookie topping the cookie! Well a few days later I found myself in the area again to meet another friend for her birthday so that warrants more cookies of course! I got her a "She works hard for the honey," Snicker doodle with nuts and a honey drizzle! Luckily she shared it with me because it was deeeelicious! Got hubs a Snicker doodle and he loved it. I went for the classic chocolate chip, because I was advised that the smore cookie I was eyeing was not a good one to eat in the car and well car cookie was required that day. Next time! Because there most definitely will be a next time! If you get 5 cookies, she throws in a 6th cookie! Woo hoo! I'm trying to save money and be kinda healthy so I stuck to one cookie a person. Hubs is very supportive, but after eating his first cookie, he says I should have gotten 6! Lol Oh and the baker is super friendly and patient as you try to decide between the 30 options!

Choco lot cookie !

Amazing service, the best and most creative cookies ever, so soft and easy to eat the entire thing. This place is always a 10/10.

Inside
Brooke R.

This place is so cute! Anna was so sweet and helped us pick out our cookies! There is so many fun flavors of cookies to choose from and the cutest cupcakes for Christmas! This was our first time going here and we picked up 6 items because we couldn't decide what we wanted!! All the cookies are so soft! We came home and tried the Oreo cookie and apple bottom snickerdoodle and OMG THEY ARE AMAZING!!! We will definitely be going here for our sweet tooth cravings!

Thanksgiving Specials
Josh F.

I like to stop by here on cheat days The ambiance is rad, and the desserts are unique & delicious. It's also a great place to get a small gift for someone if you're ballin' on a budget Some people might assume that with all those positives I listed, that the customer service is trash or some other catch. You'd be wrong. Sorry. 5 stars!

Snickers cookie
Ian W.

After seeing nothing but positive reviews about this place, I had to try it. I stopped in on a Saturday afternoon and was immediately greeted by the owner who is extremely nice. The display case was filled with a variety of cookies making it hard to decide which one to get. i ended up buying half a dozen and took them home to eat. OMG these cookies are delicious. The quality and cooking is far better than Crumbl. A bonus for me was that the cookie was cooked in the middle to a soft, but cooked center. I will definitely be back to try more of their items!!!

Individually wrapped treats for my customers!
Erica S.

So, it's no secret that I love Odd Cookie...but I had to share a photo of the best dessert I've ever had! This raspberry cake cup is absolutely to die for!!!!

Madison V.

Where can I possibly begin? Odd cookie was amazing. The communication, the promptness, the fact she gave me so many options when I told her the subject of the cupcake and had NO idea where to begin. I HIGHLY recommend this place. Everyone was talking about the cupcakes and how good they were.

Yum!

See all

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Odd Cookie Bakery is an amazing experience. The flavors from the cookies and the cupcakes are amazing. Great staff and service.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Page 3 of 3

Ask the Community - Odd Cookie Bakery

You might also consider

Della Fattoria Downtown Café - Daily turkey sandwich special. Yum!

Della Fattoria Downtown Café

4.2(1.2k reviews)
4.5 mi
•$$

Large, eclectic space. You can purchase breads and pastries and flowers if you don't want to eat…read moreinside. Come early if you want a seat without a wait. Service was decent, but it did take a while for both main dishes to come out. Some drinks are served in bowls which was fun. The French toast was amazing. Definitely get it. Portions are large and filling so you won't need to eat again until dinner.

When I walk around town and Petaluma, we decided to get something to eat and chose Della Fattoria…read moreDowntown Café. It was pretty busy, but we didn't have to wait very long. We actually got a nice window seat so we could watch what was going on downtown Petaluma. We each ordered a different sandwich. My husband had the turkey and ham sandwich and I had the chicken salad sandwich. The flavors were so divine that it really made it a very enjoyable sandwich. The wait staff is so friendly. They kept coming around checking on us and making sure that everything was fine. It was pretty busy there so it was nice to know that they were still at being attentive. You really have to sit there for a moment to see all the beautiful things that they have inside their store. It is so well decorated that it feels very homie. Also, from my understanding, they have fresh bread there in the morning and they put them out on a stand unfortunately, we got there too late, but I hear nothing but good things about their sourdough bread. Definitely a cute place to go for a nice lunch and it's right in the middle of town.

Photos
Della Fattoria Downtown Café - Pastries

Pastries

Della Fattoria Downtown Café - Omelette with white cheddar, mushrooms, onions and spinach.

Omelette with white cheddar, mushrooms, onions and spinach.

Della Fattoria Downtown Café - 1st time I've been here and there's no line! 7.4.24"! Hee

See all

1st time I've been here and there's no line! 7.4.24"! Hee

Lilajay's Baked Goods

Lilajay's Baked Goods

4.9(11 reviews)
3.2 mi
•$$

"ridicuously good gluten-free bakery" is their saying on their brownies…read more ridicuously high priced would be accurate too. but when you factor in gluten free, and all the organic shit, it may be worth it. if size matters, think of each brownie as the size of an half dollar. 2 of these half dollars will cost you a lincoln (5). this isn't voodoo economics, it's the new math of what good stuffs costs. so save up those pennies or pass up that joint.... locale: new taste marketplace (5/24) brownie flavors(2/$5) -original brownie : moist and tasty -original in dark chocolate -double dipped in white chocolate-pretty sweet -walnuts -pecan -peanut butter -caramel foodnotes: -pretty good stuff, costs more than a pretty penny -pricey for good stuff. -value 3 stars, taste 4 stars

I don't write reviews ever, but I feel compelled to write about Lilajay's. Lilajay's cookies were a…read morecorporate gift I received a few weeks ago. I was skeptical because gluten free products usually contain a ton of ingredients that you can't pronounce. I opened the package, took one bite and it was over for me. My mind was blown to pieces with the peanut butter goodness. I immediately ordered more and waited for them to be delivered. A week later I followed up because they still hadn't come, Lila responded to me way after business house telling me that they were marked as delivered - she felt terrible and would get us more cookies asap. Turned out that SOMEONE HAD STOLEN OUR COOKIES!!! I felt compelled to tell her that I had just gotten married and didn't have 1 problem with our registry stuff but when someone saw baked goods from Lilajay's they couldnt contain themselves and nabbed them. Needless to say, we received a new box of cookies with all sorts of extras and a really nice handwritten note congratulating us on our recent nuptials. I will continue to spread the word on how delicious the cookies are, and how wonderful the customer experience was. Thank you so much Lila!!! Oh and... the Peanut Butter O reallyz are pretty much the best thing I've ever had in my life.

Photos
Lilajay's Baked Goods - White Chocolate dipped Brownies!

White Chocolate dipped Brownies!

Lilajay's Baked Goods - Original Brownies!

Original Brownies!

Lilajay's Baked Goods - Chocolate Chip Cookies!

See all

Chocolate Chip Cookies!

Petaluma Pie Company - The Elvis ($10/5")

Petaluma Pie Company

4.3(655 reviews)
4.6 mi
•$$

I had such a perfect pie experience here today! Walked in with high hopes to get a strawberry…read morerhubarb pie. They didn't have one ready, but they rearranged their orders, and soon I had just the pie I wanted. I so appreciate their willingness to make me happy! The pie was absolutely delicious, wonderful fruit filling, absolutely flakey crust with cute cut outs. It was an absolute hit at our dinner gathering . I totally recommend this bakery for your dessert happiness. I also picked up a chicken hand pie for my lunch, and it was also delicious! Win win...

If you're ever in the mood for pie and don't feel like making it yourself, this is the place to go…read more I got one apple pie for my husband and I got the berry pie. I could not wait to get home to try them and it was worth the wait. The young lady at the counter did make some suggestions in case I wanted to try something different other than a sweet pie. They had meat pies there too. I said I would probably try that next time. When we got home, we had dinner and we couldn't wait for dessert and it did not disappoint. We warmed them up in the oven and put a little bit of ice cream on top and it was simply wonderful. The apples and the apple pie were nice and tart and the berries were sweet. Definitely a place to return to, but if you don't know where it is, it might be a little difficult to find, but it's in a little. I guess you would call it an adjuster way nestled in between Starbucks and the deli. It's not too fancy inside, but they have all their pies and stuff on display.

Photos
Petaluma Pie Company - Black & Blue Crumble ($10/5")

Black & Blue Crumble ($10/5")

Petaluma Pie Company - Black & Blue Crumble ($10/5")

Black & Blue Crumble ($10/5")

Petaluma Pie Company - Black & Blue Crumble ($10/5")

See all

Black & Blue Crumble ($10/5")

Odd Cookie Bakery - cupcakes - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...