Amazing!!!! 10/10 recommend!! Definitely will continue to go back every time I visit Navarre!!

Very good! Ordered our food to go and everything was still hot by the time we got back to our place (about 10 mins away). We got a pizza and wings. Pizza was good, nothing super special but hits the spot! We got mild wings and loved them! Crispy and good taste. Would definitely come back! read more

I have been going to nypd since they opened and love every bit of it. My favorite is the Stromboli's and garlic knots.

Excellent service, food, and price. We plan to go back during our week vacation. Small restaurant without a lot of seating, but well worth the wait! read more

Decided to come while passing through on vacation. I'm so glad I did! The crust and seasonings on my calzone were divine and the cheese inside was very obviously high quality. I also loved the marinara and the dine-in service was attentive. Would love to come back next time I pass through on 98. I have nothing but good things to say about it and will probably crave it. read more

NYPD Express - Cheese Calzone with Marinara sauce - Pizza Near Me - Navarre, Florida

Love It! I'll never order from a pizza chain again. Being new to the area, I'm still trying to find local eateries to make a normal. We ordered from one of the chain pizza places when we first got here. I decided we had to try NYPD- New York Pizza Depot. We loved it! The pizza crust is amazing! It has a great crunch without being thin. The butter garlic wings were delicious; they use real chopped garlic. Overall, Fatty McFoody gives NYPD read more

This place has such mixed reviews that I was hesitant ordering from them. The majority of the reviews were regarding delivery taking way to long. The food reviews all seemed good though. So I decided to order 2 hours early before I was hungry and my order happened to show up in approx 15/20 mins from the time I placed the order. Lol. Keep in mind this was an order I placed on a Monday at 6:50pm. So maybe the complaints were from the weekend or during superbowl or etc. Food was great. We ordered a large pizza with pepperoni, mushroom, black olive and artichoke. Pizza was perfectly cooked and HOT when it arrived. Also ordered mozzarella sticks, garlic butter for the pizza and a Gyro. Online mentions they put feta on the gyro, but there was no feta so (deduct a star) that was disappointing and honestly I have had a better gyro from Arbys but if you have a gyro craving it's good enough to satisfy. Delivery driver was also nice. If anyone has been to Miami Beach the food here tastes spot on to Ginos pizza (both Alton Rd and Collins Ave locations). read more

Don't get me wrong the food is good. I called in my order and they said 30 min. I showed up 30 min later and they said there was just going to be a slight wait in my Gyro. An hour and a half of waiting and they still haven't gotten me anything. No reassurances that it'll be soon or that they're even working on it. They're just avoiding any eye contact and filling other customers orders. Btw I am still standing here. read more

Pizza was amazing and I was so excited they had green olives because most places don't. The wait staff was very friendly!

I got the 18in meat lovers, 8pc garlic knots and mild wings. Pizza wasn't anything special. I enjoyed the garlic knots and wings weren't bad. read more

What's better than dinner you don't have to make after a day at the beach? Pizza was reminiscent of that 80s-style delivery I remember. They arrived in less time than they predicted with hot, fresh pies. Don't forget to tip the delivery driver! read more

My husband and I were hungry but didn't want leftovers so we chose a place not too far from our hotel that served single slices of pizza. We had a very fresh house salad and both of us got the tomato and sausage single slices. Very good crust and lots of tiny bits of tomato along with plenty of ground mild sausage. Loved it. Many workers and our waitress was friendly and attentive. read more

So good!! And great value too! Beach Week in from NOLA, an we were greatly impressed! Fast service and attentive too! Will def make a return trip on our next beach vacay! Had the Meatlovers, Greek salad and fried ravioli. All wonderful! Took leftovers home and ended up snacking on it the same night. It that's good! read more

Customer service is horrible. No doubt they are confusing online/on the phone with their new location. From the other reviews on yelp, I see I am not the only one! 2 starts because the pIzza is fine but for an $18 pepperoni pie, I would hope the customer service would be "not bad". Not even asking for good, just not bad. Basically if you don't understand what they have going on, it's your fault. Good luck! We won't be going back. read more

Ordered a deluxe pizza for two. After an hour it arrived. It was no longer hot. On top of of that the pizza was no different from a regular pizza chain just more expensive. I will not be back. read more

I asked for my pizzas lightly done no burnt marks when I got them home they were unedible with black crusts abd black bottoms never again

We have never been disappointed by the food, and they have always been nice. The ambience is nice, just what you would expect for a pizza place. It would be nice if they could have more tables, but they are limited of course by the size of the restaurant. read more

Great food, awesome pizza and rolls! The Caesar salad is really good too! Prefer to eat it there and haven't ever had a bad meal in house or with delivery/carry out. read more

NY Pizza is my family's Navarre Beach arrival day tradition. Good quality. No fuss. Friendly folks. Convenient location.

Hey..I wanted to say that we ordered a XL pizza...AKA...the original. Large pizza, and a medium.(the new large pizza, the new little pizza.) Don't like the idea of the size changes in pizza..What the heck does the Pizza industry think we are stupid. We can definitely tell when you downsize the size of the pizza.) I am so at least one place Has Great Pizza.and they changed with the sizes also..But they keep the proper size in the size of an 18 inch XL.Wish the had the same price as they us to for a pizza..but they've got to keep up with the money grubbing times.TOTALLY the best.Not only the pizza but the Stromboli's, calzone, meatballs and love their garlic knots. They r much closer to original Italian pizza even closer than Vinny R's pizza..HYPE is Great,best in the area.. read more

We decided to try this on a Saturday afternoon for lunch. We ordered and regular cheese pizza to go and eat it at home. It was so good. We are thinking about getting another one. read more

The best pizza I've ever had! Soft, fluffy, yet crispy crust! Perfection! Marinara sauce was delicious! We also got the fried ravioli and garlic knots; both were outstanding! Friendly staff and great prices! We will definitely be back! read more

First time not bad. Good food. Second time they were busy and very disorganized. Called in order. Told 50 minutes. Turned out to be three hours. Got tired of watching groups coming in ordering, eating, and leaving. read more

We are snowbirds in Navarre for the past 5 years. We love the crust on their pizza. Margarita pizza is a favorite of ours. First 4 years we stopped in about once a week but last year we felt the quality was lacking or at least not as we had experienced previously. We will try again next year and go from there. Good prices and selections. Friendly workers. read more

If you are waiting for "real" Bronx style pizza (seeing as the Bronx is the only place for real pizza) wait longer. NYPD if you were thinking New York you would be thinking horribly incorrectly. This pizza is franchise mass a produced junk. If you want good pizza in Navarre try Sal's read more

We ordered delivery food from here a few times and found everything we have tried to be good. I would definitely recommend saying "light crust" if you order pizza. My only complaint is the length of time you have to wait for deliveries. read more

I live 5 miles from this place and I am outside their "delivery zone", super disappointing considering papa johns is further but they will deliver to my house. read more

This pizza is one of my favorite restraunts but I still prefer hungry howies over anything

RIDCULOUS!!!!! Called and ordered 2 pizzas...pepperoni and supreme. 30 minutes and your order will be ready....says the pizza employee. Showed up at 20 minutes, paid and watched them make my pizzas! Not once did the "kid" behind the counter even acknowledge that 5 other people walked in after me, ordered and still received their food before I did. Note to the manager: please teach some customer service skills to your employees. I would've had no issue if the order was messed up or they accidentally gave my food to someone else. Biggest issue: Not a single apology for taking an hour to deliver 2 pizzas. In the future, I'll make them at home....with my children! read more

Our pizzas were damned good! I don't participate in the whole "real" pizza debate, but I love thin crust and this one was perfect. Not too thin that it didn't have a bit of chewiness, just right. The little girl got a small pepperoni and I tasted the sauce, not too sweet, which I liked. We got the "Mariano" which is really a Marguerita as it has fresh tomatoes (they put the sauce on their Marguerita) and it was tasty. I do think there was pesto instead of just fresh basil, but it was fine. I am picky!!!! It was delivered pretty quick and the price was on par for regular pizza joint ( of course more than the cardboard fake cheese crap chains.) read more

Great pizza, very popular so plan on a long wait for your order. Told me it would be 45 mins and took hour and 15 minutes to get order.

This is one of my favorite places to eat in Navarre. I think the pizza is excellent. The garlic knots are wonderful, and everything is very well priced. Beer prices are great too ! read more

Burned all three if our pizzas. Was told this was the best in town. This was the very worst. Even the dog couldn't eat it as it tasted like a old cigarette ash tray.... read more

Staying at Springhill Marriott in Navarre Beach for the week and sent hubby out to get a couple pies. Arrive at take-out window just to be told their take-out ovens are at full capacity but he's welcome to dine-in if he wants a pizza. Seriously?! It's Friday night during spring break and you're going to stop taking take-out orders at 8:20pm?!? But they'll take your dine-in order all night with drinks, extras and gratuity. Reading two other reviews from just a few weeks ago indicates they have management and/or business philosophy problems. read more

First of all, the pizza basics are very good, the crust (hand tossed), sauce and cheese are excellent. Once you add toppings though the ingredients are not up to the basic pizza. The pepperoni is not the best, and the green peppers were diced instead of sliced, maybe something I am not familiar with but.... Anyway next time, and there will be a next time, I will go with a simple Margarita pizza which I think will be much better. This biggest hit on NYPD at least for dine in customers is the lousy beer and wine selection. See the menu, the only draft beer choice is Bud light or Amber Bock ? Step it up NYPD. read more

Great place! I might just have to make a 2nd trip here during my stay. Fast service too!

My experience was when they first opened - NOT ny pizza - husband and I both thought it was very bland and dry - not at all what i was expecting since I have had real NY pizza in NY. one visit only - you only got my $15.00 and no repeat business read more

Nice pizza joint in Navarre, mostly set up for take out though. It can get packed quickly. The pizza is very good, I recommend the meat lovers for fellow carnivores. I also had the Cobb salad which was HUGE!! And very good. The wings were some of the best that I have had in Navarre/GB to date. The servers were friendly and the atmosphere was nice and clean. I'm sure I will be back soon. read more

Excellent food and service! Our family loves this place when we vacation in Navarre Beach. You can watch the cooks flip the pizza dough. Nice staff. read more

The antipasto salad with the Greek dressing and the garlic knots were awesome. The pizza was pretty good, but the sauce was a little bland. However, it was way better delivery pizza than any national chain restaurant. read more